17.1 Principles of Bioethics & Decisional Capacity

ABIM Internal Medicine Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 0: The ABIM Exam, Blueprint & Study Strategy

0.1 Exam Format, Question Types & the 2026 Blueprint 0.2 Eligibility, Registration, Fees & Exam-Day Logistics 0.3 Scoring, the Passing Standard & Score Reports 0.4 Building a Blueprint-Weighted Study Plan

2 Chapter 1: Cardiovascular Disease (14% of Exam)

1.1 Ischemic Heart Disease & Acute Coronary Syndromes 1.2 Antithrombotic Therapy, Secondary Prevention & Mechanical Complications of MI 1.3 Atrial Fibrillation, Atrial Flutter & Stroke Prevention 1.4 Supraventricular Tachycardias, Ventricular Arrhythmias & Bradycardias 1.5 Heart Failure: Classification, Staging & Guideline-Directed Medical Therapy 1.6 Device Therapy, HFpEF & the Cardiomyopathies 1.7 Valvular Heart Disease & Endocarditis Prophylaxis 1.8 Pericardial Disease & Acute Aortic Syndromes 1.9 Hypertension: Classification, Diagnosis & Secondary Causes 1.10 Hypertensive Crises & Dyslipidemia 1.11 Adult Congenital Heart Disease & Coarctation of the Aorta 1.12 Syncope: Reflex, Orthostatic & Cardiac Causes 1.13 Cardiac Physical Examination, Murmurs & Antithrombotic Selection

3 Chapter 2: Endocrinology, Diabetes & Metabolism (9% of Exam)

2.1 Diabetes Mellitus: Diagnosis, Glycemic Targets & Pharmacotherapy 2.2 Insulin Therapy, Hyperglycemic Emergencies & Chronic Complications 2.3 Thyroid Function Testing & Hypothyroidism 2.4 Thyrotoxicosis, Thyroid Storm & Thyroid Nodules 2.5 Adrenal & Pituitary Disorders 2.6 Hypercalcemia, Hypocalcemia & Disorders of Mineral Metabolism 2.7 Osteoporosis & Paget Disease of Bone 2.8 Ovarian, Testicular & Reproductive Endocrine Disorders 2.9 Hypoglycemia, Endocrine Tumors, Polyglandular Syndromes & Severe Hypertriglyceridemia

4 Chapter 3: Gastroenterology & Hepatology (9% of Exam)

3.1 Esophageal Disease 3.2 Stomach & Duodenal Disease and Gastrointestinal Hemorrhage 3.3 Inflammatory Bowel Disease 3.4 Celiac Disease & Irritable Bowel Syndrome 3.5 Diverticular Disease & Colorectal Cancer Screening 3.6 Viral Hepatitis, Steatotic & Alcohol-Associated Liver Disease 3.7 Cirrhosis & the Complications of Portal Hypertension 3.8 Acute Pancreatitis 3.9 Chronic Pancreatitis & Biliary Tract Disease 3.10 Inherited, Autoimmune & Drug-Induced Liver Disease 3.11 Small Intestinal Disease, Ischemia & Gastrointestinal Complications of HIV

5 Chapter 4: Infectious Disease (9% of Exam)

4.1 Lower Respiratory Tract Infections & Sepsis Syndromes 4.2 Viral Respiratory Pathogens & Tuberculosis 4.3 Central Nervous System Infections 4.4 Skin, Soft Tissue, Bone & Joint Infections 4.5 Infective Endocarditis & Cardiovascular Infection 4.6 Clostridioides difficile & Catheter-Related Bloodstream Infection 4.7 HIV Diagnosis, Antiretroviral Therapy & Prevention 4.8 Opportunistic Infections & Sexually Transmitted Infections 4.9 Fever of Unknown Origin, Neutropenic Fever & Toxic Shock 4.10 Travel-Related Illness, Vector-Borne Disease & Outbreaks 4.11 Infection Prevention, Nosocomial Infection & Postexposure Prophylaxis 4.12 Rheumatic Fever, Poststreptococcal Disease, Enteric & Hepatic Infections

6 Chapter 5: Pulmonary Disease (9% of Exam)

5.1 COPD: Diagnosis, GOLD Classification & Initial Pharmacotherapy 5.2 Interventions That Reduce COPD Mortality & Exacerbation Management 5.3 Asthma: Diagnosis, Stepwise Therapy & Status Asthmaticus 5.4 Interstitial Lung Disease & Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis 5.5 Sarcoidosis, Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis & Occupational Lung Disease 5.6 Pulmonary Embolism: Diagnosis, Risk Stratification & Anticoagulation 5.7 Pulmonary Hypertension & Sleep-Disordered Breathing 5.8 Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome & Mechanical Ventilation 5.9 Pleural Disease, Empyema & Pneumothorax 5.10 Bronchiectasis, Cystic Fibrosis & Restrictive Lung Disease 5.11 Evaluation of Cough, Dyspnea, Hemoptysis & the Solitary Pulmonary Nodule

