Study guide
17.3 Visual Appearance of Discontinuities
ASNT NDT Level II Certification Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Certification Paths: SNT-TC-1A, CP-189, and ASNT Central Certification 1.3 Level I vs Level II vs Level III Responsibilities 1.4 Application, Scheduling, Identification, and Retake Rules
2 Eligibility, Fees & Recertification
2.1 Training Hours, Experience Days, and Documentation 2.2 Vision, Practical Exams, and the Employer's Written Practice 2.3 Fees, Validity, Recertification, and 529 Funding
3 NDT Fundamentals & Method Selection
3.1 What NDT Can and Cannot Detect 3.2 Surface vs Subsurface and Method Selection Logic 3.3 Product Forms: Welds, Castings, Forgings, Wrought, In-Service Damage
4 MT Principles & Flux Fields
4.1 Magnetism, Permeability, and Flux Leakage 4.2 Flux Fields: Circular vs Longitudinal 4.3 How Discontinuities Distort Magnetic Fields
5 MT Magnetization & Demagnetization
5.1 Magnetization by Electric Current: Contact, Prods, Central Conductor 5.2 Selecting the Proper Magnetization Method: Coils, Yokes, Current Type 5.3 Demagnetization Procedures and Residual Field Limits
6 MT Equipment, Evaluation & Process Control
6.1 MT Equipment, Media, and Lighting 6.2 Types of Discontinuities Detected by MT 6.3 MT Evaluation Techniques 6.4 Quality Control of MT Equipment and Processes
7 PT Principles & Materials
7.1 PT Principles: Capillarity, Wetting, and Process Physics 7.2 Penetrant Types, Methods, and Sensitivity Classes 7.3 Developers and Process Sequence Controls
8 PT Method Selection & Process Control
8.1 Selecting the Appropriate PT Method for the Job 8.2 Surface Preparation, Dwell, Removal, and Lighting 8.3 Station Equipment, Process Control, and Safety
9 PT Indications, Evaluation & Standards
9.1 Relevant, Nonrelevant, and False Indications 9.2 Evaluating Indication Size, Shape, and Persistence 9.3 PT Procedures, ASTM/ASME Standards, and Acceptance
10 RT Principles & Exposure Technique
10.1 Radiation Physics: X-ray vs Gamma, Energy, and Attenuation 10.2 Exposure Geometry, Inverse Square Law, and Geometric Unsharpness 10.3 Radiographic Technique: kV, mA-min, Screens, and Source Selection
11 RT Image Quality, Processing & Indications
11.1 Film, Digital Detectors, Density, and Image Quality Indicators 11.2 Darkroom Facilities, Processing, and Artifact Control 11.3 Radiographic Indications, Discontinuities, and Defects
12 RT Product Discontinuities & Radiation Safety
12.1 Manufacturing Processes and Associated Discontinuities 12.2 Radiological Safety: Time, Distance, Shielding, and Dose Limits 12.3 RT Procedures, Codes, and Viewing Practice
13 UT Principles & Techniques
13.1 Sound Propagation, Modes, Velocity, and Wavelength 13.2 Transducers, Couplant, and Straight-Beam Techniques 13.3 Angle-Beam Techniques, Snell's Law, and Skip Distance
14 UT Calibration & Base Material
14.1 Calibration Blocks, DAC, TCG, and Sensitivity Setting 14.2 Evaluating Base-Material Product Forms 14.3 Evaluating Weldments
15 UT Bonds, Detection & Evaluation
15.1 Evaluating Bonded Structures 15.2 Discontinuity Detection and Characterization 15.3 General Evaluation, Sizing, and Acceptance Logic
16 VT Scope, Vision & Lighting
16.1 Purpose and Scope of VT 16.2 Elements of Vision 16.3 Elements of Lighting 16.4 Contrast and Resolution
17 VT Optics, Equipment & Discontinuities
17.1 Optics and Magnification 17.2 VT Equipment: Direct, Remote, and Measuring Tools 17.3 Visual Appearance of Discontinuities
18 VT Evaluation, Codes & Employer Topics
18.1 Evaluation and Reporting 18.2 Codes, Standards, and Specifications 18.3 Employer-Specific Topics and Written-Practice Controls
19 Specific Exam: Codes & Sectors
19.1 How the Specific Exam Differs from the General Exam 19.2 General Industry Codes and Procedure Use 19.3 Pressure Equipment Sector Codes (ASME, NBIC, API context)
20 Specific Exam: Applications & Techniques
20.1 Applications: Matching Method to Product Form and Access 20.2 Technique Selection and Essential Variables 20.3 Procedure Compliance, Reporting, and Acceptance/Rejection
21 Exam Strategy & Maintenance
21.1 Timed 50+40 Strategy and CBT Rules 21.2 Common Traps by Method 21.3 Weak-Area Review and Recertification Planning
17.3 Visual Appearance of Discontinuities
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Grazing light shows texture and tight openings; frontal light shows color; silhouette shows profile — use more than one angle before you name a line a crack.
