Study guide
9.2 Negligence Elements, Causation & Tort Remedies/Damages
Ontario Paralegal Licensing Examination P1
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Entry-Level Competency Blueprint A–I 1.3 Open-Book Indexing & Exam Strategy
2 Ethics: Integrity, Civility & Scope of Practice
2.1 Integrity, Civility & Duties to the Administration of Justice 2.2 Permitted Scope of Practice & Declining Unlawful Retainers 2.3 Competence, Quality of Service & Staff Supervision 2.4 Identifying the Client, Instructing Authority & Phantom Clients
3 Ethics: Conflicts of Interest & Confidentiality
Conflicts of Interest, Conflict Systems & Joint Retainers Confidentiality, Privilege Overlaps & Required/Justified Disclosure Withdrawal from Representation
4 Ethics: Retainers, Fees & Trust Accounting
4.1 Retainers, Scope & Managing Client Expectations 4.2 Fair Fees, Contingency, Referral Fees & Fee Splitting 4.3 Trust Accounts, Bookkeeping & Client Property 4.4 Undertakings, Trust Conditions & Errors/Omissions
5 Chapter 5: Ethics: Advocacy, Law Society Duties & Cultural Competence
5.1 Advocacy Duties, Witness Communications & Sharp Practice 5.2 Duties to the Law Society & Professional Liability Insurance 5.3 Cultural Competence, Equality & Inclusion
6 Canadian Law: Jurisdiction & Fundamentals
Canadian Government & Court Organization Jurisdiction, Legal System & Terminology Constitution Act & Charter Rights/Remedies Business, Property & Consumer Law Fundamentals
7 Evidence for Courts & Tribunals
7.1 Relevance, Materiality, Weight & Voir Dire 7.2 Hearsay, Privilege, Opinion & Improperly Obtained Evidence 7.3 Documentary Evidence, Expert Reports & Notice/Delivery Requirements
8 Civil Litigation: Small Claims Court
8.1 Pleadings & Service 8.2 Settlement Conferences & Minutes of Settlement 8.3 Motions, Ex Parte Relief & Default Proceedings 8.4 Costs, Contempt & Monetary Jurisdiction
9 Civil Litigation: Torts & Contracts
9.1 Intentional Torts & Strict Liability 9.2 Negligence Elements, Causation & Tort Remedies/Damages 9.3 Contract Formation, Terms & Defects 9.4 Contract Remedies, Damages & Unjust Enrichment
10 Criminal/Quasi-Criminal Foundations & Provincial Offences
10.1 Criminal vs Provincial Offences & Compelling Attendance 10.2 Charter Timing Motions & Sentencing Principles 10.3 POA Procedural Streams & System Roles 10.4 Mens Rea, Strict & Absolute Liability; Due Diligence Defence
11 POA Practice & Summary Conviction Procedure
11.1 Highway Traffic Act & Common POA Offences 11.2 POA Charging Documents, Trial Process, Pleas & Bail 11.3 Summary Conviction Offences, Elements & Defences 11.4 Summary Process, Bail, Pleas & Diversion Options
12 Administrative Law Foundations
12.1 Natural Justice, Fairness & the Statutory Powers Procedure Act 12.2 Tribunals vs Courts, Standing & General Tribunal Practice 12.3 Judicial Review Basics for Paralegals
13 WSIB/WSIAT & Landlord-Tenant Law
13.1 WSIB Practice, Benefits & Appeals Pathways 13.2 WSIAT Practice & Procedure 13.3 Residential Tenancies: Types, Rights & Responsibilities 13.4 Landlord and Tenant Board Procedure
14 Human Rights & Other Tribunals Within Scope
14.1 Human Rights Code Thresholds & Federal vs Provincial Divide 14.2 HRTO Procedure & Duty to Accommodate Disability 14.3 Other Specific Tribunals Within Scope
15 Issue Identification, Case Theory & ADR
15.1 Urgency, Fact Gathering & Document Review 15.2 Issue Spotting, Research & Privacy-Compliant Investigation 15.3 Theory of the Case & Client-Centred Planning 15.4 Negotiation, Mediation, Arbitration & Encouraging Settlement
16 Litigation Process: Trial & Hearing Preparation
16.1 Disclosure Requirements & Advising the Client 16.2 Capacity, Litigation Guardians & Burden/Onus of Proof at Each Stage 16.3 Admissions & Agreed Statements of Fact 16.4 Witness Preparation, Cross-Examination Prep, Anticipating Objections & Penalty/Remedy Submissions
17 Trial Conduct, Appeals & Post-Disposition
17.1 Examination-in-Chief, Cross-Examination & Re-Examination 17.2 Motions, Directed Verdict/Non-Suit & Building the Appellate Record 17.3 Appeal Rules, Merits Review & Instructions 17.4 Completing the Matter: Judgments, Settlements, Releases & Accounting
18 Practice Management for Ontario Paralegals
18.1 Limitation Ticklers, File Opening/Closing/Retention & Technology Safeguards 18.2 CPD Requirements, Practice Absences/Powers of Attorney & Succession/Contingency Planning 18.3 Ongoing Practice Costs & Professional Liability Insurance Operations
9.2 Negligence Elements, Causation & Tort Remedies/Damages
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Negligence requires proof of duty of care, breach of the standard of care, causation, and damages that are not too remote, all on a balance of probabilities
The Anns/Cooper test from Cooper v. Hobart determines duty of care in novel situations; Clements v. Clements confirmed the 'but for' test as the default causation test
Ontario's Negligence Act allows courts to apportion damages by percentage of fault where the plaintiff is contributorily negligent
Damages types include general (non-pecuniary), special (pecuniary), future care, punitive, aggravated, and nominal damages, each serving a different compensatory purpose
Canada pursues product liability primarily through negligence rather than US-style strict liability, and Ontario's Occupiers' Liability Act sets a single reasonable-care standard for all lawful and unlawful entrants
Last updated: July 2026
Negligence is the workhorse tort of Ontario civil litigation, underlying most motor vehicle, occupier, professional, and product claims that paralegals handle in Small Claims Court. The P1 exam expects candidates to walk through the four elements of a negligence claim in order, identify the leading defences, and match remedies to fact patterns.