7 Chapter 6: Rheumatology & Orthopedics (9% of Exam)

6.1 Rheumatoid Arthritis: Diagnosis & Systemic Manifestations 6.2 Antirheumatic Pharmacotherapy & the Spondyloarthropathies 6.3 Gout: Pathophysiology & Acute Management 6.4 Urate-Lowering Therapy & Calcium Pyrophosphate Deposition Disease 6.5 Osteoarthritis 6.6 Systemic Lupus Erythematosus 6.7 Systemic Sclerosis, Sjogren Syndrome & Inflammatory Myopathies 6.8 The Vasculitides 6.9 Regional Musculoskeletal Syndromes, Back Pain & Sports Injuries 6.10 Other Primary Rheumatic Disorders & Mixed Connective Tissue Disease 6.11 Osteonecrosis & Metabolic Bone Disease

8 Chapter 7: Hematology (6% of Exam)

7.1 Approach to Anemia & the Microcytic Anemias 7.2 Macrocytic, Normocytic & Hemolytic Anemias 7.3 Hemoglobinopathies, Thalassemias & Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria 7.4 Platelet Disorders, Thrombocytopenia & the Bleeding Patient 7.5 Coagulation Factor Disorders, Thrombophilia & Anticoagulant Reversal 7.6 Acute Leukemias, Chronic Leukemias & Myeloproliferative Neoplasms 7.7 Lymphomas & Plasma Cell Disorders 7.8 Myelodysplastic Syndrome, Myeloproliferative Neoplasms & Porphyria 7.9 Transfusion Medicine & Late Complications of Transplantation

9 Chapter 8: Medical Oncology (6% of Exam)

8.1 Breast, Lung, Colorectal & Prostate Cancer 8.2 Oncologic Emergencies 8.3 Genitourinary & Gynecologic Malignancies 8.4 Head and Neck, Bone & Soft Tissue Cancer and Cancer of Unknown Primary 8.5 Complications of Cancer & Its Treatment 8.6 Cancer Prevention, Survivorship & Psychosocial Care

10 Chapter 9: Nephrology & Urology (6% of Exam)

9.1 Acute Kidney Injury: Staging, Etiology & Urine Microscopy 9.2 Glomerular Disorders & Nephrotic Syndrome 9.3 Nephritic Syndromes, RPGN & Indications for Renal Replacement Therapy 9.4 Chronic Kidney Disease: Staging & Progression Retardation 9.5 Complications of Chronic Kidney Disease: Anemia, CKD-MBD & Acidosis 9.6 Hyponatremia, Hypernatremia & Water Balance 9.7 Potassium Disorders & Systematic Acid-Base Analysis 9.8 Renal Tubular Acidosis & Nephrolithiasis 9.9 Prostate Disorders, Urinary Incontinence & Other Urologic Conditions 9.10 Cystic Kidney Disease, Obstructive Uropathy, Tubulointerstitial Disease & Hematuria

11 Chapter 10: Neurology (4% of Exam)

10.1 Acute Ischemic Stroke: Syndromes & Reperfusion 10.2 Transient Ischemic Attack, Secondary Prevention & Hemorrhagic Stroke 10.3 Headache & Facial Pain 10.4 Seizures, Epilepsy & Movement Disorders 10.5 Multiple Sclerosis & Neuromuscular Junction Disorders 10.6 Motor Neuron Disease & Acute Peripheral Neuropathy 10.7 Cranial Neuropathies & Neuro-Ophthalmology 10.8 Peripheral Neuropathies, CNS Tumors & Other Neurologic Disorders

12 Chapter 11: Psychiatry & Behavioral Health (4% of Exam)

11.1 Major Depressive Disorder & Medical Mimics 11.2 Antidepressant Pharmacotherapy & Treatment-Resistant Depression 11.3 Bipolar Disorder, Mood Stabilizers & Lithium Toxicity 11.4 Anxiety, Stress-Related & Obsessive-Compulsive Disorders 11.5 Alcohol Use Disorder & Withdrawal 11.6 Pharmacotherapy for Alcohol & Opioid Use Disorder 11.7 Toxidromes, Psychiatric Emergencies & Suicide Risk Assessment 11.8 Psychotic, Somatic Symptom, Factitious & Personality Disorders 11.9 Eating Disorders, Sleep Disorders & Sexual Health

13 Chapter 12: Dermatology (3% of Exam)

12.1 Dermatitis, Papulosquamous & Inflammatory Dermatoses 12.2 Acne, Rosacea & Cutaneous Infections 12.3 Herpes Zoster & Autoimmune Blistering Diseases 12.4 Nodules, Tumors & Cutaneous Oncology 12.5 Dermatologic Emergencies & Severe Cutaneous Adverse Reactions 12.6 Pigment Disorders, Alopecia, Nail Disease & Photosensitivity 12.7 Vascular Dermatoses, Environmental Injury & Cutaneous Signs of Systemic Disease

