Study guide

10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved

California Dental Law and Ethics Examination Dentistry Jurisprudence

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Orientation

1.1 Exam Format, Legal Sources, and the Board's Enforcement Tools

2 Chapter 2: Law — Patient Information and Records

2.1 Confidentiality and Releasing Patient Information 2.2 Documenting Treatment, Prescriptions, and Record Corrections 2.3 Storing, Securing, and Disposing of Records, Including When a Practice Closes 2.4 Responding to Unauthorized Access: Breach Notification Duties 2.5 Responding to Records Requests: Rights, Refusals, Deadlines, and Fees

3 Chapter 3: Law — Advertising, Postings, and Workplace Conduct

3.1 Advertising: Specialty Claims, Patient Images, Fees, Disclosures, and Fictitious Names 3.2 Documents That Must Be Posted or Displayed in a Dental Office 3.3 Sexual Harassment Law and a Respectful Workplace

4 Chapter 4: Law — Supervising Dental Auxiliaries

4.1 Supervision Levels, the Patient-of-Record Rule, and the Dentist's Responsibility 4.2 Auxiliary Scope of Practice: DA, OA, DSA, RDA, RDAEF, RDH, and RDHAP

5 Chapter 5: Law — Infection Control, Waste, and Medical Emergencies

5.1 California's Minimum Standards for Infection Control (16 CCR § 1005) 5.2 Hazardous Waste, Medical Waste, and Amalgam Disposal 5.3 Medical Emergency Preparedness: Emergency Kits, Cal/OSHA First Aid, and Training

6 Chapter 6: Law — Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect

6.1 Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (CANRA) 6.2 Reporting Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse, and Documenting Evidence

7 Chapter 7: Law — Scope of Practice, Permits, Patient Access, and Fees

7.1 The Dentist's Scope of Practice and Procedures That Need Extra Credentials 7.2 Sedation and General Anesthesia Permits Under SB 501 7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients 7.4 Fee Estimates, Billing Limits, and Patient Financing

8 Chapter 8: Law — Consent and Telehealth

8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment 8.2 Consent for Minors: Parents, Caregivers, Emancipation, and Self-Consent 8.3 Telehealth Law for Dentists: New Patients, Consent, and Security

9 Chapter 9: Law — Prescribing and Controlled Substances

9.1 CURES: Registration, the Duty to Consult, and the Exemptions Dentists Use Most 9.2 Opioids for Minors, Scope Limits on Prescribing, and Prescription Requirements

10 Chapter 10: Ethics — Patient Education and Shared Decisions

10.1 The Ethics Framework and Confirming Understanding Across Communication Barriers 10.2 Presenting Current Conditions and Treatment Options, and Disclosing Iatrogenic Changes 10.3 Future Care Needs: Risks of Non-Treatment, Material Misconceptions, and Realistic Expectations 10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved

11 Chapter 11: Ethics — Colleagues, Referrals, Continuity, and Emergencies

11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals 11.2 Referring Patients: Competence, Medical Consultation, Professional Networks, and Referral Payments 11.3 Managing Referred Patients: Continuity, Autonomy, and Gifts From Specialists 11.4 Continuity of Care: Dismissing Patients, Interruptions, New-Patient Records, and Relocation 11.5 Emergency Treatment: Access During and After Business Hours

12 Chapter 12: Ethics — Telehealth, Billing, Impairment, Exposure, and Standard of Care

12.1 Telehealth Ethics: When It Fits, How to Deliver It, and Honest Dates on Claims 12.2 Insurance Billing Ethics: Accurate Claims, Fees, Copayments, and Codes 12.3 Dentist Impairment and the Dental Board's Diversion Program 12.4 Bloodborne Pathogen Exposure: Informing Patients and Disclosing the Dentist's Status 12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment 12.6 New or Experimental Treatments, Monitoring Patient Reactions, and Reporting Adverse Events

10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ADA Code Section 1.A requires informing the patient of the proposed treatment and any reasonable alternatives.

CDA Code Section 9 obliges a dentist to tell the patient all available treatment options, even those outside an insurer's contracted services or providers.

Before arranging patient credit, a California Medi-Cal provider's written treatment plan must say whether Medi-Cal covers an alternative medically necessary service (B&P § 654.3(h)(3)).

California Civil Code § 56.1007 lets a dentist share relevant information with family involved in care when the patient agrees or does not object.

