Study guide

2.3 Identifying and Resolving Ethical Dilemmas

ASWB Clinical Examination LCSW Licensure

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts & the 2026 Blueprint Change 1.2 The Three 2026 Content Areas 1.3 How to Use This Guide & Build Your Study Plan

2 Values & Ethics: Ethical Principles and Responsibilities

2.1 Confidentiality, HIPAA, and Protected Health Information 2.2 Informed Consent 2.3 Identifying and Resolving Ethical Dilemmas 2.4 Professional Values and Responsibilities to Clients, Colleagues, the Profession, and Society

3 Professional Wellness, Self-Care, and Development

3.1 Burnout, Secondary Trauma, Compassion Fatigue, and Self-Care 3.2 Professional Development Activities

4 Values & Ethics: Ethical Service Delivery

4.1 Protecting and Enhancing Client Self-Determination 4.2 Professional Boundaries, Dual Relationships, and Self-Disclosure 4.3 Mandatory Reporting and the Duty to Warn and Protect 4.4 Documentation and Maintaining Client Records 4.5 Responsible Billing, Managed Care, and Governmental Policy Impacts

5 Values & Ethics: Ethics in Practice Contexts

5.1 Death, Dying, and End-of-Life Ethical Issues 5.2 Ethical Issues in Clinical Supervision and Management 5.3 Termination, Electronic Practice, and Research Ethics

6 Diversity and Social Justice

6.1 Anti-Oppressive and Anti-Racist Practice 6.2 Social, Racial, Environmental, and Economic Justice 6.3 Culture, Race, Ethnicity, Gender, Sexual Orientation, and Intersectionality 6.4 Accessibility, Language, Neurodiversity, and Disability

7 Privilege, Exploitation, and Global Contexts

7.1 Privilege, Bias, Microaggressions, and Power Differentials 7.2 Exploitation, Trafficking, Truth and Reconciliation, and Global Contexts

8 Assessment and Planning: Assessment Concepts and Foundations

8.1 The Biopsychosocial Assessment Model 8.2 Typical and Atypical Development Across the Lifespan 8.3 Trauma, Stressors, Violence, and Crises 8.4 Family Dynamics and Interpersonal Relationships 8.5 Physical, Sexual, and Psychological Abuse and Neglect Across the Lifespan 8.6 Housing Instability, Homelessness, and Out-of-Home Displacement 8.7 Client Competence, Decision-Making Capacity, and Self-Monitoring

9 Assessment and Planning: DSM-5-TR Psychopathology Indicators Across the Lifespan

9.1 Mood and Anxiety Disorder Indicators (DSM-5-TR) 9.2 Trauma-, Stressor-, and Dissociative-Disorder Indicators (DSM-5-TR) 9.3 Psychotic, Bipolar, and Personality-Disorder Indicators (DSM-5-TR) 9.4 Substance Use, Addictive, and Co-Occurring Disorder Indicators (DSM-5-TR) 9.5 Eating, Neurodevelopmental, and Neurocognitive Disorder Indicators (DSM-5-TR)

10 Assessment and Planning: Assessment Methods and Techniques

10.1 Assessing Risk of Harm to Self and Others 10.2 Interviewing Principles and Techniques 10.3 The Mental Status Examination 10.4 Use of the DSM-5-TR in Clinical Assessment (Clinical-Specific)

11 Assessment and Planning: Assessment Practices, Treatment Planning, and Service Planning

11.1 Involving Clients in Problem Identification and Readiness for Change 11.2 Goal Planning, Treatment Planning, Triage, and Service Plans 11.3 Intervention Modality Selection and Cultural Considerations 11.4 Medication Effects, Client Readiness for Termination, and Community Resources

12 Intervention and Practice: Practice Concepts

12.1 Strengths-Based Practice, Empowerment, and the Helping Relationship 12.2 Interdisciplinary Collaboration and the Social Worker's Problem-Solving Role 12.3 End-of-Life Practice, Hospice, Palliative Care, and Parenting Capacity 12.4 Policies, Regulations, Legislation, and Developing Formal Documents

13 Intervention and Practice: Core Intervention Methods

13.1 Trauma-Informed Care 13.2 Verbal and Nonverbal Communication, Boundary Setting, and Emotional Regulation 13.3 Crisis Intervention, Anger Management, and Conflict Resolution 13.4 Evidence-Based Practices: CBT, DBT, MI, EMDR, and MBSR 13.5 Practice With Loss, Grief, Coping, and Stress-Management Skills

