Study guide

6.4 Capital Budgeting, NPV, IRR, and Real Options

CFA Level I Study Guide Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Orientation, Official Sources, and Exam Strategy

1.1 What Level I Tests and Why It Matters 1.2 Official Source Control and 2026 Curriculum 1.3 Eligibility, Registration, Passport, and PSM 1.4 Exam Format, Fees, Windows, and Results 1.5 Topic Weights and Session Map 1.6 Three-Hundred-Hour Study Plan

2 Chapter 2: Ethical and Professional Standards

2.1 Ethics Weight, Code, and Standards Map 2.2 Professionalism and Integrity of Capital Markets 2.3 Duties to Clients and Employers 2.4 Investment Analysis, Recommendations, and Conflicts 2.5 Responsibilities as a CFA Candidate and Member 2.6 GIPS, Performance Presentation, and Ethics Case Lab

3 Chapter 3: Quantitative Methods

3.1 Rates, Returns, and Time Value of Money 3.2 Statistics, Distributions, and Risk Measures 3.3 Probability, Conditional Expectations, and Bayes 3.4 Portfolio Mathematics and Safety-First 3.5 Sampling, Estimation, and Hypothesis Testing 3.6 Regression, Simulation, and Big Data

4 Chapter 4: Economics

4.1 Firm Market Structures and Breakeven Analysis 4.2 Business Cycles and Economic Indicators 4.3 Fiscal Policy, Monetary Policy, and Central Banks 4.4 Geopolitics, Globalization, and Trade 4.5 Foreign Exchange, Capital Flows, and Arbitrage 4.6 Economics Case Lab

5 Chapter 5: Financial Statement Analysis

5.1 FSA Framework and Information Quality 5.2 Income Statements, Revenue, Expense, and EPS 5.3 Balance Sheets, Assets, Liabilities, and Equity 5.4 Cash Flow Statements and Free Cash Flow 5.5 Inventories, Long-Lived Assets, and Taxes 5.6 Reporting Quality, Ratios, DuPont, and Modeling

6 Chapter 6: Corporate Issuers

6.1 Organizational Forms and Corporate Features 6.2 Stakeholders, ESG, and Governance Conflicts 6.3 Working Capital, Liquidity, and Cash Conversion 6.4 Capital Budgeting, NPV, IRR, and Real Options 6.5 Capital Structure, WACC, and Modigliani-Miller 6.6 Business Models and Corporate Case Lab

7 Chapter 7: Equity Investments

7.1 Market Organization, Orders, and Trading 7.2 Security Market Indexes and Efficiency 7.3 Equity Securities and Industry Analysis 7.4 Company Analysis and Competitive Position 7.5 Dividend Discount Models and Valuation Inputs 7.6 Multiples, Private Company Valuation, and Equity Case Lab

8 Chapter 8: Fixed Income

8.1 Bond Features, Issuance, and Cash Flow Structures 8.2 Yield Measures, Spot Rates, and Forward Rates 8.3 Bond Valuation, Clean Price, and Accrued Interest 8.4 Duration, Convexity, and Interest Rate Risk 8.5 Credit Risk, Ratings, and Spreads 8.6 Securitization and Fixed Income Case Lab

9 Chapter 9: Derivatives

9.1 Derivative Markets, Forward Commitments, and Claims 9.2 Forwards, Futures, and Swap Basics 9.3 Option Payoffs, Moneyness, and Risk 9.4 Arbitrage, Pricing, and No-Arbitrage Intuition 9.5 Hedging, Speculation, and Risk Management 9.6 Derivatives Case Lab

10 Chapter 10: Alternative Investments

10.1 Alternatives Role, Characteristics, and Structures 10.2 Hedge Funds, Strategies, Fees, and Risks 10.3 Private Capital, Venture, Buyout, and Private Credit 10.4 Real Estate, Infrastructure, and Commodities 10.5 Liquidity, Due Diligence, and Performance Measurement 10.6 Alternatives Case Lab

11 Chapter 11: Portfolio Management

11.1 Portfolio Return, Risk, and Diversification 11.2 Portfolio Planning, Policy, and Construction 11.3 Risk Management and Investor Objectives 11.4 Behavioral Finance and Client Decision Errors 11.5 Fintech, Data, and Portfolio Applications 11.6 Portfolio Case Lab

12 Chapter 12: Integrated CFA Level I Review

12.1 Session One Integration: Ethics, Quant, Economics, FSA, and Corporate 12.2 Session Two Integration: Equity, Fixed Income, Derivatives, Alternatives, and PM 12.3 Formula Sheet and Calculator Workflow 12.4 Question Stem Reading and Answer Elimination 12.5 Mock Exam Review and Error Log 12.6 Mixed-Topic Case Lab

13 Chapter 13: Final Countdown, Results, and Next Steps

13.1 Ninety-Day, Sixty-Day, and Thirty-Day Plan 13.2 Exam Week Prometric and Passport Checklist 13.3 PSM Completion and Result Release 13.4 If You Pass: Level II Path 13.5 If You Fail: Retake and Deferral Strategy 13.6 Career Path, Charter Requirements, and Membership 13.7 Final Readiness Audit

6.4 Capital Budgeting, NPV, IRR, and Real Options

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Capital budgeting evaluates long-term investments using incremental after-tax cash flows discounted at a risk-appropriate rate.

NPV measures value added in currency terms and is the preferred rule for maximizing firm value.

IRR can mislead with differences in scale, timing, or with nonconventional cash flows that yield multiple IRRs.