When a patient lacks capacity, the surrogate decides by the patient's known wishes or best interest, not by the surrogate's own preferences (Probate Code § 4714).

Last updated: September 2026

The duty to present alternatives (K2051)

  • Source What it requires
  • Cobbs v. Grant Reasonable disclosure of the available choices for proposed therapy (legal standard)
  • ADA Section 1.A Inform the patient of the proposed treatment " and any reasonable alternatives "

CDA Advisory Opinion 1.D.1 Fully explain proposed treatment, reasonable alternatives, and the risks of not treating

CDA Section 9 When care needs services beyond the dentist's scope, inform the patient of all available treatment options and refer. If the patient's condition needs care beyond the payer's contracted services or providers, inform the patient of all options so they can decide whether to stay in the plan or accept an outside referral at their own expense

A reasonable alternative is one a competent dentist would consider acceptable for this patient. Typical sets include:

Missing tooth: implant, fixed bridge, removable partial denture, or no replacement.

Deep caries: direct restoration, indirect restoration, root canal plus crown, extraction, or, in some cases, arrest and monitoring.

Periodontitis: nonsurgical therapy, surgery, referral to a periodontist, or palliative maintenance.

Insurance and program limits

Insurance pays for some options and not others. That limits payment, not what the dentist should disclose:

Tell the patient about the clinically best option and the covered one, and let them choose (CDA Section 9).

For Medi-Cal patients considering financing, the written treatment plan must say whether Medi-Cal would cover an alternative, medically necessary service, and that the patient may ask for Medi-Cal-covered services only (B&P § 654.3(h)(3)).

Never describe a covered alternative as "not an option" just because you prefer the other.

Referral as an alternative

Referral to a specialist is itself an alternative the patient should hear about when the case is complex (ADA 2.B). Chapter 11 covers referral duties.

When several people are involved (K2052)

Decisions often include a parent and child, divorced parents, an adult child and an elderly parent, a spouse who pays, an interpreter, a physician whose clearance is needed, or an insurer. Methods that keep decisions ethical and lawful:

Identify the decision-maker. An adult with capacity decides for themselves, even if a relative pays or disagrees. For minors and adults who lack capacity, identify the legal decision-maker (Chapter 8).

Confirm permission before sharing. With an adult patient, get their agreement, or give them a chance to object, before discussing care with family (Civil Code § 56.1007). Don't assume the person in the waiting room is entitled to details.

Address the patient directly, even when others speak for them. Ask the patient's preferences first, then invite others' questions.

Give everyone the same information. Use the same written estimate and options sheet for all parties to avoid "he said, she said" disputes.

Surface disagreements. If a daughter wants extractions and dentures for her father while he wants to keep his teeth, and he has capacity, his choice controls. If he lacks capacity, the surrogate must follow his known wishes or best interest (Probate Code § 4714), not their own convenience.

Coordinate clinical input. When a physician's input is needed, for example about anticoagulation or bisphosphonates, obtain it and share it with the patient. The patient still chooses among options.

Separate payment from choice. A family member who pays may choose what they are willing to pay for, but may not direct care for a competent adult. Offer the alternatives within the available budget.

Document who took part, what options were discussed, and who made the final decision.

Tools that help shared decisions

Option grids: a one-page table listing each option's steps, visits, longevity, risks, maintenance, and cost helps patients compare side by side.

Models and images: showing the patient their own radiographs and intraoral photos, with an explanation, makes the findings concrete.

Time to decide: for elective, costly, or irreversible care, offer a second visit instead of pressing for a decision the same day.

A good chart note for a shared decision reads: "Discussed implant, three-unit bridge, RPD, and no replacement with the patient and her daughter (the patient asked her daughter to attend). Reviewed costs and insurance coverage for each. The patient chose the RPD. Teach-back confirmed understanding."

Worked scenario

A 17-year-old needs replacement of a congenitally missing lateral incisor. His mother wants an implant now. His father, who shares joint legal custody, wants a resin-bonded bridge until growth is complete. The orthodontist advises waiting.

Explain every option (implant after growth completes, a resin-bonded bridge, a removable interim appliance, or orthodontic space closure) with its risks, including placing an implant before growth is complete.

Include the teen as the patient and invite his preferences.

Legally, either parent may consent to routine care (Family Code § 3083). For an elective, irreversible choice with active disagreement, the ethical course is to postpone until the parents and patient agree, using a reversible interim option in the meantime.

Document the discussion and the plan.