Study guide

28.3 Common Red Flags and Public Sector Fraud Schemes

Certified Government Financial Manager CGFM

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Organization, Authority and Structure of Government — Part I

1.1 Levels, Branches, and Separation of Powers 1.2 Components of Government & Public Authorities 1.3 Subnational Governments: General-Purpose vs. Special-Purpose

2 Chapter 2: Organization, Authority and Structure of Government — Part II

2.1 Legal Authority, Charters, and Sovereign Powers 2.2 Tribal Sovereignty & Intergovernmental Relations 2.3 Categorical Grants vs. Block Grants

3 Chapter 3: The Government Financial Management Cycle & Legal Framework — Part I

3.1 The Seven Phases of the Financial Management Cycle 3.2 The Closed-Loop Feedback Architecture 3.3 The Constitutional Basis: The Power of the Purse

4 Chapter 4: The Government Financial Management Cycle & Legal Framework — Part II

4.1 Types of Legislative Appropriations 4.2 The Hierarchy of Budgetary Spending Controls 4.3 Legal Mechanisms Dedicating Public Revenues

5 Chapter 5: Government Revenues, Grants & Debt Financing — Part I

5.1 Public Tax Policy and Tax Structures 5.2 Wealth and Property Taxes 5.3 Intergovernmental Grants & the Uniform Guidance Lifecycle 5.4 The OMB Uniform Guidance Grant Lifecycle (2 CFR 200)

6 Chapter 6: Government Revenues, Grants & Debt Financing — Part II

6.1 User Charges, Cost Recovery, Leases & Public-Private Partnerships 6.2 Public Debt Issuance, Bond Types & Credit Ratings 6.3 Certificates of Participation (COPs) and Lease-Revenue Bonds

7 Chapter 7: Public Accountability, Transparency & Open Government — Part I

7.1 Legislative Frameworks for Accountability: IG Act & CFO Act 7.2 Government Management Reform Act (GMRA) of 1994 7.3 Assessing Fiscal Sustainability, Solvency & SEA Reporting

8 Chapter 8: Public Accountability, Transparency & Open Government — Part II

8.1 Net Pension Liability (NPL) Recognition 8.2 Open Government, DATA Act of 2014 & Citizen-Centric Reporting 8.3 Digital Open Checkbooks

9 Chapter 9: Public Sector Ethics & Digital Government — Part I

9.1 Public Service Ethics Principles & the AGA Code of Ethics 9.2 The Ethical Spectrum: The Ethical Floor vs. The Ethical Ceiling 9.3 Managing Conflicts of Interest, Due Care, Whistleblowing & Nepotism

10 Chapter 10: Public Sector Ethics & Digital Government — Part II

10.1 Post-Employment "Revolving Door" Prohibitions (18 U.S.C. § 207) 10.2 E-Government Services, Public Portals & NIST Cybersecurity Standards 10.3 Personally Identifiable Information (PII)

11 Chapter 11: Governmental Accounting Principles & Cost Allocation — Part I

11.1 Environmental Differences, Standard Setters & GAAP Hierarchies 11.2 Standard-Setting Bodies and Jurisdictional Framework 11.3 State and Local GAAP Hierarchy: GASB Statement No. 76 11.4 Measurement Focus, Basis of Accounting & Nonexchange Transactions

12 Chapter 12: Governmental Accounting Principles & Cost Allocation — Part II

12.1 The Four GASB Statement No. 33 Nonexchange Categories 12.2 Managerial Cost Accounting, SFFAS 4 & Intergovernmental Fee Establishment 12.3 Cost Allocation under OMB Uniform Guidance (2 CFR 200 Subpart E)

13 Chapter 13: Public Budgeting Concepts & Controls — Part I

13.1 Public Budget Formulation, Structures & Budgeting Approaches 13.2 Fund 13.3 Performance-Based Budgeting (PBB) 13.4 Capital Project Financing, Capital Budgets & Revenue/Expenditure Forecasting

