Study guide
5.4 When to Use RP vs DC
ASSE 5110 Backflow Prevention Assembly Tester Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 About ASSE 5110 and the Series 5000 Program 1.2 Eligibility, 40-Hour Course, Written & Practical Format 1.3 Validity, Recertification, and Retake Rules
2 Hydraulics Fundamentals
2.1 Pressure, Head, and Atmospheric Reference 2.2 Static vs Flowing Conditions for Testers 2.3 PSID and How Differentials Are Measured
3 Backpressure, Backsiphonage & Differentials
3.1 Backpressure: Causes and Field Examples 3.2 Backsiphonage: Causes and Field Examples 3.3 How Differentials Drive Relief and Air-Inlet Action 3.4 When and Why Backflow Occurs in Distribution Systems
4 Cross-Connection Recognition
4.1 Health Hazard vs Non-Health Hazard Classification 4.2 Common Cross-Connections and Correct Protection 4.3 Containment vs Isolation Strategies
5 RP and DC Assemblies
5.1 RP (ASSE 1013) Components and Operation 5.2 RP Relief Valve Theory and Zone Protection 5.3 DC (ASSE 1015) Components and Operation 5.4 When to Use RP vs DC
6 PVB, SVB & Detector Assemblies
6.1 PVB (ASSE 1020) Components and Operation 6.2 SVB (ASSE 1056) Components and Operation 6.3 RPDA and DCDA Detector Assemblies (1047/1048) 6.4 Non-Testable Devices Testers Must Recognize
7 Test Equipment & Calibration
7.1 Three-Valve Differential Pressure Gauges 7.2 Five-Valve Gauges and Hose Discipline 7.3 Bleeding, Hookup Sequence, and Air Elimination 7.4 Calibration, Accuracy, and Field Verification
8 RP & DC Field Test Procedures
8.1 RP Field Test Procedure (USC 10th Edition) 8.2 RP Pass/Fail Criteria and Troubleshooting 8.3 DC Field Test Procedure 8.4 DC Failures and Common Causes
9 PVB/SVB Tests & Practical Sequence
9.1 PVB Field Test Procedure 9.2 SVB Field Test Procedure 9.3 Comparing the Four Practical-Exam Assemblies 9.4 Hands-On Sequence Under Practical Exam Pressure
10 Installation Requirements & Inspection
10.1 Orientation, Clearance, and Elevation Rules 10.2 RP Drainage, Air Gap, and Flood Protection 10.3 Freeze Protection and Thermal Expansion 10.4 Pre-Test Visual Inspection
11 Codes, Standards & Manuals
11.1 ASSE Series 5000 and 5110 Professional Qualifications 11.2 Device Standards 1013, 1015, 1020, 1056 11.3 USC Manual of Cross-Connection Control 10th Edition 11.4 AWWA M14, EPA 816-R-03-002, and SDWA Framework
12 Reporting, Boundaries & Exam Prep
12.1 Field Test Reports and Pass/Fail Language 12.2 Purveyor Notification and Record Retention 12.3 Tester vs Repairer vs Surveyor Boundaries 12.4 Written Exam Strategy, Study Plan, and Next Credentials
5.4 When to Use RP vs DC
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Select RP vs DC by degree of hazard first (health vs non-health), then confirm hydraulic conditions (backpressure, backsiphonage, continuous pressure)
Health-hazard applications with continuous pressure and possible backpressure require RP (or air gap)—never a DC, regardless of cost
Common exam trap: placing a DC on a toxic chemical feed, medical waste line, or treated boiler makeup because “two checks should be enough”
RPs can discharge water and need drain capacity; DCs avoid normal relief discharge but offer a lower protection level and silent failure mode
The ASSE 5110 tester reports measured condition and installation observations; the AHJ/water purveyor sets the required assembly type for the hazard
Last updated: August 2026
5.4 When to Use RP vs DC
Quick Answer: Use an RP (ASSE 1013) for health hazards under continuous pressure with backpressure and/or backsiphonage risk. Use a DC (ASSE 1015) only for non-health hazards when the AHJ allows it. Never “save money” with a DC on toxic chemical feed or other contamination risks. Testers report condition; purveyors/AHJs specify required protection.
