Study guide
6.3 Section 48 Bar, Schedule 3 Criteria, and Unlawful Non-Citizens
Migration Agents Capstone Assessment OMARA, Australia
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Australian Migration Law Framework & Statutory Interpretation
1.1 Constitutional Head of Power and the Migration Act 1958 1.2 Migration Regulations 1994, Schedules, and Legislative Instruments 1.3 Administrative Decision-Making, Natural Justice, and Ministerial Discretion 1.4 Legal Research with LEGENDcom and Policy Advice Manual (PAM3)
2 Chapter 2: Employer-Sponsored and Temporary Skilled Migration
2.1 Standard Business Sponsorship and Sponsor Obligations 2.2 Subclass 482 Skills in Demand (SID) Visa Framework 2.3 Subclass 186 Employer Nomination Scheme: TRT and Direct Entry 2.4 Labour Market Testing, Market Salary, and the Skilling Australians Fund
3 Chapter 3: General Skilled Migration and Regional Pathways
3.1 SkillSelect Architecture, EOIs, and Points Test Mechanics 3.2 Subclass 189 (Skilled Independent) and Subclass 190 (Skilled Nominated) Visas 3.3 Regional Migration Pathways: Subclass 491 and Subclass 191 3.4 Skills Assessment Authorities, ANZSCO Codes, and Australian Study Requirement
4 Chapter 4: Partner and Family Visas
4.1 Partner Visa Framework: Subclass 820/801 and Subclass 309/100 4.2 Relationship Evidence and the 12-Month De Facto Rule 4.3 Subclass 300 and Current Family Violence Evidence Rules 4.4 Parent Visas (Contributory vs Non-Contributory) and Balance of Family Test
5 Chapter 5: Child, Refugee, and Humanitarian Visas
5.1 Child Visas (Subclasses 101, 802, 102 Adoption) and Dependency Definitions 5.2 Subclass 866 and the Current Statutory Refugee Test 5.3 Complementary Protection and Non-Refoulement 5.4 Offshore Humanitarian Program: Subclasses 200–204
6 Chapter 6: Visa Compliance, Integrity Criteria, and Bridging Visas
6.1 Public Interest Criterion 4020: Integrity, Consequences, and Waiver 6.2 Health Criteria (PIC 4005/4007) and Character (PIC 4001) 6.3 Section 48 Bar, Schedule 3 Criteria, and Unlawful Non-Citizens 6.4 Bridging Visas: Status, Travel, Work, and Cessation
7 Chapter 7: Visa Cancellation and Administrative & Judicial Review
7.1 Visa Cancellation: Sections 109, 116, and 128 7.2 Section 501 Character Cancellation, Mandatory Cancellation, and Ministerial Direction No. 110 7.3 Merits Review: The Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) Mechanics and Time Limits 7.4 Judicial Review: Jurisdictional Error, Remedies, Privative Clauses, and Court Pathways
8 Chapter 8: Professional Standards and the OMARA Code of Conduct
8.1 OMARA Registration, Scope of Practice, and Consumer Protection 8.2 Code of Conduct: Core Duties, Client Identity, and Confidentiality 8.3 Conflicts of Interest, Referrals, Marketing, and MARN Use 8.4 Service Agreements, Variations, Fees, and Ending Representation
9 Chapter 9: Trust Accounting, Client Funds, and Practice Management
9.1 Client Money: Segregation, Permitted Payments, and Controls 9.2 Fees, Invoices, Receipts, Statements of Services, and Refunds 9.3 Client Files, Document Return, Transfer, and Closure 9.4 OMARA Discipline, Statutory Cooperation, and Current CPD
10 Chapter 10: Client Engagement, Assessment, and Instructions
10.1 Capstone Blueprint and Preliminary Client Contact 10.2 Initial Information, Fact Chronology, and Issue Mapping 10.3 Options, Risk Advice, and Written Instructions 10.4 Formal Engagement, Scope, Costs, and Document Plan
11 Chapter 11: Application, Representation, and Case Management
11.1 Evidence Collection, Verification, Translation, and Supervision 11.2 Merits Review, Application Preparation, and Lodgement Control 11.3 Representation, Hearings, Requests, and Ongoing Monitoring 11.4 Decision Analysis, Consequences, Liability, and File Closure
12 Chapter 12: Professional Development and Practice Management
12.1 Professional Development and Establishing a Compliant Practice 12.2 Managing Finance, Staff, Risk, and Opportunity
6.3 Section 48 Bar, Schedule 3 Criteria, and Unlawful Non-Citizens
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Section 48 limits an in-zone non-citizen who lacks a substantive visa and has had a visa refused or cancelled since last entry to the visa classes prescribed in regulation 2.12.
Regulation 2.12 currently includes specified Partner, Protection, Medical Treatment, Bridging, Child (Residence), Skilled Nominated, subclass 491, and subclass 494 classes, among others; subclass numbers are not a substitute for checking the prescribed class.
Schedule 3 criteria are not interchangeable: 3001 is a 28-day validity window, 3002 is a 12-month window, 3003 addresses a historical pre-September 1994 cohort, 3004 contains the modern factors-beyond-control and compelling-reasons test, and 3005 bars repeat reliance on specified historical Schedule 3-type grants.