14 Chapter 14: Public Budgeting Concepts & Controls — Part II

14.1 Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) 14.2 Budgetary Control Techniques & General Ledger Accounting Operations 14.3 Stock Statements vs. Flow Statements

15 Chapter 15: State & Local Fund Accounting & Budgetary Accounting — Part I

15.1 The Eleven State & Local Fund Types & Accounting Bases 15.2 Capital Projects Funds (CPF) 15.3 Custodial Funds 15.4 Modified Accrual Accounting: Revenues, Expenditures & Financing Sources

16 Chapter 16: State & Local Fund Accounting & Budgetary Accounting — Part II

16.1 Other Financing Sources (OFS) and Other Financing Uses (OFU) 16.2 Budgetary Integration, Encumbrance Entries & GASB 54 Fund Balance Classifications 16.3 Nonspendable Fund Balance

17 Chapter 17: State & Local Financial Reporting & Statements — Part I

17.1 Defining the State & Local Reporting Entity & Component Units 17.2 Pathway 3: Misleading to Exclude & Affiliated Organizations (GASB 39 & 90) 17.3 Joint Ventures 17.4 The Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) Structure & RSI

18 Chapter 18: State & Local Financial Reporting & Statements — Part II

18.1 Required Supplementary Information (RSI Other than MD&A) 18.2 Government-Wide Financial Statements, Interfund Eliminations & Reconciliation 18.3 Internal Balances (Due To / Due From)

19 Chapter 19: Federal Budgetary Accounting & the USSGL — Part I

19.1 Federal Accounting Governance: FASAB, OMB, Treasury & GAO 19.2 Comparative Analysis: The Quadripartite Leadership 19.3 Federal Budgetary Terminology, the Budgetary Equation & Fund Types

20 Chapter 20: Federal Budgetary Accounting & the USSGL — Part II

20.1 General Fund of the United States Government 20.2 The U.S. Standard General Ledger (USSGL) & Dual-Track Budgetary Accounting 20.3 Milestone 2: OMB Apportionment (Form SF 132)

21 Chapter 21: Federal Proprietary Accounting & Financial Reporting — Part I

21.1 Federal Proprietary Accounting & Fund Balance with Treasury (FBWT) 21.2 Non-FBWT Budgetary Authority (Offsets) 21.3 Stewardship PP&E: Heritage Assets and Stewardship Land (SFFAS 29) 21.4 Federal Credit Reform Act (FCRA): Direct Loans, Loan Guarantees & Subsidy Accounting

22 Chapter 22: Federal Proprietary Accounting & Financial Reporting — Part II

22.1 The Liquidating Account (Budgetary - Pre-1992) 22.2 Federal Financial Reporting: AFR, PAR, Basic Financial Statements & the U.S. Consolidated Report 22.3 The Statement of Changes in Net Position (SCNP)

23 Chapter 23: Cash, Investment & Debt Operations — Part I

23.1 Government Cash Management, Collections, Lockboxes & Banking Controls 23.2 Fees vs. Compensating Balances: Strategic Analysis 23.3 Public Investment Policies, Safety-Liquidity-Yield, Prudent Person Rule & Risk Disclosures 23.4 Authorized Public Investment Instruments: Comparative Analysis

24 Chapter 24: Cash, Investment & Debt Operations — Part II

24.1 GASB Statement No. 40: Deposit and Investment Risk Disclosures 24.2 Electronic Payments, EFT, P-Cards & Disbursement Controls 24.3 Public Benefit Disbursements: EBT and Reloadable Debit Cards

25 Chapter 25: Procurement, Asset Stewardship & Operational Systems — Part I

25.1 Public Procurement Standards, Fair Competition & Contract Administration 25.2 Contract Types and Cost Risk Allocation 25.3 Capital Asset Stewardship, Property Disposal, Inventory & OM&S Controls 25.4 Environmental Compliance and Electronic Data Sanitization

