Study guide

7.3 Silver Drawing Test (SDT) & Draw-A-Story (DAS)

Board Certified Registered Art Therapist ATR-BC

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Introduction & Foundational Theories

1.1 Exam Overview & Art Therapy Credentialing Landscape 1.2 Psychodynamic, Psychoanalytic & Jungian Roots 1.3 Humanistic, Phenomenological & Existential Orientations

2 Chapter 2: Contemporary Theories & The Expressive Therapies Continuum

2.1 Attachment Theory & Relational Neurobiology 2.2 Cognitive-Behavioral, DBT & Solution-Focused Art Therapy 2.3 Expressive Therapies Continuum (ETC) & Brain-Based Processing 2.4 Motivational Interviewing, Stages of Change & Strengths-Based Practice 2.5 Somatic, Ecotherapy & Systems-Based Approaches

3 Chapter 3: Clinical Intake, Treatment Planning & Media Selection

3.1 Intake Assessment, Biopsychosocial Evaluation & Goal Setting 3.2 Art Media Properties & The Media Dimension Scale 3.3 Studio Space Management, Containment & Physical Safety 3.4 Interviewing Skills, Empathy & Session Structure

4 Chapter 4: Individual Treatment Facilitation & Clinical Interventions

4.1 Trauma-Informed Art Therapy Interventions 4.2 Interventions for Mood, Anxiety, and Psychotic Disorders 4.3 Developmental & Pediatric Art Therapy Interventions 4.4 Crisis Intervention, Risk Imagery & Referral 4.5 DSM-5-TR Diagnosis, Mental Status & Level of Functioning

5 Chapter 5: Group Art Therapy, Family Systems & Clinical Dynamics

5.1 Group Art Therapy Models & Stages of Group Development 5.2 Family & Couples Art Therapy Interventions 5.3 Transference, Countertransference & Therapeutic Alliance 5.4 Progress Monitoring, Treatment-Plan Revision & Outcome Measurement 5.5 Art History, Formal Elements & Symbol Interpretation in Session

6 Chapter 6: Standardized Art-Based Assessment Instruments

6.1 Diagnostic Drawing Series (DDS) & Scoring Methodology 6.2 Person Picking an Apple from a Tree (PPAT) & FEATS 6.3 Kinetic Family Drawing (KFD) & House-Tree-Person (HTP)

7 Chapter 7: Expressive, Projective & Specialized Assessments

7.1 The Bird's Nest Drawing (BND) & Attachment Assessments 7.2 Mandala Assessment Research Instrument (MARI) & Archetypal Symbolism 7.3 Silver Drawing Test (SDT) & Draw-A-Story (DAS) 7.4 Bridge, Road & Draw-A-Person-in-the-Rain Projective Drawings 7.5 Cognitive, Developmental & Belief-Based Instruments: CATA, LECATA, FSA & BATA 7.6 Family Art Evaluation & Writing Art-Based Assessment Reports

8 Chapter 8: Ethical Standards, Client Rights & Boundaries

8.1 ATCB Code of Ethics, Professional Boundaries & Dual Relationships 8.2 Informed Consent, Minors & Involuntary Clients 8.3 Ownership, Display, Reproduction & Storage of Client Artwork 8.4 Fee Structures, Electronic Communication & Supervision Records

9 Chapter 9: Legal Responsibilities, Confidentiality & Diversity

9.1 Confidentiality, HIPAA & Privileged Communication 9.2 Duty to Protect, Tarasoff & Mandatory Reporting 9.3 Cultural Humility, Diversity & Social Justice in Art Therapy 9.4 Telehealth & Digital Art Therapy Practice

10 Chapter 10: Research Methodologies & Professional Credentialing

10.1 Research Designs & Methodology in Art Therapy 10.2 Evidence-Based Practice & Program Evaluation 10.3 ATCB Credentialing Continuum, Recertification & Advocacy

