Study guide
7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients
California Dental Law and Ethics Examination Dentistry Jurisprudence
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Orientation
1.1 Exam Format, Legal Sources, and the Board's Enforcement Tools
2 Chapter 2: Law — Patient Information and Records
2.1 Confidentiality and Releasing Patient Information 2.2 Documenting Treatment, Prescriptions, and Record Corrections 2.3 Storing, Securing, and Disposing of Records, Including When a Practice Closes 2.4 Responding to Unauthorized Access: Breach Notification Duties 2.5 Responding to Records Requests: Rights, Refusals, Deadlines, and Fees
3 Chapter 3: Law — Advertising, Postings, and Workplace Conduct
3.1 Advertising: Specialty Claims, Patient Images, Fees, Disclosures, and Fictitious Names 3.2 Documents That Must Be Posted or Displayed in a Dental Office 3.3 Sexual Harassment Law and a Respectful Workplace
4 Chapter 4: Law — Supervising Dental Auxiliaries
4.1 Supervision Levels, the Patient-of-Record Rule, and the Dentist's Responsibility 4.2 Auxiliary Scope of Practice: DA, OA, DSA, RDA, RDAEF, RDH, and RDHAP
5 Chapter 5: Law — Infection Control, Waste, and Medical Emergencies
5.1 California's Minimum Standards for Infection Control (16 CCR § 1005) 5.2 Hazardous Waste, Medical Waste, and Amalgam Disposal 5.3 Medical Emergency Preparedness: Emergency Kits, Cal/OSHA First Aid, and Training
6 Chapter 6: Law — Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect
6.1 Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (CANRA) 6.2 Reporting Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse, and Documenting Evidence
7 Chapter 7: Law — Scope of Practice, Permits, Patient Access, and Fees
7.1 The Dentist's Scope of Practice and Procedures That Need Extra Credentials 7.2 Sedation and General Anesthesia Permits Under SB 501 7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients 7.4 Fee Estimates, Billing Limits, and Patient Financing
8 Chapter 8: Law — Consent and Telehealth
8.1 Informed Consent, Informed Refusal, and Patients With Cognitive Impairment 8.2 Consent for Minors: Parents, Caregivers, Emancipation, and Self-Consent 8.3 Telehealth Law for Dentists: New Patients, Consent, and Security
9 Chapter 9: Law — Prescribing and Controlled Substances
9.1 CURES: Registration, the Duty to Consult, and the Exemptions Dentists Use Most 9.2 Opioids for Minors, Scope Limits on Prescribing, and Prescription Requirements
10 Chapter 10: Ethics — Patient Education and Shared Decisions
10.1 The Ethics Framework and Confirming Understanding Across Communication Barriers 10.2 Presenting Current Conditions and Treatment Options, and Disclosing Iatrogenic Changes 10.3 Future Care Needs: Risks of Non-Treatment, Material Misconceptions, and Realistic Expectations 10.4 Alternative Treatments and Shared Decisions When Several People Are Involved
11 Chapter 11: Ethics — Colleagues, Referrals, Continuity, and Emergencies
11.1 Discussing Another Dentist's Work, and When to Report Other Professionals 11.2 Referring Patients: Competence, Medical Consultation, Professional Networks, and Referral Payments 11.3 Managing Referred Patients: Continuity, Autonomy, and Gifts From Specialists 11.4 Continuity of Care: Dismissing Patients, Interruptions, New-Patient Records, and Relocation 11.5 Emergency Treatment: Access During and After Business Hours
12 Chapter 12: Ethics — Telehealth, Billing, Impairment, Exposure, and Standard of Care
12.1 Telehealth Ethics: When It Fits, How to Deliver It, and Honest Dates on Claims 12.2 Insurance Billing Ethics: Accurate Claims, Fees, Copayments, and Codes 12.3 Dentist Impairment and the Dental Board's Diversion Program 12.4 Bloodborne Pathogen Exposure: Informing Patients and Disclosing the Dentist's Status 12.5 Standard of Care: Overtreatment, Unnecessary Treatment, and Undertreatment 12.6 New or Experimental Treatments, Monitoring Patient Reactions, and Reporting Adverse Events
7.3 Protected Classes: Accepting, Dismissing, and Accommodating Patients
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The Unruh Civil Rights Act (Civil Code § 51) guarantees equal services in every California business regardless of protected traits such as disability, medical condition, primary language, or immigration status.
An Unruh Act violation carries damages of at least $4,000 per offense plus attorney's fees (Civil Code § 52(a)).
California B&P § 125.6 lets the Dental Board discipline a licensee who refuses or restricts licensed services because of a characteristic protected by the Unruh Act.