Decision order that prevents field mistakes
Selection questions on ASSE 5110 and real program design follow a consistent logic:
What is the degree of hazard? Health (contamination) vs non-health (pollution).
What hydraulic conditions apply? Backpressure, backsiphonage, or both? Continuous pressure?
What does the local program / plumbing code require for that use (containment at the meter vs isolation at the fixture)?
Which listed assembly families meet that combination?
Installation constraints (drainage for RP relief, freeze protection, orientation, accessibility for testing).
If you reverse the order—starting with price or “what fits in the pit”—you will fail written items and, worse, leave a premises under-protected.
Decision matrix by hazard and hydraulics
- Scenario (typical) Hazard Hydraulics Usual mechanical choice
- Chemical feed / toxic process water Health Continuous pressure, possible backpressure RP (or air gap)
- Hospital lab / medical equipment with contaminants Health Continuous pressure RP
- Boiler with chemical treatment Health Backpressure from pump/thermal RP
- Sewage ejector / reclaimed water interface Health Variable RP / air gap per code
Fire sprinkler without chemicals (program-dependent) Often non-health Backpressure from fire pump DC or DCDA if allowed
Fire sprinkler with antifreeze/chemical Health Backpressure RP / RPDA family
Irrigation without chemical injection (AHJ-dependent) Often non-health Continuous pressure, backsiphonage risk DC or PVB/SVB per elevation rules
- Irrigation with chemical injection Health Pump/backpressure possible RP
- Hose bibb only, no continuous pressure Varies Backsiphonage AVB (not RP/DC topic)
Vacuum breakers (AVB/PVB/SVB) remain backsiphonage-focused tools with elevation and continuous-pressure limits; they are not substitutes for RP on health-hazard backpressure lines. This section keeps the spotlight on RP vs DC .
Feature comparison table (study sheet)
- Feature RP (ASSE 1013) DC (ASSE 1015)
- Checks 2 independent 2 independent
- Relief valve Yes (zone) No
- Shutoffs 2 resilient-seated 2 resilient-seated
- Test cocks 4 typical 4 typical
- Health hazard Approved Not approved
- Non-health hazard Allowed Intended use
- Backpressure Yes Yes (non-health)
- Backsiphonage Yes Yes (non-health)
- Continuous pressure Yes Yes
- Visible failure dump Relief discharge None
- Key USC test extras Relief ≥ ~2.0 psid; CK1 ≥ 5.0 & > relief Each check ≥ 1.0 psid
- Drain / air gap at relief Required N/A
- Common fire detector form RPDA (1047) DCDA (1048)
- Typical complaint Water discharge / drain needs Silent leakage risk if failed
Memorize this table for rapid elimination on multiple-choice items.
- Common exam traps
- Trap 1: “Two checks are enough for chemicals”
A stem describes a chlorine , acid , pesticide , or antifreeze feed and offers a DC because it is cheaper and will not spit water. Wrong. Degree of hazard controls. Answer RP (or air gap if presented as an option for that premise).
- Trap 2: Confusing product numbers
- 1013 = RP
- 1015 = DC
- 1047 = RPDA
- 1048 = DCDA
- 1020 = PVB
- 1056 = SVB
Questions love swapping 1013 and 1015.
Trap 3: Mixing pass/fail numbers across assemblies
Applying 1.0 psid to RP check #1, or 5.0 psid to a DC check, or looking for a relief test on a DC.
Trap 4: Assuming the tester chooses the assembly type alone
The stem asks what the tester should do when a DC is installed on a toxic line. Correct role language: perform/observe, document, report to purveyor/AHJ —not “approve the DC because both checks held 1.2 psid.”
Trap 5: Treating discharge as automatic failure without diagnosis
An RP that discharges during the relief test when you intentionally collapse differential is supposed to open. Continuous drip under normal static conditions is abnormal. Context matters.
