Study guide
12.3 Judicial Review Basics for Paralegals
Ontario Paralegal Licensing Examination P1
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Entry-Level Competency Blueprint A–I 1.3 Open-Book Indexing & Exam Strategy
2 Ethics: Integrity, Civility & Scope of Practice
2.1 Integrity, Civility & Duties to the Administration of Justice 2.2 Permitted Scope of Practice & Declining Unlawful Retainers 2.3 Competence, Quality of Service & Staff Supervision 2.4 Identifying the Client, Instructing Authority & Phantom Clients
3 Ethics: Conflicts of Interest & Confidentiality
Conflicts of Interest, Conflict Systems & Joint Retainers Confidentiality, Privilege Overlaps & Required/Justified Disclosure Withdrawal from Representation
4 Ethics: Retainers, Fees & Trust Accounting
4.1 Retainers, Scope & Managing Client Expectations 4.2 Fair Fees, Contingency, Referral Fees & Fee Splitting 4.3 Trust Accounts, Bookkeeping & Client Property 4.4 Undertakings, Trust Conditions & Errors/Omissions
5 Chapter 5: Ethics: Advocacy, Law Society Duties & Cultural Competence
5.1 Advocacy Duties, Witness Communications & Sharp Practice 5.2 Duties to the Law Society & Professional Liability Insurance 5.3 Cultural Competence, Equality & Inclusion
6 Canadian Law: Jurisdiction & Fundamentals
Canadian Government & Court Organization Jurisdiction, Legal System & Terminology Constitution Act & Charter Rights/Remedies Business, Property & Consumer Law Fundamentals
7 Evidence for Courts & Tribunals
7.1 Relevance, Materiality, Weight & Voir Dire 7.2 Hearsay, Privilege, Opinion & Improperly Obtained Evidence 7.3 Documentary Evidence, Expert Reports & Notice/Delivery Requirements
8 Civil Litigation: Small Claims Court
8.1 Pleadings & Service 8.2 Settlement Conferences & Minutes of Settlement 8.3 Motions, Ex Parte Relief & Default Proceedings 8.4 Costs, Contempt & Monetary Jurisdiction
9 Civil Litigation: Torts & Contracts
9.1 Intentional Torts & Strict Liability 9.2 Negligence Elements, Causation & Tort Remedies/Damages 9.3 Contract Formation, Terms & Defects 9.4 Contract Remedies, Damages & Unjust Enrichment
10 Criminal/Quasi-Criminal Foundations & Provincial Offences
10.1 Criminal vs Provincial Offences & Compelling Attendance 10.2 Charter Timing Motions & Sentencing Principles 10.3 POA Procedural Streams & System Roles 10.4 Mens Rea, Strict & Absolute Liability; Due Diligence Defence
11 POA Practice & Summary Conviction Procedure
11.1 Highway Traffic Act & Common POA Offences 11.2 POA Charging Documents, Trial Process, Pleas & Bail 11.3 Summary Conviction Offences, Elements & Defences 11.4 Summary Process, Bail, Pleas & Diversion Options
12 Administrative Law Foundations
12.1 Natural Justice, Fairness & the Statutory Powers Procedure Act 12.2 Tribunals vs Courts, Standing & General Tribunal Practice 12.3 Judicial Review Basics for Paralegals
13 WSIB/WSIAT & Landlord-Tenant Law
13.1 WSIB Practice, Benefits & Appeals Pathways 13.2 WSIAT Practice & Procedure 13.3 Residential Tenancies: Types, Rights & Responsibilities 13.4 Landlord and Tenant Board Procedure
14 Human Rights & Other Tribunals Within Scope
14.1 Human Rights Code Thresholds & Federal vs Provincial Divide 14.2 HRTO Procedure & Duty to Accommodate Disability 14.3 Other Specific Tribunals Within Scope
15 Issue Identification, Case Theory & ADR
15.1 Urgency, Fact Gathering & Document Review 15.2 Issue Spotting, Research & Privacy-Compliant Investigation 15.3 Theory of the Case & Client-Centred Planning 15.4 Negotiation, Mediation, Arbitration & Encouraging Settlement
16 Litigation Process: Trial & Hearing Preparation
16.1 Disclosure Requirements & Advising the Client 16.2 Capacity, Litigation Guardians & Burden/Onus of Proof at Each Stage 16.3 Admissions & Agreed Statements of Fact 16.4 Witness Preparation, Cross-Examination Prep, Anticipating Objections & Penalty/Remedy Submissions
17 Trial Conduct, Appeals & Post-Disposition
17.1 Examination-in-Chief, Cross-Examination & Re-Examination 17.2 Motions, Directed Verdict/Non-Suit & Building the Appellate Record 17.3 Appeal Rules, Merits Review & Instructions 17.4 Completing the Matter: Judgments, Settlements, Releases & Accounting
18 Practice Management for Ontario Paralegals
18.1 Limitation Ticklers, File Opening/Closing/Retention & Technology Safeguards 18.2 CPD Requirements, Practice Absences/Powers of Attorney & Succession/Contingency Planning 18.3 Ongoing Practice Costs & Professional Liability Insurance Operations
12.3 Judicial Review Basics for Paralegals
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Judicial review supervises the legality, fairness, and reasonableness of a tribunal decision; it does not re-decide the merits the way an appeal can.
Under JRPA s. 6(1), applications for judicial review go to a three-judge panel of the Divisional Court; s. 6(2) allows a single judge only in urgent cases.
