Study guide
9.4 Variable Gage R&R: Repeatability and Reproducibility
ASQ Certified Quality Technician CQT
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Quality Philosophies, Principles, and Management Systems
1.1 Quality Philosophies & Pioneers 1.2 Quality Management Systems, Standards & Documentation 1.3 Customer-Supplier Relationships & Quality Culture
2 Chapter 2: Cost of Quality, Teams, and Professional Ethics
2.1 Cost of Quality (COQ) & Economic Trade-Offs 2.2 Quality Improvement Teams & Meeting Management 2.3 Professional Conduct & ASQ Code of Ethics
3 Chapter 3: Basic Quality Tools & Continuous Improvement
3.1 Process Mapping, Flowcharts, and SIPOC 3.2 Cause-and-Effect Analysis & Check Sheets 3.3 Pareto Analysis & Prioritization 3.4 Histograms & Scatter Diagrams
4 Chapter 4: Descriptive Statistics and Probability Distributions
4.1 Data Types, Sampling Methods, and Populations 4.2 Measures of Central Tendency and Dispersion 4.3 Normal Distribution & Z-Score Calculations 4.4 Discrete Distributions: Binomial, Poisson, and Hypergeometric
5 Chapter 5: Statistical Process Control (SPC) Fundamentals & Variables Charts
5.1 SPC Fundamentals & Process Variation 5.2 Control Limits vs. Specification Limits 5.3 X-bar and R Charts 5.4 X-bar & s Charts and Individual-Moving Range (I-MR) Charts
6 Chapter 6: Attributes Control Charts and Out-of-Control Patterns
6.1 Control Charts for Nonconforming Units: p and np Charts 6.2 Control Charts for Nonconformities: c and u Charts 6.3 Out-of-Control Rules & Process Analysis
7 Chapter 7: Process Capability and Performance Analysis
7.1 Process Stability Prerequisite & Capability Basics 7.2 Potential Capability (Cp) and Actual Capability (Cpk) 7.3 Process Performance (Pp, Ppk) and Long-Term vs. Short-Term Variation 7.4 One-Sided Tolerances and PPM Defect Calculations
8 Chapter 8: Metrology Fundamentals, Standards, and Calibration
8.1 Metrology Foundations & Environmental Controls 8.2 Precision Gage Blocks & Standards Hierarchy 8.3 Calibration Systems & NIST Traceability 8.4 Out-of-Calibration Procedures & Reverse Traceability 8.5 M&TE Identification, Control, and Customer-Supplied Equipment
9 Chapter 9: Measurement Instruments and Measurement System Analysis (Gage R&R)
9.1 Common Dimensional Hand Measuring Instruments 9.2 Fixed Gages, Optical Comparators, and CMM Systems 9.3 Measurement System Analysis: Bias, Linearity, and Stability 9.4 Variable Gage R&R: Repeatability and Reproducibility 9.5 Electronic, Weighing, and Force Measurement Equipment
10 Chapter 10: Technical Drawings, Tolerancing, and GD&T (ASME Y14.5)
10.1 Engineering Drawing Basics & Projection Methods 10.2 Datums and the Datum Reference Frame 10.3 Form and Orientation Controls in GD&T 10.4 Location, Profile, and Runout Controls with Modifiers 10.5 Classification of Product Characteristics and Defects
11 Chapter 11: Inspection Planning, Sampling Plans, and Material Disposition
11.1 Inspection Planning & Inspection Points 11.2 Acceptance Sampling & ANSI/ASQ Z1.4 11.3 Switching Rules & Variables Sampling (Z1.9) 11.4 Nonconforming Material Control & MRB Dispositions 11.5 Types of Measurements, Unit Conversion, and Rounding Rules
12 Chapter 12: Quality Audits
12.1 Quality Auditing Principles & Types 12.2 The Audit Process: Planning, Performance, and Reporting 12.3 Audit Tools and Techniques
13 Chapter 13: Risk Management, Corrective and Preventive Action, and Safety
13.1 Risk Assessment Inputs, Monitoring, and Control Plans 13.2 FMEA, Action Priority, and Technician Workplace Safety 13.3 Root Cause Analysis & Problem-Solving 13.4 Corrective and Preventive Action (CAPA) & Verification 13.5 Preventive Action, Mistake-Proofing, and Read-Across
9.4 Variable Gage R&R: Repeatability and Reproducibility
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Gage Repeatability (Equipment Variation, EV) quantifies the variation observed when one appraiser measures the same part multiple times with the same gage, representing short-term instrument noise.