26 Chapter 26: Procurement, Asset Stewardship & Operational Systems — Part II

26.1 Financial Management Information Systems (FMIS), ERP, Cloud Hosting & Automation 26.2 Development Methodologies: Waterfall vs. Agile 26.3 Shared Services Delivery & Public Sector Project Management 26.4 The PMBOK Five Process Groups

27 Chapter 27: Financial, Managerial & Forensic Analysis — Part I

27.1 Mathematical and Financial Foundations of Time Value of Money (TVM) 27.2 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 27.3 Financial Statement Trend and Comparative Analysis

28 Chapter 28: Financial, Managerial & Forensic Analysis — Part II

28.1 Earned Value Management (EVM) for Capital Project Oversight 28.2 Public Sector Data Sources and Reliability Verification 28.3 Common Red Flags and Public Sector Fraud Schemes

29 Chapter 29: Internal Control Frameworks & Enterprise Risk Management — Part I

29.1 COSO Internal Control Integrated Framework & the GAO Green Book 29.2 Component 2: Risk Assessment 29.3 Internal Control Deficiencies, Corrective Action Plans & Management Reporting

30 Chapter 30: Internal Control Frameworks & Enterprise Risk Management — Part II

30.1 FMFIA Reporting Sections 30.2 Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) & OMB Circular A-123 Implementation 30.3 Core Elements of a Federal Risk Profile

31 Chapter 31: Performance Measurement, Government Auditing & the Single Audit — Part I

31.1 Performance Measurement, SEA Reporting, GPRA & Public Accountability 31.2 Baselines, Targets, Benchmarking, and Stakeholder Engagement 31.3 Government Auditing Standards: The Yellow Book & Auditor Independence 31.4 Quality Management and External Peer Review

32 Chapter 32: Performance Measurement, Government Auditing & the Single Audit — Part II

32.1 Performance Audit Fieldwork, Reporting & Auditee Responsibilities 32.2 Cause ("Why It Happened") 32.3 The Single Audit Act & Uniform Guidance (2 CFR 200 Subpart F) 32.4 Internal Control over Compliance Testing

28.3 Common Red Flags and Public Sector Fraud Schemes

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Major public sector fraud schemes include ghost employees, shell company vendors, fictitious invoices, duplicate billing transpositions, and split purchases engineered to bypass bidding thresholds.

Forensic auditors must maintain strict chain of custody, execute structured multi-phase interviews, and promptly coordinate with Inspectors General or law enforcement upon establishing criminal indicators.

Benford's Law mathematically detects anomalous frequency distributions in unconstrained accounting disbursements, while cross-database matching identifies improper employee-vendor overlaps.

Last updated: September 2026

Common Red Flags and Public Sector Fraud Schemes

Forensic auditors examine financial records for behavioral and transaction anomalies that serve as warning indicators of fraudulent activity.

Payroll Schemes: Ghost Employees and Unauthorized Alterations

A ghost employee is an individual listed on the government's payroll who does not actually work for the entity. The ghost may be a fictitious identity created by a payroll clerk or a former employee who resigned or was terminated but was intentionally kept on the active payroll register, with direct deposit payments diverted to the perpetrator's bank account.

Audit Red Flags :

Employee records with no deductions for federal taxes, health benefits, or state retirement systems

Employees sharing a common physical residential address, bank routing number, or direct deposit account number with another active employee or payroll clerk

  • Duplicate or invalid Social Security Numbers
  • Employees with no recorded supervisory performance reviews, timesheet activity logs, or personnel files
  • Continued payroll payments after official employee separation or retirement dates
  • Procurement & Disbursement Schemes

Procurement represents the single largest expenditure category vulnerable to public sector fraud:

Shell Company Vendors : A corrupt employee establishes a fictitious business entity (often an LLC) with no physical operations, warehouse, or employees. The employee enters the shell company into the government's vendor master file, submits fabricated invoices for unrendered professional services (e.g., "Management Consulting" or "Strategic IT Planning"), and approves payments to a bank account or post office box under their control.

