Study guide

2.3 Notch-Toughness Tests, Fillet-Weld Tests & Special Examinations

AWS ASME BPVC Section IX + B31.1/B31.3 Endorsement CWI/SCWI

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Structure, Logistics & Code Navigation Strategy

1.1 Credential Overview, Prometric Delivery & July 2025 Hard-Copy Rule 1.2 The Three-Code Triad: Section IX, B31.1, and B31.3 Roles & Interrelationships 1.3 Rapid Code-Book Navigation: Tabbing, Cross-Referencing & Time Management

2 Chapter 2: Section IX Article I — General Welding Requirements

2.1 Scope, Responsibilities & Section IX Architecture 2.2 Mechanical Test Types, Specimen Dimensions & Acceptance Criteria 2.3 Notch-Toughness Tests, Fillet-Weld Tests & Special Examinations

3 Chapter 3: Section IX Article II — Procedure Qualification Fundamentals

3.1 PQR vs. WPS Workflow, Purpose & Content Requirements 3.2 Coupling and Supporting Multiple WPSs and PQRs 3.3 Test Coupons, Preparation & Required Test Specimen Allocations

4 Chapter 4: Section IX Procedure Qualification Limits & Thickness Rules

4.1 Base Metal & Deposited Weld Metal Thickness Limits 4.2 Impact Testing Requirements & Toughness Thickness Qualification Ranges 4.3 Fillet Weld Procedure Qualification Rules & Special Applications

5 Chapter 5: Section IX Article III — Welder Performance Qualification Fundamentals

5.1 Welder & Welding Operator Qualification Intent, Responsibilities & Identification 5.2 Qualification Testing Methods: Mechanical Bend Tests vs. Volumetric NDE 5.3 Welder Qualification Continuity, Expiration, and Requalification

6 Chapter 6: Section IX Welder Performance Limits, Positions & Diameters

6.1 Test Positions, Groove Weld Orientations & Production Position Limits 6.2 Welder Thickness Limits and Pipe Diameter Qualification Ranges 6.3 Welder Essential Variables: F-Numbers, Backing, and Process Transfers

7 Chapter 7: Section IX Article IV — Welding Variables by Process (Part 1: SMAW & GTAW)

7.1 Understanding Essential, Supplementary Essential & Nonessential Variables 7.2 Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW) Procedure Variables 7.3 Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) Procedure Variables

8 Chapter 8: Section IX Article IV — Welding Variables by Process (Part 2: GMAW/FCAW & SAW)

8.1 GMAW & FCAW Procedure Variables and Short-Circuiting Transfer Rules 8.2 Submerged Arc Welding (SAW) Procedure Variables and Flux-Wire Combinations 8.3 Special Variables: Heat Input, Electrical Characteristics & Shielding Gases

9 Chapter 9: Section IX Material Classifications, Numbers & Standard Documentation

9.1 Base Metal P-Numbers, Group Numbers, and S-Numbers 9.2 Filler Metal F-Numbers and As-Deposited Chemistry A-Numbers 9.3 ASME Standard Documentation: Auditing WPS, PQR, and WPQ Forms

10 Chapter 10: ASME B31.1 Power Piping — Scope, Materials, Design & Welding Fabrication

10.1 B31.1 Scope, Jurisdiction, Boiler External Piping vs. Non-Boiler External Piping 10.2 B31.1 Welding Requirements, Joint Alignment, Backing Rings & Tack Welds 10.3 B31.1 Welder & Procedure Qualification Interfacing with Section IX 10.4 B31.1 Materials, Design Conditions & Pressure Design of Components

11 Chapter 11: ASME B31.1 Power Piping — Heat Treatment, Examination, Testing & Fabrication Records

11.1 B31.1 Preheat Rules & Mandatory Temperatures 11.2 B31.1 Postweld Heat Treatment (PWHT) Rules, Temperatures & Holding Times 11.3 B31.1 Mandatory NDE Examination, Acceptance Standards & Pressure Leak Tests 11.4 B31.1 Bending, Forming, Assembly & Code Records

12 Chapter 12: ASME B31.3 Process Piping — Scope, Fluid Services, Materials, Design & Welding

12.1 B31.3 Scope, Fluid Service Classifications & Owner Responsibilities 12.2 B31.3 Welding, Joint Preparation, Backing Rings & Fabrication Details 12.3 B31.3 Procedure & Performance Qualification Rules and Section IX Exceptions 12.4 B31.3 Materials, Design Conditions & Pressure Design of Components

