Study guide

12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment

California Dental Law and Ethics Examination Dentistry Jurisprudence

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Orientation

1.1 Exam Format, Legal Sources, and the Board's Enforcement Tools

2 Chapter 2: Law — Patient Information and Records

2.1 Confidentiality and Releasing Patient Information 2.2 Documenting Treatment, Prescriptions, and Record Corrections 2.3 Storing, Securing, and Disposing of Records, Including When a Practice Closes 2.4 Responding to Unauthorized Access: Breach Notification Duties 2.5 Responding to Records Requests: Rights, Refusals, Deadlines, and Fees

3 Chapter 3: Law — Advertising, Postings, and Workplace Conduct

3.1 Advertising: Specialty Claims, Patient Images, Fees, Disclosures, and Fictitious Names 3.2 Documents That Must Be Posted or Displayed in a Dental Office 3.3 Sexual Harassment Law and a Respectful Workplace

4 Chapter 4: Law — Supervising Dental Auxiliaries

4.1 Supervision Levels, the Patient-of-Record Rule, and the Dentist's Responsibility 4.2 Auxiliary Scope of Practice: DA, OA, DSA, RDA, RDAEF, RDH, and RDHAP

5 Chapter 5: Law — Infection Control, Waste, and Medical Emergencies

5.1 California's Minimum Standards for Infection Control (16 CCR § 1005) 5.2 Hazardous Waste, Medical Waste, and Amalgam Disposal 5.3 Medical Emergency Preparedness: Emergency Kits, Cal/OSHA First Aid, and Training

6 Chapter 6: Law — Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect

6.1 Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (CANRA) 6.2 Reporting Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse, and Documenting Evidence

7 Chapter 7: Law — Scope of Practice, Permits, Patient Access, and Fees

7.1 The Dentist's Scope of Practice and Procedures That Need Extra Credentials 7.2 Sedation and General Anesthesia Permits Under SB 501 7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients 7.4 Fee Estimates, Billing Limits, and Patient Financing

8 Chapter 8: Law — Consent and Telehealth

8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment 8.2 Consent for Minors: Parents, Caregivers, Emancipation, and Self-Consent 8.3 Telehealth Law for Dentists: New Patients, Consent, and Security

9 Chapter 9: Law — Prescribing and Controlled Substances

9.1 CURES: Registration, the Duty to Consult, and the Exemptions Dentists Use Most 9.2 Opioids for Minors, Scope Limits on Prescribing, and Prescription Requirements

10 Chapter 10: Ethics — Patient Education and Shared Decisions

10.1 The Ethics Framework and Confirming Understanding Across Communication Barriers 10.2 Presenting Current Conditions and Treatment Options, and Disclosing Iatrogenic Changes 10.3 Future Care Needs: Risks of Non-Treatment, Material Misconceptions, and Realistic Expectations 10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved

11 Chapter 11: Ethics — Colleagues, Referrals, Continuity, and Emergencies

11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals 11.2 Referring Patients: Competence, Medical Consultation, Professional Networks, and Referral Payments 11.3 Managing Referred Patients: Continuity, Autonomy, and Gifts From Specialists 11.4 Continuity of Care: Dismissing Patients, Interruptions, New-Patient Records, and Relocation 11.5 Emergency Treatment: Access During and After Business Hours

12 Chapter 12: Ethics — Telehealth, Billing, Impairment, Exposure, and Standard of Care

12.1 Telehealth Ethics: When It Fits, How to Deliver It, and Honest Dates on Claims 12.2 Insurance Billing Ethics: Accurate Claims, Fees, Copayments, and Codes 12.3 Dentist Impairment and the Dental Board's Diversion Program 12.4 Bloodborne Pathogen Exposure: Informing Patients and Disclosing the Dentist's Status 12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment 12.6 New or Experimental Treatments, Monitoring Patient Reactions, and Reporting Adverse Events

12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

California B&P § 1685 makes it unprofessional conduct to require or allow, directly or through office policy, clearly excessive or unnecessary treatment, or care that discourages necessary treatment.

Clearly excessive prescribing, treatment, or diagnostic procedures is unprofessional conduct and a misdemeanor under California B&P § 1680(p).

California B&P § 725 makes repeated acts of clearly excessive treatment or diagnostic procedures unprofessional conduct for dentists.

ADA Advisory Opinion 5.B.6 says recommending or performing unnecessary services is unethical regardless of practice arrangement or contract.

The CDA Code, Section 1C, says it is unethical for a dentist to render, or cause to be rendered, substandard care.

Last updated: September 2026

Definitions (K2172, K2173)

Standard of care: what a reasonably careful dentist would do in the same or similar circumstances. Negligence falls short of it, and gross negligence is an extreme departure from it.

