Study guide

5.1 Lognormal Distributions and Exposure Data Statistics

CIH Certified Industrial Hygienist Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: The CIH Exam and How to Use This Guide

1.1 CIH Exam Format, Scoring, and Test-Day Logistics 1.2 Eligibility, Application Windows, Fees, and Certification Maintenance 1.3 The BGC Blueprint, Subject Areas, and a Calculation-First Study Plan

2 Chapter 2: Basic Science & Calculations

2.1 Gas Laws and Vapor Calculations 2.2 Unit Conversions: ppm, mg/m³, and Standard Temperature/Pressure 2.3 Fluid Mechanics and Airflow Fundamentals

3 Chapter 3: Air Sampling & Instrumentation

3.1 Active and Passive Air Sampling Strategies 3.2 Particulate and Aerosol Sampling 3.3 Direct-Reading Instruments and Calibration

4 Chapter 4: Analytical Chemistry & Lab Methods

4.1 Gas Chromatography and Mass Spectrometry 4.2 High-Performance Liquid Chromatography and Ion Chromatography 4.3 Spectroscopy and Elemental Analysis 4.4 Gravimetric, Microscopy, and Wet Chemical Methods 4.5 Laboratory Quality Assurance, Chain of Custody, and Desorption Efficiency

5 Chapter 5: Biostatistics & Epidemiology

5.1 Lognormal Distributions and Exposure Data Statistics 5.2 Upper Confidence Limits (UCL95) and Compliance Decision Rules 5.3 Epidemiological Study Designs and Measures of Association 5.4 Sampling Strategy: Sample Size, Power, and Worker Selection

6 Chapter 6: Toxicology & Biological Monitoring

6.1 Dose-Response Relationships and Points of Departure 6.2 Toxicokinetics: Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism, and Elimination 6.3 Aerosol Deposition, Clearance, and Respiratory Tract Dosimetry 6.4 Hepatic, Renal, Neurologic, and Hematologic Target Organ Toxicity 6.5 Pulmonary Toxicology, Carcinogenicity, and Reproductive Hazards 6.6 OEL Frameworks, Classifications, and Excursion Limits 6.7 Chemical Mixtures and Extended Work-Shift OEL Adjustments 6.8 Biological Exposure Indices (BEIs) and Biomonitoring

7 Chapter 7: Biohazards & Indoor Environmental Quality

7.1 Mold, Fungi, and Microbial Contaminants 7.2 Infectious Agents, Bloodborne Pathogens, and Biosafety Levels 7.3 Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) Investigations 7.4 Sanitation, Potable Water, and Personal Hygiene Programs

8 Chapter 8: Community Exposure & Environmental Health

8.1 Clean Air Act Framework, NAAQS, and New Source Review 8.2 Hazardous Air Pollutants, CEMS, and EPA Reference Methods 8.3 Atmospheric Stability, Lapse Rates, and Plume Morphology 8.4 Gaussian Plume Modeling, Plume Rise, and Environmental Fate 8.5 HAZWOPER Scope, Mandates, and Training Tiers 8.6 Protection Levels, Site Zoning, Incident Command, and Decontamination 8.7 Water Pollution, Hazardous Waste, and Community Right-to-Know

9 Chapter 9: Health Risk Analysis & Hazard Communication

9.1 GHS Hazard Classification: Health and Physical Hazard Criteria 9.2 GHS Labels, Safety Data Sheets, and Trade Secret Rules 9.3 The AIHA Exposure Assessment Strategy and Similar Exposure Groups 9.4 Qualitative Exposure Profiling and the AIHA Risk Matrix 9.5 Quantitative Health Risk Characterization: HQ, HI, and ELCR 9.6 NIOSH Occupational Exposure Banding 9.7 Risk Communication and Reporting to Affected Parties