Red Flags : Vendor address is a commercial mail drop or residential address; vendor registration date is immediately prior to first large contract award; vendor lacks a corporate website or telephone listing; vendor TIN is missing or formatted incorrectly.

Sequential Invoice Numbering : Legitimate commercial vendors have multiple clients and issue non-consecutive invoices to any single customer. When a government receives consecutive invoice numbers from a vendor over a span of several months (e.g., Invoice #1001 in January, #1002 in February, #1003 in March), it is a major red flag indicating the government is the vendor's sole client—or that a shell company is generating fictitious invoices in sequence.

Duplicate Billing and Transpositions : Corrupt or negligent vendors submit identical invoices multiple times. To bypass automated ERP duplicate invoice detection (which flags exact matches on vendor ID, invoice number, and dollar amount), perpetrators introduce deliberate transpositions or suffixes (e.g., submitting Invoice #4892, followed two weeks later by #4892-A, #4892B, or #4829 for the same dollar figure).

Split Purchases (Structuring / P-Card Fraud) : State statutes and municipal charters establish competitive bidding thresholds (e.g., formal sealed bids required for purchases exceeding $10,000). Dishonest procurement officers or purchasing card (P-Card) holders circumvent this control by intentionally splitting a large purchase into multiple smaller transactions just below the threshold (e.g., executing three separate purchases of $9,800 on consecutive days to buy $29,400 worth of equipment from a favored vendor).

Fraud Scheme Primary Vulnerability Common Audit Red Flags Recommended Forensic Test

Ghost Employee Payroll master file access; lack of HR-payroll reconciliation No benefit deductions; identical bank accounts; missing personnel file Match payroll roster to active HR roster; verify physical presence.

Shell Company Inadequate vendor vetting; single-user vendor approval P.O. Box address; no web presence; consulting services with vague deliverables Physical site inspection; verify corporate registration with Secretary of State.

Sequential Invoices Discretionary service contracts; unverified billing Invoices numbered sequentially over extended periods (e.g., #101, #102, #103) Query vendor master file for invoice sequences; review vendor customer base.

Split Purchasing Micro-purchase thresholds; P-Card approval limits Multiple transactions just below bidding threshold from same department/vendor Run transaction queries for amounts clustered within 10% below threshold.

Duplicate Billing Lax invoice matching; manual invoice processing Invoice numbers with suffixes (-A, -1); matching dollar amounts across dates Automated query for matching vendor, amount, and date ranges.

  • Advanced Forensic Testing: Benford's Law and Data Matching
  • Benford's Law (First-Digit Analysis)

Benford's Law (also called the First-Digit Law) is a mathematical phenomenon establishing that in naturally occurring, multi-digit numerical datasets, the distribution of leading digits follows a specific logarithmic curve rather than a uniform distribution (where each digit 1 through 9 would appear 11.1% of the time). P ( d ) = log ⁡ 10 ( 1 + 1 d ) P(d) = \log_{10} \left( 1 + \frac{1}{d} \right) P ( d ) = lo g 10 ​ ( 1 + d 1 ​ )

Where d d d is the leading digit ( d ∈ { 1 , 2 , … , 9 } d \in \{1, 2, \dots, 9\} d ∈ { 1 , 2 , … , 9 } ).

  • Leading Digit ( d d d ) Theoretical Expected Frequency Cumulative Probability
  • 1 30.1% 30.1%
  • 2 17.6% 47.7%
  • 3 12.5% 60.2%
  • 4 9.7% 69.9%
  • 5 7.9% 77.8%
  • 6 6.7% 84.5%
  • 7 5.8% 90.3%
  • 8 5.1% 95.4%
  • 9 4.6% 100.0%

When fraudsters fabricate numbers—such as inventing fake expense vouchers, fabricating travel claims, or forging construction invoices—they rarely replicate Benford's logarithmic distribution. Human beings instinctively create numbers starting with middle-to-higher digits (4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9) and cluster amounts just beneath supervisory thresholds (e.g., repeatedly submitting claims starting with $4,900 when the approval threshold is $5,000).

