Study guide

5.3 Complementary Protection and Non-Refoulement

Migration Agents Capstone Assessment OMARA, Australia

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Australian Migration Law Framework & Statutory Interpretation

1.1 Constitutional Head of Power and the Migration Act 1958 1.2 Migration Regulations 1994, Schedules, and Legislative Instruments 1.3 Administrative Decision-Making, Natural Justice, and Ministerial Discretion 1.4 Legal Research with LEGENDcom and Policy Advice Manual (PAM3)

2 Chapter 2: Employer-Sponsored and Temporary Skilled Migration

2.1 Standard Business Sponsorship and Sponsor Obligations 2.2 Subclass 482 Skills in Demand (SID) Visa Framework 2.3 Subclass 186 Employer Nomination Scheme: TRT and Direct Entry 2.4 Labour Market Testing, Market Salary, and the Skilling Australians Fund

3 Chapter 3: General Skilled Migration and Regional Pathways

3.1 SkillSelect Architecture, EOIs, and Points Test Mechanics 3.2 Subclass 189 (Skilled Independent) and Subclass 190 (Skilled Nominated) Visas 3.3 Regional Migration Pathways: Subclass 491 and Subclass 191 3.4 Skills Assessment Authorities, ANZSCO Codes, and Australian Study Requirement

4 Chapter 4: Partner and Family Visas

4.1 Partner Visa Framework: Subclass 820/801 and Subclass 309/100 4.2 Relationship Evidence and the 12-Month De Facto Rule 4.3 Subclass 300 and Current Family Violence Evidence Rules 4.4 Parent Visas (Contributory vs Non-Contributory) and Balance of Family Test

5 Chapter 5: Child, Refugee, and Humanitarian Visas

5.1 Child Visas (Subclasses 101, 802, 102 Adoption) and Dependency Definitions 5.2 Subclass 866 and the Current Statutory Refugee Test 5.3 Complementary Protection and Non-Refoulement 5.4 Offshore Humanitarian Program: Subclasses 200–204

6 Chapter 6: Visa Compliance, Integrity Criteria, and Bridging Visas

6.1 Public Interest Criterion 4020: Integrity, Consequences, and Waiver 6.2 Health Criteria (PIC 4005/4007) and Character (PIC 4001) 6.3 Section 48 Bar, Schedule 3 Criteria, and Unlawful Non-Citizens 6.4 Bridging Visas: Status, Travel, Work, and Cessation

7 Chapter 7: Visa Cancellation and Administrative & Judicial Review

7.1 Visa Cancellation: Sections 109, 116, and 128 7.2 Section 501 Character Cancellation, Mandatory Cancellation, and Ministerial Direction No. 110 7.3 Merits Review: The Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) Mechanics and Time Limits 7.4 Judicial Review: Jurisdictional Error, Remedies, Privative Clauses, and Court Pathways

8 Chapter 8: Professional Standards and the OMARA Code of Conduct

8.1 OMARA Registration, Scope of Practice, and Consumer Protection 8.2 Code of Conduct: Core Duties, Client Identity, and Confidentiality 8.3 Conflicts of Interest, Referrals, Marketing, and MARN Use 8.4 Service Agreements, Variations, Fees, and Ending Representation

9 Chapter 9: Trust Accounting, Client Funds, and Practice Management

9.1 Client Money: Segregation, Permitted Payments, and Controls 9.2 Fees, Invoices, Receipts, Statements of Services, and Refunds 9.3 Client Files, Document Return, Transfer, and Closure 9.4 OMARA Discipline, Statutory Cooperation, and Current CPD

10 Chapter 10: Client Engagement, Assessment, and Instructions

10.1 Capstone Blueprint and Preliminary Client Contact 10.2 Initial Information, Fact Chronology, and Issue Mapping 10.3 Options, Risk Advice, and Written Instructions 10.4 Formal Engagement, Scope, Costs, and Document Plan

11 Chapter 11: Application, Representation, and Case Management

11.1 Evidence Collection, Verification, Translation, and Supervision 11.2 Merits Review, Application Preparation, and Lodgement Control 11.3 Representation, Hearings, Requests, and Ongoing Monitoring 11.4 Decision Analysis, Consequences, Liability, and File Closure

12 Chapter 12: Professional Development and Practice Management

12.1 Professional Development and Establishing a Compliant Practice 12.2 Managing Finance, Staff, Risk, and Opportunity

5.3 Complementary Protection and Non-Refoulement

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Section 36(2)(aa) applies where substantial grounds establish a necessary and foreseeable real risk of significant harm if the person is removed to the receiving country.

