Study guide
2.5 Privilege Exceptions in Litigation & Court-Ordered Evaluations
California Law and Ethics Examination LPCC
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: California LPCC Practice Act & BBS Regulatory Standards
1.1 Exam Blueprint, Format & Logistics 1.2 California LPCC Practice Act & BBS Governance 1.3 LPCC Scope of Practice, Diagnosis & Assessment Limits 1.4 Unprofessional Conduct, Disciplinary Process & Enforcement 1.5 APCC Registration, Supervision Rules & Continuing Education 1.6 Third-Party Payors, Reimbursement & Mental Health Parity
2 Chapter 2: Confidentiality, Privilege & Patient Records
2.1 California Psychotherapist-Patient Privilege & Subpoenas 2.2 Confidentiality Mandates, HIPAA, CMIA & Mandatory Exceptions 2.3 Treatment of Minors, Minor Consent & Parental Access 2.4 Clinical Recordkeeping, Retention Schedules & Patient Access 2.5 Privilege Exceptions in Litigation & Court-Ordered Evaluations
3 Chapter 3: Mandated Abuse Reporting & Vulnerable Populations
3.1 Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act (CANRA) Definitions & Mandate 3.2 CANRA Filing Procedures, SCAR Submissions & Reporter Immunity 3.3 Elder and Dependent Adult Abuse Reporting Mandates 3.4 Intimate Partner Violence, Domestic Violence & Special Populations
4 Chapter 4: Tarasoff Duty, Danger to Others & Crisis Interventions
4.1 Tarasoff Mandate, Civil Code § 43.92, Ewing Expansion & Duty to Protect 4.2 Suicide Risk Assessment, Crisis Intervention & Safety Planning 4.3 LPS Act Involuntary Psychiatric Holds (5150/5585), Criteria & Designation
5 Chapter 5: Professional Ethics, Boundaries & Relationships
5.1 Dual and Multiple Relationships, Boundary Crossings vs Violations 5.2 Strict Prohibition of Sexual Misconduct & Mandatory BBS Brochure Distribution 5.3 Informed Consent, Disclosures, Fee Setting & Financial Integrity 5.4 Required Disclosures at the Outset: Licensure Status, Fees & Good Faith Estimates
6 Chapter 6: Practice Operations, Telehealth & Supervision Standards
6.1 California Telehealth Laws, Standards of Care & Out-of-State Practice 6.2 BBS Clinical Supervision Requirements & Responsibilities 6.3 Advertising Regulations, Title Protection & Ethical Termination
7 Chapter 7: Professional Competence, Integrity & Objectivity (Ethics 2.1)
7.1 Practicing Within the Scope of Competence 7.2 Cultural Competence, Diversity-Informed Practice & Nondiscrimination 7.3 Conflicts of Interest & Conflicting Counselor Roles 7.4 Personal Values, Beliefs & Professional Objectivity 7.5 Counselor Impairment, Substance Use & Fitness to Practice 7.6 Consultation, Professional Development & Expanding Competence
8 Chapter 8: Responsibility to Clients & the Counseling Relationship (Ethics 2.2)
8.1 Ethical Informed Consent & Clients Who Cannot Consent Independently 8.2 Clients Receiving Services Elsewhere & Client Transfers 8.3 Selecting, Administering & Reporting Clinical Assessments 8.4 Necessary Care, Utilization Pressure & Incentives to Limit Treatment 8.5 Client Welfare, Dignity & the Right to Autonomy 8.6 Ethical Confidentiality with Couples, Families & Groups 8.7 Conflicting Legal, Ethical & Workplace Obligations 8.8 Advocacy, Interdisciplinary Collaboration & Referral 8.9 Interruption of Services & Continuity of Care
9 Chapter 9: Practice Policies & Professional Responsibilities (Ethics 2.3)
9.1 Ethical Use of Technology & Electronic Communication 9.2 Fee Policies, Unpaid Balances, Bartering & Gifts 9.3 Multiple Roles, Professional Testimony & Forensic Opinions 9.4 Ethics of Evaluation & Research 9.5 Addressing Unethical or Incompetent Colleague Conduct
2.5 Privilege Exceptions in Litigation & Court-Ordered Evaluations
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Evidence Code section 1016 removes privilege for communications relevant to a mental or emotional condition the patient has tendered as an issue in litigation, but the exception is limited to the condition placed at issue.
Evidence Code section 1020 removes privilege for communications relevant to an alleged breach of duty arising out of the psychotherapist-patient relationship, which covers malpractice suits, BBS complaints, and fee collection actions.
Evidence Code section 1017 removes privilege when the psychotherapist is appointed by court order to examine the patient, except when the appointment was made at the request of the defendant's lawyer in a criminal proceeding to advise the defense.
The existence of an exception does not authorize the counselor to release records unilaterally; the therapist still asserts privilege under section 1015 and produces only on the holder's valid waiver or a judge's order.
Other exceptions include section 1018 (services sought to plan or commit a crime or tort), section 1024 (dangerous patient), section 1026 (information required to be reported to a public agency), and section 1027 (child under 16 believed to be a crime victim).
Last updated: August 2026
2.5 Privilege Exceptions in Litigation & Court-Ordered Evaluations
Exam Focus: Two tasks in content area 1.2. T15 — comply with laws regarding privilege exceptions to address situations involving client litigation (K39, K40). T16 — comply with laws regarding privilege exceptions in court-appointed or defendant-requested evaluation or treatment (K41, K42).
