Study guide

6.3 MT Evaluation Techniques

ASNT NDT Level II Certification Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Certification Paths: SNT-TC-1A, CP-189, and ASNT Central Certification 1.3 Level I vs Level II vs Level III Responsibilities 1.4 Application, Scheduling, Identification, and Retake Rules

2 Eligibility, Fees & Recertification

2.1 Training Hours, Experience Days, and Documentation 2.2 Vision, Practical Exams, and the Employer's Written Practice 2.3 Fees, Validity, Recertification, and 529 Funding

3 NDT Fundamentals & Method Selection

3.1 What NDT Can and Cannot Detect 3.2 Surface vs Subsurface and Method Selection Logic 3.3 Product Forms: Welds, Castings, Forgings, Wrought, In-Service Damage

4 MT Principles & Flux Fields

4.1 Magnetism, Permeability, and Flux Leakage 4.2 Flux Fields: Circular vs Longitudinal 4.3 How Discontinuities Distort Magnetic Fields

5 MT Magnetization & Demagnetization

5.1 Magnetization by Electric Current: Contact, Prods, Central Conductor 5.2 Selecting the Proper Magnetization Method: Coils, Yokes, Current Type 5.3 Demagnetization Procedures and Residual Field Limits

6 MT Equipment, Evaluation & Process Control

6.1 MT Equipment, Media, and Lighting 6.2 Types of Discontinuities Detected by MT 6.3 MT Evaluation Techniques 6.4 Quality Control of MT Equipment and Processes

7 PT Principles & Materials

7.1 PT Principles: Capillarity, Wetting, and Process Physics 7.2 Penetrant Types, Methods, and Sensitivity Classes 7.3 Developers and Process Sequence Controls

8 PT Method Selection & Process Control

8.1 Selecting the Appropriate PT Method for the Job 8.2 Surface Preparation, Dwell, Removal, and Lighting 8.3 Station Equipment, Process Control, and Safety

9 PT Indications, Evaluation & Standards

9.1 Relevant, Nonrelevant, and False Indications 9.2 Evaluating Indication Size, Shape, and Persistence 9.3 PT Procedures, ASTM/ASME Standards, and Acceptance

10 RT Principles & Exposure Technique

10.1 Radiation Physics: X-ray vs Gamma, Energy, and Attenuation 10.2 Exposure Geometry, Inverse Square Law, and Geometric Unsharpness 10.3 Radiographic Technique: kV, mA-min, Screens, and Source Selection

11 RT Image Quality, Processing & Indications

11.1 Film, Digital Detectors, Density, and Image Quality Indicators 11.2 Darkroom Facilities, Processing, and Artifact Control 11.3 Radiographic Indications, Discontinuities, and Defects

12 RT Product Discontinuities & Radiation Safety

12.1 Manufacturing Processes and Associated Discontinuities 12.2 Radiological Safety: Time, Distance, Shielding, and Dose Limits 12.3 RT Procedures, Codes, and Viewing Practice

13 UT Principles & Techniques

13.1 Sound Propagation, Modes, Velocity, and Wavelength 13.2 Transducers, Couplant, and Straight-Beam Techniques 13.3 Angle-Beam Techniques, Snell's Law, and Skip Distance

14 UT Calibration & Base Material

14.1 Calibration Blocks, DAC, TCG, and Sensitivity Setting 14.2 Evaluating Base-Material Product Forms 14.3 Evaluating Weldments

15 UT Bonds, Detection & Evaluation

15.1 Evaluating Bonded Structures 15.2 Discontinuity Detection and Characterization 15.3 General Evaluation, Sizing, and Acceptance Logic

16 VT Scope, Vision & Lighting

16.1 Purpose and Scope of VT 16.2 Elements of Vision 16.3 Elements of Lighting 16.4 Contrast and Resolution

17 VT Optics, Equipment & Discontinuities

17.1 Optics and Magnification 17.2 VT Equipment: Direct, Remote, and Measuring Tools 17.3 Visual Appearance of Discontinuities

18 VT Evaluation, Codes & Employer Topics

18.1 Evaluation and Reporting 18.2 Codes, Standards, and Specifications 18.3 Employer-Specific Topics and Written-Practice Controls

19 Specific Exam: Codes & Sectors

19.1 How the Specific Exam Differs from the General Exam 19.2 General Industry Codes and Procedure Use 19.3 Pressure Equipment Sector Codes (ASME, NBIC, API context)

20 Specific Exam: Applications & Techniques

20.1 Applications: Matching Method to Product Form and Access 20.2 Technique Selection and Essential Variables 20.3 Procedure Compliance, Reporting, and Acceptance/Rejection

21 Exam Strategy & Maintenance

21.1 Timed 50+40 Strategy and CBT Rules 21.2 Common Traps by Method 21.3 Weak-Area Review and Recertification Planning

6.3 MT Evaluation Techniques

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Classify every particle pattern as relevant, nonrelevant, or false before you talk about accept or reject.