Undercut is a melted groove at the toe; overlap is an unfused rolled lip; underfill is a sunken weld face; a crack is a tight fracture.
Surface-breaking incomplete fusion looks like a dark line or step at the fusion boundary, not like a rounded pore or a shy weld face.
Product form changes the picture: cold shuts and hot tears on castings, laps and seams on forgings, regular tool lay on machined parts, process faults on welds.
Arc strikes remelt parent metal; spatter sits on it; mechanical damage is directional with displaced metal; pitting is a cavity a pit gauge can read.
Last updated: August 2026
The ASNT NDT Level II visual-testing general exam lists Visual Appearance of Discontinuities as official VT topic 7. The items are not asking you to recite an acceptance table — that work sits in evaluation, reporting, and codes (the next chapter). This topic asks whether you can name what you see : how a crack looks versus undercut, overlap, porosity, underfill, surface-breaking incomplete fusion, an arc strike, spatter, corrosion, pitting, mechanical damage, and misalignment, and how that picture changes with product form and lighting angle .
An indication is what you see. A discontinuity is an interruption in the typical structure of the material. A defect is a discontinuity that fails the named acceptance standard . Topic 7 lives in the first two words. Candidates who jump from a dark line to "reject" have skipped the work this topic tests.
Lighting angle: texture versus profile
Lighting is not a comfort item. It is how appearance is created.
Lighting What it reveals What it hides or fakes
Grazing / low-angle (beam nearly parallel to the surface) Texture, tight cracks, laps, seams, shallow undercut, tool marks, grinding scratches Overall color and heat tint; can over-dramatize harmless ripples
Frontal / diffuse Color, contrast, stains, heat tint, general corrosion, printed marks, spatter as discrete blobs Tight linear openings that do not cast a shadow
Silhouette / grazing along a profile Reinforcement height, underfill as a valley, undercut as a notch, hi-lo mismatch, an overlap lip The interior of a pit
Oblique from two directions A real groove — the shadow moves and the opening persists — versus a stain that never becomes a groove —
Rule: use at least two lighting directions before you name a tight linear mark a crack. A grind scratch lights up from one direction and dies from the other. A crack that is open stays a dark, often jagged line more persistently and does not follow the regular lay of a grind or a tool.
Coaxial light down a borescope can wash texture . If the only light is on-axis, a tight toe crack can vanish. Add a grazing component, or rock the tip, before you write NI.
- How weld discontinuities look
- Cracks
A crack is a fracture. Visually it is a tight, linear opening, often jagged or branched , sometimes with a slight mismatch of the two faces. It can be extremely fine. Confirm with 5–10× and grazing light from more than one side.
Locations teach the name:
Toe crack — leaves the fusion line into the HAZ or along the toe.
Throat or centerline crack — along the weld axis, often a hot / solidification crack.
Crater crack — star-shaped in an unfilled crater at a stop.
Root crack — on an accessible root, a tight line at the root face or HAZ.
Underbead crack — may be invisible to VT until it breaks the surface. Absence of a surface line is not proof the HAZ is uncracked.
Do not confuse a crack with slag lines (wider, often pickable), grind marks (parallel, uniform, shiny), or weld ripples (regular, rounded). Product-form cousins — a cold shut , a forging lap , a seam — can look linear. Name them from origin and shape , not from the single word "line."
Undercut
Undercut is a groove melted into the base metal at the toe (or at an accessible root). It looks like a dark shadow line along the fusion boundary and, in silhouette, like a notch . An undercut gauge or a pit-style bridge seats across the adjacent plate and reads depth . The bottom is a melted groove, not a fracture through solid metal.
Continuous or intermittent. Not underfill (the weld face itself is shy). Not a crack (tight fracture, no melted groove). Not hi-lo (member offset).
Overlap
Overlap (cold lap) is weld metal that rolls over onto the parent without fusing . It looks like a rolled lip or a shelf. Lighting from the parent-metal side throws a shadow under the lip. A fingernail or a thin feeler may enter the crevice. That crevice is a ready-made crack starter. VT should catch overlap because it is a surface profile condition, not a subsurface plane.
Porosity
Porosity is trapped gas. On the surface it looks like rounded pinholes or craters , scattered, clustered, or aligned. Piping (worm-hole) porosity is elongated, often nearly perpendicular to the face. A cluster is a field of holes , not a crack. Do not promote a line of pores into a linear crack without seeing a fracture that connects them.
Underfill
Underfill is a weld face or accessible root that sits below the adjacent parent surface. The joint looks sunken — a valley. A straightedge rocks; silhouette lighting makes the valley obvious. It is the weld metal that is shy, not a groove melted into the plate beside the weld.
