Study guide
C.26 Insurance Policy and Company Selection
Certified Financial Planner CFP
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 A. Professional Conduct and Regulation
A.1 Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct A.1.1 The Six Ethical Principles A.2 Procedural Rules and Discipline A.2.1 Fitness Standards for Candidates A.3 Financial Institutions Overview A.3.1 Broker-Dealers vs. RIAs A.4 SEC and Securities Regulation A.4.1 FINRA and Broker-Dealer Regulation A.4.2 State Securities Regulation A.5 Consumer Protection Laws A.5.1 Privacy and Confidentiality Requirements A.6 Fiduciary Duty and Application
2 B. General Principles of Financial Planning
B.7 The Financial Planning Process B.7.1 Establishing the Client Relationship B.7.2 Gathering Client Data and Goals B.8 Personal Financial Statements B.8.1 Key Financial Ratios B.9 Cash Flow Management B.9.1 Emergency Fund Planning B.10 Debt Management Strategies B.10.1 Mortgage and Home Financing B.11 Economic Concepts B.11.1 Planning for Inflation B.12 Time Value of Money Concepts B.12.1 TVM Calculations and Applications B.12.2 Loan Amortization B.13 Education Needs Analysis B.14 Education Savings Vehicles B.14.1 529 Plans In-Depth B.15 Education Funding Strategies B.16 Gift/Income Tax Strategies
3 C. Risk Management and Insurance Planning
C.17 Principles of Risk and Insurance C.17.1 Risk Management Process C.18 Analysis of Risk Exposures C.19 Health Insurance Fundamentals C.19.1 Types of Health Insurance Plans C.20 Disability Income Insurance C.20.1 Disability Policy Features C.21 Long-Term Care Insurance C.22 Annuities Overview C.22.1 Fixed vs. Variable Annuities C.23 Life Insurance Fundamentals C.23.1 Types of Life Insurance C.24 Business Owner Insurance Solutions C.25 Insurance Needs Analysis C.26 Insurance Policy and Company Selection
4 D. Investment Planning
D.27 Equity Securities D.27.1 Fixed Income Securities D.27.2 Mutual Funds and ETFs D.27.3 Taxation of Investment Vehicles D.28 Systematic Risk D.28.1 Unsystematic Risk D.29 Economic and Market Cycles D.30 Measures of Risk and Return D.30.1 Investment Performance Measures D.31 Asset Allocation Strategies D.31.1 Portfolio Diversification D.32 Bond and Stock Valuation D.32.1 Stock Valuation Models D.33 Investment Policy Statement D.33.1 Modern Portfolio Theory D.34 Active vs. Passive Investing D.34.1 Common Investment Strategies D.35 Alternative Investments D.35.1 Options and Derivatives
5 E. Tax Planning
E.36 Income Tax Fundamentals E.36.1 Filing Status and Tax Brackets E.37 Types of Income E.37.1 Deductions and Credits E.37.2 Capital Gains and Losses E.38 Business Entity Taxation E.38.1 Self-Employment Tax E.39 Taxation of Trusts and Estates E.40 Tax Reduction Strategies E.40.1 Retirement Account Tax Strategies E.41 Property Transactions E.41.1 Basis Rules for Acquired Property E.42 AMT and NIIT E.42.1 Special Tax Situations E.43 Charitable Giving Strategies
6 F. Retirement Savings and Income Planning
F.44 Retirement Needs Analysis F.44.1 Sources of Retirement Income F.45 Social Security Benefits F.45.1 Social Security Claiming Strategies F.45.2 Medicare Planning F.46 Eldercare and Special Needs Planning F.47 Qualified Plan Overview F.47.1 Defined Benefit Pension Plans F.47.2 Defined Contribution Plans F.48 Eligibility and Vesting F.48.1 Coverage and Discrimination Testing F.48.2 Contribution and Benefit Limits F.48.3 401(k) Plan Features F.49 Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation F.49.1 Executive Compensation Plans F.50 Retirement Plan Selection for Businesses F.50.1 Individual Retirement Accounts F.51 Distribution Rules F.51.1 Required Minimum Distributions F.52 Retirement Income Strategies F.52.1 Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategies F.53 Business Succession Planning
7 G. Estate Planning
G.54 Property Titling and Beneficiary Designations G.54.1 Beneficiary Designations G.55 Strategies to Transfer Property G.55.1 Lifetime Gifting Strategies G.56 Wills and Estate Documents G.56.1 Powers of Attorney G.56.2 Advance Directives and Healthcare Documents G.57 Federal Gift Tax G.57.1 Federal Estate Tax G.57.2 Generation-Skipping Transfer Tax G.58 Sources for Estate Liquidity G.58.1 Life Insurance for Estate Liquidity G.59 Trust Fundamentals G.59.1 Revocable Living Trusts G.59.2 Irrevocable Trusts G.59.3 Trust Income Taxation G.60 Marital Deduction Planning G.60.1 QTIP Trusts G.60.2 Portability of Estate Tax Exemption G.61 Intra-family and Business Transfer Techniques G.61.1 Family Limited Partnerships G.61.2 GRATs and IDGTs G.62 Postmortem Estate Planning Techniques G.62.1 Disclaimer Planning G.62.2 Estate Tax Elections G.63 Planning for Divorce and Unmarried Couples G.63.1 Estate Planning for Unmarried Couples G.63.2 Planning for Blended Families G.64 Planning for Special Needs and Circumstances G.64.1 Special Needs Trusts G.64.2 ABLE Accounts