10 Chapter 10: Industrial Ventilation Principles & LEV Design

10.1 Elimination, Substitution, Isolation, Containment, and Process Change 10.2 LEV Hood Taxonomy and Capture Velocity Selection 10.3 Hood Airflow Equations, Entry Losses, and Hood Static Pressure 10.4 Particulate Transport Aerodynamics and Duct Sizing 10.5 Duct Friction, Fitting Losses, and System Balancing 10.6 Fan Categories and Pressure Dynamics Across the Fan 10.7 System Curves, the Fan Laws, and Density Corrections

11 Chapter 11: General Ventilation, Air Cleaning & Diagnostics

11.1 Dilution Ventilation Principles and Steady-State Modeling 11.2 Transient Purging and Air Distribution Geometry 11.3 Particulate Air Cleaning: Cyclones, Baghouses, Scrubbers, and ESPs 11.4 Gaseous Emission Control and Air Cleaner Selection 11.5 Ventilation System Troubleshooting and Testing

12 Chapter 12: Noise Measurement & Hearing Conservation

12.1 Acoustic Physics and Decibel Mathematics 12.2 Sound Propagation, Octave Bands, and Frequency Weighting 12.3 Noise Dose Metrics and OSHA versus ACGIH Criteria 12.4 Exchange Rates, Extended Shifts, and Dosimetry Field Protocols 12.5 Engineering Noise Controls and Hearing Protector Attenuation 12.6 Hearing Conservation Programs and Standard Threshold Shifts 12.7 Hand-Arm and Whole-Body Vibration

13 Chapter 13: Thermal Stress Assessment & Control

13.1 Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) and Heat Stress Indices 13.2 Heat-Related Disorders, Acclimatization, and Work/Rest Regimens 13.3 Cold Stress Evaluation and Wind Chill

14 Chapter 14: Ionizing Radiation Protection

14.1 Ionizing Radiation Physics and Radioactive Decay Kinetics 14.2 Radiation Units, Radiobiology, and Health Effects 14.3 ALARA, Stay-Time, and the Inverse Square Law 14.4 Shielding Physics, Material Selection, and Gamma Constants 14.5 Radiation Detection Instruments and Spectrometry 14.6 Personnel Dosimetry, Dose Limits, and Contamination Surveys

15 Chapter 15: Non-Ionizing Radiation & Laser Safety

15.1 The Non-Ionizing Spectrum and Static/ELF Field Exposures 15.2 Radiofrequency and Microwave Exposure: SAR, Standards, and Surveys 15.3 Ultraviolet, Visible, and Infrared Radiation Hazards 15.4 Laser Safety Classifications and Optical Density Calculations 15.5 Illumination, Lighting Design, and Visual Performance

16 Chapter 16: Non-Engineering Controls & Personal Protective Equipment

16.1 Respiratory Protection Programs and Assigned Protection Factors 16.2 Maximum Use Concentration, Oxygen Deficiency, and Breathing Air 16.3 Particulate Filters, Sorbent Cartridges, and Change Schedules 16.4 Respirator Fit Testing Protocols 16.5 Chemical Protective Clothing and Dermal Exposure Control

17 Chapter 17: Ergonomics & Workstation Design

17.1 Soft-Tissue Biomechanics and WMSD Pathophysiology 17.2 Ergonomic Risk Factors and Their Interaction Effects 17.3 The Revised NIOSH Lifting Equation 17.4 RULA, REBA, the Strain Index, and the ACGIH HAL TLV 17.5 Anthropometry and Workstation Geometry 17.6 VDT Workstations, Hand Tool Design, and Administrative Ergonomics

18 Chapter 18: Work Environments & Industrial Processes

18.1 Welding Fume Emissions, Metal Fume Fever, and Cr(VI)/Manganese Toxicology 18.2 Foundry Operations and Hot Work Fire Prevention 18.3 Vapor Degreasing, Pickling, Electroplating, and Cyanide Baths 18.4 Spray Coatings, Isocyanates, and Semiconductor Manufacturing 18.5 Confined Spaces and High-Hazard Industrial Operations 18.6 Asbestos, Lead, and Silica: Regulated Substance Programs 18.7 Abrasive Blasting and Surface Preparation

19 Chapter 19: IH Program Management & Professional Ethics

19.1 The BGC Code of Ethics: Canons and Enforcement 19.2 Professional Liability, Standard of Care, and Expert Testimony 19.3 Occupational Health & Safety Management Systems (ISO 45001, ANSI Z10) 19.4 Exposure Records Access and Medical Surveillance 19.5 OSHA Injury and Illness Recordkeeping and Enforcement

5.1 Lognormal Distributions and Exposure Data Statistics

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Workplace occupational exposure measurements almost universally follow lognormal distributions because airborne concentrations are bounded on the left by zero and modulated by multiplicative environmental and behavioral factors.