Describe relevant indications as linear or rounded, then measure length (and width if the procedure requires it) against the acceptance standard named in the procedure.

Reinspect with a second field direction, a different current type, or after demagnetization when orientation, magnetic writing, or a questionable pattern is in play.

Record the essential variables the procedure lists — method, current, media, lighting, area, and indication data — so the evaluation can be reconstructed.

"Looks bad" is not a disposition; only the governing code, specification, or procedure decides defect.

Last updated: August 2026

Evaluation Techniques is official MT general topic 9 on the outline administered prior to 15 December 2026 . After 15 December 2026 the same work sits inside the revised domain interpret, evaluate, and document , with codes and procedures as the authority for accept/reject. The teaching point does not change: particles are not a verdict. Particles are a pattern you classify, measure, and compare to a written standard.

ASTM E1444 and ASTM E709 describe how to produce and view indications. ASME Section V, Article 7 tells you how to perform the examination for ASME work. Neither document is, by itself, the accept/reject table for a weld or a forging. That table lives in the construction code , the customer specification , or the procedure that invokes them. A Level II who rejects a part because "it looks like a crack" without opening that table has not evaluated the indication.

Classify first: relevant, nonrelevant, or false

Use the same vocabulary as the rest of this guide and as the method standards.

A relevant indication is caused by a discontinuity that must be evaluated against the acceptance standard. A sharp linear buildup at a carbon-steel weld toe is relevant until proven otherwise.

A nonrelevant indication is caused by a known geometry or a permitted condition , not by a rejectable discontinuity. Thread roots, keyway corners, press-fit edges, abrupt section changes, the edge of a drilled hole, and the weld-toe radius can all leak flux. Magnetic writing (local residual patterns from contact with another magnetized object or from incomplete demagnetization) is also nonrelevant once you have identified it.

A false indication is not caused by a leakage field from the part. Lint that fluoresces, drain lines of wet bath on a horizontal surface, dirt, scale flakes, over-dusted dry powder, a cracked UV filter that adds visible glare, or particles trapped in spatter are false.

Classification is a process, not a glance.

Confirm lighting, media, and magnetization were valid. A pattern seen under 50 lux of white light on visible powder is not ready to classify.

Wipe, blow, or rinse gently if the procedure allows a check for false media piles, then reapply if required.

Look at the geometry . Does the pattern follow a thread, a toe, or a section change for its entire length?

Change field direction or demagnetize and reinspect if magnetic writing is suspected. Writing often disappears or moves; a crack does not.

Only then call the pattern relevant, nonrelevant, or false.

A nonrelevant geometric collector can hide a real crack at the same location. If the procedure requires it, grind or machine the geometry (within remaining-thickness rules) and reinspect. Do not stamp "nonrelevant" on a toe simply because toes collect powder.

Linear versus rounded

After a pattern is relevant , describe its shape in the language the acceptance standard uses.

Shape Typical industry meaning Common MT sources

Linear Length is large compared with width; many codes treat an indication as linear when length is about three times width or more Fatigue cracks, seams, laps, toe cracks, grinding cracks, heat-treat cracks

Rounded Length and width are similar; not crack-like Surface porosity, slag that broke the surface, sand inclusions, some cold shuts

Aligned / accumulated Several indications in a line or cluster that the standard may add together A train of pores, a broken seam, intermittent toe cracking

The 3:1 length-to-width idea is a common code convention , not an ASNT secret number. Some specifications use different wording ("crack-like," "elongated"). Use the definition in the governing standard . If the stem does not give a definition, treat a sharp, crack-like particle line as linear and a blob as rounded.

Linear is not automatically rejectable. Rounded is not automatically acceptable. A 1-inch linear seam on a bar may be rejectable; a 1/16-inch linear slag pop on a weld may be acceptable. The table decides.

Measure against the acceptance standard — not against instinct

Record length along the indication, location (weld, HAZ, base metal, distance from a datum), and orientation (parallel to the weld, transverse, radial). Some procedures also want width or a sketch. Measure the particle pattern with a scale or optical aid the procedure allows. Do not "split the difference" because you think the crack is shorter than the powder.

