Study guide

4.2 Ethical Decision-Making

ASWB Social Work Licensing Exam Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction: ASWB Social Work Licensing Exam Overview

ASWB Exam Overview ASWB Exam Levels and Prerequisites Study Strategies for the ASWB Exam ASWB Clinical Exam Content Areas (2026 Blueprint)

2 Chapter 1: Human Development, Diversity & Behavior in the Environment

1.1 Human Development Theories 1.2 Diversity and Cultural Competence 1.3 Behavior in the Social Environment 1.4 Lifespan Development

3 Chapter 2: Assessment, Diagnosis & Treatment Planning

2.1 Biopsychosocial Assessment 2.2 DSM-5-TR Diagnosis 2.3 Treatment Planning 2.4 Measurement and Assessment Tools

4 Chapter 3: Psychotherapy, Clinical Interventions & Case Management

3.1 Therapeutic Approaches 3.2 Crisis Intervention and Safety 3.3 Group and Family Therapy 3.4 Case Management and Advocacy

5 Chapter 4: Professional Values & Ethics

4.1 NASW Code of Ethics 4.2 Ethical Decision-Making 4.3 Legal and Regulatory Issues 4.4 Professional Development

6 Chapter 5: Social Work Practice Across Settings

5.1 Clinical Mental Health Practice 5.2 Healthcare Social Work 5.3 Community and Policy Practice

4.2 Ethical Decision-Making

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Ethical dilemmas occur when two or more ethical principles conflict and there is no clear right answer

Ethical decision-making models provide a structured process for analyzing and resolving dilemmas

Dual relationships (multiple relationships) occur when a social worker has a professional and another type of relationship with a client

Confidentiality is a fundamental ethical obligation with specific legal exceptions (duty to warn, mandated reporting, court orders)

Informed consent requires that clients understand the nature of services, risks, benefits, alternatives, and their right to refuse

Self-determination means respecting the client's right to make their own decisions, even when the social worker disagrees

  • Cultural context must be considered in ethical decision-making to avoid imposing dominant cultural values
  • Last updated: October 2026

Ethical dilemmas arise frequently in social work practice when two or more ethical principles, values, or obligations conflict. Unlike ethical violations (where there is a clear right and wrong), ethical dilemmas involve situations where the social worker must choose between competing "goods" or determine the least harmful course of action.

Ethical Decision-Making Models

Several ethical decision-making models provide structured approaches for analyzing dilemmas:

ETHIC Model (Congress, 2000):

  • E xamine — Examine relevant personal, societal, agency, client, and professional values
  • T hink — Think about what ethical standards apply (NASW Code of Ethics)
  • H ypothesize — Hypothesize about possible courses of action and their consequences
  • I dentify — Identify who will benefit and who will be harmed by each option
  • C onsult — Consult with supervisor, colleagues, or ethics committee

Reamer's Ethical Decision-Making Framework:

  • Identify the ethical issues, including competing values and principles
  • Identify all individuals, groups, and organizations affected
  • Identify all possible courses of action and the participants in each
  • Examine the reasons in favor of and opposed to each option
  • Consult with colleagues and experts
  • Make the decision and document the decision-making process
  • Monitor and evaluate the outcome
  • Hierarchy of Ethical Obligations

When ethical principles conflict, some obligations generally take priority. A commonly used hierarchy (adapted from Loewenberg, Dolgoff, and Harrington) ranks ethical principles:

  • Protection of life — highest priority (e.g., breaking confidentiality to prevent suicide)
  • Equality and inequality — fair and equal treatment
  • Autonomy and freedom — self-determination
  • Least harm — choosing the option that causes the least damage
  • Quality of life — promoting well-being
  • Privacy and confidentiality — protecting client information
  • Truthfulness and full disclosure — being honest with clients

Key point: Protection of life always takes priority over confidentiality. This is why mandated reporting and duty to warn override the obligation to keep client information confidential.

Dual Relationships (Multiple Relationships)

Dual relationships occur when a social worker has a professional relationship and simultaneously or sequentially has another type of relationship with the same person (personal, financial, social, business, etc.).

Types of Dual Relationships:

  • Social: Socializing with a client outside of sessions
  • Business: Entering into a business arrangement with a client

Romantic/Sexual: Having a romantic or sexual relationship with a client (always prohibited with current clients)

  • Familial: Providing services to a friend's family member
  • Digital: Accepting a client's social media connection request

NASW Guidelines on Dual Relationships:

Social workers should avoid dual relationships when possible

When dual relationships are unavoidable (especially in rural or small communities), the social worker must take steps to protect the client and maintain clear boundaries

  • The social worker bears the responsibility for setting and maintaining appropriate boundaries
  • Document any unavoidable dual relationships and the steps taken to manage them
  • Consult with a supervisor or colleague when dual relationship concerns arise