Study guide

9.4 Reviewing Client Requirements and Product-Form MT Specifications

ASNT NDT Level III Magnetic Particle Testing MT

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Magnetization Principles and Physics

1.1 Magnetic Fields, Poles, and Domain Theory 1.2 The Hysteresis Loop and B-H Curve 1.3 Longitudinal vs. Circular Magnetization Fields 1.4 Magnetic Flux Leakage Theory and Defect Detectability 1.5 Probability of Detection, Reliability, and Technique Validation

2 Chapter 2: Direct Contact and Longitudinal Magnetization Techniques

2.1 Head Shots and Direct Contact Techniques 2.2 Prod Techniques and Localized Circular Magnetization 2.3 Longitudinal Coil Magnetization and Calculations

3 Chapter 3: Central Conductor, Yoke, and Vector Magnetization

3.1 Central Conductor (Induced Current) Techniques 3.2 Electromagnetic Yokes and Portable Field Techniques 3.3 Multidirectional and Vector Magnetization

4 Chapter 4: Magnetic Particles and Carrier Vehicles

4.1 Particle Characteristics: Physical, Magnetic, and Optical Properties 4.2 Dry Powder Systems and Application Techniques 4.3 Wet Particle Systems: Water vs. Petroleum Distillate Vehicles 4.4 Bath Concentration, Centrifuge Settling, and Maintenance

5 Chapter 5: Electrical Waveforms, Equipment, and Demagnetization

5.1 Current Waveforms and Penetration: AC, HWDC, FWDC, and 3-Phase FWDC 5.2 Stationary Wet Horizontal Benches and Portable Units 5.3 Demagnetization Principles, Methods, and Residual Field Limits

6 Chapter 6: Quality Control, Calibration, and System Performance

6.1 Lighting and Viewing Environment Requirements 6.2 Field Indicators and System Performance Check Devices 6.3 Equipment Calibration and Periodic Verifications 6.4 Bath Contamination, Water Break, and Cleanliness Tests

7 Chapter 7: Inherent and Primary Processing Discontinuities

7.1 Ingot and Casting Discontinuities 7.2 Wrought and Primary Forming Discontinuities 7.3 Secondary Processing Discontinuities: Machining and Heat Treating

8 Chapter 8: Service Discontinuities and Indication Evaluation

8.1 Service Discontinuities: Fatigue, Stress Corrosion, and Creep 8.2 Welding Discontinuities and Weldment Examination 8.3 Indication Classification: Relevant, Non-Relevant, and False 8.4 MT Reports, Records, and Documentation Review

9 Chapter 9: Industry Codes, Standards, and Acceptance Criteria

9.1 ASME Section V, Article 7 (Mandatory MT Requirements) 9.2 ASTM E1444 vs. ASTM E709 vs. ISO 9934 9.3 Acceptance Criteria in Fabrication Codes: ASME VIII, AWS D1.1, and API 1104 9.4 Reviewing Client Requirements and Product-Form MT Specifications

10 Chapter 10: Level III Responsibilities, Procedures, Training, and Program Oversight

10.1 Level III Duties, SNT-TC-1A, and ANSI/ASNT CP-189 10.2 Preparation and Qualification of MT Written Procedures 10.3 Safety, Environmental, and Health Considerations in MT 10.4 Developing and Delivering MT Training Programs 10.5 Developing and Administering MT Qualification Examinations 10.6 MT Program Audits, Supplier Oversight, and Personnel Performance

9.4 Reviewing Client Requirements and Product-Form MT Specifications

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ISO 17638 gives the magnetic particle technique for welds while ISO 23278 gives the acceptance levels, so invoking only one of the pair leaves either the method or the accept/reject basis unstated.

SAE AMS 2641 qualifies the petroleum-base vehicle and the AMS 3040 to AMS 3046 series qualifies the magnetic particles, so a purchase order citing only ASTM E1444 leaves consumable qualification undefined.

MIL-STD-1949 has been superseded by ASTM E1444; a Level III cannot certify compliance to a cancelled document and must obtain written customer concurrence before substituting the successor.

