Study guide

7.2 The Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz Coordination Rule

Queensland Electrical Licence Capstone Assessment Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Capstone Overview

1.1 Current Capstone Exam Facts 1.2 Capstone Written & Practical Format 1.3 Queensland ESO Licence Pathway

2 AS/NZS 3000 Fundamentals

2.1 Scope & Fundamental Principles 2.2 Nominal Voltages & System Classifications 2.3 Conductor Identification & Colour Coding 2.4 Protection Against Electric Shock

3 Isolation, Switching & Special Locations

3.1 Isolation & Switching 3.2 Special Locations (Bathrooms, Pools & More) 3.3 Installation Defects & Rectification

4 Cable Selection Basics (AS/NZS 3008)

4.1 Current-Carrying Capacity & Installation Methods 4.2 Reference Temperatures & Insulation Types 4.3 Grouping & Thermal Derating Factors 4.4 Cable Short-Circuit Capacity

5 Voltage Drop & Selection Order

5.1 Voltage Drop (mV/A·m) & the 5% Limit 5.2 Order of Cable-Selection Checks 5.3 Worked Cable Selection Examples

6 Maximum Demand Calculations

6.1 Diversity & Appendix C Overview 6.2 Domestic Table C1 Demand Factors 6.3 Commercial Demand & Mains/Main-Switch Sizing

7 Circuit Protection Coordination

7.1 Overload & Short-Circuit Protection 7.2 The Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz Coordination Rule 7.3 Circuit-Breaker Curves & Breaking Capacity 7.4 Discrimination & Selectivity

8 RCDs, Division of Circuits & SELV/PELV

8.1 RCD Types & 30 mA Additional Protection 8.2 Division of Circuits 8.3 SELV & PELV Systems

9 Earthing & the MEN System

9.1 MEN System Principles & Fault Return Path 9.2 The MEN Link at the Main Switchboard 9.3 Main Earthing Conductor Sizing (Table 5.1) 9.4 Equipotential Bonding

10 Electrodes, Adiabatic & Prospective Fault Current

10.1 Earth Electrodes & Arrangements 10.2 The Adiabatic Equation for Protective Conductors 10.3 Prospective Fault Current

11 Earth-Fault-Loop Impedance & Disconnection

11.1 Earth-Fault-Loop Impedance (Zs = Ze + R1 + R2) 11.2 Disconnection Times (0.4 s & 5 s) 11.3 Breaking Capacity Coordination with PFC

12 Consumer Mains & Submains

12.1 Point of Supply Definitions 12.2 Consumer Mains Sizing & Installation 12.3 Submains Definitions & Sizing 12.4 Neutral & Earth Separation Downstream

13 QLD Electrical Safety Legislation

13.1 Electrical Safety Act 2002 & the ESO 13.2 Licensing Classes & Worker Duties 13.3 Certificates of Testing & Compliance 13.4 Construction Sites (AS/NZS 3012)

14 Safe Work & Critical Theory

14.1 Safe Isolation & Lock-Out/Tag-Out 14.2 Energised Electrical Work Controls 14.3 Effects of Electric Current (Critical EPC Theory)

15 Testing & Verification

15.1 AS/NZS 3000 Section 8 Test Sequence 15.2 Earth Continuity & Polarity 15.3 Insulation Resistance (1 MΩ at 500 V DC) 15.4 RCD Testing & Loop-Impedance Verification 15.5 AS/NZS 3017 Verification, Reporting & Documentation

16 DC, AC & Three-Phase Circuit Theory

16.1 DC Circuits, Ohm’s Law & Power 16.2 AC Generation, RMS Values & Phase 16.3 Three-Phase Systems & Phase Sequence

17 Motors, Transformers & Switchboards

17.1 Motor Selection, Enclosures & Starting Methods 17.2 Motor Overload & Short-Circuit Protection 17.3 Transformer Key Safety Issues 17.4 Switchboard Location, Arrangement & Form Types