Gage Reproducibility (Appraiser Variation, AV) quantifies the variation observed in measurement averages across different appraisers measuring identical parts with the same gage, representing operator technique differences.
Under AIAG guidelines, a measurement system is acceptable if %GRR < 10%, conditionally acceptable between 10% and 30% based on application criticality, and unacceptable if %GRR > 30%.
The Number of Distinct Categories (ndc = 1.41 * PV / GRR) defines the gage's effective discrimination relative to process variation, strictly requiring ndc >= 5 for valid statistical process control.
The ANOVA method is superior to the Average and Range method because it mathematically partitions and tests the Operator-by-Part interaction effect, revealing whether specific appraisers struggle with specific part geometries.
Last updated: September 2026
- 9.4 Variable Gage R&R: Repeatability and Reproducibility
- Understanding Precision: Repeatability (EV) and Reproducibility (AV)
While accuracy (bias, linearity, stability) assesses whether a measurement system is centered on the true reference standard, precision assesses the spread or dispersion of repeated measurements. In industrial quality control, precision is evaluated through a Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (Gage R&R) study.
Total measurement system precision error is mathematically partitioned into two distinct physical components: PRECISION ERROR DECOMPOSITION:
- TOTAL GAGE R&R VARIATION (sigma_GRR)
- |
- +----------------+----------------+
- | |
- REPEATABILITY REPRODUCIBILITY
- Equipment Variation (EV) Appraiser Variation (AV)
- | |
- Same appraiser - Different appraisers
- Same gage - Same gage
- Same part / characteristic - Same parts
- Short time intervals - Different techniques / clamping
- Inherent gage noise / play - Human interface differences
- 1. Repeatability (Equipment Variation, EV)
Repeatability is the variation observed when one appraiser uses the same gage to measure the same characteristic on the same identical part multiple times under identical operating conditions.
What it reflects : The inherent mechanical, structural, and electrical noise of the measurement device itself.
Root causes of high EV : Mechanical backlash in gear teeth, loose spindle bearings, sloppy slideways, electronic sensor drift, lack of gage rigidity, elastic fixture flexing, or friction in indicator dials.
2. Reproducibility (Appraiser Variation, AV)
Reproducibility is the variation observed in the average of measurements made by different appraisers using the same gage when measuring identical characteristics on the same set of parts.
What it reflects : The variability introduced by the human beings operating the measurement equipment.
Root causes of high AV : Inconsistent clamping force, differences in operator hand squeeze, varying sight angles causing parallax, improper part seating against datums, differing interpretations of zero, or poor operational training.
Combining EV and AV into Total Gage R&R ( G R R GRR GRR )
Because repeatability and reproducibility are independent sources of variance, their variances sum directly: σ G R R 2 = σ Repeatability 2 + σ Reproducibility 2 = σ E V 2 + σ A V 2 \sigma^2_{GRR} = \sigma^2_{\text{Repeatability}} + \sigma^2_{\text{Reproducibility}} = \sigma^2_{EV} + \sigma^2_{AV} σ GRR 2 = σ Repeatability 2 + σ Reproducibility 2 = σ E V 2 + σ A V 2 G R R = E V 2 + A V 2 \mathbf{GRR = \sqrt{EV^2 + AV^2}} GRR = E V 2 + A V 2
Variable Gage R&R Study Architecture and Design Rules
To perform a statistically rigorous variable Gage R&R study, the quality technician must follow standardized AIAG design protocols:
The Standard Study Structure: 10-3-3 Architecture
10 Parts ( n = 10 n = 10 n = 10 ) : Representative parts selected from the manufacturing process.
3 Appraisers ( k = 3 k = 3 k = 3 ) : Operators who normally inspect the product on production shifts.
3 Trials ( r = 3 r = 3 r = 3 ) : Each operator measures each part three separate times.
Total Data Points : 10 parts × 3 operators × 3 trials = 90 individual measurements 10 \text{ parts} \times 3 \text{ operators} \times 3 \text{ trials} = \mathbf{90 \text{ individual measurements}} 10 parts × 3 operators × 3 trials = 90 individual measurements . (Note: For coarse screening or smaller operations, a 10 × 2 × 2 = 40 10 \times 2 \times 2 = 40 10 × 2 × 2 = 40 -point study is sometimes permitted, but the 10-3-3 structure is the industrial benchmark).