13 Chapter 13: ASME B31.3 Process Piping — Heat Treatment, Examination, Testing, Fabrication & Records

13.1 B31.3 Preheat and Postweld Heat Treatment Rules & Tables 13.2 B31.3 Inspection vs. Examination Responsibilities & Examination Extents 13.3 B31.3 Acceptance Criteria for Weld Imperfections 13.4 B31.3 Pressure Leak Testing: Hydrostatic, Pneumatic & Sensitive Leak Tests 13.5 B31.3 Bending, Forming, Assembly & Records

2.3 Notch-Toughness Tests, Fillet-Weld Tests & Special Examinations

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ASME Section IX Article I does not establish impact testing energy values or test temperatures; QW-171 mandates that Charpy V-notch (CVN) test temperatures, minimum absorbed energy, and lateral expansion criteria are governed entirely by the referencing construction code (e.g., ASME B31.3 Table 323.3.5 or Section VIII Div 1 UG-84).

When Charpy impact testing is mandated by a construction code, the 'supplementary essential variables' listed in QW-250 become mandatory essential variables for procedure qualification.

Under QW-182 the fillet-weld fracture test is loaded to break the specimen through the weld with the root in tension; the fractured surface shall show complete penetration to the root and be free of cracks and incomplete fusion, with inclusions and porosity limited to a total length of 3/8 in. (10 mm) on the fractured surface.

Fillet-weld procedure macro-examination under QW-183 and QW-462.4(a) requires cutting five cross-sections from the test assembly; each etched face must exhibit complete fusion at the root and between layers, freedom from cracks, and leg lengths within specified concavity/convexity limits.

Welder performance visual examination (QW-194) requires complete joint penetration and fusion, with zero tolerance for cracks, lack of penetration, or lack of fusion prior to conducting mechanical or volumetric NDE testing.

Last updated: September 2026

2.3 Notch-Toughness Tests, Fillet-Weld Tests & Special Examinations

Beyond standard tension and guided-bend tests, ASME Section IX Article I governs specialized test methods designed to evaluate low-temperature notch toughness, fillet weld structural integrity, and nondestructive volumetric quality. For the AWS ASME Endorsement exam, candidates must master the precise boundaries where Section IX procedural rules intersect with the external requirements of referencing construction codes such as ASME B31.1 , ASME B31.3 , and ASME Section VIII .

1. Notch-Toughness Tests (QW-170)

Brittle fracture in pressure piping and vessels occurs rapidly without significant plastic deformation, typically at low service temperatures or in thick-walled components subjected to high restraint. Notch-toughness testing evaluates the capacity of the weld metal and heat-affected zone (HAZ) to resist brittle crack propagation.

The Fundamental Code Rule (QW-171.1)

One of the most notorious traps on the AWS Endorsement examination revolves around where to find impact test acceptance criteria. Candidates often search through Section IX looking for tables of required foot-pounds ( f t ⋅ l b f ft\cdot lbf f t ⋅ l b f ) or Joules ( J J J ).

CRITICAL CODE FACT : ASME Section IX DOES NOT establish Charpy impact energy values, lateral expansion thresholds, or test temperatures.

Paragraph QW-171.1 explicitly dictates that:

The test procedures, specimen dimensions, and notch configurations shall conform to the referencing construction code or ASTM A370.

The test temperature and acceptance criteria (such as minimum average absorbed energy, minimum single specimen energy, shear percentage, or mils lateral expansion) are dictated solely by the referencing construction code (such as ASME B31.3 Table 323.3.5, ASME B31.1 para 124, or Section VIII Division 1 Table UG-84.1).

Role of Supplementary Essential Variables

In Article IV (QW-250 variable tables), variables are classified as Essential , Supplementary Essential , or Nonessential .

Under standard conditions, Supplementary Essential Variables are treated as Nonessential.

However , when the referencing construction code mandates notch-toughness testing (e.g., low-temperature service under B31.3 Fluid Service rules), all supplementary essential variables automatically become mandatory essential variables for that WPS/PQR.

Examples include limits on heat input ( k J / in. kJ/\text{in.} k J / in. ), changes in welding process progression (uphill vs. downhill), changes in base metal P-Number Group Numbers, and increases in postweld heat treatment temperature or time.