The Four Elements of Negligence
A plaintiff must prove, on a balance of probabilities:
Duty of care — a legal obligation to avoid causing reasonably foreseeable harm to the plaintiff.
Standard of care (breach) — the defendant fell below what a reasonable person would have done in the circumstances.
Causation — the breach actually caused the plaintiff's loss.
Remoteness and damages — the loss was not too remote, and it can be proven.
Duty of Care
Canadian courts use the Anns/Cooper test , from Cooper v. Hobart , to decide whether a duty of care exists in a novel situation:
Stage 1: Was the harm reasonably foreseeable, and was there sufficient proximity between the parties? This traces back to Lord Atkin's "neighbour principle" in Donoghue v. Stevenson : a person must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions that could reasonably be foreseen to injure their neighbour.
Stage 2: Are there residual policy reasons to negate or limit the duty, such as indeterminate liability or a conflicting statutory duty?
Many duty relationships are already well established by prior cases — driver and pedestrian, doctor and patient, occupier and visitor — and do not require a fresh Anns/Cooper analysis in every file.
Standard of Care
The standard is that of the reasonable person in the defendant's position, not perfection. Courts weigh the probability and severity of harm, the cost of precautions, and the utility of the defendant's conduct. Professionals, including paralegals, are held to the standard of a reasonably competent member of their own profession rather than an ordinary person, following ter Neuzen v. Korn . Children are generally held to the standard of a reasonable child of similar age, intelligence, and experience, unless they are engaged in an inherently adult activity such as driving a motor vehicle.
Causation
Causation is tested with the "but for" test : but for the defendant's negligence, would the plaintiff's harm have occurred? The Supreme Court of Canada, in Clements v. Clements , confirmed "but for" as the default test, reserving the more relaxed material contribution to risk test for rare cases involving multiple negligent defendants where it is impossible to know which one factually caused the harm, and where it would be unfair to the plaintiff to deny recovery altogether.
Remoteness
Even where causation is proven, a defendant is only liable for reasonably foreseeable types of damage , under the Wagon Mound principle, not every consequence that flows, however unlikely, from the breach. The "thin skull rule" is an important exception: a defendant must take the plaintiff as found and is liable for the full extent of an unusually severe injury, even if the extent was unforeseeable, provided the general type of injury was itself foreseeable.
Defences to Negligence
Defence Effect
Contributory negligence Damages are apportioned between the parties based on relative fault, under Ontario's Negligence Act
Voluntary assumption of risk (volenti) A complete bar to recovery; rarely succeeds, because it requires proof the plaintiff accepted both the physical and the legal risk
Expired limitation period Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002 sets a basic two-year limitation period, running from discovery of the claim
Contributory negligence is the defence most often tested. Ontario's Negligence Act allows a court to apportion fault between a plaintiff and one or more defendants by percentage, reducing the plaintiff's recovery accordingly. A plaintiff found 20% at fault for failing to wear a seatbelt, for example, has total damages reduced by 20%, regardless of how the accident itself was caused.
Types of Damages
Type Purpose Example
General (non-pecuniary) damages Compensate pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life Capped by the Supreme Court "trilogy" of 1978, now indexed to roughly $450,000 or more
Special (pecuniary) damages Compensate quantifiable financial loss Lost wages, medical expenses, property repair costs
Future care costs Compensate ongoing future losses Future income loss, future rehabilitation and attendant care
Punitive (exemplary) damages Punish and deter high-handed or malicious conduct Rarely awarded, as in Whiten v. Pilot Insurance Co.
Aggravated damages Compensate additional distress caused by the manner of the wrongdoing An insurer's bad-faith conduct in denying a legitimate claim
Nominal damages Recognize a legal wrong where no real loss is proven A token award, often symbolic
A plaintiff also has a duty to mitigate — to take reasonable steps to minimize the loss — and cannot recover for losses that reasonable mitigation would have avoided.
Product Liability
Canada does not have a United States-style regime of strict product liability; product claims are generally pursued in negligence , alongside any available contract claim for breach of the Sale of Goods Act implied conditions, or a claim under the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 . Manufacturers owe two related duties:
A duty to design and manufacture products that are reasonably safe for their intended use.
A duty to warn of known dangers, including risks discovered only after the product has already been sold — a continuing obligation, not a one-time disclosure.
The learned intermediary rule , discussed by the Supreme Court in Hollis v. Dow Corning Corp. , allows a manufacturer of a product supplied through a learned intermediary, such as a physician prescribing a medical implant, to satisfy the duty to warn by adequately informing that intermediary in some circumstances. In Hollis , however, the Court held the manufacturer remained liable because the warning actually given to the intermediary was inadequate.
Occupiers' Liability
Ontario's Occupiers' Liability Act replaces the old common law categories of invitee, licensee, and trespasser with a single statutory duty: occupiers must take reasonable care in all the circumstances to see that persons on the premises, and their property, are reasonably safe. This unified standard is central to the slip-and-fall claims that make up a large share of paralegal-handled Small Claims files, and paralegals must be able to identify who qualifies as an "occupier" — which can include a tenant, landlord, or contractor in control of the premises, not only the registered owner.