Three Inflexible Execution Rules
Parts Must Span Process Variation : The 10 parts must not be chosen consecutively from one hour of production. They must be selected randomly across days or shifts to encompass the full range of historical manufacturing variation (from the low end to the high end of typical production). Selecting 10 nearly identical parts artificially deflates Part Variation ( P V PV P V ), causing calculated % G R R \%GRR % GRR to appear disastrously inflated!
Blind Numbering : The 10 parts must be coded or labeled so that the appraisers cannot identify which part they are measuring. If an operator sees "Part 3" and remembers they measured it at 1.002 " 1.002" 1.002" earlier, they will subconsciously bias their second reading to 1.002 " 1.002" 1.002" , destroying the study's validity.
Completely Randomized Order : In Trial 1, Appraiser A measures all 10 parts in randomized order (e.g., 7, 2, 9, 1, ...). Then Appraiser B measures them in a newly randomized order, followed by Appraiser C. In Trials 2 and 3, the parts are re-randomized. Technicians must never allow an appraiser to measure the same part 3 times consecutively!
Mathematical Methodologies: Average and Range ( X ˉ − R \bar{X}-R X ˉ − R ) vs. ANOVA
Two mathematical techniques are recognized by AIAG for calculating Gage R&R:
1. The Average and Range ( X ˉ − R \bar{X}-R X ˉ − R ) Method
The Average and Range method is the traditional calculation technique historically favored on shop floors because it can be computed manually using range statistics and tabulations of d 2 ∗ d_2^* d 2 ∗ constants.
Step-by-Step Computational Formulas:
Range per Part Trial : For each appraiser on each part, calculate the range across trials: R i j = X max − X min R_{ij} = X_{\max} - X_{\min} R ij = X m a x − X m i n .
Average Range per Appraiser : Calculate the average range for Appraiser A ( R ˉ A \bar{R}_A R ˉ A ), Appraiser B ( R ˉ B \bar{R}_B R ˉ B ), and Appraiser C ( R ˉ C \bar{R}_C R ˉ C ).
Grand Average Range ( R ˉ ˉ \bar{\bar{R}} R ˉ ˉ ) : R ˉ ˉ = R ˉ A + R ˉ B + R ˉ C k \bar{\bar{R}} = \frac{\bar{R}_A + \bar{R}_B + \bar{R}_C}{k} R ˉ ˉ = k R ˉ A + R ˉ B + R ˉ C
Equipment Variation (Repeatability, E V EV E V ) : E V = R ˉ ˉ × K 1 = R ˉ ˉ d 2 ∗ ( m , g ) EV = \bar{\bar{R}} \times K_1 = \frac{\bar{\bar{R}}}{d_2^*(m, g)} E V = R ˉ ˉ × K 1 = d 2 ∗ ( m , g ) R ˉ ˉ Where K 1 = 1 / d 2 ∗ K_1 = 1 / d_2^* K 1 = 1/ d 2 ∗ . For r = 3 r = 3 r = 3 trials, K 1 = 0.5908 K_1 = 0.5908 K 1 = 0.5908 ( d 2 ∗ ≈ 1.693 d_2^* \approx 1.693 d 2 ∗ ≈ 1.693 ).
Appraiser Averages : Calculate the overall grand average measurement for each appraiser ( X ˉ A , X ˉ B , X ˉ C \bar{X}_A, \bar{X}_B, \bar{X}_C X ˉ A , X ˉ B , X ˉ C ).
Appraiser Difference ( X ˉ diff \bar{X}_{\text{diff}} X ˉ diff ) : X ˉ diff = X ˉ max − X ˉ min \bar{X}_{\text{diff}} = \bar{X}_{\max} - \bar{X}_{\min} X ˉ diff = X ˉ m a x − X ˉ m i n
Appraiser Variation (Reproducibility, A V AV A V ) : A V = ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 − E V 2 n × r AV = \sqrt{(\bar{X}_{\text{diff}} \times K_2)^2 - \frac{EV^2}{n \times r}} A V = ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 − n × r E V 2 Where n = 10 n = 10 n = 10 parts, r = 3 r = 3 r = 3 trials, and K 2 = 1 / d 2 ∗ K_2 = 1 / d_2^* K 2 = 1/ d 2 ∗ for k k k appraisers (for k = 3 k = 3 k = 3 appraisers, K 2 = 0.5231 K_2 = 0.5231 K 2 = 0.5231 ). (Important rule: If the value under the square root is negative, set A V = 0 AV = 0 A V = 0 ) .