Specimen Location & Removal (QW-172 & QW-463.1(f))

When impact testing is required, standard Charpy V-notch (CVN) specimens ( 10 mm × 10 mm × 55 mm 10\text{ mm} \times 10\text{ mm} \times 55\text{ mm} 10 mm × 10 mm × 55 mm ) are extracted from the test coupon:

Specimen Orientation : Transverse to the longitudinal axis of the weld, with the notch cut perpendicular to the surface of the plate or pipe.

Required Locations : A minimum of one set (typically 3 specimens per set) must be taken from the weld metal centerline , and one set must be taken from the heat-affected zone (HAZ) .

HAZ Notch Placement : The notch must be positioned to sample the maximum amount of HAZ microstructure (often verified by optical macro-etching prior to cutting the notch).

2. Fillet-Weld Tests (QW-180)

Fillet welds represent a significant percentage of all structural, socket, and attachment welds in piping and vessels. Section IX provides dedicated qualification testing protocols for fillet welds under paragraph QW-180, utilized for both procedure qualification (QW-202.2(c) and QW-451.3) and performance qualification (QW-303.2 and QW-452.5). [Fillet Weld Test Assembly: QW-462.4(a)]

  • ┌────────────────────────────────────┐
  • │ Stem / Web Plate │
  • └──────────────────┬─────────────────┘
  • │
  • Fillet Weld 1 ──► /\ │ /\ ◄── Fillet Weld 2
  • /__\ │ /__\
  • ───────────────────┴───────────────────
  • Base / Flange Plate
  • Fillet-Weld Fracture Test (QW-182)

The fillet-weld fracture test evaluates internal soundness and root fusion:

Specimen Preparation : The test assembly (T-joint) is sectioned to produce the fracture specimen; the specimen length and cut locations are fixed by the applicable QW-462.4 figure for the coupon being tested, so read the figure rather than assuming a length.

Loading Method : The stem plate is loaded (by hydraulic press or mechanical blow) such that the root of the weld is subjected to tension until the specimen fractures or bends flat upon itself.

Acceptance Criteria (QW-182) :

The fractured surface must show complete penetration to the root of the joint .

The weld must be completely free of cracks and free from lack of fusion .

Porosity and Inclusion Limits : The sum of the lengths of inclusions and porosity visible on the fractured surface shall not exceed 3/8 in. (10 mm) .

Fillet-Weld Macro-Examination (QW-183)

Macro-examination provides a cross-sectional metallurgical window into weld geometry, fusion, and profile:

Specimen Extraction & Number of Cuts :

For Procedure Qualification (QW-462.4(a)) : The test assembly must be cut perpendicularly to provide five (5) cross-sections , each approximately 2 in. 2\text{ in.} 2 in. ( 50 mm 50\text{ mm} 50 mm ) long. One face of each cross-section is prepared for examination.

For Welder Performance Qualification (QW-462.4(b)) : A 2-cross-section cut is utilized from the end of the break coupon.

Surface Preparation & Etching : The cross-sections are smoothed and polished with fine emery paper, then treated with a suitable chemical etching reagent (such as 5% to 10% Nital solution for carbon steel, or ferric chloride/mixed acids for stainless steel) to provide a clear, high-contrast distinction between weld metal, HAZ, and parent metal.

Acceptance Criteria (QW-183) : Visual examination of the etched cross-sections under optical magnification (up to 10x):

Must exhibit complete fusion at the root and between individual weld passes.

Must be completely free of cracks .

Must be free of lack of penetration .

Must demonstrate acceptable fillet leg sizing: The difference between the actual leg lengths on a single fillet weld shall not exceed 1 / 8 in. 1/8\text{ in.} 1/8 in. ( 3 mm 3\text{ mm} 3 mm ) to avoid excessive convexity or severe concavity.

3. Visual Examination & Volumetric NDE (QW-190)

Article I also establishes the acceptance criteria for non-destructive examinations used during qualification.

Visual Examination (QW-194)

Before any mechanical test specimens are sectioned from a welder performance coupon, the coupon must undergo rigorous visual examination. Paragraph QW-194 mandates that performance coupons shall exhibit:

Complete joint penetration across the entire root.

Complete fusion between the weld metal and the base metal.

Zero tolerance for cracks, incomplete penetration, or lack of fusion.

