Study guide

Capacity, refusal and substitute decisions

AMC CAT MCQ Examination AMC Part 1

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Acute Coronary Syndromes & ECG Localization

ACS recognition and ECG localisation Reperfusion and infarction complications

2 Heart Failure, Cardiogenic Shock & Cardiac Arrhythmias

Heart failure assessment and treatment Arrhythmias and conduction emergencies

3 Systemic Hypertension & Peripheral Vascular Disease

Blood pressure and cardiovascular risk Secondary hypertension and arterial disease

4 Valvular Heart Disease, Infective Endocarditis & Pericarditis

Aortic and mitral valve disease Endocarditis and pericardial emergencies

5 Asthma & COPD Acute Flares and Maintenance

Asthma and COPD diagnosis and maintenance Acute asthma and COPD exacerbations

6 Pneumonia, pleural disease and respiratory failure

Pneumonia and infected pleural collections Pulmonary embolism, effusions and pneumothorax Respiratory failure, ARDS and sepsis

7 GI bleeding, bowel inflammation and malabsorption

GI bleeding assessment and resuscitation Varices, ulcers, reflux and lower GI bleeding IBD patterns and severe colitis assessment IBD treatment, coeliac disease and IBS

8 Chronic Liver Disease, Cirrhosis Complications & Acute Hepatitis

Cirrhosis diagnosis and prognosis Decompensation, viral hepatitis and surveillance

9 Diabetes, thyroid and adrenal disease

Diabetes diagnosis and ongoing care DKA, HHS and complication monitoring Thyroid disease assessment Thyroid emergencies and adrenal disease

10 Acute Kidney Injury, Chronic Kidney Disease & Fluid/Electrolyte Emergencies

AKI and chronic kidney disease Potassium and sodium emergencies

11 Anaemias, Inflammatory Arthropathies & Geriatric Comprehensive Assessment

Anaemia, bruising and blood disorders Arthritis, autoimmune disease and geriatric care

12 Evaluation of the Acute Abdomen, Peritonitis & Appendicitis

Abdominal pain, peritonitis and resuscitation Appendicitis diagnosis and treatment Perforation and mesenteric ischaemia

13 Small and Large Bowel Obstruction & Colorectal Surgical Pathology

Small bowel obstruction Colonic obstruction, volvulus and cancer recognition Colorectal care, diverticulitis and anorectal symptoms

14 Gallbladder Disease, Biliary Tract Infections & Acute Pancreatitis

Gallstones and biliary obstruction Cholangitis and pancreatitis diagnosis Pancreatitis severity and treatment

15 Advanced Trauma Life Support, Primary Survey & Life-Threatening Thoracic Injuries

Trauma primary survey and adjuncts Chest trauma and immediate threats

16 Traumatic Brain Injury, Intracranial Haemorrhage & Spinal Cord Clearance

Head injury, imaging and haemorrhage Herniation and spinal cord injury

17 Major Fractures, Joint Dislocations & Acute Compartment Syndrome

Fracture assessment and open injuries Compartment syndrome, dislocations and pelvic injury

18 Thermal Burns, Haemorrhagic Shock Resuscitation & Surgical Wound Care

Burn assessment and fluid resuscitation Bleeding shock, wound care and tetanus

19 Aortic Aneurysms & Acute Arterial Limb Ischaemia

Aneurysm recognition and planned care Ruptured aneurysm and acute limb ischaemia

20 Urological Emergencies, Testicular Torsion & Haematuria Investigation

Retention, stones and obstructed infection Scrotal pain and haematuria

21 Preoperative Risk Stratification & Postoperative Surgical Complications

Preoperative assessment and medicines Postoperative complications and prevention

22 Early Pregnancy Bleeding, Ectopic Pregnancy & Antenatal Screening

Miscarriage and ectopic pregnancy Antenatal screening and early-pregnancy comparisons

23 Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy & Medical Complications in Pregnancy

Pregnancy hypertension and preeclampsia Eclampsia, HELLP and antepartum bleeding

24 Intrapartum Monitoring, Postpartum Haemorrhage & Obstetric Emergencies

Labour physiology and CTG assessment CTG response and postpartum haemorrhage Obstetric emergencies and preterm birth

25 Abnormal Uterine Bleeding, Pelvic Pain & Endometriosis

Abnormal bleeding and structural causes Endometrial sampling and endometriosis PCOS diagnosis and long-term care

26 Contraception, Emergency Contraception & Pregnancy Termination

Contraceptive choice and missed pills Emergency contraception and abortion

27 Australian Cervical Screening Program & Gynaecological Malignancies

Cervical screening and cervical cancer Endometrial and ovarian cancer

28 Neonatal Resuscitation, Congenital Conditions & Neonatal Jaundice

Newborn resuscitation, Apgar and cyanosis Neonatal jaundice assessment Jaundice treatment and congenital screening

29 Developmental Milestones, Growth Charts & Failure to Thrive

Developmental milestones Regression, autism and support Faltering growth and developmental comparisons

30 The Limping Child, Septic Arthritis vs Transient Synovitis & Paediatric Hip Conditions

Limp assessment and septic-joint risk Joint-infection management and Perthes disease SUFE and paediatric hip comparisons