Total Gage R&R ( G R R GRR GRR ) : G R R = E V 2 + A V 2 GRR = \sqrt{EV^2 + AV^2} GRR = E V 2 + A V 2
Part Variation ( P V PV P V ) :
Calculate the average for each part across all appraisers and trials ( X ˉ P 1 , … , X ˉ P 10 \bar{X}_{P1}, \dots, \bar{X}_{P10} X ˉ P 1 , … , X ˉ P 10 ). R p = X ˉ P , max − X ˉ P , min R_p = \bar{X}_{P,\max} - \bar{X}_{P,\min} R p = X ˉ P , m a x − X ˉ P , m i n P V = R p × K 3 PV = R_p \times K_3 P V = R p × K 3 Where K 3 = 1 / d 2 ∗ K_3 = 1 / d_2^* K 3 = 1/ d 2 ∗ for n n n parts (for n = 10 n = 10 n = 10 parts, K 3 = 0.3146 K_3 = 0.3146 K 3 = 0.3146 ).
- Total Variation ( T V TV T V ) : T V = G R R 2 + P V 2 TV = \sqrt{GRR^2 + PV^2} T V = GR R 2 + P V 2
- 2. The ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) Method
The ANOVA method is the globally preferred modern standard for Gage R&R. While the range method only estimates main effects, ANOVA decomposes the total sum of squares into four statistical components:
- Parts Variance ( σ Part 2 \sigma^2_{\text{Part}} σ Part 2 )
- Appraisers Variance ( σ Appraiser 2 \sigma^2_{\text{Appraiser}} σ Appraiser 2 )
Appraiser-by-Part Interaction Variance ( σ Appraiser × Part 2 \sigma^2_{\text{Appraiser} \times \text{Part}} σ Appraiser × Part 2 )
Equipment Error / Repeatability ( σ Residual / Error 2 \sigma^2_{\text{Residual / Error}} σ Residual / Error 2 )
Important
The Decisive Advantage of ANOVA : ANOVA explicitly measures the Operator-by-Part Interaction . If the interaction p p p -value is statistically significant ( p < 0.05 p < 0.05 p < 0.05 ), it indicates that certain appraisers obtain systematically different readings on certain specific part geometries (for example, Appraiser A exerts excessive clamping force on thin-walled parts, but measures thick parts accurately). The Average and Range method cannot detect interaction effects!
AIAG Acceptance Benchmarks and Tolerance vs. Process Variation
Once total G R R GRR GRR is calculated, it must be evaluated as a percentage against an engineering baseline. In modern MSA, two distinct baselines are evaluated:
1. % G R R \%GRR % GRR Relative to Total Variation ( σ Process \sigma_{\text{Process}} σ Process )
Evaluates whether the measurement system is capable of monitoring process shifts for Statistical Process Control (SPC) : % G R R T V = G R R T V × 100 % \%GRR_{TV} = \frac{GRR}{TV} \times 100\% % GR R T V = T V GRR × 100%
2. % G R R \%GRR % GRR Relative to Specification Tolerance ( Tolerance \text{Tolerance} Tolerance )
Evaluates whether the measurement system is capable of inspecting and sorting parts against blueprint specifications : % G R R Tol = 6 × G R R USL − LSL × 100 % ( or 5.15 × G R R Tolerance × 100 % in older manuals ) \%GRR_{\text{Tol}} = \frac{6 \times GRR}{\text{USL} - \text{LSL}} \times 100\% \quad \left(\text{or } \frac{5.15 \times GRR}{\text{Tolerance}} \times 100\% \text{ in older manuals}\right) % GR R Tol = USL − LSL 6 × GRR × 100% ( or Tolerance 5.15 × GRR × 100% in older manuals )
(Note: AIAG 4th Edition standardizes on 6 σ 6\sigma 6 σ , representing 99.73 % 99.73\% 99.73% coverage, whereas older 3rd Edition manuals utilized 5.15 σ 5.15\sigma 5.15 σ for 99.0 % 99.0\% 99.0% coverage) .
The AIAG Acceptance Criteria Matrix
Percentage Range Measurement System Capability Status Required Engineering Action
% G R R < 10 % \%GRR < 10\% % GRR < 10% Acceptable Measurement system is fully capable. Recommended for all quality inspections and SPC charting.
