Study guide
3.3 Related-Party Transactions and First Sale for Export
U.S. Customs Broker License Examination CBLE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Logistics, Eligibility, and Professional Governance
1.1 CBLE Examination Format, Scoring, and Category Structure 1.2 Eligibility Requirements, Application Procedures, and License Issuance 1.3 Triennial Status Reporting and Continuing Education Requirements 1.4 Statutory Fees, Application Vetting, and Appeals of Adverse Decisions
2 Chapter 2: Harmonized Tariff Schedule Classification Principles
2.1 HTSUS Structure, Legal Hierarchy, and Chapter Notes 2.2 General Rules of Interpretation 1 through 4 2.3 GRIs 5 and 6 and Classification Doctrines 2.4 Chapter 98 Special Classification Provisions 2.5 CBP Rulings, CROSS, and Classification Research (19 CFR Part 177) 2.6 Textile and Apparel Classification (Section XI)
3 Chapter 3: Customs Valuation and Appraisement
3.1 The Valuation Hierarchy and Price Actually Paid or Payable 3.2 Statutory Additions and Exclusions from Transaction Value 3.3 Related-Party Transactions and First Sale for Export 3.4 Alternative Valuation Methods: Deductive, Computed, and Fallback 3.5 Allowances for Shortage, Damage, Casualty, and Abandonment (19 CFR Part 158) 3.6 The Rate of Duty Date and the Entered Value Declaration
4 Chapter 4: Right to Make Entry, Documentation, and Entry Procedures
4.1 Right to Make Entry and Customs Power of Attorney 4.2 Entry Filing, Immediate Delivery, and CBP Form 3461 4.3 Entry Summary, CBP Form 7501, and Automated Commercial Environment 4.4 Entry Types, Informal Entry, and In-Bond Transit 4.5 Commercial Invoice and Entry Documentation Requirements (19 CFR Part 141, Subpart F) 4.6 Importer of Record Numbers, CBP Form 5106, and Schedule D Port Codes 4.7 The Practical Exercise: Working a 7501, an Invoice, and a 5106 Under Time Pressure 4.8 Examination, Detention, Conditional Release, and Redelivery
5 Chapter 5: Customs Bonds and Revenue Protection
5.1 Customs Bond Structure, Parties, and Legal Obligations 5.2 Continuous vs. Single Transaction Bonds and Activity Codes 5.3 Bond Formula Calculations, Sufficiency, and Breach
6 Chapter 6: Liquidation, Protests, and Post-Summary Adjustments
6.1 Liquidation Process, Bulletin Notice, and Statutory Deemed Liquidation 6.2 Administrative Protests and Judicial Review 6.3 Post Summary Corrections and Reconciliation
7 Chapter 7: Country of Origin, Marking Rules, and Trade Agreements
7.1 Substantial Transformation and Origin Determination 7.2 Country of Origin Marking and Exceptions 7.3 United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) 7.4 Other Free Trade Agreements and Preference Programs
8 Chapter 8: Customs Duties, Taxes, User Fees, and Trade Remedies
8.1 Duty Calculations: Ad Valorem, Specific, Compound, and Column Rates 8.2 Customs User Fees: Merchandise Processing Fee and Harbor Maintenance Fee 8.3 Trade Remedy Measures: Antidumping, Countervailing, Section 301, and Section 232
9 Chapter 9: Customs Broker Licensure, Operations, and Compliance
9.1 Broker Licensing, National Permits, and Office Supervision 9.2 Responsible Supervision and Control 9.3 Broker Duties, Diligence, Funds Handling, and Prohibited Relations 9.4 Recordkeeping, Customs Audits, and Disciplinary Sanctions 9.5 "Customs Business" Defined and Unlicensed Practice 9.6 Change Notifications and Broker Employee Reporting (19 CFR 111.28(b), 111.30)
10 Chapter 10: Special Regimes, Drawback, Enforcement, and Partner Government Agencies
10.1 Foreign Trade Zones and Customs Bonded Warehouses 10.2 Duty Drawback: Manufacturing and Unused Merchandise 10.3 Customs Enforcement, Section 1592 Penalties, and Prior Disclosure 10.4 Partner Government Agencies and Border Security Compliance 10.5 Intellectual Property Rights Border Enforcement (19 CFR Part 133)
11 Chapter 11: Quota Administration and the Rotating Specialty Category
11.1 Absolute and Tariff-Rate Quotas: Definitions, Establishment, and Administration 11.2 Quota Priority, the Opening Moment, and Prorating 11.3 Quota Interactions: Foreign Trade Zones, Warehouses, Visas, and Bonds
3.3 Related-Party Transactions and First Sale for Export
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Parties are legally related under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(g)(1) if they share common officers/directors, are partners, employer/employee, family members, or if one party owns or controls 5% or more of voting stock.