Then open the acceptance standard named in the procedure . Examples you will see in industry — not as ASNT answers — include ASME construction-code surface tables, AWS D1.1 visual/MT workmanship limits, and customer aerospace tables that reject any linear indication in a critical zone. The exam item will usually print the limit in the stem ("linear relevant indications longer than 1/8 in / 3 mm are rejectable"). Your job is to apply that sentence, not to invent a shop custom.

Worked logic the specific exam likes:

Indication is relevant and linear, measured length 5 mm , limit 3 mm → reject (defect).

Indication is relevant and rounded, diameter 2 mm , limit 3 mm isolated rounded → accept if spacing rules are also met.

Indication follows a keyway corner, no crack-like extension, procedure calls geometry nonrelevant → accept as nonrelevant , and record that classification.

Indication "looks ugly" but the standard has no rejectable condition → you do not reject it on taste. You may still report it if the procedure requires recording all relevant indications.

Defect means the discontinuity failed the acceptance standard . It is not a synonym for crack, and it is not a synonym for indication.

When to reinspect with a different field

Reinspection is an evaluation technique, not an admission of failure.

Change field direction (about 90°) when:

The suspected discontinuity would run parallel to the first field (longitudinal seam after only a coil shot; transverse crack after only a head shot).

The first pattern is weak, broken, or one-sided and may be orientation-limited.

The procedure requires two directions on every area and the second direction is still due.

Change current type when:

An AC-yoke pass is clean but the concern is near-surface (underbead, shallow burst). A DC or HWDC yoke, prods, or a bench head shot may be the procedure's next step.

A DC residual pattern is cluttered. An AC field can both examine the surface and help shake off residual writing.

Demagnetize and reinspect when:

You suspect magnetic writing or residual leakage from a previous shot.

Particles cling everywhere and you cannot tell geometry from discontinuity.

Do not keep dusting more dry powder onto a maybe. Over-application creates false lines and buries relevant ones.

Recording essential variables

If it is not recorded, it was not a controlled examination. The procedure lists essential variables ; typical MT records include:

  • Procedure identification and revision
  • Part identity, material, and area examined
  • Equipment identity (yoke, bench, power pack) and magnetization method
  • Current type (AC, HWDC, DC) and amperage or pole spacing / ampere-turns
  • Particle system (dry visible, wet visible, wet fluorescent), color or designation, and bath batch if wet
  • Lighting measurements (UV-A μW/cm² and ambient lux, or white-light lux)
  • Process-control status for that shift (yoke lift, bath centrifuge, system-performance piece)
  • Indication data: relevant / nonrelevant / false; linear / rounded; length; location; disposition
  • Technician identification and date

ASME Section V, Article 7 and ASTM E1444 both expect the examination to be reproducible from the record. A report that says only "MT OK" fails topic 9 even if the weld is perfect.

The procedure is the law

Evaluation has a hard stop. You may characterize. You may measure. You may recommend a grind-and-reinspect sequence if the procedure allows blending of shallow relevant indications. You may not :

  • Accept a crack-like relevant indication because "it will be painted" or "it always looks like that."
  • Reject a geometric collector because a supervisor "does not like powder on threads."

Swap in a different acceptance table from another job.

Use particle brightness or "how bad it looks" as a severity scale that the standard does not define.

If the governing specification is silent, the Level II does not invent a limit. The report describes the indication and states that no acceptance criterion was provided — and the work stops until the Level III or the customer names a standard.

Realistic exam scenarios

Particle buildup follows a bolt thread root for 360° and stops at the thread. No crack-like extension runs into the shank. The procedure treats geometric collectors as nonrelevant. Classification: nonrelevant . Disposition: accept for that indication. If a radial line leaves the root into the shank, that extension is relevant and goes to the length table.

A 3/16 in (5 mm) sharp line sits at a fillet-weld toe. The procedure rejects linear relevant indications longer than 1/8 in (3 mm). Classification: relevant, linear . Disposition: reject . The Level II does not call it undercut by eye and walk away.

A longitudinal coil shot on a bar is clean. The drawing shows a history of seams . Evaluation is incomplete until a circular field is applied. A clean single-direction exam is not a clean part.

A fluorescent line appears, then vanishes after a gentle rinse and does not return on a controlled reapply. That is a false drain or dirt line, not a crack that "healed."

Topic 9 rewards slow language: classify, describe, measure, compare, record. Speed without a standard is how Level II reports get torn up.