Study guide
8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment
California Dental Law and Ethics Examination Dentistry Jurisprudence
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Orientation
1.1 Exam Format, Legal Sources, and the Board's Enforcement Tools
2 Chapter 2: Law — Patient Information and Records
2.1 Confidentiality and Releasing Patient Information 2.2 Documenting Treatment, Prescriptions, and Record Corrections 2.3 Storing, Securing, and Disposing of Records, Including When a Practice Closes 2.4 Responding to Unauthorized Access: Breach Notification Duties 2.5 Responding to Records Requests: Rights, Refusals, Deadlines, and Fees
3 Chapter 3: Law — Advertising, Postings, and Workplace Conduct
3.1 Advertising: Specialty Claims, Patient Images, Fees, Disclosures, and Fictitious Names 3.2 Documents That Must Be Posted or Displayed in a Dental Office 3.3 Sexual Harassment Law and a Respectful Workplace
4 Chapter 4: Law — Supervising Dental Auxiliaries
4.1 Supervision Levels, the Patient-of-Record Rule, and the Dentist's Responsibility 4.2 Auxiliary Scope of Practice: DA, OA, DSA, RDA, RDAEF, RDH, and RDHAP
5 Chapter 5: Law — Infection Control, Waste, and Medical Emergencies
5.1 California's Minimum Standards for Infection Control (16 CCR § 1005) 5.2 Hazardous Waste, Medical Waste, and Amalgam Disposal 5.3 Medical Emergency Preparedness: Emergency Kits, Cal/OSHA First Aid, and Training
6 Chapter 6: Law — Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect
6.1 Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (CANRA) 6.2 Reporting Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse, and Documenting Evidence
7 Chapter 7: Law — Scope of Practice, Permits, Patient Access, and Fees
7.1 The Dentist's Scope of Practice and Procedures That Need Extra Credentials 7.2 Sedation and General Anesthesia Permits Under SB 501 7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients 7.4 Fee Estimates, Billing Limits, and Patient Financing
8 Chapter 8: Law — Consent and Telehealth
8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment 8.2 Consent for Minors: Parents, Caregivers, Emancipation, and Self-Consent 8.3 Telehealth Law for Dentists: New Patients, Consent, and Security
9 Chapter 9: Law — Prescribing and Controlled Substances
9.1 CURES: Registration, the Duty to Consult, and the Exemptions Dentists Use Most 9.2 Opioids for Minors, Scope Limits on Prescribing, and Prescription Requirements
10 Chapter 10: Ethics — Patient Education and Shared Decisions
10.1 The Ethics Framework and Confirming Understanding Across Communication Barriers 10.2 Presenting Current Conditions and Treatment Options, and Disclosing Iatrogenic Changes 10.3 Future Care Needs: Risks of Non-Treatment, Material Misconceptions, and Realistic Expectations 10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved
11 Chapter 11: Ethics — Colleagues, Referrals, Continuity, and Emergencies
11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals 11.2 Referring Patients: Competence, Medical Consultation, Professional Networks, and Referral Payments 11.3 Managing Referred Patients: Continuity, Autonomy, and Gifts From Specialists 11.4 Continuity of Care: Dismissing Patients, Interruptions, New-Patient Records, and Relocation 11.5 Emergency Treatment: Access During and After Business Hours
12 Chapter 12: Ethics — Telehealth, Billing, Impairment, Exposure, and Standard of Care
12.1 Telehealth Ethics: When It Fits, How to Deliver It, and Honest Dates on Claims 12.2 Insurance Billing Ethics: Accurate Claims, Fees, Copayments, and Codes 12.3 Dentist Impairment and the Dental Board's Diversion Program 12.4 Bloodborne Pathogen Exposure: Informing Patients and Disclosing the Dentist's Status 12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment 12.6 New or Experimental Treatments, Monitoring Patient Reactions, and Reporting Adverse Events
8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Under Cobbs v. Grant (1972), California requires disclosure of the information a reasonable patient would find material to deciding on the proposed treatment.
Truman v. Thomas (1980) extended California's disclosure duty to the risks of refusing a recommended test or treatment, so informed refusal must be documented.
California Probate Code § 4609 defines capacity as the ability to understand a decision's nature and consequences, including its benefits, risks, and alternatives, and to make and communicate it.
Since January 1, 2023, California Probate Code § 4712 ranks decision-makers for an incapacitated adult: patient-designated surrogate, then health care agent, then conservator or guardian.