Trap 6: Using PVB logic on backpressure health hazards
A PVB may be fine for certain backsiphonage-only cases; it is not the answer when the stem includes a booster pump and toxic fluid.
Cost and maintenance tradeoffs (honest comparison)
- Factor RP DC
- Purchase cost Usually higher Usually lower
- Installation Needs drain / air gap for relief Often simpler drain needs
Operating “nuisance” Possible relief spit (expansion, supply swings, first-check weep) Rare external water loss
- Annual testing time Relief + two checks (more steps) Two checks
- Failure visibility Discharge can alert owners Failures may be silent
- Protection level Higher (health hazard) Lower (non-health)
- Flood risk if drain poor Real if relief opens hard Lower from the assembly itself
Owners sometimes pressure testers or plumbers to “put in a DC so we stop wasting water.” That is a program and design conversation with the purveyor—not a free upgrade path for health hazards. Thermal expansion tanks, pressure management, and proper drain design solve many nuisance RP discharges without illegal under-protection.
Tester vs AHJ / purveyor boundaries
Clear role language protects you ethically and on exam wording:
Role Responsibility
Water purveyor / AHJ Sets required protection type for hazard class; enforces cross-connection ordinance; accepts or rejects assemblies
Surveyor (e.g., ASSE 5120 path) Identifies cross-connections and recommends protection types within program rules
ASSE 5110 tester Field-tests assemblies, records values, notes installation defects (plugged relief, missing cocks, wrong orientation), reports pass/fail of the assembly’s condition
- Repairer (e.g., ASSE 5130 path) Rebuilds or replaces internals when authorized
- Owner / plumber Installs listed assemblies as required; maintains freeze protection and drains
If you find a DC on a health-hazard service , you still test it if asked, but your report must not imply that a passing 1.0 psid reading satisfies a health-hazard requirement. Note the assembly type and the program’s required type when your jurisdiction’s form allows; notify the purveyor per local procedure.
Selection walkthroughs
Walkthrough A — Car wash reclaim. Reclaim tanks and soaps can introduce non-potable, potentially contaminated water. Continuous pressure and pump-driven backpressure are likely. Select RP for containment/isolation as the program specifies. A DC “to avoid mess from relief water” is an exam fail.
Walkthrough B — Dry fire sprinkler without chemicals. Many programs accept DC or DCDA for non-health fire lines, with detector metering preferred for theft/leak detection. If antifreeze loops are added later, protection often upgrades to RP/RPDA .
Walkthrough C — Apartment domestic service with no special hazards. Some purveyors require containment RPs on all multi-family services regardless of internal hazards; others allow DCs or none at the meter with isolation devices inside. Follow the written program —selection is not pure physics in isolation.
Walkthrough D — Softener with salt only. Sodium chloride brine is often treated as non-health by some programs and health-related by others depending on local classification and concentration risks. When a stem labels the softener brine non-health and offers DC vs RP, DC can be correct; when it emphasizes contamination of the public supply and requires highest protection, RP appears. Read the hazard wording carefully.
Integrating Chapters 3–5 for exam readiness
Chapter 3 taught backpressure vs backsiphonage and why differentials matter.
Section 5.1–5.2 taught how the RP uses differentials with a relief.
Section 5.3 taught the DC without relief .
This section forces the selection skill: match assembly capability to hazard + hydraulics, avoid traps, respect authority roles.
When you reach field-test procedures, you will execute different gauge sequences for RP and DC, but selection logic stays the same: right device first, then right test .
Closing checklist before the next chapter
Before moving to PVB, SVB, and detector assemblies, confirm you can:
Sketch RP and DC flow paths and name every major part.
State USC-style numbers: relief ~ 2.0 , RP CK1 5.0 + above relief , RP CK2 tight (no psid) , DC checks 1.0 .
Explain continuous RP drip vs intentional relief opening during test.
Reject DC on health hazards.
State that testers report; AHJs require .
Those five skills dominate assembly-operation items in the 20% components-and-operation domain and reappear throughout field-test and installation questions.