6.2 Circularity and Cylindricity

ASME GDTP Senior Level Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Senior Level vs Technologist and Y14.5 Revisions 1.3 How to Use This Guide and Study Strategy 1.4 The Y14.5-2018 Senior Exam and What Changed from 2009

2 Dimensioning and Symbology

2.1 Y14.5 Dimensioning Rules, Limits, and Fits 2.2 Basic Dimensions and Their Role 2.3 Feature Control Frame Structure and Reading 2.4 GD&T Symbols, Modifiers, and Communication 2.5 Screw Threads, Gears, and Splines 2.6 Angular Surfaces, Tapers, Radii, and Special Tolerance Cases

3 Datum Referencing I: Selection and Precedence

3.1 Functional Datum Feature Selection 3.2 Datum Precedence and Degrees of Freedom 3.3 Datum Targets 3.4 Datum Feature Simulators

4 Datum Referencing II: Modifiers and Shift

4.1 Multiple Datum Features and Datum Reference Frames 4.2 RMB, MMB, and LMB on Datum Features 4.3 Datum Shift Behavior 4.4 Planar vs Datum Feature of Size

5 Datum Referencing III: Setup and Calculations

5.1 Inclined and Translated Datum Features 5.2 Inspection Setup and Datum Establishment 5.3 Datum Calculation Walkthrough 5.4 Customized Datum Reference Frames and Rotational Constraint 5.5 Free State, Restrained Condition, and Nonrigid Parts

6 Form Controls

6.1 Flatness and Straightness 6.2 Circularity and Cylindricity 6.3 Rule #1, Form, and Size

7 Orientation Controls

7.1 Parallelism, Perpendicularity, and Angularity 7.2 Orientation Zones and Material Modifiers 7.3 Avoiding Unnecessary Orientation and Over-Control

8 Location I: Position and Boundaries

8.1 Position Tolerancing and True Position 8.2 Virtual and Resultant Condition 8.3 Bonus Tolerance at MMC and LMC

9 Location II: Application and Modifiers

9.1 Selecting MMC, LMC, and RFS by Function 9.2 Fixed and Floating Fastener Formulas 9.3 Projected Tolerance Zones 9.4 Coordinate Conversion and Appendix B Position Calculations

10 Location III: Patterns and Allocation

10.1 Composite Position Tolerancing 10.2 Patterns, Simultaneous Requirements, and Multiple Segments 10.3 Slots, Tabs, and Tolerance Allocation 10.4 Coaxial Feature Controls, Concentricity, and Symmetry

11 Profile I: Fundamentals and Strategy

11.1 Profile of Line and Surface 11.2 Defining the True Profile 11.3 Datum-Referenced Profile Strategy 11.4 Equal and Unequal Disposition

12 Profile II: Scope and Verification

12.1 All-Around, All-Over, and Limited Scope 12.2 Composite Profile and Coplanarity 12.3 Castings, Weldments, Sheet Metal, and CMM Evaluation 12.4 Combined Controls and Profile as a Refinement

13 Runout Controls

13.1 Circular and Total Runout 13.2 Datum-Axis Simulation and Rotating Parts 13.3 Runout vs Position, Profile, and Form

14 Exam Strategy and Calculations

14.1 Virtual/Resultant Condition and Bonus Formulas 14.2 Datum Shift and Worst-Case Boundary Calculations 14.3 Functional Gaging and Verification 14.4 Test-Day Tactics, Common Traps, and Review

6.2 Circularity and Cylindricity

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Circularity (roundness) is evaluated per cross-section within two concentric circles and never references a datum; each section is judged independently.

Cylindricity uses two concentric coaxial cylinders and simultaneously limits circularity, generator straightness, and taper across the whole cylinder.

Cylindricity is not circularity-over-the-length; it is the maximum of circularity, generator straightness, and taper, all bundled into one zone.

Neither circularity nor cylindricity controls size (governed by ± limits and Rule #1) or location (which requires a datum via runout or position).

Adding a datum reference to a cylindricity callout is a drawing error; if datum-tied cylinder control is needed, use total runout or profile.

Last updated: August 2026

6.2 Circularity and Cylindricity

Quick Answer: Circularity (roundness) controls individual cross-sections of a surface; cylindricity controls the whole cylinder at once. Circularity's zone is two concentric circles per cross-section and never references a datum. Cylindricity's zone is two concentric coaxial cylinders, simultaneously controlling circularity, straightness, and taper. Both are form controls with no datum reference. Senior questions focus on what cylindricity bundles versus what circularity leaves uncontrolled, and on the trade-off against profile or runout.