Transaction value between related parties is acceptable only if the importer demonstrates that the relationship did not influence the price under the Circumstances of the Sale test, or closely approximates a statutory Test Value.
Statutory Test Values (identical/similar TV, deductive value, or computed value to unrelated buyers) serve solely as comparison benchmarks and cannot be substituted as the entered customs value.
Under the First Sale for Export doctrine (Nissho Iwai), a multi-tier transaction may be appraised on the manufacturer-middleman sale if proven to be a bona fide sale of goods clearly dedicated for export to the U.S. at arm's-length pricing.
Under CBP Treasury Decision T.D. 96-87, an importer claiming First Sale valuation bears the legal burden of producing complete, unredacted multi-tier documentation including purchase orders, commercial invoices, and proof of payment.
Last updated: September 2026
3.3 Related-Party Transactions and First Sale for Export
Quick Answer: Under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(g)(1), parties are legally related if one entity directly or indirectly owns or controls 5% or more of the voting stock of the other, or if they share common officers, directors, or familial ties. A related-party transaction can still be appraised under Transaction Value if the importer proves under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(b)(2)(B) that the relationship did not influence the price (Circumstances of the Sale test) or closely matches a statutory Test Value. Separately, in multi-tier supply chains, the First Sale for Export doctrine ( Nissho Iwai American Corp. v. United States ) permits appraisement on the manufacturer-to-middleman price, provided the importer proves a bona fide sale, clear dedication to the U.S. at the first sale, and an arm's-length price.
Statutory Definition of Related Persons
Under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(g)(1) and 19 CFR 152.102(g), two commercial parties are treated as related persons if they fall into any of the following seven statutory categories:
Members of the same family, including brothers and sisters (whether by whole or half blood), spouse, ancestors, and lineal descendants.
Any officer or director of an organization and such organization.
An officer or director of an organization and an officer or director of another organization, if such individuals are also partners.
Partners.
Employer and employee.
Any person directly or indirectly owning, controlling, or holding with power to vote, 5 percent or more of the outstanding voting stock or shares of any organization and such organization.
Two or more persons directly or indirectly controlling, controlled by, or under common control with, any person.
EXAM WARNING: On CBLE questions, candidates frequently confuse the customs 5% voting stock ownership threshold under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(g)(1)(F) with corporate tax thresholds (often 50% or 80%) or SEC thresholds (10%). For customs valuation, 5% voting equity creates a related party!
Overcoming the Related-Party Hurdle for Transaction Value
Under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(b)(2)(B) and 19 CFR 152.103(j)(2), the mere fact that the buyer and seller are related does not automatically invalidate transaction value. Transaction value remains acceptable if the importer establishes that the relationship did not distort the price, utilizing one of two statutory avenues:
1. The Circumstances of the Sale Test (19 CFR 152.103(j)(2)(i))
CBP examines the manner in which the buyer and seller organize their commercial relations and negotiate prices. The importer can validate the price by demonstrating any of three standard market behaviors:
Manner of Unrelated Pricing: The price was settled in a manner consistent with the normal pricing practices of the industry in question.
Sales to Unrelated Buyers: The seller settles prices for the related buyer in the same manner as it sells to unrelated buyers.