Clause 820.211(2)(d)(ii) can displace criteria 3001, 3003, and 3004 where compelling reasons exist, and Waensila requires decision-time consideration rather than limiting the inquiry to application-time circumstances.
A valid Partner application does not itself make an unlawful applicant lawful or guarantee a bridging visa; status, detention, removal, work, travel, and cessation require separate urgent advice.
Last updated: September 2026
6.3 Section 48, Schedule 3, and Unlawful Status
Three questions must be answered separately: can the person make a valid application despite section 48; does the visa’s Schedule 2 criteria import any Schedule 3 requirements; and what visa, if any, keeps the person lawful while the new matter is pending? Success on one question does not answer the others.
Section 48
Section 48 applies where the person is in the migration zone, does not hold a substantive visa, and since last entering Australia has had a visa refused or cancelled on a statutory basis covered by the section. The person may apply in the migration zone only for a visa of a class prescribed in regulation 2.12. An attempted application for another class does not become valid merely because the portal accepts data or payment.
Current regulation 2.12 prescribes classes, not a free-floating list of subclasses. They include Partner (Temporary) and Partner (Residence), protection visas, Medical Treatment (Visitor), the Bridging classes, Child (Residence), Skilled—Nominated (Permanent), Skilled Work Regional (Provisional), and Skilled Employer Sponsored Regional (Provisional), plus other listed classes. Confirm the class and Schedule 1 item for the proposed application. For example, subclass 820 is within Partner (Temporary) (Class UK), while a subclass 186 application is not made valid by regulation 2.12.
Section 48 operates on applications made in the migration zone. Departure may permit an offshore application and changes the “since last entering” inquiry if the person later re-enters, but leaving does not erase PIC consequences, return criteria, re-entry bans, location criteria, or another application bar. Advise about present status, departure arrangements, the prospect of obtaining a visa offshore, and whether the person can lawfully return.
Repeat protection applications
Section 48A is a separate bar for a non-citizen in the migration zone who, since last entering, has been refused a Protection visa or held a Protection visa that was cancelled. Regulation 2.12 does not displace section 48A. Section 48B gives the Minister a personal, non-compellable public-interest power to determine that section 48A does not prevent a further Protection-visa application. A request does not itself authorise an application, keep the person lawful, stay removal, or require the Minister to consider exercising the power.
What Schedule 3 actually says
Schedule 3 is incorporated only where the particular Schedule 2 clause requires it. The five criteria perform different functions:
Criterion Current role
3001 The application was validly made within 28 days after the “relevant day” defined in 3001(2). The relevant-day definition has several limbs; it is not always simply visa expiry.
3002 The application was validly made within 12 months after that relevant day. It is a timing criterion, not itself a factors-beyond-control test.
3003 A substantive merits criterion for a narrow historical cohort who had not held a substantive visa on or after 1 September 1994 and were an illegal entrant or held an expiring entry permit on 31 August 1994.
3004 The modern merits criterion for a person who ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994, or entered unlawfully on or after that date without a later substantive visa. It tests factors beyond control, compelling reasons, substantial compliance, counterfactual eligibility, intended compliance, and the transitional-condition rule.
3005 No visa or entry permit has previously been granted on the basis of specified Schedule 3 or historical equivalent criteria. It is not an assurance-of-support or “valid reasons” test.
Read the subclass clause to see which criteria it imports. Do not say every non-substantive holder must satisfy all five. For a primary subclass 820 applicant who lacks a substantive visa, clause 820.211(2)(d)(ii) ordinarily refers to criteria 3001, 3003, and 3004 , subject to the compelling-reasons alternative. Criterion 3002 appears in the separate diplomatic or special-purpose limb.
Partner waiver and Waensila
Clause 820.211(2)(d)(ii) does not “waive Schedule 3” in the abstract. It provides an alternative where the Minister is satisfied there are compelling reasons for not applying the named criteria . In Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection , the Full Court held that the inquiry is not confined to compelling circumstances existing at application; relevant circumstances up to decision must be considered.
Evidence must establish why the criteria should not be applied in this case. Possible facts include the best interests and dependency of Australian children, serious sponsor illness or disability, family violence, custody orders, safety, and the real consequences of separation. Pregnancy, relationship length, finances, or inconvenience are not automatic outcomes. Link each fact to the applicant, sponsor, children, lawful offshore alternative, expected separation, and evidence. Continue updating the case because the decision-time position matters.
Status workflow
An unlawful person remains exposed to section 189 detention until a visa is in effect. A valid subclass 820 application does not itself guarantee an immediate BVC or BVE grant. Obtain all prior grants, refusal and notification evidence, movement records, bridging records, and any review history. Identify the available bridging subclass and criteria, lodge only on informed instructions, and check grant, commencement, conditions, work, reporting, travel, and cessation from the actual notice.
Scenario
Liam’s Student visa application was refused after his Working Holiday visa ended, he did not seek review, his BVA later ceased, and he is now unlawful. He has an Australian de facto partner who is pregnant. Section 48 applies, but Partner (Temporary) (Class UK) is prescribed, so an otherwise valid subclass 820 application can be made. Because Liam lacks a substantive visa, analyse clause 820.211(2)(d), the named Schedule 3 criteria, and the compelling-reasons alternative. Build decision-time evidence under Waensila, but explain that neither the pregnancy nor the application guarantees the waiver, visa grant, or bridging status.