8 H. Psychology of Financial Planning
H.65 Client and Planner Attitudes, Values, Biases H.65.1 Money Scripts and Money Attitudes H.65.2 Planner Self-Awareness H.66 Behavioral Finance H.66.1 Cognitive Biases H.66.2 Emotional Biases H.66.3 Heuristics and Mental Accounting H.67 Sources of Money Conflict H.67.1 Couples and Money Conflict H.67.2 Family and Intergenerational Money Conflict H.68 Principles of Counseling H.68.1 Therapeutic Techniques in Financial Planning H.68.2 Professional Boundaries and Referrals H.69 General Principles of Effective Communication H.69.1 Listening and Questioning Skills H.69.2 Managing Difficult Conversations H.69.3 Non-Verbal Communication H.70 Crisis Events with Severe Consequences H.70.1 Death and Divorce H.70.2 Job Loss and Health Crisis H.70.3 Sudden Wealth and Sudden Loss H.70.4 Natural Disasters and Traumatic Events
C.26 Insurance Policy and Company Selection
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Policy comparison should evaluate coverage features, riders, exclusions, premium structure, and flexibility
A.M. Best, S&P, Moody's, and Fitch are the four major insurance rating agencies, each with different rating scales
A.M. Best is the specialty rating agency focused specifically on insurance industry financial strength
Policy illustrations show both guaranteed and non-guaranteed values; focus on guaranteed elements for conservative projections
The COMDEX score is a composite ranking (1-100) combining ratings from all major agencies
Policy replacement via 1035 exchange allows tax-free transfers but may trigger surrender charges, new contestability periods, and underwriting requirements
Last updated: January 2026
Insurance Policy and Company Selection
Selecting the right insurance policy and insurer is as important as determining the appropriate coverage amount. A policy that meets a client's needs from a financially stable insurer provides peace of mind that claims will be paid when needed. The CFP exam tests your understanding of policy comparison factors, insurer rating systems, policy illustrations, and replacement considerations.
Policy Comparison Factors
When comparing life insurance policies, financial planners must evaluate multiple factors beyond just premium cost. A comprehensive comparison ensures the policy meets the client's current and future needs.
Coverage Features
Death Benefit Options:
- Feature Description Considerations
- Level Death Benefit Fixed amount throughout policy Predictable, lower cost
- Increasing Death Benefit Grows over time (typically with cash value) Hedge against inflation
- Flexible Death Benefit Can be adjusted by policyholder Universal life policies
- Return of Premium Pays back premiums if insured survives term Higher premium but recovery option
Premium Structure:
- Type Characteristics Best For
- Level Premiums Same amount for policy duration Budgeting certainty
- Graded Premiums Start low, increase over time Younger clients, growing income
- Single Premium One lump-sum payment Wealth transfer, estate planning
- Flexible Premiums Can vary within limits Universal life, cash flow flexibility
- Common Life Insurance Riders
Riders are optional policy additions that provide enhanced coverage for additional premium. Evaluate riders based on the client's specific needs and cost-effectiveness.
Most Valuable Riders:
- Rider Benefit Premium Impact Best Candidates
- Waiver of Premium Premiums waived if disabled Moderate Working professionals
- Accelerated Death Benefit Early access if terminally ill Often free or low cost All policyholders
- Guaranteed Insurability Purchase more coverage without underwriting Moderate Young, healthy clients
- Long-Term Care Rider Access death benefit for LTC expenses Significant Those without LTC coverage
- Child Term Rider Term coverage on children Low Parents of young children
Riders to Evaluate Carefully:
- Rider Considerations
- Accidental Death Benefit May duplicate existing coverage; limited triggers
- Return of Premium Significantly higher cost; evaluate opportunity cost
- Disability Income Rider Often limited benefits; standalone policies may be better
- Exam Tip: Rider Evaluation
When the CFP exam asks about riders, focus on cost-effectiveness and fit for the client's situation. Accelerated death benefit and waiver of premium are almost always valuable. Return of premium riders require careful cost-benefit analysis.