18 Wiring Systems, Aerials & Hazardous Areas

18.1 Cable Installation & Termination Requirements 18.2 Final Subcircuits Into Switchboards 18.3 Aerial Conductors & Underground Wiring 18.4 Hazardous Areas & Classified Zones

19 Drawings, Commissioning & Fault Rectification

19.1 Reading, Sketching & Interpreting Electrical Diagrams 19.2 Commissioning & Decommissioning 19.3 Diagnosing & Rectifying Faults

20 Workplace Safety, Rescue & High Voltage

20.1 Statutory WHS Duties, Supervision & Duty of Care 20.2 Asbestos, Silica & Hazardous Gases 20.3 Workplace Safety Checks & Hazard Control 20.4 Rescue From Live Electrical Conductors 20.5 Electric Shock First Aid & CPR 20.6 High Voltage Dangers & Distribution Systems

7.2 The Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz Coordination Rule

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Ib is the circuit design current; In is the protective device rated current; Iz is the conductor CCC after all applicable derating for the installed method

Ib ≤ In prevents nuisance operation: the device rating must be at least the intended continuous design load

In ≤ Iz ensures the cable can carry the protective device’s continuous rating so overload heat is limited in the conductors before the device is expected to operate

Sizing a breaker to the load alone while ignoring Iz is a classic the capstone and site defect — the cable may overheat under currents the breaker still considers acceptable

Iz always means after derating (grouping, insulation, ambient, enclosure); tabulated free-air CCC is not automatically Iz

Last updated: August 2026

The Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz Coordination Rule

Quick Answer: For ordinary overload coordination taught with AS/NZS 3000 / AS/NZS 3008: Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz . Ib = design current of the circuit, In = rated current of the protective device, Iz = current-carrying capacity of the conductors after derating. The left inequality stops chronic nuisance tripping on normal load; the right inequality stops the cable cooking under currents the device still allows.

The Three Currents You Must Name

Every cable-and-protection question on the capstone eventually collapses to three numbers. Write them on the page before you touch a table.

Symbol Name Meaning

Ib Design current Current the circuit is designed to carry in normal service (from load calculation, diversity where applicable, or stated design load)

In Protective device rating Rated current of the fuse or circuit-breaker protecting the conductors

Iz Cable capacity in situ Current-carrying capacity of the installed conductors after all AS/NZS 3008 derating factors for method, ambient, grouping, thermal insulation, etc.

Iz is not the raw catalogue CCC for a cable lying on a cool bench. Chapter 4 taught derating; this chapter uses the result. If grouping and roof insulation cut a tabulated 32 A down to 22 A, then Iz = 22 A for coordination — not 32 A.

Why Ib ≤ In

The protective device must be able to carry the intended design current continuously without operating. If In < Ib , the breaker or fuse is smaller than the load you claim the circuit will supply. Outcomes:

Nuisance tripping or fuse melting in normal service.

Pressure to “upsize the breaker” without revisiting cable size — which creates the next inequality’s trap.

A design that was never honest about load.

So In is chosen at least equal to Ib (and in practice often the next standard rating above Ib, subject to other rules). Lighting and socket circuits, fixed appliances and motor circuits all start from a clear Ib before In is selected.

Note: motor starting and inrush are handled with curve type and sometimes dedicated motor protection (Section 7.3), not by violating Ib ≤ In for continuous rating. A 10 A design current still wants In ≥ 10 A; a Type C or D characteristic may be chosen so start current does not instantaneous-trip.

Why In ≤ Iz

This is the inequality candidates forget under time pressure.

The protective device’s In is the continuous current it is designed to carry indefinitely without operating. Conductors on the load side (and generally the protected run) must be able to carry at least that continuous current without exceeding their temperature limits. If Iz < In :

Currents between Iz and In can flow for a long time without the device treating them as overload.

The cable is the weak thermal link: insulation temperature rises above the design limit while the breaker “sees” a current it considers acceptable.

You have not provided effective overload protection of the conductors relative to their installed capacity.