14 Chapter 13: Obstetrics & Gynecology / Women's Health (3% of Exam)

13.1 Contraception, Preconception Care & Teratogenicity 13.2 Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy & Gestational Diabetes 13.3 Thyroid Disease & Venous Thromboembolism in Pregnancy 13.4 Menopause & Menopausal Hormone Therapy 13.5 Abnormal Uterine Bleeding, Endometrial Disease & Gynecologic Cancer Screening 13.6 Breast Disorders & Diseases of the Vulva and Vagina 13.7 Menstrual Disorders, Fibroids, Endometriosis & Early Pregnancy Complications

15 Chapter 14: Geriatric Syndromes (3% of Exam)

14.1 Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment & Frailty 14.2 Falls, Gait Assessment & Polypharmacy 14.3 Urinary Incontinence & Pressure Injuries in Older Adults 14.4 Mild Cognitive Impairment, Dementia & Its Subtypes 14.5 Delirium & the Pharmacotherapy of Cognitive Disorders 14.6 Palliative Care, Hospice & Advance Care Planning 14.7 Chronic Wounds, Nutrition, Swallowing, Constipation & Hip Fracture 14.8 Sensory Impairment, Dizziness, Elder Mistreatment & Care Settings

16 Chapter 15: Allergy & Immunology (2% of Exam)

15.1 Anaphylaxis: Recognition & Emergency Management 15.2 Urticaria & Angioedema 15.3 Drug Allergy, Desensitization & Adult Immunodeficiency 15.4 Food Allergy, Insect Venom Hypersensitivity, Serum Sickness & Contrast Reactions 15.5 Rhinitis, Conjunctivitis, Eosinophilic & Mast Cell Disorders

17 Chapter 16: Preventive Medicine, Immunization & Clinical Epidemiology

16.1 The USPSTF Framework & Evidence-Based Cancer Screening 16.2 Cardiovascular & Metabolic Screening and Primary Prevention 16.3 Adult Immunization & Vaccines in Special Populations 16.4 Clinical Epidemiology, Biostatistics & Study Design

18 Chapter 17: Miscellaneous - Ethics, Patient Safety & Quality Improvement (2% of Exam)

17.1 Principles of Bioethics & Decisional Capacity 17.2 Informed Consent, Treatment Refusal & Special Scenarios 17.3 Surrogate Decision-Making, Advance Directives & Confidentiality 17.4 Patient Safety Science, Medical Error & Diagnostic Reasoning 17.5 Quality Improvement Methods, Health Disparities & Health Equity

19 Chapter 18: Perioperative Medicine & Medical Consultation

18.1 Preoperative Cardiovascular Risk Assessment 18.2 Preoperative Pulmonary Risk & Perioperative Medication Management 18.3 Perioperative Anticoagulation, Bridging & Postoperative Complications

20 Chapter 19: Ophthalmology (1% of Exam)

19.1 The Acute Red Eye & Ophthalmic Emergencies 19.2 Painless Vision Loss & Chronic Ophthalmic Disease 19.3 Uveitis, Scleritis & Orbital Disease

21 Chapter 20: Otolaryngology & Dental Medicine (1% of Exam)

20.1 Dizziness, Vertigo & Epistaxis 20.2 Ear Disorders, Hearing Loss & Upper Respiratory Infections 20.3 Oral Cavity, Salivary Gland, Laryngeal & Taste and Smell Disorders

17.1 Principles of Bioethics & Decisional Capacity

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Primarily ethics is an enumerated subsection of the Miscellaneous blueprint category, and ethics in the elderly is a separate Geriatric Syndromes subsection.

Capacity requires the ability to communicate a choice, understand relevant information, appreciate the situation and consequences, and reason about options.

Capacity is decision-specific, so a patient may lack capacity for a complex choice while retaining it for a simpler one.

A cognitive screening score does not establish or exclude capacity by itself.

Competence is a legal determination made by a court, whereas capacity is assessed clinically by any physician.

Last updated: August 2026

Medical ethics, clinical decision-making capacity, informed consent, and surrogate decision-making represent core competencies tested extensively on the ABIM Internal Medicine Board Examination. Internists frequently encounter complex scenarios involving treatment refusal, conflicting family wishes, advance directives, and confidentiality dilemmas. Mastery of biomedical ethical frameworks and legal standards is essential for compassionate, legally sound patient care.

1. The Four Core Principles of Biomedical Ethics

Modern clinical biomedical ethics rests upon the principlism framework articulated by Tom Beauchamp and James Childress. When navigating difficult clinical dilemmas, physicians must systematically evaluate and balance four fundamental moral principles.

