Study guide
18.1 Evaluation and Reporting
ASNT NDT Level II Certification Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Certification Paths: SNT-TC-1A, CP-189, and ASNT Central Certification 1.3 Level I vs Level II vs Level III Responsibilities 1.4 Application, Scheduling, Identification, and Retake Rules
2 Eligibility, Fees & Recertification
2.1 Training Hours, Experience Days, and Documentation 2.2 Vision, Practical Exams, and the Employer's Written Practice 2.3 Fees, Validity, Recertification, and 529 Funding
3 NDT Fundamentals & Method Selection
3.1 What NDT Can and Cannot Detect 3.2 Surface vs Subsurface and Method Selection Logic 3.3 Product Forms: Welds, Castings, Forgings, Wrought, In-Service Damage
4 MT Principles & Flux Fields
4.1 Magnetism, Permeability, and Flux Leakage 4.2 Flux Fields: Circular vs Longitudinal 4.3 How Discontinuities Distort Magnetic Fields
5 MT Magnetization & Demagnetization
5.1 Magnetization by Electric Current: Contact, Prods, Central Conductor 5.2 Selecting the Proper Magnetization Method: Coils, Yokes, Current Type 5.3 Demagnetization Procedures and Residual Field Limits
6 MT Equipment, Evaluation & Process Control
6.1 MT Equipment, Media, and Lighting 6.2 Types of Discontinuities Detected by MT 6.3 MT Evaluation Techniques 6.4 Quality Control of MT Equipment and Processes
7 PT Principles & Materials
7.1 PT Principles: Capillarity, Wetting, and Process Physics 7.2 Penetrant Types, Methods, and Sensitivity Classes 7.3 Developers and Process Sequence Controls
8 PT Method Selection & Process Control
8.1 Selecting the Appropriate PT Method for the Job 8.2 Surface Preparation, Dwell, Removal, and Lighting 8.3 Station Equipment, Process Control, and Safety
9 PT Indications, Evaluation & Standards
9.1 Relevant, Nonrelevant, and False Indications 9.2 Evaluating Indication Size, Shape, and Persistence 9.3 PT Procedures, ASTM/ASME Standards, and Acceptance
10 RT Principles & Exposure Technique
10.1 Radiation Physics: X-ray vs Gamma, Energy, and Attenuation 10.2 Exposure Geometry, Inverse Square Law, and Geometric Unsharpness 10.3 Radiographic Technique: kV, mA-min, Screens, and Source Selection
11 RT Image Quality, Processing & Indications
11.1 Film, Digital Detectors, Density, and Image Quality Indicators 11.2 Darkroom Facilities, Processing, and Artifact Control 11.3 Radiographic Indications, Discontinuities, and Defects
12 RT Product Discontinuities & Radiation Safety
12.1 Manufacturing Processes and Associated Discontinuities 12.2 Radiological Safety: Time, Distance, Shielding, and Dose Limits 12.3 RT Procedures, Codes, and Viewing Practice
13 UT Principles & Techniques
13.1 Sound Propagation, Modes, Velocity, and Wavelength 13.2 Transducers, Couplant, and Straight-Beam Techniques 13.3 Angle-Beam Techniques, Snell's Law, and Skip Distance
14 UT Calibration & Base Material
14.1 Calibration Blocks, DAC, TCG, and Sensitivity Setting 14.2 Evaluating Base-Material Product Forms 14.3 Evaluating Weldments
15 UT Bonds, Detection & Evaluation
15.1 Evaluating Bonded Structures 15.2 Discontinuity Detection and Characterization 15.3 General Evaluation, Sizing, and Acceptance Logic
16 VT Scope, Vision & Lighting
16.1 Purpose and Scope of VT 16.2 Elements of Vision 16.3 Elements of Lighting 16.4 Contrast and Resolution
17 VT Optics, Equipment & Discontinuities
17.1 Optics and Magnification 17.2 VT Equipment: Direct, Remote, and Measuring Tools 17.3 Visual Appearance of Discontinuities
18 VT Evaluation, Codes & Employer Topics
18.1 Evaluation and Reporting 18.2 Codes, Standards, and Specifications 18.3 Employer-Specific Topics and Written-Practice Controls
19 Specific Exam: Codes & Sectors
19.1 How the Specific Exam Differs from the General Exam 19.2 General Industry Codes and Procedure Use 19.3 Pressure Equipment Sector Codes (ASME, NBIC, API context)
20 Specific Exam: Applications & Techniques
20.1 Applications: Matching Method to Product Form and Access 20.2 Technique Selection and Essential Variables 20.3 Procedure Compliance, Reporting, and Acceptance/Rejection
21 Exam Strategy & Maintenance
21.1 Timed 50+40 Strategy and CBT Rules 21.2 Common Traps by Method 21.3 Weak-Area Review and Recertification Planning
18.1 Evaluation and Reporting
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
A complete VT evaluation measures, locates from a stated datum, and describes type, length, orientation, and depth only when the visual tools can actually measure it.