When Benford's Law APPLIES : Unconstrained, multi-order-of-magnitude financial records, such as municipal check registers, general ledger transaction values, full-year purchase card expenditures, and travel reimbursement claims.

When Benford's Law DOES NOT APPLY : Assigned identification numbers (check numbers, ZIP codes, Social Security Numbers), datasets with rigid statutory minimums or maximums (fixed hourly wages of $15.00 to $22.00, or flat $50 parking fines), and populations with limited numerical spread.

Cross-Database Matching and Entity Resolution

Forensic auditors employ relational database queries to link disparate datasets, exposing hidden relationships between internal employees and external vendors:

Employee-to-Vendor Matching : Executing inner joins between the employee master file and vendor master file matching on:

  • Tax Identification Numbers (matching employee SSN to vendor TIN)
  • Physical residential street addresses
  • Bank account routing and transit numbers
  • Telephone numbers

Any match indicates an immediate conflict of interest, undisclosed self-dealing, or a potential shell company scheme.

Public Assistance Roll Cross-Matching : Comparing public entitlement enrollment lists against state department of corrections incarceration records or the federal Social Security Administration's Death Master File to identify deceased or ineligible recipients collecting benefits.

  • Investigative Interviewing, Evidence Preservation & Law Enforcement Coordination
  • Phased Investigative Interviewing Techniques

Forensic interviews follow a disciplined, non-linear progression designed to gather facts, test consistency, and ultimately elicit admissions:

Introductory / Rapport Phase : Establishing professional rapport, reviewing the interview's administrative purpose, and assessing the interviewee's normal baseline verbal and non-verbal behavioral cues.

Informational Phase : Asking open-ended, non-threatening questions ( "Can you walk me through the step-by-step process of how vendor invoices are received and approved in your division?" ) to collect operational details and identify control gaps.

Assessment Phase : Introducing hypothetical or diagnostic questions to gauge integrity and reaction ( "Why do you think someone in this department might bypass the competitive bidding requirements?" ).

Admission-Seeking Phase : Reserved exclusively for the target subject when documentary evidence conclusively establishes wrongdoing. Conducted using direct, confident accusation while providing face-saving rationalizations to facilitate confession.

Evidence Preservation and Chain of Custody

Evidence gathered in a forensic audit must satisfy strict legal standards to ensure admissibility in court:

Document Integrity : Original documents must be protected from contamination. Working copies should be used for daily audit testing. Forensic images of digital hard drives and server databases must be acquired using bit-stream, write-blocking forensic tools, generating verifiable SHA-256 hash checksums.

Chain of Custody : A meticulous written record accounting for the chronological receipt, custody, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical and electronic evidence. The log must document:

  • Exact description and serial number of the item
  • Identity of the person who collected it
  • Exact date, time, and physical location of acquisition
  • Secure storage facility location (e.g., locked evidence vault)
  • Signatures of all individuals transferring and receiving custody

A break in the chain of custody can lead a trial judge to exclude critical financial records, destroying an otherwise sound criminal prosecution.

Coordination with Offices of Inspector General (OIG) and Law Enforcement

Auditors must understand the jurisdictional boundary between administrative auditing and criminal investigation. Under standard governmental auditing guidelines, when an auditor uncovers clear indicators of criminal activity (bribery, kickbacks, forgery, wire fraud):

Cease Routine Auditing : The auditor must immediately pause routine inquiries and contact legal counsel and the designated Office of Inspector General (OIG) or law enforcement authority.

Avoid Alerting Subjects : Continuing routine audit testing after discovering criminal fraud risks tipping off the perpetrator, leading to document destruction, witness tampering, or flight.

Maintain Workpaper Confidentiality : Protect investigative working papers from premature public records disclosure (e.g., FOIA requests) under statutory law enforcement investigatory exemptions.

Loading diagram... Public Sector Forensic Auditing and Fraud Investigation Pipeline