31 Croup, Bronchiolitis, Paediatric Asthma & Anaphylaxis

Croup Bronchiolitis Paediatric asthma Paediatric anaphylaxis

32 Evaluation of the Febrile Child, Sepsis & Meningococcal Disease

Febrile neonates and young infants Meningococcal disease and paediatric sepsis Bacterial meningitis and CSF interpretation Kawasaki disease and follow-up

33 Paediatric Surgical Abdomen, Dehydration & Child Protection / Non-Accidental Injury

Pyloric stenosis Intussusception and dehydration Child protection and injury assessment

34 The Mental State Examination & Suicide Risk Stratification

Mental state examination and psychotic symptoms Suicide formulation and mental health law

35 Major Depressive Disorder, Bipolar Affective Disorder & Mood Stabilisers

Depression assessment and treatment Serotonin toxicity and bipolar presentations Mood stabilisers and ECT

36 Generalised Anxiety, Panic Disorder, PTSD & Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder

Anxiety, panic and agoraphobia OCD and trauma-related disorders

37 Schizophrenia, Acute Psychosis & Antipsychotic Management

Psychosis assessment and antipsychotics Clozapine and severe adverse effects

38 Substance Use Disorders & Acute Withdrawal Syndromes

Substance disorders and alcohol withdrawal Wernicke disease, opioids and stimulants

39 Delirium vs Dementia, Perinatal Mood Disorders & Paediatric Psychiatry

Delirium and dementia assessment Cognitive behaviour, perinatal and childhood psychiatry

40 Medicare, PBS, AHPRA & Good Medical Practice Framework

Australian health services and Medicare PBS access and professional registration Professional boundaries and notifications

41 Informed Consent (Rogers v Whitaker), Mental Capacity & Involuntary Treatment

Consent, material risks and young people Capacity, refusal and substitute decisions

42 Patient Privacy, Confidentiality Exceptions & Mandatory Notifications

Privacy, disclosure and child reporting Driving fitness and threat disclosure

43 First Nations health and preventive care

First Nations health, determinants and cultural safety Community care, Item 715 and CTG medicines Immunisation and cancer screening entry points Screening pathways and primary CVD prevention

44 Epidemiological Metrics, Clinical Study Designs & Notifiable Communicable Diseases

Epidemiology, calculations, bias and surveillance

45 Neurological presentations

Stroke, TIA and focal weakness Headache, facial pain and vertigo Seizures, collapse and altered consciousness Numbness, movement disorders and generalised weakness

46 Musculoskeletal pain

Back, neck, bone and soft tissue pain

47 Eye presentations

Altered vision and retinal disease Red eye, ocular injury and discharge

48 Ear, nose, throat and oral health

Ear pain, hearing loss and tinnitus Nasal problems, neck lumps, hoarseness and dysphagia Toothache, mouth symptoms, dry mouth and halitosis

49 Skin, hair and nails

Rash, itch, infection and skin ulcers Skin lesions, hair loss and nail abnormalities

50 Breast health and feeding

Breast lumps, discharge and breastfeeding problems

51 Sexual and reproductive presentations

Genital symptoms, discharge and pelvic infection Menopause, prolapse and urinary symptoms Infertility and sexual dysfunction

52 Palliative care and carers

The dying patient, symptoms and carers

53 Eating disorders and personality care

Eating disorders, obesity and weight change Personality difficulties, self-harm and complex care

54 Sleep presentations

Insomnia, snoring and daytime sleepiness

55 Poisoning, resuscitation and environmental emergencies

Poisoning, toxidromes and antidote decisions Cardiopulmonary arrest, choking and emergency help Bites, stings, heat, cold and drowning

56 Communication, rights and professional practice

Communication, handover, errors and complaints Healthcare rights, inclusive care and equitable access Certificates, deaths, CPD and supervision Telehealth, images, prescribing and doctors' health

57 Genetics, research and donation

Genetic testing, research and organ donation

58 Travel, fever and outbreaks

Fever, travellers and outbreak response

Capacity, refusal and substitute decisions

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

A capable adult can refuse treatment even when clinicians disagree.

Assess understanding, retention, weighing and communication for the decision at hand.

Use supported decision-making and reassess reversible causes of impaired capacity.

Last updated: October 2026

Marion's Case (1992): Limits to Parental Consent

In Secretary, Department of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB (Marion's Case) (1992) 175 CLR 218 , the High Court of Australia defined the strict boundaries of parental decision-making authority over children with intellectual disabilities.

Case Background: Marion was a 14-year-old girl with severe intellectual disability, epilepsy, and behavioral issues. Her parents sought authorization to consent to a hysterectomy and bilateral oophorectomy to eliminate menstruation and prevent future pregnancy.

The High Court's Ruling:

Parental authority does NOT extend to consenting to non-therapeutic, irreversible, highly invasive medical interventions that extinguish reproductive capability or permanently alter bodily integrity.

Such procedures are designated Special Medical Procedures .

Performing a non-therapeutic sterilisation without independent judicial authorization constitutes unlawful battery.