Relevant means a discontinuity or geometric condition the acceptance table must see; nonrelevant means known permitted contour such as weld ripple; relevant is not the same word as rejectable.
Weld ripple is typical solidification contour; a sharp irregular line that leaves the ripple and enters the HAZ is evaluated as a relevant crack-like indication, not as more ripple.
When acceptance depends on depth or opening that VT cannot measure, stop the visual accept/reject, report what you can measure, and request the complementary method the procedure names.
A VT record that the procedure requires is not a lone check-mark: type, measurable size, orientation, location, disposition, and the named sketch or photograph belong on the form before a hold-point sign-off.
Last updated: August 2026
The ASNT NDT Level II visual general exam lists Evaluation and Reporting as official VT topic 8. Those items are not asking whether you can see a weld bead. They are asking whether you can measure , locate , and describe what you see, tell relevant geometry from a discontinuity , know when visual testing has reached its limit, and leave an auditable record that a Level III or a customer can reconstruct without standing next to you.
Visual testing (VT) reports conditions that are open to the viewed surface — or that change the surface contour enough to be seen under the procedure's lighting and viewing rules. An indication is what you observe. A discontinuity is an interruption in the typical structure or contour of the material or weld. A defect is a discontinuity that the named acceptance standard rejects. Evaluation is the work of moving from the first word to the third without guessing depth you did not measure and without calling every shadow a crack.
Measure, locate, and describe
A Level II who writes "undercut noted" has not evaluated anything. The method's product is a description that another qualified person can take to the same weld and find the same condition. Three verbs sit on every serious VT report.
Verb What you record What you do not invent
Measure Length along the surface; width if the procedure wants it; depth or height if a gauge or optical aid can actually measure it ; remaining fillet leg or throat if that is the table's unit A crack depth inferred from how "dark" the line looks; an undercut depth guessed as half the visible width
Locate Distance from a stated datum — weld centerline, a stamped reference, a clock position, a station or node number, a nozzle mark, or a map grid the traveler names "Near the middle," "on the good side," or a photo with no scale and no identity
Describe Type (crack-like, undercut, porosity, overlap, underfill, reinforcement, mismatch, arc strike, pit, and so on), orientation (longitudinal, transverse, branching), and which surface (weld metal, HAZ , base metal, root, face, toe) A diagnosis you cannot support ("hydrogen crack, first pass") when the visual evidence is only "linear, transverse, 12 mm, toe of weld 3"
Depth if measurable is the phrase that separates honest VT from fiction. A fillet-weld gauge , a V-WAC or similar undercut gauge, a high-low / mismatch gauge, and a reinforcement / cam gauge measure contour . They do not measure how far a tight crack runs into the throat. If the acceptance table rejects on undercut depth and the gauge fits the groove, you measure depth and apply the table. If the acceptance table rejects on crack depth and all you have is a surface line, you do not assign a millimetre depth from appearance.
