Study guide
11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals
California Dental Law and Ethics Examination Dentistry Jurisprudence
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Orientation
1.1 Exam Format, Legal Sources, and the Board's Enforcement Tools
2 Chapter 2: Law — Patient Information and Records
2.1 Confidentiality and Releasing Patient Information 2.2 Documenting Treatment, Prescriptions, and Record Corrections 2.3 Storing, Securing, and Disposing of Records, Including When a Practice Closes 2.4 Responding to Unauthorized Access: Breach Notification Duties 2.5 Responding to Records Requests: Rights, Refusals, Deadlines, and Fees
3 Chapter 3: Law — Advertising, Postings, and Workplace Conduct
3.1 Advertising: Specialty Claims, Patient Images, Fees, Disclosures, and Fictitious Names 3.2 Documents That Must Be Posted or Displayed in a Dental Office 3.3 Sexual Harassment Law and a Respectful Workplace
4 Chapter 4: Law — Supervising Dental Auxiliaries
4.1 Supervision Levels, the Patient-of-Record Rule, and the Dentist's Responsibility 4.2 Auxiliary Scope of Practice: DA, OA, DSA, RDA, RDAEF, RDH, and RDHAP
5 Chapter 5: Law — Infection Control, Waste, and Medical Emergencies
5.1 California's Minimum Standards for Infection Control (16 CCR § 1005) 5.2 Hazardous Waste, Medical Waste, and Amalgam Disposal 5.3 Medical Emergency Preparedness: Emergency Kits, Cal/OSHA First Aid, and Training
6 Chapter 6: Law — Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect
6.1 Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (CANRA) 6.2 Reporting Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse, and Documenting Evidence
7 Chapter 7: Law — Scope of Practice, Permits, Patient Access, and Fees
7.1 The Dentist's Scope of Practice and Procedures That Need Extra Credentials 7.2 Sedation and General Anesthesia Permits Under SB 501 7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients 7.4 Fee Estimates, Billing Limits, and Patient Financing
8 Chapter 8: Law — Consent and Telehealth
8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment 8.2 Consent for Minors: Parents, Caregivers, Emancipation, and Self-Consent 8.3 Telehealth Law for Dentists: New Patients, Consent, and Security
9 Chapter 9: Law — Prescribing and Controlled Substances
9.1 CURES: Registration, the Duty to Consult, and the Exemptions Dentists Use Most 9.2 Opioids for Minors, Scope Limits on Prescribing, and Prescription Requirements
10 Chapter 10: Ethics — Patient Education and Shared Decisions
10.1 The Ethics Framework and Confirming Understanding Across Communication Barriers 10.2 Presenting Current Conditions and Treatment Options, and Disclosing Iatrogenic Changes 10.3 Future Care Needs: Risks of Non-Treatment, Material Misconceptions, and Realistic Expectations 10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved
11 Chapter 11: Ethics — Colleagues, Referrals, Continuity, and Emergencies
11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals 11.2 Referring Patients: Competence, Medical Consultation, Professional Networks, and Referral Payments 11.3 Managing Referred Patients: Continuity, Autonomy, and Gifts From Specialists 11.4 Continuity of Care: Dismissing Patients, Interruptions, New-Patient Records, and Relocation 11.5 Emergency Treatment: Access During and After Business Hours
12 Chapter 12: Ethics — Telehealth, Billing, Impairment, Exposure, and Standard of Care
12.1 Telehealth Ethics: When It Fits, How to Deliver It, and Honest Dates on Claims 12.2 Insurance Billing Ethics: Accurate Claims, Fees, Copayments, and Codes 12.3 Dentist Impairment and the Dental Board's Diversion Program 12.4 Bloodborne Pathogen Exposure: Informing Patients and Disclosing the Dentist's Status 12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment 12.6 New or Experimental Treatments, Monitoring Patient Reactions, and Reporting Adverse Events
11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
ADA Code Section 4.C requires informing patients of their present oral health status without disparaging comment about prior services.
ADA Advisory Opinion 4.C.1 advises consulting the previous treating dentist, where possible, before judging prior treatment.
The ADA Code obliges dentists to report instances of gross or continual faulty treatment by other dentists to the appropriate reviewing agency.
ADA Code Section 2.D requires a dentist with first-hand knowledge that a colleague is practicing while chemically impaired to report it to a dental society's professional assistance committee.
California insurers must report professional liability settlements or awards over $3,000 against a licensee to the licensing agency within 30 days (B&P § 801).