Special medical procedures: Non-therapeutic sterilisation of a minor falls outside ordinary parental authority and requires the appropriate court process. Do not assume every guardianship tribunal has jurisdiction over a minor; obtain specialist legal advice.

Routine Pediatric Care : Decision-Making Authority: Parents / Legal Guardians; Legal Reference: Common law parental authority

Mature Minor Seeking Contraception : Decision-Making Authority: The minor independently (if capable of full comprehension); Legal Reference: Gillick v West Norfolk (1986)

Non-therapeutic Irreversible Sterilisation : Decision-Making Authority: Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia or State Guardianship Tribunal; Legal Reference: Marion's Case (1992)

Contested special treatment for a minor : Decision-Making Authority: Obtain current specialist and legal advice; parental agreement, the minor’s capacity and court requirements depend on treatment and jurisdiction; Legal Reference: Current law and the relevant court decisions

Life-saving Emergency in an Unconscious Minor : Decision-Making Authority: Treating medical team (doctrine of emergency / necessity); Legal Reference: Australian common law emergency doctrine

Assessing Mental Capacity: The Functional Approach

In Australian law, every adult is legally presumed to have decision-making capacity unless proven otherwise. Capacity cannot be determined solely on the basis of age, psychiatric diagnosis, cognitive disability, or whether a clinician agrees with the patient's choice.

Core Tenets of the Functional Framework

Decision-Specific: Capacity is not global. A patient with moderate dementia may lack the capacity to execute a complex estate will or consent to an elective coronary artery bypass graft, but may retain full capacity to consent to a routine influenza vaccination or blood test.

Time-Specific: Capacity fluctuates. In conditions such as delirium, acute intoxication, hypercapnia, or post-ictal confusion, capacity must be evaluated at the specific time the clinical decision is required. If a decision can safely be deferred until the acute metabolic or toxic state resolves, it should be postponed.

The Four-Part Functional Test: To possess capacity for a specific medical decision, the patient must be able to:

Understand: Comprehend the relevant clinical information regarding the illness, proposed treatment, realistic alternatives, and the consequences of refusing therapy.

Retain: Retain the relevant information long enough to deliberate and reach a decision.

Weigh: Process and weigh the risks, benefits, and trade-offs of the options in the balance.

Communicate: Express their choice clearly through speech, writing, signing, or augmented communication tools.

The Right to Make Unwise Decisions

A competent adult has the absolute right to make a medical decision that healthcare professionals, family members, or society regard as foolish, irrational, or contrary to their medical interests. An eccentric or unwise decision does not establish mental incapacity.

  • Treatment Refusal, Advance Care Directives & Substitute Decision-Makers
  • The Absolute Right to Refuse Treatment

A competent adult has an absolute common law right to decline any medical therapy—including artificial nutrition, mechanical ventilation, renal dialysis, or life-saving blood products. When a competent adult makes an informed refusal, treating physicians must respect that refusal. Administering treatment over an informed, competent refusal constitutes medical battery and trespass to the person.

Jehovah's Witness Patients and Blood Products

A classic clinical scenario involves adult Jehovah's Witness patients who refuse blood transfusions:

Adult refusal: Confirm decision-specific capacity, voluntariness and understanding, record the particular products/procedures declined or accepted, and respect an applicable informed refusal. A signature is useful evidence but is not the sole basis of valid refusal; beliefs differ between individuals.

Clinicians must optimize all non-blood management options (e.g., tranexamic acid, cell salvage, high-dose erythropoietin, intravenous iron, desmopressin, and surgical hemostasis).

Children and transfusion: Parents cannot refuse necessary lifesaving treatment merely because of their own beliefs. Use the local emergency statutory pathway or urgent court advice/order when needed. Mature-minor refusals also require careful legal assessment rather than assuming the adult refusal rule applies unchanged.

The Emergency Doctrine (Doctrine of Necessity)

When an adult patient is unconscious, delirious, or incompetent, and immediate clinical treatment is essential to save life or prevent serious, irreversible damage to health, clinicians are authorized under the common law doctrine of necessity to administer emergency medical treatment without consent. The emergency doctrine does not apply if clinicians are aware of an existing, legally valid advance refusal applicable to the emergency situation.

Advance care and substitute decisions

An advance directive may be statutory or recognised at common law; it is not always confined to a standard written form. Establish validity, applicability, revocation and the local statutory framework. A current capacitated decision takes precedence over an earlier plan. A valid applicable refusal is not erased merely because the patient becomes unconscious.

If capacity is absent, first check for an applicable directive and any appointed decision maker or tribunal guardian, including the scope of their authority. Default hierarchies vary. In NSW, a “person responsible” hierarchy differs from Victoria’s medical treatment decision maker scheme; an adult child is not automatically first in every state. Decisions should reflect the person’s known wishes and values, with the relevant statutory test when these are unknown.

If a substitute decision seems outside their authority or inconsistent with the legal standard, seek senior/legal or tribunal advice promptly. Emergency powers have defined conditions and do not automatically override a known valid refusal. Continue comfort care and communication regardless of whether a particular intervention is declined.

Primary references (checked 7 October 2026): Medical Board code .