The Geometric Mean (GM = exp(mean(ln(x)))) is the median of a lognormal distribution and measures central tendency, while the Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD = exp(sd(ln(x)))) is a dimensionless metric of multiplicative dispersion (GSD >= 1.0).

The estimated population Arithmetic Mean (AM = GM · exp(0.5 · ln²(GSD))) is always greater than the Geometric Mean for lognormal data, directly reflecting the asymmetric right-skewed tail of peak exposure concentrations.

The estimated 95th percentile (X95 = GM · GSD^1.645) defines the upper boundary below which 95% of all daily shift exposures occur, serving as the standard AIHA benchmark for evaluating exposure profile acceptability.

Goodness-of-fit techniques—including the Shapiro-Wilk W-test on log-transformed data, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, and lognormal probability plots—verify that exposure data conform to lognormality before parametric modeling.

Last updated: August 2026

Lognormal Distributions and Exposure Data Statistics

Occupational hygiene exposure assessment relies heavily on applied biostatistics to characterize workplace air concentrations, validate exposure acceptability, and demonstrate regulatory compliance. Unlike classical industrial quality control data—which often exhibit symmetric, bell-shaped Gaussian behavior—workplace chemical, physical, and aerosol exposure measurements almost universally follow lognormal distributions .

A thorough understanding of lognormal mathematics, parameter estimation, upper percentile calculations, and goodness-of-fit validation is essential for any practicing Certified Industrial Hygienist (CIH).

1. Normal vs. Lognormal Distributions in Occupational Hygiene

A continuous random variable X is lognormally distributed if its natural logarithm, Y = ln(X), is normally distributed with mean µy and variance σy². That is, if Y ~ N(µy, σy²), then X = exp(Y) ~ Lognormal(µy, σy²).

Why Exposure Data Are Lognormal

Workplace environmental concentrations exhibit lognormality due to fundamental physical and statistical principles:

Physical Boundary at Zero (x > 0): Chemical concentrations and sound pressures cannot assume negative values. A normal distribution assigns finite non-zero probability to negative values whenever the mean is within two to three standard deviations of zero, which is physically impossible for chemical concentrations.

Multiplicative Generation and Dispersion Mechanisms: According to the Central Limit Theorem , when a process is governed by the addition of numerous independent random variables, the resulting sum tends toward a normal distribution. However, airborne contaminant concentrations in workplaces are determined by the product of multiple independent, fluctuating physical factors:

  • Source emission rate (mass volatilized per unit time)
  • General and local exhaust ventilation rates (air changes per hour, room capture velocity)
  • Worker proximity, position, and orientation relative to the contaminant source
  • Cyclic process duration and production throughput
  • Ambient barometric pressure, room temperature, and cross-draft turbulence

Because ln(A · B · C · D) = ln(A) + ln(B) + ln(C) + ln(D), taking the logarithm transforms a multiplicative physical process into an additive one, resulting in a normal distribution in log space and a lognormal distribution in linear concentration space .