10 % ≤ % G R R ≤ 30 % 10\% \le \%GRR \le 30\% 10% ≤ % GRR ≤ 30% Conditionally Acceptable May be acceptable based on application criticality, cost of replacement instrumentation, or customer concurrence.
% G R R > 30 % \%GRR > 30\% % GRR > 30% Unacceptable Measurement system is incapable. Cannot reliably distinguish good product from bad product. Requires immediate corrective action (redesign, re-fixturing, operator retraining, or gage replacement).
Number of Distinct Categories ( n d c ndc n d c ) and Process Discrimination
A gage may possess high sensitivity, yet still be incapable of dividing process variation into meaningful sub-groups. To quantify practical measurement discrimination, the AIAG standard defines the Number of Distinct Categories ( n d c ndc n d c ) :
Important
Number of Distinct Categories ( n d c ndc n d c ) : Represents the number of non-overlapping 97 % 97\% 97% confidence intervals that span the expected product variation. It defines the gage's ability to detect process variation. n d c = 1.41 × ( P V G R R ) = 2 × ( P V G R R ) \mathbf{ndc = 1.41 \times \left(\frac{PV}{GRR}\right) = \sqrt{2} \times \left(\frac{PV}{GRR}\right)} ndc = 1.41 × ( GRR PV ) = 2 × ( GRR PV ) Note: Always truncate (round down) the calculated value to the nearest integer! NUMBER OF DISTINCT CATEGORIES (ndc) INTERPRETATION:
ndc = 1: [=============================================] (UNACCEPTABLE: Gage sees parts as one chunk!)
Cannot distinguish parts; completely obscured by gage noise.
ndc = 3: [ Low Group ] [ Mid Group ] [ High Group ] (COARSE SCREENING ONLY)
Can only sort into coarse buckets; invalid for SPC control charts.
ndc >= 5: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] (ACCEPTABLE FOR SPC)
Gage cleanly separates natural process variation into distinct categories.
AIAG Criteria for n d c ndc n d c :
n d c ≥ 5 ndc \ge 5 n d c ≥ 5 : Acceptable . The measurement system possesses adequate discrimination to support Statistical Process Control (SPC) control charts and process capability analysis ( C p , C p k C_p, C_{pk} C p , C p k ).
2 ≤ n d c < 5 2 \le ndc < 5 2 ≤ n d c < 5 : Conditionally Acceptable for Coarse Sorting Only . The system can divide parts into high, medium, and low groups, but is too coarse to detect process trends or maintain variables control charts.
n d c < 2 ndc < 2 n d c < 2 (i.e., n d c = 1 ndc = 1 n d c = 1 ) : Unacceptable . Measurement noise completely swamps part-to-part variation. The system cannot distinguish one part from another.
Attribute Agreement Analysis: Fleiss' Kappa and Concordance
When quality inspections produce binary or nominal classifications (Pass/Fail, Conforming/Nonconforming, Good/Bad visual defect sorting) rather than continuous variables data, technicians must conduct an Attribute Agreement Analysis (Attribute Gage R&R).
Study Setup
Select 30 to 50 parts with known reference master status (determined by engineering experts or laboratory metrology).
The sample must include conforming parts, nonconforming parts, and critically: borderline / marginal parts .
Have 2 to 3 appraisers inspect the parts across 2 to 3 trials in blind, randomized order.
Key Metrics Evaluated
Within-Appraiser Agreement (Repeatability) : How consistently does Operator A classify the same part across repeated trials?
Between-Appraiser Agreement (Reproducibility) : How frequently do Appraiser A, Appraiser B, and Appraiser C agree with each other on the same part?
Agreement with Reference Standard (Accuracy / Effectiveness) : How frequently do appraiser classifications match the true known master status?
Fleiss' Kappa ( κ \kappa κ ) Statistic
Raw percent agreement is deceptive because appraisers can agree purely by random guessing. To eliminate chance agreement, MSA calculates Cohen's Kappa (for 2 raters) or Fleiss' Kappa (for > 2 > 2 > 2 raters): κ = P observed − P expected 1 − P expected \kappa = \frac{P_{\text{observed}} - P_{\text{expected}}}{1 - P_{\text{expected}}} κ = 1 − P expected P observed − P expected
Where P observed P_{\text{observed}} P observed is the proportion of observed agreements, and P expected P_{\text{expected}} P expected is the proportion of agreements expected purely by random chance.