11 Chapter 11: Clinical Supervision, Documentation & Studio Administration

11.1 Clinical Supervision Models & Vicarious Trauma Management 11.2 Clinical Documentation Systems & Health Records 11.3 Studio Safety, Toxicology & Material Hazards 11.4 Program Development, Funding & Third-Party Reimbursement 11.5 Outreach, Interagency Consultation, Milieu Programming & Universal Precautions

7.3 Silver Drawing Test (SDT) & Draw-A-Story (DAS)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Developed by art therapist Rawley Silver (EdD, ATR-BC), the Silver Drawing Test of Cognition and Emotion (SDT) and Draw-A-Story (DAS) are empirically validated, non-verbal assessment instruments designed to bypass linguistic, auditory, and cultural barriers.

The SDT assesses cognitive functioning and emotional projection across three distinct subtests: Predictive Drawing (evaluating horizontal and vertical spatial conservation adapted from Jean Piaget's water-level tasks), Drawing from Observation (drawing three-dimensional geometric arrangements), and Drawing from Imagination (synthesizing selected stimulus cards into an original narrative composition).

The Draw-A-Story (DAS) is a specialized screening instrument for depression, covert aggression, and suicide risk in children, adolescents, and adults, requiring clients to select two or more stimulus drawings, depict an interaction, and write an accompanying titled story.

The DAS utilizes a standardized 5-point Emotional Content Scale ranging from Score 1 (Strongly Negative: depicting death, catastrophic destruction, mutilation, hopeless victimization, or suicide) to Score 5 (Strongly Positive: depicting mutual nurturing, creative mastery, heroic rescue, or transformative humor).

A critical competency for the ATR-BC examination is distinguishing between developmentally normative aggression (playful battles, cartoon conflict, superhero triumphs) and clinical indicators of lethal self-harm, severe depression, or violent ideation.

Last updated: September 2026

Non-Verbal Assessment Philosophy of Rawley Silver

The Silver Drawing Test of Cognition and Emotion (SDT) and the Draw-A-Story (DAS) were developed by pioneering art therapist and educator Rawley Silver (EdD, ATR-BC) . Silver recognized a critical, systemic limitation in traditional psychological and psychiatric assessment: conventional assessment batteries rely overwhelmingly on verbal fluency, auditory comprehension, and linguistic articulation. Consequently, individuals with verbal or auditory impairments are routinely misdiagnosed, their cognitive abilities underestimated, and their emotional distress overlooked.

Silver specifically engineered her non-verbal assessment instruments to serve diverse, underserved populations, including:

Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing Individuals : Clients who communicate primarily through sign language or visual modalities, eliminating auditory testing bias.

Speech and Language Impairments : Children and adults with expressive language disorders, developmental apraxia of speech, or selective mutism.

Neurological and Post-Stroke Patients : Individuals presenting with expressive aphasia, traumatic brain injury (TBI), or stroke-induced cognitive deficits.

Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Clients : Immigrants, refugees, and non-native English speakers who would be severely penalized by standard English verbal tests.

Children and Adolescents with Trauma : Youth who lack the developmental vocabulary or emotional defenses to articulate traumatic memories verbally.

Silver synthesized cognitive developmental psychology—most notably the epistemological theories of Jean Piaget and Jerome Bruner —with psychodynamic projective principles. Her tests prove that drawing is not merely an aesthetic recreation, but a fundamental cognitive language capable of demonstrating complex spatial reasoning, hypothetical problem-solving, and profound emotional projection.