Compare ROIC with WACC: value is created only when invested capital earns more than its opportunity cost.

Real options (expand, abandon, delay, switch, stage) add value by giving managers flexibility under uncertainty.

Last updated: June 2026

Capital allocation and project value

Capital budgeting decides which long-term projects deserve capital, a factory, software platform, distribution center, acquisition, or product launch. The decisions shape cash flows, risk, and strategic flexibility for years. The 2026 curriculum builds every decision rule on incremental after-tax cash flows : count only cash flows that occur because the project is accepted.

Four cash-flow rules drive most exam errors:

Exclude sunk costs. Money already spent (a feasibility study, prior research) is irrelevant.

Include opportunity costs. A factory built on land the firm could have sold has a real cost.

Include externalities. Capture cannibalization of existing products and positive spillovers.

Ignore financing costs in the cash flows. Interest is already captured in the discount rate; double-counting it understates NPV.

Also include incremental working-capital investment, capital expenditures, taxes, and terminal (salvage) cash flows.

NPV decision rule

Net present value (NPV) is the present value of expected incremental cash flows minus the initial outlay, discounted at a rate that reflects the project's risk, not blindly the firm's average. NPV = sum of discounted project cash flows - initial outlay.

Positive NPV: project earns more than the required return and adds value. Accept.

Zero NPV: project earns exactly the required return.

Negative NPV: project destroys value (given the forecasts). Reject.

NPV is the strongest rule because it is in currency terms and assumes reinvestment at the required return. For mutually exclusive projects, choose the higher NPV.

IRR and ranking problems

The internal rate of return (IRR) is the discount rate that sets NPV to zero. For an independent project with conventional cash flows, accept if IRR exceeds the required return. But IRR has limits the exam exploits:

A small project can show a high IRR yet add little value.

Scale and timing differences make NPV and IRR rank mutually exclusive projects differently.

Nonconventional cash flows (sign changes after the first outflow) can produce multiple IRRs or none.

IRR implicitly assumes reinvestment at the IRR, often unrealistically high.

When NPV and IRR conflict, follow NPV.

Profitability and ROIC

Return on invested capital (ROIC) links operating profit to the capital that produced it: ROIC = NOPAT / invested capital, where NOPAT is net operating profit after tax. ROIC is value-relevant only against WACC (weighted average cost of capital). If ROIC exceeds WACC, growth creates value; if ROIC is below WACC, growth destroys value even while accounting earnings rise, a frequent exam trap.

Real options

A real option is managerial flexibility embedded in a real project, valuable because management can react as uncertainty resolves.

  • Real option Managerial action Example
  • Expand Scale up after good results Add production lines if demand is strong
  • Abandon Exit and recover value Sell equipment if prices collapse
  • Delay (timing) Wait before committing Hold a lease while demand is uncertain
  • Switch Change input, output, or process Burn gas or oil by relative price
  • Stage (sequence) Invest in phases Fund a pilot before a national rollout

A pilot may carry a negative stand-alone NPV yet create a valuable option to expand into a large market; an abandonment option cuts downside by letting the firm exit before all losses occur. Real options can make a project worth more than a static NPV implies.

Capital budgeting workflow

Classify the project as independent or mutually exclusive.

Forecast incremental after-tax operating cash flows.

Add working capital, capex, opportunity costs, and terminal cash flows.

Exclude sunk costs and financing costs.

Discount at a risk-appropriate required return.

Accept positive-NPV independent projects; pick the highest NPV among exclusives.

Test sensitivity, scenarios, and embedded real options.

Other decision rules and their pitfalls

The curriculum also covers supporting criteria the exam contrasts with NPV. The profitability index (PI) equals the present value of future cash flows divided by the initial outlay; accept when PI exceeds 1.0, which is mathematically equivalent to a positive NPV and is useful for ranking under a capital constraint. Payback period counts the years to recover the initial outlay; it is simple and signals liquidity, but it ignores the time value of money and all cash flows after payback. Discounted payback fixes the time-value flaw but still ignores later cash flows.

None of these dominates NPV for value maximization, but each can break a tie or flag a liquidity concern.

A short worked NPV example

Suppose a project costs 1,000 today and returns 600 at the end of year 1 and 600 at the end of year 2, with a 10% required return. The present values are 600/1.10 = 545.5 and 600/1.21 = 495.9, summing to 1,041.4. NPV = 1,041.4 - 1,000 = 41.4, so the project adds value and should be accepted. The IRR here solves 1,000 = 600/(1+r) + 600/(1+r)^2, giving roughly 13.1%, comfortably above the 10% hurdle, so NPV and IRR agree for this independent conventional project. Conflicts arise only with mutually exclusive projects of different scale or timing, where NPV governs.

Mistakes that destroy capital-budgeting answers

The exam concentrates errors in a few places: discounting at the firm's average WACC when project risk differs, including financing cash flows that the discount rate already captures, treating a sunk cost as relevant, and forgetting the recovery of net working capital at project end. Catch these and most capital-budgeting items become routine.

Exam focus

If NPV and IRR conflict, prefer NPV. For "relevant cash flow" items, reject sunk costs, keep opportunity costs, and exclude interest. For real-option items, look for management flexibility under uncertainty. PI above 1.0 equals positive NPV; payback ignores both the time value of money and post-payback cash flows. Capital allocation is not pure math: limited capital is ranked by NPV, strategic fit, risk, and timing, but value still requires earning above the cost of capital over time.