Circularity — per-section roundness

Circularity (still commonly called "roundness") uses a circularity symbol and a tolerance value t. For any single cross-section perpendicular to the feature's axis (or, for a sphere, any great-circle section), the surface must lie within a zone of two concentric circles separated radially by t. The zone is located and oriented to minimize departure—it floats per section, and circularity does not reference a datum .

Critical features:

Each cross-section is evaluated independently. A part can be a stack of perfectly round sections of different diameters and still pass circularity while failing cylindricity (taper).

The zone may translate to the actual center of each section; it is not pinned to the drawing axis.

Circularity does not control taper, straightness of the axis, or the size of the feature (size is governed by the ± limits and Rule #1).

Circularity is the natural control for bearing journals, seal surfaces, and ball/spherical interfaces where local roundness governs function but taper along the length is tolerated by the assembly.

Worked example — bearing journal

A bearing journal Ø25 h6 (Ø25 +0/−0.013) carries a circularity tolerance of 0.003. At three cross-sections the roundness deviation is measured:

Section A: 0.002 mm — conforming
Section B: 0.004 mm — nonconforming
Section C: 0.0015 mm — conforming

The part fails because any single nonconforming section fails the feature . The diameter at each section could be within the size limits and the part can still fail circularity; size compliance is necessary but not sufficient.

Trap: circularity vs concentricity/runout

Circularity does not locate the section's center on the datum axis. A shaft section can be perfectly round yet displaced off-axis; circularity passes, but runout or position would catch the offset. This is a common Senior distractor that confuses circularity (form) with runout (composite form + location).

Cylindricity — the whole cylinder at once

Cylindricity uses a cylindricity symbol and a tolerance value t. The entire cylindrical surface must lie within a zone of two concentric coaxial cylinders separated radially by t. The zone is free to translate and orient to minimize the separation, but the two cylinders share a common axis.

What cylindricity simultaneously controls:

Circularity of every cross-section (because the zone bounds each section to an annular band).

Straightness of every longitudinal surface element (the generators lie between the coaxial cylinders).

Taper along the length (the two coaxial cylinders constrain diameter variation end-to-end).

What cylindricity does not control:

Size — the diameter must still satisfy the ± limits and Rule #1.

Location or orientation of the axis — the cylinder zone floats; it does not pin the axis to a datum. Runout or position controls location.

A datum reference is not allowed on cylindricity (it is a form control); a drawing that adds datums to a cylindricity callout is incorrect.

Circularity vs cylindricity vs profile vs runout — selection table

Need Best control Why
Local roundness only (bearing journal, ball) Circularity Cheap, per-section, allows taper
Whole cylinder: round + straight + no taper Cylindricity Single control bundles all three
Cylinder form tied to a datum axis (runout-style) Total runout Composite control with datum reference
Cylinder including size and location to datums Profile of a surface Size + form + location in one callout
Cylinder size controlled, form derived from Rule #1 ± limits only Rule #1 gives perfect form at MMC for free
Worked example — hydraulic ram

A hydraulic ram Ø40 f7 (Ø40 −0.025/−0.050) carries a cylindricity tolerance of 0.005. The ram is measured on a roundness/straightness/taper machine:

Roundness (worst section): 0.003 mm
Generator straightness (worst line): 0.006 mm
Taper (diameter difference end-to-end): 0.002 mm

The cylindricity deviation is the smallest radial separation between two coaxial cylinders containing the whole surface. The dominant term here is generator straightness (0.006), so cylindricity is approximately 0.006 mm , exceeding 0.005. The ram is nonconforming even though circularity alone would pass. This is the Senior insight: cylindricity is not "circularity over the length"; it is the maximum of circularity, generator straightness, and taper, all bundled.

Trade-off traps

Cylindricity is expensive to verify. Unlike circularity (which needs a turntable per section), cylindricity needs a 3-D trace or a precision V-block/center method. Senior exam questions ask about inspection cost trade-offs: if function tolerates taper, use circularity; if taper matters, cylindricity; if location matters, runout.

Cylindricity does not control size or location. A cylindricity 0.01 ram can still be Ø40.000 when the low limit is Ø39.950; size is governed by the ± dimension and Rule #1, not by the cylindricity symbol.

Adding a datum to cylindricity is a drawing error. If the designer wants the cylinder controlled relative to a datum axis, the correct control is total runout or profile, not cylindricity-with-datum.

Senior application takeaways

Use circularity when local roundness governs function and taper/axis straightness are acceptable.

Use cylindricity when the full cylinder must be round, straight, and untapered, and datum reference is not needed.

Switch to total runout when the cylinder must also rotate true to a datum axis; switch to profile when size, form, and location all belong in one callout.

Never let a circularity-pass result imply cylindricity-pass; cylindricity is the strict superset.