Kappa Value ( κ \kappa κ ) Agreement Level System Interpretation
κ > 0.75 \kappa > 0.75 κ > 0.75 Excellent Agreement Measurement system is highly capable for visual/attribute sorting.
0.40 ≤ κ ≤ 0.75 0.40 \le \kappa \le 0.75 0.40 ≤ κ ≤ 0.75 Moderate / Acceptable Agreement Conditionally acceptable; requires defect limit boundary samples and operator training.
κ < 0.40 \kappa < 0.40 κ < 0.40 Poor Agreement Unacceptable; attribute criteria are ambiguous and unreliable.
- Step-by-Step Worked Numerical Example: Full Gage R&R Calculation
- Scenario Data
A quality technician conducts a variable Gage R&R study on a CNC lathe turning diameter. The study employs n = 10 n = 10 n = 10 parts , k = 3 k = 3 k = 3 operators , and r = 3 r = 3 r = 3 trials ( 90 90 90 total data points). The engineering print specification is 1.2500 " ± 0.0100 " 1.2500" \pm 0.0100" 1.2500" ± 0.0100" (Total Tolerance = 0.0200 " = 0.0200" = 0.0200" ).
The preliminary data analysis yields the following calculated summary statistics:
Grand Average Range across all operators and parts : R ˉ ˉ = 0.00085 " \bar{\bar{R}} = 0.00085" R ˉ ˉ = 0.00085"
Operator Grand Averages : X ˉ A = 1.25040 " \bar{X}_A = 1.25040" X ˉ A = 1.25040" , X ˉ B = 1.25012 " \bar{X}_B = 1.25012" X ˉ B = 1.25012" , X ˉ C = 1.24998 " \bar{X}_C = 1.24998" X ˉ C = 1.24998"
Part Averages Range : R p = X ˉ P , max − X ˉ P , min = 1.25600 " − 1.24350 " = 0.01250 " R_p = \bar{X}_{P,\max} - \bar{X}_{P,\min} = 1.25600" - 1.24350" = 0.01250" R p = X ˉ P , m a x − X ˉ P , m i n = 1.25600" − 1.24350" = 0.01250"
Constants from AIAG Tables:
- For r = 3 r = 3 r = 3 trials: K 1 = 0.5908 K_1 = 0.5908 K 1 = 0.5908
- For k = 3 k = 3 k = 3 operators: K 2 = 0.5231 K_2 = 0.5231 K 2 = 0.5231
- For n = 10 n = 10 n = 10 parts: K 3 = 0.3146 K_3 = 0.3146 K 3 = 0.3146
Step 1: Calculate Repeatability (Equipment Variation, E V EV E V ) E V = R ˉ ˉ × K 1 = 0.00085 " × 0.5908 = 0.0005022 " EV = \bar{\bar{R}} \times K_1 = 0.00085" \times 0.5908 = \mathbf{0.0005022"} E V = R ˉ ˉ × K 1 = 0.00085" × 0.5908 = 0.0005022"
Step 2: Calculate Reproducibility (Appraiser Variation, A V AV A V )
First, find the maximum difference between operator averages: X ˉ diff = X ˉ A − X ˉ C = 1.25040 " − 1.24998 " = 0.00042 " \bar{X}_{\text{diff}} = \bar{X}_A - \bar{X}_C = 1.25040" - 1.24998" = 0.00042" X ˉ diff = X ˉ A − X ˉ C = 1.25040" − 1.24998" = 0.00042"
Now compute A V AV A V : A V = ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 − E V 2 n × r AV = \sqrt{(\bar{X}_{\text{diff}} \times K_2)^2 - \frac{EV^2}{n \times r}} A V = ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 − n × r E V 2 ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 = ( 0.00042 " × 0.5231 ) 2 = ( 0.0002197 ) 2 ≈ 4.8269 × 10 − 8 (\bar{X}_{\text{diff}} \times K_2)^2 = (0.00042" \times 0.5231)^2 = (0.0002197)^2 \approx 4.8269 \times 10^{-8} ( X ˉ diff × K 2 ) 2 = ( 0.00042" × 0.5231 ) 2 = ( 0.0002197 ) 2 ≈ 4.8269 × 1 0 − 8 E V 2 n × r = ( 0.0005022 ) 2 10 × 3 = 2.5220 × 10 − 7 30 ≈ 8.4068 × 10 − 9 \frac{EV^2}{n \times r} = \frac{(0.0005022)^2}{10 \times 3} = \frac{2.5220 \times 10^{-7}}{30} \approx 8.4068 \times 10^{-9} n × r E V 2 = 10 × 3 ( 0.0005022 ) 2 = 30 2.5220 × 1 0 − 7 ≈ 8.4068 × 1 0 − 9 A V = 4.8269 × 10 − 8 − 8.4068 × 10 − 9 = 3.9862 × 10 − 8 ≈ 0.0001997 " AV = \sqrt{4.8269 \times 10^{-8} - 8.4068 \times 10^{-9}} = \sqrt{3.9862 \times 10^{-8}} \approx \mathbf{0.0001997"} A V = 4.8269 × 1 0 − 8 − 8.4068 × 1 0 − 9 = 3.9862 × 1 0 − 8 ≈ 0.0001997"
Step 3: Calculate Total Gage R&R ( G R R GRR GRR ) G R R = E V 2 + A V 2 = ( 0.0005022 ) 2 + ( 0.0001997 ) 2 GRR = \sqrt{EV^2 + AV^2} = \sqrt{(0.0005022)^2 + (0.0001997)^2} GRR = E V 2 + A V 2 = ( 0.0005022 ) 2 + ( 0.0001997 ) 2 G R R = 2.5220 × 10 − 7 + 3.9880 × 10 − 8 = 2.9208 × 10 − 7 ≈ 0.0005404 " GRR = \sqrt{2.5220 \times 10^{-7} + 3.9880 \times 10^{-8}} = \sqrt{2.9208 \times 10^{-7}} \approx \mathbf{0.0005404"} GRR = 2.5220 × 1 0 − 7 + 3.9880 × 1 0 − 8 = 2.9208 × 1 0 − 7 ≈ 0.0005404"
Step 4: Calculate Part Variation ( P V PV P V ) P V = R p × K 3 = 0.01250 " × 0.3146 = 0.0039325 " PV = R_p \times K_3 = 0.01250" \times 0.3146 = \mathbf{0.0039325"} P V = R p × K 3 = 0.01250" × 0.3146 = 0.0039325"
Step 5: Calculate Total Variation ( T V TV T V ) T V = G R R 2 + P V 2 = ( 0.0005404 ) 2 + ( 0.0039325 ) 2 TV = \sqrt{GRR^2 + PV^2} = \sqrt{(0.0005404)^2 + (0.0039325)^2} T V = GR R 2 + P V 2 = ( 0.0005404 ) 2 + ( 0.0039325 ) 2 T V = 2.9208 × 10 − 7 + 1.5465 × 10 − 5 = 1.5757 × 10 − 5 ≈ 0.0039695 " TV = \sqrt{2.9208 \times 10^{-7} + 1.5465 \times 10^{-5}} = \sqrt{1.5757 \times 10^{-5}} \approx \mathbf{0.0039695"} T V = 2.9208 × 1 0 − 7 + 1.5465 × 1 0 − 5 = 1.5757 × 1 0 − 5 ≈ 0.0039695"
Step 6: Evaluate % G R R \%GRR % GRR Acceptance Criteria
% G R R \%GRR % GRR Relative to Total Variation (Process) : % G R R T V = G R R T V × 100 % = 0.0005404 " 0.0039695 " × 100 % = 13.62 % \%GRR_{TV} = \frac{GRR}{TV} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0005404"}{0.0039695"} \times 100\% = \mathbf{13.62\%} % GR R T V = T V GRR × 100% = 0.0039695" 0.0005404" × 100% = 13.62%
% G R R \%GRR % GRR Relative to Specification Tolerance : % G R R Tol = 6 × G R R Tolerance × 100 % = 6 × 0.0005404 " 0.0200 " × 100 % = 0.0032424 " 0.0200 " × 100 % = 16.21 % \%GRR_{\text{Tol}} = \frac{6 \times GRR}{\text{Tolerance}} \times 100\% = \frac{6 \times 0.0005404"}{0.0200"} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0032424"}{0.0200"} \times 100\% = \mathbf{16.21\%} % GR R Tol = Tolerance 6 × GRR × 100% = 0.0200" 6 × 0.0005404" × 100% = 0.0200" 0.0032424" × 100% = 16.21%
Evaluation : Both % G R R T V \%GRR_{TV} % GR R T V ( 13.6 % 13.6\% 13.6% ) and % G R R Tol \%GRR_{\text{Tol}} % GR R Tol ( 16.2 % 16.2\% 16.2% ) fall cleanly between 10 % 10\% 10% and 30 % 30\% 30% . The measurement system is Conditionally Acceptable .