Policy Exclusions
All life insurance policies contain exclusions that limit coverage in certain circumstances. Common exclusions include:
- Exclusion Typical Duration Details
- Suicide Clause First 2 years Death by suicide pays only return of premiums
- Contestability Period First 2 years Insurer can contest claims for misrepresentation
- Material Misrepresentation Indefinite (fraud) False statements on application may void coverage
- War Exclusion Varies Death in military combat may be excluded
- Aviation Exclusion Varies Private pilot activities may be excluded
- Hazardous Activities Varies Skydiving, racing, etc. may be excluded
- Policy Flexibility
Evaluate how the policy can adapt to changing circumstances:
- Conversion privileges (term to permanent)
- Premium payment flexibility (for universal life)
- Face amount adjustments
- Loan provisions and interest rates
- Dividend options (for participating policies)
- Surrender options and charges
- Insurer Financial Strength Ratings
The financial strength of an insurance company determines its ability to pay claims. Rating agencies evaluate insurers and assign ratings that indicate their financial health and claims-paying ability.
Major Rating Agencies
Four primary agencies rate insurance company financial strength:
- Agency Focus History Key Distinction
- A.M. Best Insurance specialty Since 1899 Only agency focused exclusively on insurance
- S&P Global Ratings Broad financial markets Since 1860 Widely recognized across all industries
- Moody's Investors Service Broad financial markets Since 1909 Uses unique alphanumeric scale
- Fitch Ratings Broad financial markets Since 1913 Dual headquarters (NY and London)
- Rating Scale Comparison
Each agency uses a different rating scale, making direct comparisons complex:
- Category A.M. Best S&P Moody's Fitch
- Highest A++ (Superior) AAA Aaa AAA
- Excellent/High A+ AA+, AA, AA- Aa1, Aa2, Aa3 AA+, AA, AA-
- Good/Upper Medium A, A- A+, A, A- A1, A2, A3 A+, A, A-
- Fair/Lower Medium B++, B+ BBB+, BBB, BBB- Baa1, Baa2, Baa3 BBB+, BBB, BBB-
- Marginal/Non-Investment B, B- BB+ and below Ba1 and below BB+ and below
- Weak/Poor C++, C+, C, C- B+ to D B1 to C B+ to D
- Exam Tip: Rating Scale Differences
An A+ rating means different things from different agencies! A.M. Best's A+ is the second-highest category (excellent), while S&P's A+ is the fifth-highest category. Always identify which agency issued the rating before interpreting it.
Understanding Each Agency's Scale
A.M. Best (Insurance Specialty):
- Uses letter grades with + and - modifiers
- A++ and A+ = Superior; A and A- = Excellent
- B++ and B+ = Good; B and B- = Fair
- Most relevant for insurance-specific analysis
- Ratings below B+ are considered "vulnerable"
S&P Global Ratings:
- Uses AAA through D scale with + and - modifiers
- BBB- and above = Investment grade
- BB+ and below = Speculative grade
- 19 total rating categories
Moody's Investors Service:
- Uses Aaa through C scale with numeric modifiers (1, 2, 3)
- Baa3 and above = Investment grade
- Ba1 and below = Non-investment grade
- 21 total rating categories
Fitch Ratings:
- Uses AAA through D scale with + and - modifiers
- Similar structure to S&P
- 24 total rating categories
- Minimum Recommended Ratings
For life insurance purchases, financial planners generally recommend companies with:
- Agency Minimum Recommended Category Description
- A.M. Best A- or higher Excellent or Superior
- S&P A- or higher Strong or Very Strong
- Moody's A3 or higher Upper Medium Grade or Higher
- Fitch A- or higher Strong or Higher
- COMDEX Score
The COMDEX score provides a composite ranking that combines ratings from all agencies:
- Scale : 1 to 100
- Calculation : Percentile ranking based on all rated companies
- Interpretation : Higher scores indicate better relative standing
- Minimum recommended : 75 or higher
Advantages of COMDEX:
- Simplifies comparison across different rating scales
- Accounts for multiple agency perspectives
- Easy to understand percentile format
Limitations:
- Only includes companies rated by multiple agencies
- May mask important differences between agency assessments
- Policy Illustrations
A policy illustration is a projection showing how a life insurance policy is expected to perform under various assumptions. Understanding illustrations is critical for comparing policies and setting realistic expectations.