Compliance is resolved parameter by parameter using the most restrictive applicable value, not document by document, because invoked documents commonly differ on dark adaptation, UV-A minimum, verification intervals, and residual field limits.

Evaluating a subcontractor's MT capability means examining its written practice, qualified procedures, current certifications and vision records, traceable calibration and process-control logs, and ideally a witnessed demonstration.

Last updated: September 2026

9.4 Reviewing Client Requirements and Product-Form MT Specifications

Two of the five official Level III MT topic areas contain tasks that are contractual rather than technical: "interpret Codes, Standards, and Specification MT requirements" and "review client MT requirements." In practice these are the tasks that consume a working Level III's week. A purchase order arrives citing four documents of different vintage, two of which conflict, one of which was cancelled a decade ago, and the shop needs a technique sheet by Thursday.

Chapters 9.1 through 9.3 covered the three documents that dominate North American fabrication: ASME Section V Article 7 (how), ASTM E1444 and E709 and ISO 9934 (practice and guidance), and the construction codes that own acceptance criteria. This section covers the rest of the document landscape and the review process that turns it into one defensible technique.

The MT Specification Landscape Beyond the Big Three

Document Family Representative Documents What It Controls

Aerospace consumables SAE AMS 2641 (petroleum-base magnetic particle inspection vehicle); AMS 3040 through AMS 3046 (the magnetic particles themselves — dry non-fluorescent, wet non-fluorescent concentrates and ready-to-use suspensions, and wet fluorescent concentrates and suspensions) Qualification of the materials, not the technique. A purchase order that invokes ASTM E1444 without an AMS particle specification leaves consumable qualification unstated.

Aerospace reference standards SAE AS 5371 (notched shims / QQIs); SAE AS 5282 (tool steel ring, the Ketos/Betz ring) The artifacts used for field verification and system performance checks.

Aerospace personnel NAS 410 (US) and EN 4179 (Europe), which are maintained in close correspondence Qualification and certification of MT personnel in aviation, space, and defence, including the Responsible Level III concept and stricter vision requirements.

Weld-specific international ISO 17638 (non-destructive testing of welds — magnetic particle testing) and ISO 23278 (acceptance levels for magnetic particle testing of welds) Technique and acceptance for weldments outside the ASME/AWS system. Note the split: ISO 17638 tells you how, ISO 23278 tells you what is acceptable.

Product-form practices ASTM A275 (magnetic particle examination of steel forgings) and comparable product-form practices for castings, tubing, and bar Method details that vary by product form; A275, for example, sets its own DC yoke lifting requirement of 40 lbf at a 3 to 6 in. pole spacing.

Piping codes ASME B31.1 (power piping) and ASME B31.3 (process piping) When MT is required and the acceptance criteria; B31.3's magnetic particle criteria reject any crack or linear indication.

Legacy and cancelled MIL-STD-1949 (superseded by ASTM E1444); older AMS and company specifications still printed on 1980s drawings A live audit risk. A cancelled document cannot be complied with, and substituting its successor is an engineering decision that must be documented, not assumed.

Audit criteria Customer quality-system audits and the Nadcap NDT audit criteria (the AC7114 series, which includes a magnetic particle checklist) How a third party will judge the programme, which in practice sets the documentation bar higher than the technical codes do.

A Structured Client Requirement Review

Treat requirement review as a documented engineering activity with an output artifact — a requirements matrix — rather than as reading a purchase order.

Step 1 — Build the document tree. List every document invoked, with revision and date: purchase order, drawing and its notes, prime-contractor process specification, industry standard, construction code, personnel standard. Record the invocation path, because a document invoked by another document is still binding.

Step 2 — Check currency and existence. Confirm each document is current and obtainable. Cancelled or superseded documents, and revisions that do not exist, are raised to the customer in writing before work starts.