14 Intervention and Practice: Clinical and Specialty Intervention Methods

14.1 Engaging Voluntary and Involuntary Clients and Harm Reduction 14.2 Advocacy, Psychoeducation, Contracting, and Goal-Setting 14.3 Addiction Intervention Techniques and Case Management 14.4 Family Therapy Models, Interventions, and Approaches 14.5 Couples Interventions (Clinical-Specific), Group Work, and Service Networks

15 Intervention and Practice: Evaluation, Research, and Supervision

15.1 Evaluating the Progress and Effectiveness of Interventions 15.2 Program Evaluation, Agency Evaluation Methods, and Quality Assurance 15.3 Basic and Applied Research Design: Quantitative, Qualitative, Reliability, and Validity 15.4 Supervision and Consultation Models, Transference/Countertransference, and Fiscal Management

2.3 Identifying and Resolving Ethical Dilemmas

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

An ethical dilemma involves a conflict between two or more competing values, rights, or duties — distinct from a legal question or a clinical problem

The NASW Code of Ethics is the primary ethical framework for social workers and is organized into six ethical standards sections covering responsibilities to clients, colleagues, practice settings, the profession, the broader society, and social workers' ethical responsibilities overall

Reamer's seven-step ethical decision-making model and the Ethical Principles Screen (EPS) are the most commonly tested frameworks; both require identifying the issue, consulting the Code, weighing principles and consequences, and documenting the decision

Core ethical principles include autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, justice, fidelity, and veracity; in dilemmas these principles compete and must be ranked by the specific situation

Documenting the decision-making process — including consultation sought and the reasoning applied — is itself an ethical and legal safeguard under NASW 3.04

Last updated: August 2026

ASWB Clinical exam items in this area typically present a scenario and ask what the social worker should do first or next . The trick is recognizing when a situation is a true ethical dilemma — a conflict between competing values — versus a legal question with a clear answer or a clinical problem that calls for a treatment adjustment.

Distinguishing Ethical Dilemmas From Other Problems

Situation Type Defining Feature Example

Ethical dilemma Two or more values, rights, or duties conflict; no single answer is clearly correct A teen client discloses risky behavior and asks the social worker not to tell a parent — self-determination vs. safety

Legal issue A statute, regulation, or court order governs the situation A court orders release of records — the question is compliance, not values

Clinical problem The challenge is treatment formulation, not values conflict A client is not responding to the current intervention — adjust the treatment plan

The exam rewards the candidate who says "this is a legal issue, so follow the law" when it is legal, and "this is an ethical dilemma, so apply a decision-making model" when it is not. Misclassifying is the most common error.

The NASW Code of Ethics as the Primary Framework

The NASW Code is the primary ethical framework for U.S. social workers. The 2021 revision (still current in 2026) is organized into four parts:

Preamble — the mission and core values of the profession.

Purpose of the NASW Code of Ethics — articulates the Code's six major functions.

Ethical Principles — six broad principles based on the core values.

Ethical Standards — six sections of enforceable rules:

  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities to clients (standards 1.01–1.17)
  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities to colleagues (2.01–2.10)
  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities in practice settings (3.01–3.10)
  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities as professionals (4.01–4.08)
  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities to the social work profession (5.01–5.02)
  • Social workers' ethical responsibilities to the broader society (6.01–6.04)

The Code is hierarchical in spirit: a standard can be overridden only by another standard or an overriding legal duty. When two standards conflict, the social worker ranks them by the situation — this is exactly what a decision-making model helps with.

Ethical Principles Screen (EPS)

The Ethical Principles Screen (EPS) , developed by Elaine Congress, is a tool for ranking ethical principles in a dilemma. It lists seven principles in priority order:

  • Protection of life
  • Equality and inequality
  • Autonomy and freedom
  • Harm minimization (least harm)
  • Quality of life
  • Privacy and confidentiality
  • Truthfulness and full disclosure

The EPS is hierarchical : when principles conflict, the higher-ranked principle generally prevails. Protection of life sits at the top — which is why a credible suicidal threat can override confidentiality. The EPS is a screening tool, not a substitute for the NASW Code, but the exam tests the ranking.

Reamer's Seven-Step Ethical Decision-Making Model

Frederic Reamer's seven-step model is the most widely taught and most commonly tested decision-making framework. The steps:

Identify the ethical issue(s) and the applicable NASW standards, laws, regulations, and agency policies.

Identify the individuals, groups, and organizations likely to be affected by the decision.

Brainstorm possible courses of action and evaluate the consequences of each for the parties identified in step 2.