Section 36(2A) exhaustively lists arbitrary deprivation of life, the death penalty, torture, cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment, and degrading treatment or punishment.

Section 36(2B)(a) concerns reasonable relocation, paragraph (b) effective authority protection, and paragraph (c) a risk faced by the population generally rather than personally.

Complementary protection does not require a Convention reason, but section 36(2C), third-country rights, credibility, and the statutory definitions of harm must still be assessed.

Last updated: September 2026

5.3 Complementary Protection and Non-Refoulement

Complementary protection must be assessed independently when a person does not meet the statutory refugee definition. It protects against specified extreme harm without requiring race, religion, nationality, particular-social-group membership, or political opinion as the reason.

Criterion and real-risk inquiry

Under section 36(2)(aa), the Minister must have substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of removal to a receiving country, there is a real risk the person will suffer significant harm. The inquiry is forward-looking and evidence-based. It considers the person’s particular circumstances, credible country information, likely actors, state response, and all reasonably available areas of return.

The real-risk concept is not a balance-of-probabilities requirement, but speculative or merely possible harm is insufficient. Analyse each claimed harm, source, likelihood, location, and reason the applicant personally faces it.

Exhaustive significant harm categories

Section 36(2A) states that significant harm occurs where the person will be:

  • arbitrarily deprived of life;
  • subjected to the death penalty being carried out;
  • subjected to torture;
  • subjected to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment; or

subjected to degrading treatment or punishment.

The Act defines torture, cruel or inhuman treatment, and degrading treatment. Severe pain, intention, purpose, extreme humiliation, and lawful-sanctions qualifications differ between definitions. Do not replace the statutory elements with a general humanitarian-hardship test. Poverty, lack of preferred medical treatment, discrimination, or distress may be grave without falling within an exhaustive category unless the facts meet its definition.

Correct section 36(2B) mapping

The prior guide reversed the paragraphs. The current exceptions are:

paragraph (a)—reasonable relocation: no real risk is taken to exist if it would be reasonable for the person to relocate to an area without the risk;

paragraph (b)—authority protection: no real risk if an authority of the country can provide protection such that the risk is removed; and

paragraph (c)—general population risk: no real risk where the risk is faced by the population generally and not by the non-citizen personally.

Relocation requires more than theoretical physical access. Assess the person, proposed area, safety, support, lawful residence, essential needs, and reach of the actor. Authority protection must actually remove the real risk, not merely show that police exist. For paragraph (c), identify whether an individual characteristic or circumstance creates a personal risk different from the general hazard.

Exclusions and other countries

Section 36(2C) excludes specified international crimes, serious non-political crime, acts contrary to UN purposes, security danger, and certain particularly serious criminals who endanger the community. Section 36(3) and related provisions address rights to enter and reside in another country, subject to their statutory exceptions. These are separate from the merits of harm in the claimed receiving country.

Evidence method

Use current, attributable country sources and explain why they apply to this person. Medical or psychological evidence can support past harm and vulnerability but does not itself prove future country conditions. Where accounts changed, give the client a fair opportunity to explain and assess the explanation in context.

Scenario

A resident of a city exposed to indiscriminate shelling invokes complementary protection. Paragraph 36(2B)(c), not paragraph (a), addresses a risk faced by the population generally and not personally. The agent should examine whether the applicant has a personal feature—location, occupation, disability, ethnicity, prior targeting, or inability to access shelter—that makes the risk personal. If a safe area is proposed, paragraph (a) separately asks whether relocation there is reasonable; paragraph (b) separately asks whether authority protection removes the risk.

Alternative protection analysis

Run complementary protection as a separate statutory pathway after, and not as a substitute for, refugee analysis. Create one row for each alleged form of significant harm and identify the actor, future-risk evidence, receiving country, personal exposure, relocation possibility, available authority protection, general-population issue, and any section 36(2C) exclusion. Test whether the harm fits one of the exhaustive section 36(2A) categories; hardship, poor services, discrimination, or danger may be serious without meeting that definition. Address cumulative facts where they bear on the defined harm, but do not invent an open-ended humanitarian discretion. Check third-country residence or entry rights and the practical durability of those rights. In submissions, state why the risk is necessary and foreseeable on the evidence and why each paragraph of section 36(2B) does or does not apply. This structure keeps complementary protection legally distinct while using the same disciplined credibility and country-research record.