Distributional Comparison Matrix

  • Property Normal (Gaussian) Distribution Lognormal Distribution
  • Domain / Range (-∞, +∞) (includes impossible negative concentrations) (0, +∞) (strictly non-negative)

Symmetry & Skewness Perfectly symmetric; Skewness = 0 Right-skewed (positive skewness); long tail of peak exposures

  • Central Tendency Relationship Mean = Median = Mode Mode < Median (GM) < Arithmetic Mean (AM)
  • Primary Parameters Arithmetic Mean (µ), Arithmetic Std Dev (σ) Geometric Mean (GM), Geometric Std Dev (GSD)
  • Dispersion Metric Additive interval: µ ± kσ Multiplicative interval: GM /(×) GSD(k)

Typical IH Application Direct-reading instrument calibration drift, pump flow errors Personal 8-hour TWA exposures, airborne dust/vapor samples

2. Geometric Mean (GM) and Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD)

When analyzing a dataset of n occupational exposure samples {x1, x2, …, xn}, the data are first transformed to the natural log scale: yi = ln(xi).

The Geometric Mean (GM)

The Geometric Mean (GM) is the antilogarithm of the arithmetic mean of the log-transformed data. It represents the median (50th percentile) of the lognormal exposure distribution: y ˉ = 1 n ∑ i = 1 n ln ⁡ ( x i ) = ln ⁡ ( x 1 ) + ln ⁡ ( x 2 ) + ⋯ + ln ⁡ ( x n ) n \bar{y} = \frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \ln(x_i) = \frac{\ln(x_1) + \ln(x_2) + \dots + \ln(x_n)}{n} y ˉ ​ = n 1 ​ i = 1 ∑ n ​ ln ( x i ​ ) = n ln ( x 1 ​ ) + ln ( x 2 ​ ) + ⋯ + ln ( x n ​ ) ​ GM = exp ⁡ ( y ˉ ) = exp ⁡ ( 1 n ∑ i = 1 n ln ⁡ ( x i ) ) = x 1 ⋅ x 2 … x n n \mathbf{\text{GM} = \exp(\bar{y}) = \exp\left( \frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \ln(x_i) \right) = \sqrt[n]{x_1 \cdot x_2 \dots x_n}} GM = exp ( y ˉ ​ ) = exp ( n 1 ​ i = 1 ∑ n ​ ln ( x i ​ ) ) = n x 1 ​ ⋅ x 2 ​ … x n ​ ​

Physical Meaning: Exactly 50% of the daily exposure shifts in the sampled population are expected to fall below the GM, and 50% will exceed it. The GM has the same units as the original concentration measurements (e.g., ppm or mg/m³).

The Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD)

The Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD) is the antilogarithm of the sample standard deviation of the log-transformed data (sy): s y = ∑ i = 1 n ( ln ⁡ ( x i ) − y ˉ ) 2 n − 1 s_y = \sqrt{\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n} (\ln(x_i) - \bar{y})^2}{n - 1}} s y ​ = n − 1 ∑ i = 1 n ​ ( ln ( x i ​ ) − y ˉ ​ ) 2 ​ ​ GSD = exp ⁡ ( s y ) \mathbf{\text{GSD} = \exp(s_y)} GSD = exp ( s y ​ )

Physical Meaning: Unlike the arithmetic standard deviation, the GSD is dimensionless and strictly greater than or equal to 1.0 (GSD ≥ 1.0). A GSD = 1.0 indicates zero variance (sy = 0), where all measured exposure concentrations are identical.

Multiplicative Coverage Intervals

In a lognormal distribution, standard deviation intervals operate multiplicatively around the Geometric Mean:

  • 68.27% of exposures lie within: [ GM/GSD, GM · GSD ] = [exp(ȳ - sy), exp(ȳ + sy)]
  • 95.45% of exposures lie within: [ GM/GSD², GM · GSD² ] = [exp(ȳ - 2sy), exp(ȳ + 2sy)]
  • 99.73% of exposures lie within: [ GM/GSD³, GM · GSD³ ] = [exp(ȳ - 3sy), exp(ȳ + 3sy)]
  • Interpreting GSD in Similar Exposure Groups (SEGs)

The American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) utilizes the GSD as a primary diagnostic indicator of exposure variability within a defined Similar Exposure Group (SEG):

GSD Value Range Degree of Exposure Variability Industrial Hygiene Interpretation

GSD < 1.5 Very Low Variability Highly uniform operations; automated closed processes; consistent environmental control.