Step 7: Calculate Number of Distinct Categories ( n d c ndc n d c ) n d c = 1.41 × ( P V G R R ) = 1.41 × ( 0.0039325 " 0.0005404 " ) = 1.41 × 7.277 = 10.26 ndc = 1.41 \times \left(\frac{PV}{GRR}\right) = 1.41 \times \left(\frac{0.0039325"}{0.0005404"}\right) = 1.41 \times 7.277 = 10.26 n d c = 1.41 × ( GRR P V ) = 1.41 × ( 0.0005404" 0.0039325" ) = 1.41 × 7.277 = 10.26
Truncating to the nearest integer: n d c = 10 ndc = 10 n d c = 10 .
Discrimination Evaluation : Because n d c = 10 ≥ 5 ndc = 10 \ge 5 n d c = 10 ≥ 5 , the gage possesses excellent discrimination, capable of dividing part variation into 10 distinct categories. It is fully qualified for Statistical Process Control (SPC) charting.
- Technician Inspection Scenarios & Common Exam Traps
- Real-World Shop Scenario: Investigating High %GRR
A quality technician conducts a Gage R&R on an optical shaft measurement gage and finds % G R R = 38 % \%GRR = 38\% % GRR = 38% (unacceptable). The technician's manager immediately demands that all operators be sent to an off-site training course to improve their measurement technique. The technician reviews the data sheet and notes:
- E V = 0.0018 " EV = 0.0018" E V = 0.0018"
- A V = 0.0003 " AV = 0.0003" A V = 0.0003"
Root Cause Diagnosis : The manager's decision is fundamentally flawed. E V EV E V accounts for over 97 % 97\% 97% of the total measurement variance ( E V 2 / G R R 2 = ( 0.0018 ) 2 / [ ( 0.0018 ) 2 + ( 0.0003 ) 2 ] = 0.973 EV^2 / GRR^2 = (0.0018)^2 / [(0.0018)^2 + (0.0003)^2] = 0.973 E V 2 / GR R 2 = ( 0.0018 ) 2 / [( 0.0018 ) 2 + ( 0.0003 ) 2 ] = 0.973 ). Appraiser variation ( A V AV A V ) is tiny. Training operators will not improve E V EV E V by even one percent! The problem is mechanical equipment variation: worn spindle bearings, loose optical stage guide rails, or camera vibration. The technician must rebuild the mechanical fixture.
Common Exam Traps for CQT Candidates
Exam Trap 1: Truncating n d c ndc n d c : Always round down (truncate) n d c ndc n d c to the integer. If n d c = 4.95 ndc = 4.95 n d c = 4.95 , it is 4 , which fails the requirement of n d c ≥ 5 ndc \ge 5 n d c ≥ 5 . Never round up to 5!
Exam Trap 2: Variance Summation vs. Standard Deviations : Remember that variances add directly ( σ G R R 2 = σ E V 2 + σ A V 2 \sigma^2_{GRR} = \sigma^2_{EV} + \sigma^2_{AV} σ GRR 2 = σ E V 2 + σ A V 2 ), but standard deviations do not add linearly ( G R R ≠ E V + A V GRR \ne EV + AV GRR = E V + A V ). You must take the square root of the sum of squares: G R R = E V 2 + A V 2 GRR = \sqrt{EV^2 + AV^2} GRR = E V 2 + A V 2 .
Exam Trap 3: Handpicked "Golden" Parts in Study Design : If an exam question asks: "What happens if an engineer hand-selects 10 parts that are all machined near nominal?" Handpicking identical parts slashes Part Variation ( P V PV P V ). Because % G R R = G R R G R R 2 + P V 2 \%GRR = \frac{GRR}{\sqrt{GRR^2 + PV^2}} % GRR = GR R 2 + P V 2 GRR , a tiny P V PV P V forces the denominator to shrink, causing % G R R \%GRR % GRR to skyrocket falsely.
Exam Trap 4: ANOVA Interaction Interpretation : If an ANOVA Gage R&R indicates a significant p p p -value for the Operator × \times × Part interaction ( p < 0.05 p < 0.05 p < 0.05 ), the root cause is that appraisers apply different techniques to different part sizes (e.g., operator deflection on thin parts, or inconsistent sight angles on tall parts).