Components of Policy Illustrations
Basic Illustration Elements:
- Element Description
- Premium Outlay Annual premiums required
- Death Benefit Amount payable at death
- Cash Surrender Value Amount available if policy surrendered
- Policy Loans Available loan amounts and interest rates
- Dividends Projected dividend payments (participating policies)
- Guaranteed vs. Non-Guaranteed Values
Every illustration shows two sets of projections:
Guaranteed Values:
- Represent the contractual minimum the insurer must provide
- Based on worst-case assumptions
- Minimum interest crediting rate
- Maximum mortality charges
- Insurance company is legally bound to these values
Non-Guaranteed (Current) Values:
- Projections based on current assumptions
- May be significantly higher than guaranteed values
Subject to change based on:
- Investment performance
- Mortality experience
- Company expenses
- Not promises or guarantees
- Column Type Interest Assumption Mortality Assumption Use For
- Guaranteed Minimum rate Maximum charges Conservative planning
- Midpoint Average of guaranteed and current Average Reference only
- Current/Non-Guaranteed Current crediting rate Current charges Optimistic scenario
- Exam Tip: Illustration Analysis
When evaluating illustrations, always focus primarily on guaranteed values. Non-guaranteed projections may never materialize. The midpoint column is NOT the most likely scenario; it's simply a mathematical average. Clients should understand that actual results may fall anywhere between guaranteed and non-guaranteed values.
Red Flags in Illustrations
Watch for these warning signs when reviewing policy illustrations:
- Red Flag Concern
- Wide gap between guaranteed and current values High sensitivity to assumption changes
- Premiums that "vanish" in early years Based on non-guaranteed assumptions
- Cash value projections showing rapid early growth May not materialize
- No guaranteed death benefit after certain age Policy may lapse if underfunded
- Unrealistic interest rate assumptions Performance unlikely to match
- Illustration Signature Requirements
Before a policy is issued, both the agent and client must sign the illustration, acknowledging:
- Receipt and review of the complete illustration
- Understanding that non-guaranteed elements may change
- Recognition that actual results may differ from projections
Never sign an illustration without thorough review and understanding.
Policy Replacement Considerations
Replacing an existing life insurance policy requires careful analysis. While replacement may sometimes be appropriate, it can also result in financial harm if not properly evaluated.
When Replacement May Be Appropriate
- Situation Why Replace
- Better rates available Health improved, more competitive market
- Needed features unavailable New riders or policy types
- Insurer financial concerns Rating downgrades, merger concerns
- Policy underperforming Universal life cost increases
- Changed needs Different coverage type needed
- 1035 Exchange
Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code allows tax-free exchanges of life insurance policies:
Permitted Exchanges:
- Life insurance policy to life insurance policy
- Life insurance policy to annuity
- Annuity to annuity
NOT Permitted (Taxable):
Annuity to life insurance policy
1035 Exchange Requirements:
- Same owner on old and new policies
- Same insured on old and new policies
- Direct transfer between companies (no check to owner)
- Proper documentation and paperwork
- Replacement Risks and Costs
Before recommending replacement, evaluate these factors:
- Factor Consideration
- Surrender Charges May reduce available cash value significantly
- New Contestability Period 2-year period restarts on new policy
- New Suicide Clause 2-year exclusion restarts
- Underwriting Requirements Health changes may affect eligibility or pricing
- Commission Incentives Agents earn new commissions on replacements
- Lost Policy Benefits Older policies may have favorable provisions
- MEC Status New policy may become a Modified Endowment Contract
- Outstanding Loan Considerations
If the existing policy has an outstanding loan:
- The loan may create a taxable event during exchange
- Consider paying off loans before replacement
- Evaluate tax implications with a tax professional
- Exam Tip: Replacement Suitability
The CFP exam emphasizes that replacement should only occur when clearly in the client's best interest. Red flags include agents pushing replacement primarily for commission purposes, replacement of policies with favorable grandfathered provisions, and exchanges that would create MEC status.
Alternatives to Replacement
Consider these alternatives before replacing a policy:
- Alternative Description
- Plan Change Convert or modify existing policy
- Supplemental Coverage Add new policy without replacing
- Loan Repayment Restore death benefit by paying loans
- Paid-Up Options Use existing value for reduced paid-up coverage
- Extended Term Convert to term coverage using cash value
- Summary: Policy and Company Selection
- Factor Key Considerations
- Policy Features Death benefit type, premium structure, flexibility
- Riders Waiver of premium, accelerated death benefit most valuable
- Exclusions 2-year suicide and contestability clauses standard
- A.M. Best Ratings A++ highest; B+ minimum for purchase
- Rating Comparison A+ means different things from different agencies
- COMDEX Composite score 1-100; prefer 75+
- Illustrations Focus on guaranteed values, not current assumptions
- Replacement 1035 exchange is tax-free; evaluate all costs and risks