If an incapacitated California adult has no legally recognized decision-maker, the provider may choose a surrogate, starting with the spouse or domestic partner, under Probate Code § 4712(b).
Last updated: September 2026
The California disclosure standard (K1163)
In Cobbs v. Grant (1972), the California Supreme Court replaced the "what doctors customarily say" standard with a patient-centered one. A practitioner has a duty of reasonable disclosure of the available choices for proposed treatment and of the dangers inherently and potentially involved. What must be disclosed is measured by what is material to the patient's decision: what a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know. Remote risks of common, simple procedures need not be listed. Causation is judged objectively: would a reasonable person in the patient's position have declined had they been adequately informed?
A practical disclosure covers:
The diagnosis and the nature of the proposed treatment.
Material risks , including serious risks even if uncommon, such as permanent paresthesia after a third-molar extraction near the canal.
Expected benefits and likely prognosis.
Reasonable alternatives , including no treatment.
The risks of doing nothing .
Costs , where they bear on the choice (Section 7.4).
Exceptions recognized in Cobbs
An emergency in which the patient is unconscious or unable to decide and delay would cause harm.
A patient who asks not to be told .
The rare case where disclosure would so upset the patient that they could not weigh the choice rationally ( therapeutic privilege ). This is narrow and almost never applies in dentistry.
Informed refusal
In Truman v. Thomas (1980), the Court held that the duty to disclose includes the risks of refusing a recommended test or treatment. A patient who declines periodontal therapy, a biopsy, or a referral must be told the specific consequences, and the refusal should be documented, ideally with a signed informed-refusal form.
Consent is a process
The signature on a form documents consent; the conversation creates it. Performing a substantially different procedure from the one the patient agreed to, such as extracting an adjacent tooth "while in there," can be battery as well as negligence. The CDA Code (Section 1D) calls fully informed consent "essential," and Advisory Opinion 1.D.1 requires explaining treatment "in a manner that is accurate, easily understood."
Written consent required by statute
Situation Requirement Source
Moderate sedation, deep sedation, or GA Written informed consent; for minors, from a parent or guardian with statutory GA language B&P § 1682(e)
Restorative materials Board Dental Materials Fact Sheet given before restorative work, with signed acknowledgment in the chart B&P § 1648.15
Telehealth Verbal or written consent to telehealth, documented B&P § 2290.5(b) (Section 8.3)
Research or experimental treatment Experimental subject's bill of rights and a signed, dated consent form Health and Safety Code §§ 24172–24173 (Section 12.6)
- Patient financing Written treatment plan and 14-point credit notice B&P § 654.3
- Capacity and patients with cognitive impairment (K1162)
Probate Code § 4609 defines capacity as the ability to understand the nature and consequences of a decision and to make and communicate it, including understanding the significant benefits, risks, and alternatives . Capacity is decision-specific and can change. A patient with mild dementia may be able to consent to a cleaning but not to full-mouth extractions under sedation. Presume an adult has capacity and assess it when there is a reason to doubt. Can the patient explain back what will happen, why, and what the options are?
Who decides when an adult lacks capacity
Since January 1, 2023 (AB 2338), Probate Code § 4712 sets a priority order:
A surrogate the patient designated by personally telling the supervising provider. This is recorded in the chart and lasts for the course of treatment or 60 days, whichever is shorter (§ 4711).
An agent under an advance health care directive or power of attorney for health care.
A conservator or guardian with health care authority. A conservator of a person adjudicated to lack capacity has exclusive authority (§ 2355).
If none exists, the provider may choose a surrogate : an adult who has shown special care and concern, knows the patient's values, and is available and willing. Candidates include the spouse or domestic partner, an adult child, a parent, an adult sibling, an adult grandchild, or an adult relative or close friend (§ 4712(b)). A domestic partner has the same authority as a spouse (§ 4716).
How surrogates decide: follow the patient's instructions and known wishes. If those are unknown, decide in the patient's best interest , considering the patient's personal values (§ 4714).
Practical steps
Identify the decision-maker before the appointment and put their documents in the chart.
Involve the patient as much as possible, and seek their assent even when someone else consents.
Use plain language, visual aids, and teach-back (Chapter 10).
For patients from long-term care facilities, confirm who holds authority. Facility staff do not automatically have it.
Note
A patient's right to choose is not a right to demand substandard care. The CDA Code (Section 1C) says it is unethical to render substandard care, so a dentist may decline a patient's request for a treatment that falls below the standard.