Incomplete fusion at the surface
Incomplete fusion (lack of fusion) that breaks the surface looks like a tight dark line or a step at the fusion boundary — unfused bevel, unfused land, or unfused interpass that you can see. A thin feeler or a probe may enter. Distinguish it from a toe crack by location (unmelted face versus a fracture through melted metal or HAZ) and from a pore by shape (linear step versus a rounded cavity).
Incomplete penetration at an open root looks like a leftover land or a dark centerline groove — the joint was not consumed. Different name, same visual idea: you can still see the original joint.
Arc strikes and spatter
An arc strike is a localized remelt of parent metal off the intended weld (or beside it). It looks like a small crater with a halo of heat tint, and it may contain a crack in the crater. It is not a blob sitting on the surface.
Spatter is discrete globules of weld metal stuck to the surface — scattered BBs, sometimes with a tiny neck. Frontal light shows them. Dense spatter can hide a toe. Spatter sits on the metal; an arc strike remelts it.
Reinforcement and profile
Excess reinforcement is extra metal on the face — a high convex bead, obvious in silhouette. Insufficient fillet throat is a concave or undersize profile that a fillet gauge reads. Those are geometry conditions. They are not cracks.
- Corrosion, pitting, mechanical damage, misalignment
- Corrosion
General corrosion looks like rust, scale, loss of mill finish, color change, and roughness. Localized corrosion is a patch, under-deposit attack, or crevice rust at a lap or a bolt. VT sees color, texture, and corrosion product . It does not measure remaining wall unless you add a pit gauge, a remaining-thickness tool, or another method. Heat tint on stainless is a color map, not automatically metal loss.
Pitting
Pitting is a discrete cavity , often with an undercut mouth or a dark or bright bottom. A pit gauge bridges on surrounding metal and drops a stylus into the pit. Do not confuse service pits with as-welded surface porosity (rounded, in weld metal, from the process) or with gas holes on a casting (solidification, often toward the cope).
Mechanical damage
Gouges, nicks, clamp marks, grind gouges, tool chatter, scoring, and handling dents are directional . They often show displaced metal or a bright cut. Grind marks are parallel and regular; a crack is not. A grind that erases a weld toe can also erase the evidence of undercut — record the repair, do not pretend the toe was never there.
Misalignment
Hi-lo / mismatch is one member standing above the other at the joint. It looks like a step . A hi-lo gauge reads it. Related pictures: out-of-plane distortion, angular misalignment, a root gap that is too tight or too wide. Misalignment is geometry . It can hide or exaggerate undercut and can look like overlap if you only glance.
Product-form differences
The same English word does not look the same on every product. Chapter 3 sorted origin families; this topic is the photograph .
Product What VT is usually hunting What it looks like What it is not
Weld Process faults above Toes, faces, roots, HAZ, adjacent parent A plate lamination will not look like a weld-toe crack
Casting Surface porosity, cold shuts , hot tears , misruns, sand inclusions, chaplets, parting-line mismatch, scabs Cold shut: a smooth, often oxidized line where two streams met and did not fuse. Hot tear: ragged, oxidized, at a change of section. Misrun: incomplete fill, rounded cold edges. Parting line: a mold match, not a fracture. Do not call a parting line a crack. Do not call as-cast shrink a service pit.
Forging / wrought Laps , seams , bursts, scale pits Lap: a fold of metal, often with scale inside, a crease parallel to the working direction . Seam: a tight longitudinal line from an elongated inclusion or rolled-out crack. A lap can look like a crack until you see the folded lip and the scale .
Machined Tool marks, chatter, scoring, nicks, burrs, leftover stock Regular, periodic marks matching the tool ; chatter is wavy; a nick is local Regular tool marks are not cracks. A crack crosses the lay .
Service damage can sit on any product. Fatigue cracks are tight, often at toes, keyways, and section changes. They need grazing light and 5–10×. Early fatigue is a poor radiographic target; it is a visual and surface-method target once it breaks the surface.
Realistic exam scenarios
A dark line at the toe is jagged, opens under grazing light from two directions, and does not accept an undercut-gauge seat as a melted groove. Appearance: crack , not undercut.
A groove is melted into the plate at the toe, the shadow is a notch in silhouette, and an undercut gauge reads a depth. Appearance: undercut , not overlap and not underfill.
A rolled lip at the toe throws a shadow underneath and a feeler enters. Appearance: overlap .
A straightedge rocks on a sunken weld face; the plate beside the weld is intact. Appearance: underfill .
On a sand casting, a smooth oxidized line sits where two streams met. Appearance: cold shut — a casting confluence, not a weld-toe crack and not a machined tool mark.
On a forging, a crease with scale runs parallel to grain flow and shows a folded lip. Appearance: lap , not a fatigue crack and not weld overlap.
On a machined shaft, regular spiral marks follow the tool. Appearance: tool lay . A tighter line that crosses that lay is the crack candidate.
Topic 7 language is short: name what it looks like , which light revealed it, and which product form can even produce it. The table that accepts or rejects it is the next chapter.