Unnecessary treatment: treatment no diagnosis supports. Examples include restoring sound teeth, replacing intact restorations without cause, or scaling and root planing healthy periodontium.

Overtreatment: treatment beyond what the diagnosed condition reasonably requires. Examples include crowns where conservative restorations would do, full-mouth rehabilitation when targeted care would meet the patient's goals, or radiographs more often than the patient's risk warrants.

Undertreatment: failing to recommend or provide necessary care, sometimes driven by capitation or cost. The law treats this seriously too.

The law

Provision Rule

B&P § 1685 Unprofessional conduct for a licensee to require, directly or through an office policy, or knowingly permit care that discourages necessary treatment or permits clearly excessive, incompetent, grossly negligent, repeatedly negligent, or unnecessary treatment, judged by the standard of practice in the community

B&P § 1680(p) Clearly excessive prescribing or administering of drugs or treatment, or clearly excessive use of diagnostic procedures or facilities, judged by the dental profession's customary standards, is unprofessional conduct and a misdemeanor ($100–$600 fine and/or 60–180 days in jail)

B&P § 725 Repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, treatment, or diagnostic procedures are unprofessional conduct for a dentist, and repeated excessive prescribing or treatment is a misdemeanor

  • B&P § 1670 Incompetence, gross negligence, or repeated negligent acts are grounds for discipline
  • B&P § 810 / Penal Code § 550 Billing an insurer for unnecessary services as if necessary is a false claim

§ 1685 reaches owners and managers. A dentist-owner who sets production quotas that push associates to diagnose more crowns, or a policy that bonuses staff for selling treatment regardless of need, can be disciplined even if the owner never touched the patient. It also covers the opposite case: an office policy that discourages necessary but poorly reimbursed care.

The ethics codes

ADA 5.B.6: recommending or performing unnecessary services is unethical, "regardless of the type of practice arrangement or contractual obligations."

ADA Section 3 (Beneficence): contract obligations "do not excuse dentists from their ethical duty to put the patient's welfare first."

ADA 5.A (Representation of Care): don't misrepresent the care being provided.

CDA 1C: it is unethical to render, or cause to be rendered, substandard care , and CDA defines standards of care where the law does not.

ADA 2.A: keep knowledge and skills current so that recommendations reflect current evidence.

Keeping recommendations honest

Diagnosis first. Every treatment item should trace to a charted finding: a radiograph, probing depth, fracture line, or symptom.

Use evidence-based thresholds. Consider caries risk, periodontal classification, and radiograph selection criteria based on the patient's individual risk, not a fixed schedule.

Offer the conservative option. Present less invasive alternatives, including monitoring, alongside more extensive ones (Section 10.4).

Don't let pay rules drive diagnosis. Associates facing quotas can document their reasoning, decline to diagnose unsupported treatment, and raise concerns. Firing an employee for trying to comply with the Dental Practice Act is itself unprofessional conduct (§ 1680(q)).

Welcome second opinions on large treatment plans (ADA 2.B.1).

Review your own patterns. A sudden rise in root canals per new patient, or in quadrant scaling on every adult, should prompt self-review.

Diagnostic procedures count too

Section 1680(p) and § 725 reach the "clearly excessive use of diagnostic procedures," not just treatment. Taking full-mouth radiographs at every visit regardless of risk, repeating cone-beam CT without a clinical question, or ordering tests that will not change management all expose patients to cost and, for imaging, radiation without benefit. The ADA and FDA's radiographic selection recommendations tie imaging to each patient's history, risk, and clinical findings. Following them, and charting why each image was taken, is the best defense.

How excessive treatment is judged

In a Board investigation, a dental consultant or expert compares the records with the standard of practice in the community . Did the findings support the diagnosis? Was the chosen treatment within the range reasonable dentists would select? Were alternatives offered? Thin documentation makes appropriate treatment look excessive, so the records should show the evidence behind every recommendation.

Worked scenario

A dental support organization's management contract sets a monthly production target for each associate, and a regional manager emails associates a list of patients with "unscheduled treatment" to "convert." An associate finds that several listed "crowns" are for teeth with small, arrested lesions.

The associate must not perform unnecessary crowns (ADA 5.B.6; B&P § 1680(p)), and should document her own diagnosis and the conservative plan.

Any licensee who requires unnecessary treatment through an office policy, or knowingly permits it, commits unprofessional conduct under § 1685 . An unlicensed manager who directs clinical decisions may also be practicing dentistry without a license (§ 1625(e)).

The associate may raise the concern with the owner, and a Board complaint is available if the practice continues.