Surface appearance must demonstrate clean workmanship and absence of severe burn-through, undercut exceeding code limits, or excessive reinforcement.

Radiographic (RT) and Ultrasonic (UT) Examination (QW-191)

Under QW-302.2, volumetric NDE (RT or UT) may be substituted for guided-bend tests to qualify a welder on groove welds, provided specific process restrictions are observed (e.g., GMAW short-circuiting transfer mode is prohibited from using RT alone without bend tests due to high susceptibility to cold-lap/lack of fusion).

Discontinuity Type Radiographic Acceptance Criteria (QW-191.1.2) Ultrasonic Acceptance Criteria (QW-191.2.2)

Cracks, Lack of Fusion, Incomplete Penetration Strictly Unacceptable regardless of length. Strictly Unacceptable regardless of amplitude or length.

Elongated Slag Inclusions Max length depends on thickness t t t :; - For t < 3 / 8 in. t < 3/8\text{ in.} t < 3/8 in. : max 1 / 8 in. 1/8\text{ in.} 1/8 in. ( 3 mm 3\text{ mm} 3 mm ); - For 3 / 8 in. ≤ t ≤ 2 − 1 / 4 in. 3/8\text{ in.} \le t \le 2-1/4\text{ in.} 3/8 in. ≤ t ≤ 2 − 1/4 in. : max 1 / 3 t 1/3 t 1/3 t ; - For t > 2 − 1 / 4 in. t > 2-1/4\text{ in.} t > 2 − 1/4 in. : max 3 / 4 in. 3/4\text{ in.} 3/4 in. ( 19 mm 19\text{ mm} 19 mm ). Indications exceeding reference level with lengths greater than:; - 1 / 8 in. 1/8\text{ in.} 1/8 in. for t ≤ 3 / 8 in. t \le 3/8\text{ in.} t ≤ 3/8 in. ; - 1 / 3 t 1/3 t 1/3 t for 3 / 8 in. < t ≤ 2 − 1 / 4 in. 3/8\text{ in.} < t \le 2-1/4\text{ in.} 3/8 in. < t ≤ 2 − 1/4 in. ; - 3 / 4 in. 3/4\text{ in.} 3/4 in. for t > 2 − 1 / 4 in. t > 2-1/4\text{ in.} t > 2 − 1/4 in. .

Rounded Indications (Porosity) Must not exceed limits defined in Section IX Appendix I charts. Signals evaluated against calibrated amplitude distance-amplitude curves (DAC).

Critical Distinction : Volumetric NDE can qualify welders (WPQ), but CANNOT qualify a groove welding procedure (PQR). A PQR requires destructive tension and bend tests under QW-451 to prove mechanical strength and ductility; radiography cannot measure ultimate tensile strength or elongation!

4. Summary Comparison: Article I Mechanical and NDE Examinations

Test Method Code Paragraph Primary Application Number of Specimens Required Core Rejection Threshold

Tension Test QW-150 / QW-153 Procedure (PQR) 2 specimens (QW-451.1) Breaking load below MSTS (weld) or below 0.95 MSTS (base metal).

Guided-Bend Test QW-160 / QW-163 Procedure & Performance 4 side bends (or 2 face + 2 root) Open defect > 1 / 8 in. 1/8\text{ in.} 1/8 in. ( 3 mm 3\text{ mm} 3 mm ); corner cracks > 1 / 4 in. 1/4\text{ in.} 1/4 in. ( 6 mm 6\text{ mm} 6 mm ).

Charpy V-Notch QW-170 / QW-171 Procedure (when required) 1 set (3) weld + 1 set (3) HAZ Governed by construction code (B31.1, B31.3, Section VIII).

Fillet Fracture QW-182 Fillet Procedure & Welder Specimen sectioned per the applicable QW-462.4 figure Incomplete root penetration; any crack or lack of fusion; sum of inclusions/porosity > 3 / 8 in. 3/8\text{ in.} 3/8 in. .

Macro-Etch QW-183 Fillet Procedure & Welder 5 cuts for PQR (QW-462.4(a)); 2 cuts for WPQ Incomplete root fusion; leg inequality > 1 / 8 in. 1/8\text{ in.} 1/8 in. ; any crack.

Visual Exam QW-194 Welder Performance Full test coupon Incomplete penetration, lack of fusion, or any surface crack.

Loading diagram... Structure and Governance of Section IX Notch-Toughness, Fillet, and NDE Testing