The Silver Drawing Test of Cognition and Emotion (SDT): Subtests and Architecture

The Silver Drawing Test (SDT) evaluates two distinct psychological domains concurrently: cognitive developmental maturity and underlying emotional content . The SDT comprises three standardized subtests , each administered using dedicated test booklets and drawing stimuli. ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐

  • │ SILVER DRAWING TEST (SDT) BATTERY │
  • ├───────────────────┬───────────────────┬────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ Subtest 1: │ Subtest 2: │ Subtest 3: │
  • │ Predictive Drawing│ Observation │ Drawing from Imagination │
  • ├───────────────────┼───────────────────┼────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ • Piagetian Tasks │ • 3D Cylinders & │ • Choose 2+ Stimulus Drawings │
  • │ • Water-Level Line│ Foam Prisms │ • Create Original Narrative │
  • │ • Plumb-Line Slopes│• Perspective & │ • Dual Scoring: Cognitive & │
  • │ • Spatial Frames │ Relative Scale │ Emotional Content (1 to 5) │
  • └───────────────────┴───────────────────┴────────────────────────────────┘
  • Subtest 1: Predictive Drawing (Spatial Concepts)

Theoretical Basis : Directly adapted from Jean Piaget's water-level and plumb-line conservation experiments , which evaluate an individual's understanding of horizontal and vertical spatial frames of reference.

Administrative Task : The client is presented with outline drawings of bottles and containers displayed in various orientations: upright, tilted at a 45-degree angle, and lying horizontally. The client is instructed to draw where the water line would be inside each bottle if it were half-full. In the verticality task, the client is shown a picture of a steep mountain slope and instructed to draw a house and trees on the hill.

Cognitive Evaluation : Evaluates whether the client has achieved spatial conservation and the transition from Piaget's preoperational to concrete and formal operational thought:

Preoperational / Concrete Failures : The client draws the water parallel to the tilted base of the bottle (believing water tilts with the glass) or draws trees jutting out at 90-degree right angles to the slanted mountain slope rather than maintaining true gravitational verticality.

Mature Operational Success : The client understands that liquid surfaces remain strictly horizontal regardless of bottle orientation and that trees grow vertically upright against gravity.

Subtest 2: Drawing from Observation (Spatial Relations)

Theoretical Basis : Evaluates visual-spatial perception, proportion, depth cues, and sequential ordering without verbal mediation.

Administrative Task : A physical, three-dimensional arrangement of geometric forms—typically consisting of a cylinder, a rectangular prism, and a small foam block—is arranged in front of the client on the table. The client is directed to draw the objects exactly as they observe them from their personal line of sight.

Cognitive Evaluation : Scored on an objective 5-point scale evaluating: accurate depiction of three-dimensional depth, object overlap, proportional scale between objects, and spatial relationships (foreground, middle ground, background).

Subtest 3: Drawing from Imagination (Cognitive Synthesis & Affective Projection)

Administrative Task : The client is presented with an array of standardized line drawings (the stimulus sheet) depicting various subjects: people, animals, vehicles, and environmental objects. The client is instructed to choose two or more subjects, combine them to create an original picture showing something happening, and provide a title or brief written story .

Dual Scoring Framework :

Cognitive Scale (Level of Representation & Synthesis) : Scored from 1 to 5 based on how successfully the client integrates the chosen stimuli into a coherent, spatial scene (ranging from isolated, unconnected copies at Score 1 to fully integrated, dynamic compositions demonstrating depth and narrative interaction at Score 5).

Emotional Content Scale : Evaluates the emotional tone, interpersonal dynamics, and thematic narrative on Silver's 5-point ordinal scale , where 1 = strongly negative (lethal, morbid, or solitary/helpless content), 3 = ambivalent, neutral, or unemotional , and 5 = strongly positive (effective, caring, or successful relationships). The identical 1-to-5 anchors are used on the Draw-A-Story, which allows scores from the two instruments to be compared directly.

Loading diagram... Silver Drawing Test (SDT) & Draw-A-Story (DAS) Diagnostic Assessment Framework

The Draw-A-Story (DAS) Assessment Protocol: Screening Depression and Suicide Risk

Developed by Rawley Silver in 1988 (and updated in 2002), the Draw-A-Story (DAS): Screening for Depression and Emotional Needs is one of the most widely validated projective-objective screening instruments in art therapy. While adapted from Subtest 3 of the SDT, the DAS functions as an autonomous, rapid clinical screening tool designed specifically to detect hidden depression, unexpressed grief, covert aggression, and lethal suicide risk in children, adolescents, and adults.