Step 3 — Extract parameter by parameter. For each controlled parameter, record what each document says: +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | EXAMPLE PARAMETER EXTRACTION (abridged requirements matrix) |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | Parameter | ASME V Art 7 | ASTM E1444 | Customer Spec |
  • |--------------------+----------------+----------------+----------------------|
  • | Dark adaptation | >= 5 min | >= 1 min | silent |
  • | Ambient white light| <= 2 fc | <= 2 fc | <= 1 fc |
  • | UV-A at surface | >= 1000 uW/cm2 | >= 1000 uW/cm2 | 1200 to 2500 uW/cm2 |
  • | Yoke lift check | each day used | 6 months | each shift |
  • | Residual field | no number | 3 G | 2 G max |
  • | Acceptance criteria| none (defers) | per drawing | per drawing + spec |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Step 4 — Apply the most-restrictive rule, parameter by parameter. Compliance is not a document-level choice; it is a parameter-level one. In the matrix above the compliant technique uses a 5-minute dark adaptation, a 1 fc ambient ceiling, a 1 200 to 2 500 µW/cm² UV-A window, a daily yoke check, and a 2 G residual limit. Choosing "we work to E1444" would silently violate three customer requirements.

Step 5 — Resolve genuine conflicts in writing. A conflict exists when two requirements cannot both be met — not merely when they differ. Where a customer specification demands something the code forbids, or two invoked documents are mutually exclusive, the Level III raises a written technical query and obtains a written disposition. Verbal resolution with a buyer is not a record.

Step 6 — Flow the result down. The resolved requirement set must reach the technique sheet, the inspector's work instruction, the process control logs, the report form, and — where work is subcontracted — the subcontract documents. A requirement that stops at the Level III's desk has not been implemented.

Evaluating Whether a Supplier Can Actually Meet Them

"Evaluate contractor/subcontractor MT capabilities" is the other half of requirement review, and it is answered with evidence, not assurances:

Written practice — does it exist, does it name a designated Level III, and does it meet the personnel standard the customer invoked (SNT-TC-1A, CP-189, or NAS 410)?

Procedures — are they qualified for the material, thickness, coating, and geometry in question, and approved by a Level III qualified in MT?

Personnel — current certifications in MT at the required level, current annual vision records, and documented training and experience hours.

Equipment — calibration certificates traceable to a national metrology institute, with intervals matching whichever document governs, plus the process-control logs (concentration, contamination, ring or shim checks, lighting).

Demonstration — for critical work, a witnessed technique demonstration on representative hardware rather than a paper review alone.

Surveillance — a re-inspection or blind-sample agreement check after award, not just at qualification.

Worked Scenario: Four Documents, One Technique Sheet

Scenario: A purchase order for overhauled landing-gear pistons invokes (a) the customer's own MT process specification at Revision H, (b) ASTM E1444, (c) a drawing note citing "MIL-STD-1949," and (d) NAS 410 for personnel. The customer specification requires 1 500 µW/cm² minimum UV-A and a 1 G residual field limit. The shop's existing procedure was written to ASTM E1444 with 1 000 µW/cm² and 3 G.

Level III analysis and actions:

MIL-STD-1949 is superseded by ASTM E1444. The Level III cannot certify compliance to a cancelled standard. The substitution is raised in writing, and the customer's written concurrence is retained with the job record — an unrecorded substitution is a finding waiting to happen.

The customer specification is more restrictive on two parameters. The technique sheet must adopt 1 500 µW/cm² and 1 G, not the E1444 floors. Note also that a 1 G residual limit is near the practical floor set by Earth's ambient field, so the demagnetization procedure must include East-West part orientation and a defined measurement location.

NAS 410 changes the personnel gate, not the technique. Near-vision and colour-perception requirements are stricter than the SNT-TC-1A baseline, and NAS 410 requires annual practical evaluation or documented technical audit of each inspector. The Level III verifies that every assigned inspector's file satisfies NAS 410 specifically, and that a Responsible Level III is designated.

Consumables are unspecified. Neither the drawing nor the purchase order names an AMS particle specification. The Level III selects and documents a qualified particle and vehicle specification rather than leaving the consumable uncontrolled, and confirms batch certifications are on file.

Output. One technique sheet, listing every governing document with revision, the most-restrictive value adopted for each parameter, the written customer disposition on the MIL-STD-1949 substitution, and the specific acceptance criteria taken from the drawing.