1.5 ≤ GSD ≤ 2.0 Moderate (Normal) Variability Well-defined, homogeneous SEG. Typical of well-managed industrial operations where workers perform similar tasks.

2.0 < GSD ≤ 3.0 High Variability Moderately variable SEG; significant shift-to-shift, task, or seasonal variations exist.

GSD > 3.0 Extremely High Variability Heterogeneous group. Indicates that workers performing fundamentally different tasks or operating under vastly different controls were improperly pooled into a single SEG. The group must be subdivided into distinct sub-SEGs.

3. Arithmetic Mean (AM) vs. Geometric Mean (GM)

In occupational hygiene toxicology and epidemiology, understanding the divergence between the Arithmetic Mean and Geometric Mean is critical:

Geometric Mean (extGM): Represents the median (50th percentile) exposure. It is the most robust measure of typical daily exposure because it is resistant to extreme high-end outliers.

Arithmetic Mean (extAM): Represents the average mass of chemical inhaled over time. Chronic toxicological effects, cumulative internal body burden, and occupational disease risks are proportional to the true Arithmetic Mean, not the Geometric Mean.

Population Relationships in Lognormal Distributions

For a true lognormal population with log-scale parameters µy and σy: AM = exp ⁡ ( μ y + 1 2 σ y 2 ) = GM ⋅ exp ⁡ ( 1 2 ln ⁡ 2 ( GSD ) ) \mathbf{\text{AM} = \exp\left( \mu_y + \frac{1}{2}\sigma_y^2 \right) = \text{GM} \cdot \exp\left( \frac{1}{2}\ln^2(\text{GSD}) \right)} AM = exp ( μ y ​ + 2 1 ​ σ y 2 ​ ) = GM ⋅ exp ( 2 1 ​ ln 2 ( GSD ) ) Variance ( X ) = exp ⁡ ( 2 μ y + σ y 2 ) ( exp ⁡ ( σ y 2 ) − 1 ) = AM 2 ⋅ ( exp ⁡ ( s y 2 ) − 1 ) \text{Variance}(X) = \exp(2\mu_y + \sigma_y^2) \left( \exp(\sigma_y^2) - 1 \right) = \text{AM}^2 \cdot \left( \exp(s_y^2) - 1 \right) Variance ( X ) = exp ( 2 μ y ​ + σ y 2 ​ ) ( exp ( σ y 2 ​ ) − 1 ) = AM 2 ⋅ ( exp ( s y 2 ​ ) − 1 ) Mode ( X ) = exp ⁡ ( μ y − σ y 2 ) = GM exp ⁡ ( σ y 2 ) \text{Mode}(X) = \exp(\mu_y - \sigma_y^2) = \frac{\text{GM}}{\exp(\sigma_y^2)} Mode ( X ) = exp ( μ y ​ − σ y 2 ​ ) = exp ( σ y 2 ​ ) GM ​

Because 1/2σy² > 0 whenever variability exists (sy > 0), the Arithmetic Mean is always strictly greater than the Geometric Mean (extAM > extGM) . As exposure variability (extGSD) increases, the arithmetic mean is pulled substantially higher into the upper tail.

Sample Estimation Note: While the naive sample arithmetic mean x̄ = 1/nΣ xi is an unbiased estimator of the population mean, for small lognormal datasets (n < 30), the Minimum Variance Unbiased Estimator (MVUE) or parametric estimator AM = GM · exp(0.5 sy²) provides a more efficient point estimate of the true long-term arithmetic mean.

4. Estimating Exposure Percentiles (The 95th Percentile, X95)

Under the AIHA Exposure Assessment Strategy, exposure acceptability is judged by evaluating the 95th percentile (X95) of the exposure distribution relative to the Occupational Exposure Limit (OEL). The 95th percentile represents an exposure level that is exceeded on only 5% of work shifts (or 1 out of every 20 workdays).