Since Vavilov (2019 SCC 65), reasonableness is the presumptive standard of review, rebutted only by statutory appeal rights or narrow rule-of-law categories.
Courts generally require exhaustion of adequate alternative remedies and can deny relief for undue delay in bringing an application.
Under current LSO By-Law 4, a P1 paralegal's scope of practice does not include representing a client in the Divisional Court on judicial review.
Last updated: July 2026
Judicial review is deliberately the last topic in this chapter because it sits at the outer edge of a paralegal's competence: the P1 exam expects you to recognize when a matter has become a judicial review issue and understand the basic legal framework — not to conduct the review yourself. Getting this boundary right is itself a tested competency.
What Judicial Review Is (and Isn't)
Judicial review is the process by which a superior court supervises the legality of decisions made by administrative tribunals, boards, and other statutory decision-makers. It is not a retrial and not a substitute for an appeal: the reviewing court does not re-decide the merits or substitute its own preferred outcome. Instead, it asks whether the decision-maker acted within its authority, followed a fair process, and reached a decision that can be justified under the law and the record — the court supervises how the decision was made, not simply whether the court agrees with it.
Appeal vs Judicial Review
Appeal Judicial Review
Source of the right Only exists if the enabling statute expressly creates it Available as a residual supervisory jurisdiction of the Superior Court, even with no statutory appeal right
Governing statute The tribunal's own enabling Act Judicial Review Procedure Act (JRPA), R.S.O. 1990, c. J.1
What is examined Often the merits/substance of the decision Legality, fairness, and reasonableness of the decision and process
Typical forum Varies by statute (Divisional Court, Superior Court) Divisional Court
Deference to tribunal Depends on the appellate standard set by statute Governed by the Vavilov framework (below)
A paralegal's first job when a client says "I want to appeal" is to check the enabling statute: if it creates no appeal route, the only avenue is judicial review — a different process with different rules, remedies, and, critically, a different forum.
The Judicial Review Procedure Act and the Divisional Court
Before 1971, a party seeking to challenge a tribunal decision needed the correct historical prerogative writ — certiorari , mandamus , prohibition — each with its own technical rules. The JRPA replaced that patchwork with a single, unified application for judicial review , while preserving the underlying remedies (the court can still quash a decision as if granting certiorari, compel action as if granting mandamus, or issue a declaration or injunction). Under JRPA s. 6(1) , an application for judicial review must be made to the Divisional Court , normally heard by a panel of three judges . Section 6(2) allows a single judge of the Superior Court to hear an urgent application only where the delay of waiting for the Divisional Court would likely cause a failure of justice — a high bar that courts apply narrowly, especially now that expedited panel hearings are routinely available.
Standard of Review After Vavilov
Since Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v Vavilov (2019 SCC 65), the starting point for every judicial review application is a presumption of reasonableness review : the court asks whether the tribunal's decision is justified, transparent, and intelligible in light of the facts and law, and it defers to the tribunal's expertise rather than asking what the court itself would have decided. That presumption is rebutted — meaning the stricter correctness standard applies instead — only in narrow circumstances: where the legislature has provided a statutory right of appeal (appellate standards then apply), or where rule-of-law concerns demand a single correct answer, such as constitutional questions, general questions of law of central importance to the legal system, or disputes about jurisdictional boundaries between two tribunals. For the exam, the key takeaway is the default : most tribunal decisions get reasonableness review, meaning the court will uphold a decision that falls within a range of defensible outcomes even if the court might have decided differently itself.
Remedies, Delay & Exhausting Alternatives
Courts hearing a judicial review application can grant several remedies, alone or in combination: quashing the decision (sending it back for redetermination), declarations , injunctions , and orders compelling a tribunal to act ( mandamus ) or preventing it from proceeding ( prohibition ). Two practical limits matter for spotting exam fact patterns. First, courts generally require an applicant to exhaust adequate alternative remedies — an internal appeal, reconsideration process, or statutory review — before turning to judicial review, except in exceptional circumstances such as a genuine breach of natural justice. Second, although the JRPA itself does not set a single fixed limitation period, courts can refuse relief for undue delay in bringing the application, so paralegals must flag review deadlines to clients immediately rather than waiting.
The Scope-of-Practice Boundary Every P1 Candidate Must Know
This is the single most important practical point in this section: judicial review applications are heard in the Divisional Court , and under Law Society Act By-Law 4 , a P1 paralegal's scope of practice does not currently extend to representing a client in the Divisional Court. A paralegal who has represented a client all the way through a tribunal hearing must recognize the moment that file needs judicial review and refer the client to a lawyer rather than attempting to act — continuing to act would breach both By-Law 4 and the scope-of-practice duties covered earlier in this guide. The Law Society consulted the profession in 2025 on a proposal to expand paralegal scope to include certain Divisional Court appeals and judicial reviews; candidates should rely on the scope rules in force at the time of their exam , not on a pending proposal.
Paralegal Scenario
A paralegal successfully represents a tenant at an LTB hearing, but the adjudicator refuses to let the tenant call a witness and issues an eviction order the same day. The tenant wants to challenge the decision. Because the Residential Tenancies Act provides an appeal route to the Divisional Court only on a question of law, and this fact pattern instead raises a fairness problem (refusal to call a witness), the stronger avenue may be judicial review rather than a statutory appeal — but either path lands in the Divisional Court, which is outside this paralegal's scope. The correct, exam-tested answer is to advise the tenant of the option and the urgency of any deadline, and refer them to a lawyer, rather than filing the application personally.