In Bragdon v. Abbott (1998), the U.S. Supreme Court held that HIV infection is a disability under the ADA and refused to accept a dentist's unsupported claim of risk.
Under the ADA, a dental office must provide auxiliary aids such as a qualified sign language interpreter when needed for effective communication, and may not charge the patient for them.
Last updated: September 2026
The legal framework (K1141)
Law Who is protected What it forbids
Unruh Civil Rights Act , Civil Code § 51 Sex (including gender identity and expression), race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability , medical condition , genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language , immigration status Denying full and equal services in all business establishments of every kind , including dental offices
B&P § 125.6 Any Unruh characteristic A licensee who refuses to perform a licensed activity, or discriminates or restricts it, because of such a characteristic is subject to discipline
ADA Title III (federal) People with disabilities, including HIV and hepatitis Private dental offices are public accommodations and must give equal access and effective communication
ACA Section 1557 (federal) Race, color, national origin (including language), sex, age, disability Applies to providers receiving federal financial assistance, such as Medi-Cal
Remedies are significant. Civil Code § 52(a) makes a violator liable for actual damages, up to three times actual damages, but not less than $4,000 per offense , plus attorney's fees.
The ADA Code agrees. Section 4.A lets dentists use "reasonable discretion" in selecting patients but forbids refusing patients or denying service because of race, creed, color, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, or disability. Advisory Opinion 4.A.1 says treatment and referral decisions for patients with disabilities or bloodborne pathogens must be made "on the same basis" as for other patients. The CDA Code (Section 1B) adds religion and ethnicity.
The narrow defenses
B&P § 125.6 recognizes three situations that are not discrimination:
Medical necessity. Considering a characteristic is allowed when it is medically necessary and used solely to decide the appropriate diagnosis or treatment. For example, a medical condition may change the choice of anesthetic.
Direct threat. A licensee need not treat someone who poses a significant risk to others' health or safety that cannot be eliminated by modifying policies or providing auxiliary aids.
Qualification. A licensee is never required to perform a procedure they are not qualified to perform. The answer is then a nondiscriminatory referral.
The HIV case every dentist should know
In Bragdon v. Abbott , 524 U.S. 624 (1998), a dentist refused to fill an HIV-positive patient's cavity in his office, offering to do it in a hospital at extra cost. The Supreme Court held that HIV infection, even without symptoms, is a disability under the ADA, and that a "direct threat" defense must rest on objective, scientific evidence , such as CDC guidance, not the provider's own fear. Standard precautions are designed to make routine dental care safe for every patient. Refusing or steering HIV-positive patients elsewhere is discrimination.
Accommodation duties (K1142)
Under ADA Title III, a dental office must provide auxiliary aids and services so a patient with a hearing, vision, or speech disability can communicate effectively:
Qualified sign language interpreters , on site or through video remote interpreting, when the conversation is complex, such as informed consent for surgery or explaining a treatment plan.
Written notes or exchanged text for simple communication, if they work for the patient.
Large print, readers, or accessible electronic forms for patients with low vision.
Key rules:
No surcharge. The office cannot bill the patient for the interpreter or other aid.
Consult the patient about which aid works, and give their choice primary consideration.
Do not require patients to bring their own interpreter. An accompanying adult may interpret only in an emergency or when the patient asks and the adult agrees. A minor child may interpret only in an emergency.
The defenses of undue burden or fundamental alteration are measured against the whole practice's resources and are rarely met for an interpreter.
Offices receiving federal funds must also provide free language assistance for patients with limited English proficiency (Section 1557), and Unruh protects primary language . Other accommodations include admitting service animals to public areas, making reasonable changes to scheduling or policies, and assisting with transfers.
Accepting and ending relationships lawfully
Accepting: apply the same criteria to every applicant, such as insurance participation, schedule capacity, and scope of services. A "not accepting new Medi-Cal patients" policy applied to everyone is lawful. Refusing a patient who uses a wheelchair or who speaks only Spanish is not.
Ending: a dentist may dismiss a patient for legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons such as repeated missed appointments, nonpayment, abusive conduct, or refusal to follow essential care. The dismissal must meet the abandonment rules: written notice , a reasonable chance to find another dentist, and protection of the patient's health (B&P § 1680(u); ADA Code 2.F). Dismissing a patient because of a protected characteristic, or in retaliation for giving evidence to the Board (B&P § 1680(q)), is unlawful.
Worked scenario
A Deaf patient needs a surgical extraction and asks for an ASL interpreter. The office manager suggests the patient's 12-year-old son interpret to save the $150 fee, or else the patient should go elsewhere.
Using the child for surgical consent is inappropriate.
Refusing care to avoid the cost violates ADA Title III and Unruh, and exposes the dentist to discipline under § 125.6.
The office should book a qualified interpreter at its own expense.