Standardized Materials and Administration Directive

Materials : The standardized DAS booklet (containing drawing space and blank lines for writing) and a standard set of 14 stimulus drawing cards . The stimulus drawings depict diverse subjects: an aggressive predator (e.g., lion, snake, shark), a vulnerable creature (e.g., mouse, baby bird, small kitten), human figures of various ages and postures, inanimate vehicles (e.g., car, boat), and environmental props (e.g., ladder, tree, sword).

The Directive : The clinician lays out the stimulus cards and instructs the client:

"Look at these drawings and choose two or more that interest you. Imagine something happening between the characters or things you chose, then draw a picture showing what is happening. When you finish your drawing, write a story about it below and give your story a title."

If the client is unable to write due to motor limitations, age, or language barriers, the clinician transcribes the client's spoken story verbatim without editorial modification.

The 5-Point Emotional Content Scale: Operational Scoring Criteria

Silver developed an objective, empirically validated 5-point ordinal scale to score the emotional content of the DAS drawing and narrative. Extensive research establishes that persistent low scores strongly correlate with clinical depression, psychiatric hospitalization, and self-harm risk.

Detailed Breakdown of the 5 Emotional Content Scale Points

Score Classification Operational Criteria & Graphic Manifestation Typical Clinical Narrative Excerpt

1 Strongly Negative / Destructive / Victimization Imagery depicts catastrophic disaster, fatal violence, unmitigated mutilation, lethal suicide, or hopeless victimization . Characters are murdered, drown, fall to their deaths, or weep inconsolably with no rescue or hope. "The shark tore the swimmer to pieces. There was blood everywhere and no one heard his screams. He died alone."

2 Mildly Negative / Vulnerability / Frustration Depicts danger, sadness, loss, or ongoing struggle , but avoids absolute fatal catastrophe. Characters face serious obstacles, sadness, or abandonment, but survival remains possible. "The little kitten is lost in the rain. She is cold and crying, looking for her mother who went away."

3 Neutral / Ambivalent / Routine Depicts ordinary daily routines, neutral interactions, or mixed emotional elements that balance each other out. Neither overtly joyful nor distressing; emotionally matter-of-fact. "A man is driving his car down the road to go to work. A dog is walking on the sidewalk watching him pass."

4 Mildly Positive / Cooperative / Adaptive Depicts positive interactions, friendly collaboration, overcoming a minor obstacle, or playful humor . Characters help one another or enjoy an active shared pursuit. "The boy and his dog climbed up the ladder to build a treehouse together. They finished it before sunset."

5 Strongly Positive / Nurturing / Mastery Depicts exceptional mutual care, heroic rescue, deep affection, triumph over severe adversity, or transformative creative mastery . "The brave firefighter saved the baby bear from the burning forest. Everyone celebrated and the bear found a safe new home."

[!CRITICAL] Empirical Suicide Risk Indicator : In large-scale normative and clinical validation studies, Silver established that individuals who obtain an Emotional Content score of 1 on the DAS—especially when accompanied by persistent themes of helplessness, self-blame, and inescapable death—are at statistically elevated risk for acute clinical depression and active suicidal ideation. A score of 1 warrants an immediate clinical suicide risk assessment.

Differentiating Normal Developmental Aggression from Pathological Violence and Self-Harm

A critical competency evaluated on the ATR-BC examination is the clinician's ability to distinguish developmentally normative aggressive fantasy from pathological aggression, violent acting-out, or lethal self-harm on the DAS.