Orientation is not decoration. A longitudinal crack-like line in weld metal is a different evaluation problem from a transverse line that crosses the toe into the HAZ. Branching or a sharp change of direction is part of the description because it is how a crack distinguishes itself from a straight tool mark or a weld ripple crest.
Location without a datum is not a location. "Undercut on the downstream toe, 40 mm starting 15 mm from the upstream edge of stamp W12, clockwise from the 12 o'clock flow mark" is a location. "Undercut on that weld we did Tuesday" is a conversation.
Relevant, nonrelevant, and false — VT versions
The same three classes used in magnetic particle and penetrant evaluation apply here. Collapsing them into "real crack" versus "junk" misses items.
Class Cause Typical VT examples First action
Relevant A discontinuity or a geometric condition the acceptance table addresses Surface-breaking cracks, open porosity, undercut , overlap , underfill , excess reinforcement , mismatch , incomplete fusion visible at the surface, arc strikes, pitting Measure, locate, describe, then compare with the named table
Nonrelevant Known geometry or a permitted surface condition, not a rejectable discontinuity by itself Regular weld ripple / weave contour, permitted as-welded face roughness, a designed groove or hole, a allowed mill-scale or heat-tint condition when the specification leaves that surface as-rolled or as-welded Identify the geometry; look for a crack-like extension beyond it; record the class
False Not caused by a discontinuity or by intended part geometry Dirt, oil, marker, grinding smear , loose mill scale flakes, rust stain that is only color, a shadow from low-angle light, a paint run Clean or change lighting and look again; do not measure a smear as undercut
Relevant is not rejectable. Undercut is a relevant geometric condition even when the measured depth is inside the table. You still measure it. You do not ignore it because "codes allow some undercut." You also do not reject every relevant indication on sight. The table decides defect versus acceptable discontinuity after you have described the condition in the table's units.
Weld ripple versus crack
Weld ripple (the regular, repeating solidification lines of a stringer or weave) is typical weld contour . It follows the travel and oscillation. Crests are blunt, spacing is roughly even, and the lines stay inside the weld face. That pattern is nonrelevant geometry unless a specification demands a blended or ground finish and the ripple violates that finish requirement.
A crack that a Level II is expected to catch visually is a sharp , often irregular line. It may start in a crater, at a toe, or in a stop-start. It does not keep the ripple spacing. The teaching contrast the outline wants is this: a line that leaves the ripple , crosses the toe , and continues into the HAZ is not more contour. It is a relevant crack-like indication until proven otherwise. Do not grind it "to see if it goes away" unless the procedure authorizes metal removal as part of evaluation, and never grind away the only evidence before it is recorded.
A crater crack sits in the termination puddle and is often star-shaped or short and jagged. It is relevant. A neatly filled crater with only the same ripple as the rest of the bead is contour.
Mill scale versus pitting
Mill scale is the oxide layer from hot rolling or high-temperature exposure. Intact scale can look dark, flaky, or mapped. Loose flakes, color change alone, and scale that the specification allows to remain on an as-rolled surface are not automatically pits . Pitting is metal loss: a cavity with a measurable mouth, a remnant wall, or a cluster of depressions in the base metal or weld. You distinguish them by contour and metal loss , not by how brown the surface is. A rust bloom that wipes off and leaves the original surface is stain (often false or nonrelevant discoloration). A cavity that remains after cleaning is pitting and is relevant . Depth of a pit is recorded only if a gauge or optical method the procedure allows can measure it; otherwise you record mouth size, location, and that depth was not visually measurable.
Related pairs use the same logic. A grinding mark is a broad, directional scratch with a visible lay; a crack is sharp and does not follow the wheel. Spatter is attached droplets; porosity is a cavity in the metal. Heat tint is color; underfill is missing weld metal below the plate surface. Learn the pair, then measure the one that is a discontinuity.