Hence In ≤ Iz : choose a cable (or installation method) so that after derating, capacity is at least the protective device rating used for that coordination check.

  • Inequality Plain-English reason Failure if violated
  • Ib ≤ In Device rating ≥ design load Nuisance operation or dishonest load/device match

In ≤ Iz Cable (after derating) ≥ device continuous rating Cable overheats under currents the device still allows

Together: Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz .

The Classic Trap: “Breaker Matches the Load”

Exam and site story:

Load calculation gives Ib = 18 A .

Candidate selects a 20 A MCB ( In = 20 A ) — so far Ib ≤ In looks fine.

Candidate grabs 2.5 mm² because “that’s what we always use,” without checking the installed method.

After grouping and thermal insulation, Iz = 17 A .

Now In (20 A) > Iz (17 A) — coordination fails.

The trap was sizing the breaker to the load only . Correct practice:

Establish Ib .

Select In ≥ Ib (standard rating).

Select cable / method so Iz ≥ In (read AS/NZS 3008, apply derating).

Still check voltage drop, fault withstand and disconnection (Chapters 4–5 themes).

If Iz cannot reach In, increase conductor size , improve installation method/grouping, or redesign — do not pretend derating does not apply.

Worked Teaching Example A — Final Subcircuit

Given (illustrative numbers — verify live AS/NZS 3008 tables on assessment day):

Single-phase final subcircuit, Ib = 16 A continuous design current.

Proposed MCB In = 20 A .

Copper thermoplastic twin-and-earth, clipped direct, no extra derating → suppose tabulated CCC for 2.5 mm² ≈ 27 A (illustrative) → Iz ≈ 27 A .

Check: 16 ≤ 20 ≤ 27 → passes continuous coordination. Still verify voltage drop and short-circuit withstand before locking the design.

Change only the installation method: same 2.5 mm² in a hot, grouped roof-space route. After factors, Iz = 18 A . Now 16 ≤ 20 ≤ 18 fails on In ≤ Iz. Upsize to a size whose derated Iz ≥ 20 A, or revise enclosure/grouping. The load did not change — Iz did.

Worked Teaching Example B — Refusing to Upsize In Blindly

Ib = 28 A . Someone proposes In = 32 A on a cable whose derated Iz = 30 A . Ib ≤ In holds (28 ≤ 32), but In ≤ Iz fails (32 ≰ 30). Illegal “fix”: leave the 32 A breaker and hope. Legal paths: larger cable / better method so Iz ≥ 32 A, or a redesign that uses a lower In only if Ib and application still allow (usually you do not drop In below a proper Ib). Never “fix” coordination by ignoring Iz.

Relationship to Maximum Demand and Submains

For consumer mains and submains, Ib is often the diversified maximum demand (Chapter 6) or the design current of that distribution run. The same rule applies: main switch / protective device In and mains conductor Iz must satisfy Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz (alongside distributor rules and voltage-drop limits). Large MCCBs do not exempt you from the inequality; they only change how In is labelled on the trip unit.

What the Rule Does Not Replace

Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz is continuous overload coordination . It does not by itself prove:

Short-circuit breaking capacity (Icu/Ics vs prospective fault current).

Instantaneous curve suitability for motor starting.

Discrimination between upstream and downstream devices.

Earth-fault loop impedance / disconnection times.

Voltage drop ≤ 5% end-to-end.

Pass the inequality, then keep walking the selection checklist.

Capstone Open-Book Habits

Write Ib, In, Iz with units (A) and state the derating assumptions for Iz.

Show the two comparisons explicitly — markers reward visible logic.

Quote that Iz comes from AS/NZS 3008 after factors, not from memory of “2.5 mm² = 20 A always.”

If a question gives only load and breaker rating, ask yourself what is missing: Iz .

Bridge Forward

With continuous coordination understood, Section 7.3 explains why two breakers of equal In behave differently on start current and fault current (curves), and whether the device can interrupt the fault at all (breaking capacity).

Loading diagram... Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz continuous coordination