The Rule Before the Exceptions
Evidence Code § 1014 creates the psychotherapist-patient privilege; § 1013 identifies the holder; § 1015 obligates the psychotherapist to claim it. Every exception below operates against that baseline, and none of them converts the counselor into the decision-maker. The correct sequence never changes: Legal demand arrives
- > Assert privilege (Evid. Code 1015)
- > Notify the client / client's counsel
- > The HOLDER waives, or a JUDGE orders production
- > Produce only what the waiver or order covers
An exception is an argument the requesting party can make to a court . It is not self-executing permission for the counselor to hand over the file.
- Litigation-Based Exceptions (T15)
- § 1016 — The Patient-Litigant Exception
There is no privilege as to a communication relevant to an issue concerning the mental or emotional condition of the patient if that issue has been tendered by the patient (or by a party claiming through the patient, or by a beneficiary of the patient).
Three refinements the exam tests:
The patient must tender the issue. A defendant cannot manufacture the exception by asserting that the plaintiff's mental condition is relevant. The plaintiff must put it at issue — for example, by claiming emotional distress damages.
The exception is bounded by the condition tendered. A claim of PTSD from a car accident does not open twenty years of unrelated therapy records. California courts require the scope of discovery to be tailored, and clients frequently file protective motions to narrow it.
Garden-variety distress. A plaintiff who claims only ordinary upset incident to a legal claim, without alleging a diagnosable condition or ongoing treatment, may not have tendered the issue at all.
§ 1020 — Breach of Duty Arising Out of the Relationship
There is no privilege as to a communication relevant to an issue of breach, by the psychotherapist or by the patient, of a duty arising out of the psychotherapist-patient relationship. This is what allows a defense in:
- a malpractice suit by the client against the counselor;
- a BBS complaint filed by the client;
a fee collection action brought by the counselor against the client.
The scope is limited to what is relevant to the alleged breach; § 1020 does not open the entire record for other purposes.
Related litigation exceptions
Section Exception
§ 1018 Services sought or obtained to enable or aid anyone to plan or commit a crime or tort, or to escape detection after one
§ 1019 Communications relevant to an issue between parties claiming through a deceased patient
§ 1026 Information the psychotherapist or patient is required to report to a public employee, or required to be recorded in a public office open to inspection
§ 1027 Patient is a child under 16 , the psychotherapist has reasonable cause to believe the child was a crime victim, and disclosure is in the child's best interest
- Court-Appointed and Defendant-Requested Evaluations (T16)
- § 1017 — Court-Appointed Psychotherapist
There is no privilege if the psychotherapist is appointed by order of a court to examine the patient . The person examined must be told before the examination that the relationship is evaluative and that what they say is not privileged.
The critical carve-out: the exception does not apply when the psychotherapist is appointed at the request of the lawyer for the defendant in a criminal proceeding in order to provide the lawyer with information needed to advise the defendant whether to enter a plea based on insanity or to present a defense based on the defendant's mental or emotional condition. In that situation privilege is preserved , because the evaluation is functionally part of the defense's confidential work. Who requested the appointment?
- COURT, on its own or a party's motion -> 1017 applies: NO privilege
- DEFENSE COUNSEL in a criminal case, to
- advise on plea or mental-state defense -> privilege PRESERVED
- Competence and sanity proceedings
§ 1023 removes privilege in a criminal proceeding to determine the defendant's sanity where the examination was ordered under the applicable Penal Code provision.
§ 1025 removes privilege in a proceeding to determine whether a person is or is not competent , where the psychotherapist was appointed by the court.
In all of these, the evaluating clinician's duty is a notice duty: tell the person, before the evaluation begins, who ordered it, who will receive the report, and that privilege does not attach.
Practical Protocol When an Exception May Apply
Do not decide the legal question. The counselor's job is to assert privilege and let the court rule.
Notify the client and the client's attorney immediately, in writing.
Object in writing before the production deadline if the client asserts privilege or cannot be reached.
If a judge orders production , comply — but produce only the records the order specifies, and ask for in-camera review or a protective order where the order is broader than the tendered issue.
Never volunteer more than the exception covers. Over-production is a confidentiality breach even when some disclosure was proper.
Document every communication, objection, and production.
Vignettes
Vignette 1 — The emotional distress claim. A client sues her employer alleging that harassment caused severe depression, and the defense subpoenas ten years of therapy records. Best answer: § 1016 may apply to the condition the client tendered, but not to a decade of unrelated treatment. The counselor asserts privilege, notifies the client's attorney so a protective motion can narrow the scope, and produces only what a court order covers.
Vignette 2 — The BBS complaint. A former client files a Board complaint alleging boundary violations, and the Board requests the client's records. Best answer: § 1020 removes privilege as to communications relevant to the alleged breach of duty arising out of the relationship. The counselor cooperates through counsel and produces what is relevant to the allegations rather than the entire unrelated file.
Vignette 3 — The defense evaluation. A criminal defense attorney retains an LPCC to evaluate the defendant so counsel can decide whether to raise a mental-state defense. Best answer: under the § 1017 carve-out, privilege is preserved. The clinician informs the defendant of the purpose, reports to the retaining attorney, and does not disclose to the prosecution or the court absent the defense's waiver.