Last updated: September 2026
Talking about a previous dentist's treatment (K2041)
A new patient says, "My last dentist put in this crown two years ago, and it hurts." The radiograph shows an open margin and recurrent decay. What you say next is governed by ADA Section 4.C (Justifiable Criticism) :
Patients should be informed of their present oral health status without disparaging comment about prior services.
Advisory Opinion 4.C.1 explains the reasoning:
Patients depend on the dentist's expertise, so comments must be truthful, informed, and justifiable .
Where possible, and within the law, consult the previous treating dentist to learn the circumstances. The crown may have been a temporary compromise the patient chose, or recurrent decay may reflect two years of poor home care.
A difference of opinion about preferred treatment should never be presented in a way that implies mistreatment.
Unjustified disparaging comments can themselves lead to discipline.
The CDA Code matches this. Advisory Opinion 1.F.1 requires finding out from the previous dentist "under what circumstances and conditions the treatment was performed" and forbids disparaging differences of opinion. Section 10C puts the burden on a dentist who comments publicly to show the evidence would lead a reasonable dentist to believe the comment is true.
Instead of Say
"Whoever did this was incompetent." "This crown has a gap at the edge and decay underneath. Let's talk about how to fix it."
"You should sue your old dentist." "I'd like to contact your previous dentist to understand the history, if that's all right with you."
"I'd never have done a root canal there." "There are a few ways this could have been treated. Here is what I recommend now."
Expert witnesses: a dentist may testify when it is essential to a just outcome (ADA 4.D), but may not accept a contingent fee (4.D.1). Under the CDA Code (10A), a dentist giving an expert opinion about a person may not accept that person as a patient until the litigation ends.
When a dentist must or should report another professional (K2141)
California has no general statute requiring dentists to report a colleague's substandard work to the Board. The duties are a mix of legal mandates and ethical obligations :
Situation Duty Source
Gross or continual faulty treatment by another dentist Ethical duty to report to "the appropriate reviewing agency as determined by the local component or constituent society" (peer review) ADA 4.C; CDA 1.F.1
A colleague practicing while chemically impaired Ethical duty to urge treatment, and, with first-hand knowledge, to report to a dental society's professional assistance committee ADA 2.D
Child, elder, or dependent adult abuse by anyone, including another provider or a facility's staff Legal mandated report to the proper agency Penal Code § 11166; Welfare and Institutions Code § 15630 (Chapter 6)
Unlicensed practice , such as an unlicensed person doing dental procedures Report to the Dental Board, which can seek an injunction; unlicensed practice is a crime B&P §§ 1701, 1705; 1680(c)
Sexual misconduct with patients Report to the Board; it is unprofessional conduct B&P §§ 726, 1680(e)
Insurance fraud by a provider Report to the insurer or the Department of Insurance; fraud is grounds for discipline B&P § 810
Reports that others must make
Insurers must report to the licensing agency any professional liability settlement or arbitration award over $3,000 within 30 days (B&P § 801).
A licensee without insurance must report such settlements, judgments, or awards over $3,000 themselves within 30 days (§ 802).
Licensees must report a patient's death during treatment, and hospital transfers, within seven days (§ 1680(z)).
Protection for people who report
It is unprofessional conduct to threaten or harass a patient or licensee for providing evidence in a disciplinary or legal action, or to fire an employee for trying to comply with the Dental Practice Act (B&P § 1680(q)). The Board also defends people who report to its diversion program against defamation claims (§ 1699).
How peer review works
Organized dentistry's peer review process, run by component societies with the CDA, is the "reviewing agency" the ADA Code has in mind. A patient or dentist can ask that a dispute about the quality or appropriateness of care be reviewed by trained dentist volunteers, who examine the patient and records and may recommend a refund or corrective treatment. Peer review supplements, and does not replace, a patient's right to complain to the Dental Board, which protects the public by licensing and discipline. A dentist who encourages the patient to use either route, and who documents findings objectively, meets both the ethical duty and the duty of veracity.
Putting it together
A patient presents with extensive recurrent decay under crowns placed by the same dentist over the past year, several with open margins, and says other patients from that office have similar problems.
Treat the patient honestly and without disparaging comments (ADA 4.C).
Consider contacting the prior dentist to understand the history, with the patient's permission.
If the pattern suggests gross or continual faulty treatment , the ethical duty is to report to the appropriate peer review body. The patient may also file a complaint with the Dental Board, and the dentist may explain how.
Document findings objectively in the chart.