Developmental Norms vs. Clinical Pathology

Children and adolescents—particularly school-aged boys—frequently depict battle scenes, predator chases, explosions, or superheroes fighting villains. Inexperienced clinicians frequently overpathologize these drawings, mistaking developmental play for violent psychopathology. ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐

  • │ DAS AGGRESSION DIFFERENTIATION │
  • ├───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ DEVELOPMENTALLY NORMATIVE │ CLINICAL PATHOLOGY / SUICIDE RISK │
  • │ (Score 2 to 3 / Adaptive) │ (Score 1 / High Clinical Concern) │
  • ├───────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────┤
  • │ • Playful cartoon humor │ • Gruesome mutilation & torture │
  • │ • Hero vs. villain combat │ • Glorification of senseless slaughter
  • │ • Moral justice restored │ • Victim has zero defense or agency│
  • │ • Creative mastery / adventure │ • Persistent identification with │
  • │ • Client identifies with hero │ helpless victim or dead entity │
  • │ • Conventional video-game motifs │ • Overt themes of suicide/hanging │
  • └───────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────┘
  • Diagnostic Indicators of Pathological Risk

Sole Identification with the Hopeless Victim : When the client explicitly identifies with the character undergoing horrific destruction (e.g., "The boy has no friends, so he jumps off the bridge and dies" ), signaling collapsed self-worth and suicidal intent.

Absence of Justice or Resolution : Unlike superhero combat where evil is defeated, pathological narratives depict unmitigated cruelty where the innocent victim is pulverized without purpose or intervention.

Bizarre or Sadistic Details : Depicting meticulous torture, dismemberment, or excessive anatomical gore, which correlates with conduct disorder, severe antisocial traits, or uncontained trauma reenactment.

Comprehensive Comparison Matrix: Silver Drawing Test (SDT) vs. Draw-A-Story (DAS)

The following clinical matrix details the operational architecture, administrative directives, and clinical applications of Rawley Silver's non-verbal assessments:

Assessment Dimension Silver Drawing Test of Cognition & Emotion (SDT) Draw-A-Story (DAS): Screening Instrument

Primary Purpose Dual assessment of non-verbal cognitive operations and underlying emotional projection. Rapid clinical screening for depression, covert aggression, and suicidal ideation.

Subtests & Structure Three distinct subtests: 1) Predictive Drawing; 2) Drawing from Observation; 3) Drawing from Imagination. Single narrative task: Select 2+ stimulus figures, draw interactive picture, write titled story.

Theoretical Grounding Jean Piaget (spatial conservation/water-level); Jerome Bruner; psychodynamic projection. Psychodynamic projective theory; cognitive-affective screening; attachment vulnerability.

Administration Media Dedicated SDT booklet; pencil; physical 3D forms (cylinders/prisms) for Subtest 2. DAS response form; pencil; standardized deck of 14 stimulus drawing cards.

Scoring Scales Cognitive scales (1 to 5 for space, observation, representation); Emotional Content scale (1 to 5); Self-Image scale (1 to 5). Standardized 5-point Emotional Content Scale (1 = Strongly Negative to 5 = Strongly Positive).

Key Target Populations Deaf/hard of hearing; aphasic stroke patients; traumatic brain injury; ESL/ELL; cognitive delays. Children, adolescents, and adults suspected of depression, trauma, masking, or suicide risk.

Critical Exam Hallmark Subtest 1 water-level task directly tests horizontal spatial conservation without language. Score of 1 (hopeless death/victimization) serves as a validated screener for suicide assessment.

Psychometric Rigor, Cultural Humility, and ATR-BC Board Standards

Rawley Silver's assessments stand as exemplary models of psychometric rigor in art therapy literature:

Inter-Rater Reliability : Peer-reviewed studies consistently report inter-rater reliability coefficients ranging from .80 to .95 across trained raters utilizing Silver's standardized visual anchor scoring manuals.

Cross-Cultural Validity : Because the SDT and DAS bypass English language dependency, validation studies conducted across North America, Europe, Asia, and Latin America demonstrate consistent scoring norms across diverse cultural and linguistic demographics.

Board Examination Integration : On the ATCBE, candidates must remember that while the DAS effectively screens for depressive and suicidal themes, no drawing test is an autonomous diagnostic instrument . A score of 1 on the DAS mandates immediate, direct clinical inquiry (e.g., asking directly: "Have you had thoughts of wanting to end your life?" ), consultation with the treatment team, and implementation of a safety plan.