Consult with relevant colleagues, supervisors, ethics committees, and legal counsel.

Make the decision and document the reasoning, the consultation, and the steps taken.

Implement the decision.

Monitor, evaluate, and document the outcomes; adjust as needed.

The exam most often tests steps 1, 4, and 5 — identify the issue, consult, and document. When an item asks what the social worker should do first in a dilemma, the answer is almost always to identify the issue and relevant standards/laws or to seek consultation , depending on urgency.

Principle-Based Ethics: The Core Principles

The bioethical principles that ground most ethical reasoning in clinical practice:

Autonomy — the client's right to self-determination (NASW 1.02).

Beneficence — acting in the client's best interest.

Nonmaleficence — avoiding harm ("first, do no harm").

Justice — fair, equitable treatment; allocation of resources.

Fidelity — keeping promises and trust.

Veracity — truthfulness.

In a dilemma, two or more of these principles will pull in different directions. The clinician's job is to name them, weigh them in the specific situation, and document the reasoning.

  • Common Clinical Dilemmas
  • Confidentiality vs. Duty to Protect

A client with command hallucinations names a specific coworker as a target. Confidentiality (NASW 1.07) says protect the disclosure; duty to protect (state Tarasoff-style law, reinforced by EPS principle 1 — protection of life) says warn the identifiable victim and notify law enforcement. The decision: protection of life prevails, the social worker takes reasonable steps to protect the victim, and discloses only the minimum necessary.

Self-Determination vs. Safety

A client with a serious mental illness wants to stop taking medication and leave a supportive residence. Self-determination (NASW 1.02) says respect the client's choice; beneficence and nonmaleficence say the client may decompensate. The decision depends on whether the client meets civil-commitment criteria (imminent danger to self or others, or grave disability). If they do not, the social worker respects the choice while continuing to engage and offer services. If they do, the social worker pursues involuntary evaluation per state law.

Dual Relationships in Rural, Military, and Religious Communities

In small or closed communities, dual relationships are sometimes unavoidable. A rural clinician may have a client who is also the only mechanic in town; a military social worker may treat a fellow service member's family; a clinician in a faith community may have a client who is a fellow congregant. NASW 1.06 requires social workers to avoid conflicts of interest and dual relationships that could impair professional judgment or risk harm to clients — but acknowledges that some dual relationships are unavoidable. When unavoidable, the social worker must set clear boundaries, document the dual relationship, obtain informed consent about its limits, and seek consultation to verify that the relationship is not exploitative.

Vignette: The Small-Town Dual Relationship

A clinical social worker in a rural town accepts a new client for therapy. The client is the spouse of the social worker's child's school principal, and they regularly attend the same small church. What should the social worker do?

Best practice: (1) Assess whether the dual relationship could impair clinical judgment or risk harm; (2) Discuss the dual relationship openly with the client as part of informed consent, including what the social worker will do if a social encounter occurs; (3) Document the dual relationship and the steps taken; (4) Seek consultation or supervision to verify that the arrangement is not exploitative; (5) Refer out if the dual relationship cannot be managed safely.

Resource Allocation

A community mental health agency has a waiting list of three months. A social worker must decide how to allocate scarce slots among clients with comparable need. The principle of justice applies: allocation should be fair, transparent, and based on clinically relevant criteria (urgency, fit, capacity to benefit), not on personal preference or favoritism. NASW 3.09 (commitments to employers) and the broader-society standards (6.01–6.06) bear here.

Documenting the Decision-Making Process

NASW 3.04 requires social workers to document professional and ethical decisions accurately and in a timely manner. A defensible note for an ethical decision includes:

  • The dilemma identified and the competing values or standards
  • The relevant NASW standards, laws, and agency policies considered
  • The consultation sought (supervisor, ethics committee, legal counsel) and the date
  • The reasoning that produced the decision
  • The action taken and the follow-up plan

Documentation is not a chore after the decision; it is part of the decision. An undocumented decision is, in a malpractice review, a decision that may as well not have been made.

Consultation and Supervision

NASW 2.05 (consultation) requires social workers to seek advice and counsel from colleagues, supervisors, or experts when it serves the client's interests. In ethical dilemmas, consultation is both an ethical expectation and a clinical protection. The exam rewards answers that include "consult with supervisor or ethics committee" — particularly when the situation is novel, high-stakes, or legally complex.

The unifying exam rule: when two values conflict, do not rush to action. Name the dilemma, identify the relevant standards and laws, consult, decide, and document.

Loading diagram... Reamer's Seven-Step Ethical Decision-Making Model