Ethical Principle Definition & Clinical Scope Clinical Application & Tensions

Autonomy Respect for the patient's moral right to self-determination , bodily integrity, and independent choice. Requires voluntary decision-making free from coercion, manipulation, or undue influence. An adult with decision-making capacity has the absolute right to accept or refuse any proposed medical treatment, even if refusal results in disability or death. Autonomy frequently conflicts with Beneficence.

Beneficence The affirmative duty of healthcare providers to act in the best interest of the patient , promote their physical and psychological well-being, and restore health. Recommending evidence-based therapies (e.g., primary percutaneous coronary intervention for STEMI). Beneficence must never be pursued through unauthorized paternalism that overrides a competent patient's autonomy.

Non-Maleficence "Primum non nocere" — First, do no harm . Obligates clinicians to avoid inflicting intentional harm, minimize procedural/pharmacologic risks, and ensure that anticipated benefits outweigh potential burdens. Withholding non-beneficial or futile invasive interventions (e.g., CPR in terminal refractory shock) that inflict suffering without physiological benefit; deprescribing harmful polypharmacy in frail elderly patients.

Justice The obligation to distribute healthcare resources, benefits, risks, and costs fairly, equitably, and non-discriminatorily across all patients and populations. Distributive justice in allocating scarce resources (e.g., ICU beds, ECMO circuits, deceased-donor solid organs via UNOS criteria); avoiding bias based on race, socioeconomic status, gender identity, or insurance.

• 2. Decisional Capacity Assessment in Clinical Practice
• A. Capacity vs. Competence: Critical Legal and Clinical Distinction

Decision-Making Capacity (Clinical): A clinical determination made by any licensed treating physician regarding a patient's ability to make a SPECIFIC medical decision at a SPECIFIC point in time . It is dynamic, decision-specific, and can fluctuate with acute physiological or neuropsychiatric changes.

Competence (Legal): A global legal status determined solely by a judge/court of law regarding an individual's overall legal qualification to manage property, enter into contracts, or execute legal documents. All adult patients are legally presumed competent until adjudicated incompetent in a formal court hearing.

B. The Four Essential Functional Abilities Required for Capacity

To possess decision-making capacity for a given clinical choice, a patient must simultaneously demonstrate all four of the following functional criteria:

Understanding: The ability to comprehend and recall the relevant medical facts, including the nature of the illness, proposed diagnostic tests or treatments, the anticipated prognosis, potential risks, expected benefits, and reasonable alternatives (including the consequences of no treatment).

Bedside Inquiry: "Can you explain in your own words what condition you have and what treatment we are recommending?"

Appreciation: The ability to apply the medical information to one's own personal situation and acknowledge that one has the illness and that the proposed treatments (or refusals) have direct, real-world consequences for oneself.

Bedside Inquiry: "Do you believe you have this medical condition? What do you think will happen to your health if you decide not to undergo this procedure?"

Reasoning: The ability to engage in a logical, rational thought process, compare risks and benefits, manipulate information coherently, and articulate why one choice is preferred over another in accordance with one's own personal values, goals, or beliefs.

Bedside Inquiry: "How did you weigh the risks versus the benefits in reaching this decision? Why does this choice make the most sense for you?"

Expressing a Choice: The ability to communicate a clear, definitive, voluntary, and stable choice over time (verbally, in writing, or via reliable non-verbal communication such as blinking, head nodding, or pointing to communication boards).

• Bedside Inquiry: "What is your final decision regarding having this surgery?"
• C. The Sliding Scale Model of Capacity (Risk-Sensitive Threshold)

Capacity is not an "all-or-none" phenomenon; it operates on a sliding scale proportional to the stakes of the medical decision:

Low Stakes / High Benefit Decisions (Low Threshold): Agreeing to a low-risk, highly effective therapy (e.g., accepting oral antibiotics for uncomplicated cellulitis or phlebotomy for routine laboratory work) requires only a basic level of understanding and assent.

Moderate Stakes Decisions (Moderate Threshold): Deciding between two medically reasonable options with balanced risk profiles (e.g., choosing between elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy versus medical management with observation) requires standard functional understanding and comparative reasoning.

High Stakes / Grave Consequence Decisions (High Threshold): Refusing a life-saving, low-risk therapy (e.g., refusing emergency surgical repair for a ruptured appendicitis, refusing mechanical ventilation for acute hypercapnic respiratory failure, or refusing antibiotics for bacterial meningitis) requires an exceptionally high and rigorous threshold of demonstrable appreciation, reasoning, and internal consistency.

Loading diagram... Clinical Algorithm for Decisional Capacity Assessment and Surrogate Decision-Making

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.

• Up Next
• 17.2 Informed Consent, Treatment Refusal & Special Scenarios
• Continue learning