When to stop and request another method
VT is a surface method. It is excellent at contour and at open, visible discontinuities. It is the wrong last word when the acceptance question is something the eye cannot answer. Stop the visual accept/reject — not the job, unless safety requires it — and request the complementary method the procedure or the ITP already names, or elevate to the Level III if the document is silent.
Stop and call another method when:
A linear indication might be a tight crack and the procedure names MT or PT for confirmation of surface breaking.
The table rejects on depth (crack depth, remaining wall, or an undercut the gauge cannot enter) and VT cannot measure that depth.
The concern is subsurface — incomplete penetration not open to the viewed face, lamellar tearing, or a buried lack of fusion — and the contract already requires UT, RT, or another volumetric method at that joint.
Surface condition blocks VT (coating, heavy scale that this hold point does not allow you to remove, or a geometry the eye cannot resolve) and remote optics still cannot meet the procedure's resolution.
Remote VT in a tube or vessel shows a feature smaller than the system can reliably measure, and the procedure requires a measurable record.
What you do not do is invent a PT or MT exam because you are curious, skip a required VT hold point because "UT will catch it later," or accept a crack-like line because "it is only visual." Complementary methods answer the question VT cannot. They do not erase the duty to describe what VT already saw.
Report forms, sketches, and photographs
The report is the product. A traveler check-box is not a substitute unless the written practice and the procedure explicitly treat that box as the complete record for a no-indication exam. When relevant indications exist, or when the procedure requires a narrative even for accept, the record typically carries:
- Item identity: job, drawing, weld or part number, heat or serial if used
- Procedure identity and revision , plus the named acceptance standard
- Technique: direct or remote, magnification if used, lighting arrangement if the procedure records it
- Measuring aids actually used (fillet gauge, undercut gauge, scale)
- Date, inspector identification, and certification level the written practice requires on the form
For each relevant indication: type , length , depth or height if measured , orientation , location from a datum , surface, photo or sketch reference, and disposition (accept, reject, hold, or "evaluate by [method]")
A sketch needs a datum, a weld cross-section or plan view that matches the joint, and dimensions. A photograph needs identification in the frame or in the file name the procedure specifies, a scale or a known feature, and lighting that does not hide the contour you claim to have measured. A beautiful photo of an unlocated weld is not a report. A report that says "see photo" with no measurements is not an evaluation.
If you cleaned, ground under authorization, or changed lighting to dismiss a false indication, record that action. Tomorrow's auditor should not have to guess why the first photo showed a black line and the second did not.
Hold points
A hold point is a planned stop in fabrication or in-service work where VT (or another examination) must be completed and signed before the next operation hides the surface. Typical visual hold points include fit-up (alignment, root opening, cleanliness), root pass , after back-gouge, final visual of the completed weld, after postweld heat treatment when the procedure wants a re-look at contour, and in-service or shutdown VT of the same geometry.
You sign a hold point only after the examination the procedure describes is finished and the record exists. You do not sign ahead so welding can continue. You do not sign a hold point you could not access. You do not waive a hold point because the weld "looks fine from the platform." If the surface will be covered — insulation, coating, the next weld pass, a fitting — the hold point is there because later VT cannot reconstruct what you were supposed to see.
A reject or a hold at a hold point stops that operation until disposition. The Level II's job is to document the condition and the stop. The Level III, engineering, or the customer, as the written practice names them, owns a repair or use-as-is decision that changes acceptance.
Realistic exam scenarios
A stem shows a regular weave on the face and a sharp line leaving the toe into the HAZ: classify the weave as contour and the line as relevant; measure and locate the line. A stem gives length and a photo but asks for depth of a hairline crack: the correct move is that depth is not measurable by VT. A stem offers a rust-colored plate with flakes that wipe off versus a cavity that remains after cleaning: stain versus pitting. A stem asks what belongs on the report when the procedure requires a record: type, measurable size, orientation, datum location, disposition, and the named sketch or photo — not a lone accept check. A stem places you at a root-pass hold point you cannot see: you do not sign; you get access or you elevate the missed hold point.