All Costs Plus Profit: The price is adequate to ensure recovery of all costs of production plus an amount for profit that is equivalent to the seller's overall profit realized over a representative period in sales of merchandise of the same class or kind.
2. The Test Values Test (19 U.S.C. § 1401a(b)(2)(B))
The importer demonstrates that the transaction value closely approximates one of three statutory benchmarks in sales to unrelated U.S. buyers occurring at or about the same time:
- The transaction value of identical or similar merchandise;
- The deductive value of identical or similar merchandise; or
The computed value of identical or similar merchandise.
CRITICAL CBLE RULE ON TEST VALUES: A test value is strictly a comparison standard . If the entered price closely approximates a test value, the entered transaction value is approved. The importer cannot substitute the test value itself as the entered value! Furthermore, an importer cannot use a test value derived from a sale between two related parties.
The First Sale for Export Doctrine ( Nissho Iwai )
In international trade, merchandise frequently moves through a three-tier supply chain: ┌────────────────────────┐ First Sale ┌────────────────────────┐ Second Sale ┌────────────────────────┐
- │ Foreign Manufacturer │ ───────────────────> │ Foreign Middleman │ ───────────────────> │ U.S. Buyer │
- │ (Factory in Vietnam) │ Invoice: $70 │ (Trading Co. in HK) │ Invoice: $100 │ (Importer of Record) │
- └────────────────────────┘ └────────────────────────┘ └────────────────────────┘
Historically, customs authorities insisted on appraising imported goods on the "second sale" ($100)—the price paid by the U.S. importer. However, in the landmark decision Nissho Iwai American Corp. v. United States , 982 F.2d 505 (Fed. Cir. 1992), following E.C. McAfee Co. v. United States , 842 F.2d 314 (Fed. Cir. 1988), the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed that:
A transaction value may be based on the price paid by the middleman to the foreign manufacturer (the "First Sale"), provided the transaction represents a valid sale for exportation to the United States.
The Three Mandatory Legal Prongs of Nissho Iwai
To appraise merchandise under the first sale price ($70 rather than $100), the importer must substantiate three legal requirements:
Bona Fide Sale: The transaction between the manufacturer and middleman must be a genuine sale under commercial law. Title, risk of loss, and operational control must pass from the manufacturer to the middleman. Sham transactions, where the middleman is a mere paper invoicing shell or an agent operating on consignment without title, fail this test.
Clear Dedication to the United States: At the time of the first sale, the goods must have been manufactured and irrevocably destined for export to the United States. Evidence of dedication includes: custom U.S. electrical plugs (110V/60Hz), English warning labels, U.S. trademark stamping, retailer-specific UPC bar codes, and shipping containers routed directly to a U.S. port without entering foreign commerce. Goods manufactured for generic global inventory and subsequently allocated to a U.S. purchase order fail this test.
Arm's-Length Pricing: The price paid by the middleman to the manufacturer must be an arm's-length market price, completely free of non-market distortion, subsidies, or unrecorded assists.
Documentation and Audit Defense Checklist (T.D. 96-87)
Under CBP Treasury Decision T.D. 96-87 and CBP Informed Compliance Publication Bona Fide Sales & Sales for Exportation , an importer claiming first sale valuation bears a heavy burden of proof. During a Focused Assessment or audit, the broker and importer must produce complete, unredacted records for both transactions:
Document Category First Sale Tier (Manufacturer → Middleman) Second Sale Tier (Middleman → U.S. Buyer)
Purchase Orders P.O. issued by Middleman to Factory specifying U.S. requirements P.O. issued by U.S. Buyer to Middleman
Commercial Invoices Factory's commercial invoice billed to Middleman Middleman's commercial invoice billed to U.S. Buyer
Proof of Payment Bank wire transfer (SWIFT MT103), LC, or canceled check from Middleman to Factory Bank wire transfer from U.S. Buyer to Middleman
Shipping Documents Factory bill of lading / packing list identifying U.S. destination Ocean Master/House Bill of Lading naming U.S. Port of Arrival
Production Records Factory production records showing manufacture commenced against U.S. order Factory cost sheets validating arm's-length pricing