General Formula for Lognormal Percentiles

For any desired percentile p (where 0 < p < 1), the corresponding standard normal Z-score (Zp) is applied in log space: ln ⁡ ( X p ) = y ˉ + Z p ⋅ s y \ln(X_p) = \bar{y} + Z_p \cdot s_y ln ( X p ​ ) = y ˉ ​ + Z p ​ ⋅ s y ​

Exponentiating both sides yields the master percentile equation: X p = exp ⁡ ( y ˉ + Z p ⋅ s y ) = GM ⋅ GSD Z p \mathbf{X_p = \exp(\bar{y} + Z_p \cdot s_y) = \text{GM} \cdot \text{GSD}^{Z_p}} X p ​ = exp ( y ˉ ​ + Z p ​ ⋅ s y ​ ) = GM ⋅ GSD Z p ​

Standard Normal Z-Scores for Common IH Percentiles

  • Percentile (p) Standard Normal Score (Zp) Lognormal Percentile Expression
  • 50th Percentile (X50) Z(0.50) = 0.000 X50 = GM · GSD⁰ = GM (Median)
  • 75th Percentile (X75) Z(0.75) = +0.674 X75 = GM · GSD(0.674)
  • 90th Percentile (X90) Z(0.90) = +1.282 X90 = GM · GSD(1.282)
  • 95th Percentile (X95) Z(0.95) = +1.645 X95 = GM · GSD(1.645)
  • 99th Percentile (X99) Z(0.99) = +2.326 X99 = GM · GSD(2.326)
  • Probability of Exceedance (fe)

Conversely, to calculate the probability that an individual random work shift will exceed the Occupational Exposure Limit (OEL), calculate the standardized log-scale Z-score: Z = ln ⁡ ( OEL ) − y ˉ s y = ln ⁡ ( OEL / GM ) ln ⁡ ( GSD ) Z = \frac{\ln(\text{OEL}) - \bar{y}}{s_y} = \frac{\ln(\text{OEL} / \text{GM})}{\ln(\text{GSD})} Z = s y ​ ln ( OEL ) − y ˉ ​ ​ = ln ( GSD ) ln ( OEL / GM ) ​

The exceedance fraction (fe = P(X > OEL)) is determined from the standard cumulative normal distribution table: f e = 1 − Φ ( Z ) = Φ ( − Z ) f_e = 1 - \Phi(Z) = \Phi(-Z) f e ​ = 1 − Φ ( Z ) = Φ ( − Z )

5. Cumulative Lognormal Probability Plots & Goodness-of-Fit

Before applying parametric lognormal equations (X95 = GM · GSD(1.645)), the industrial hygienist must confirm that the sample dataset adequately fits a lognormal distribution.

Constructing Cumulative Lognormal Probability Plots

A lognormal probability plot graphs log-transformed exposure concentrations against their empirical cumulative probabilities (or probit / normal quantiles):

Sort the n exposure measurements in ascending order: x((1)) ≤ x((2)) ≤ s ≤ x((n)).

Assign an empirical cumulative plotting position (Pi) to each ith ordered data point using an established ranking formula:

  • Hazen's Formula: Pi = (i - 0.5)/n × 100%
  • Blom's Formula: Pi = (i - 0.375)/(n + 0.25) × 100%
  • Chegodayev's Formula: Pi = (i - 0.3)/(n + 0.4) × 100%

Plot ln(x((i))) on the linear vertical axis against the normal score Zi = Φ⁻¹(Pi) (or cumulative percent on probability paper) on the horizontal axis.

Graphical Diagnostics

Straight-Line Fit: If the plotted points fall along a straight line (R² > 0.90), lognormality is validated.

Estimating Parameters Graphically:

The concentration at the 50th percentile line (Z = 0) equals the Geometric Mean (GM) .

The ratio of the concentration at the 84.13th percentile (Z = +1) to the 50th percentile equals the Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD) : GSD = X(84.13) / X50.

S-Shaped Curve: Indicates a bimodal mixture of two distinct exposure groups incorrectly combined into one SEG.

Down-Curving Upper Tail: Indicates truncation, such as the effective operation of an engineering capture hood capping maximum exposures.

Formal Goodness-of-Fit Hypothesis Tests

Test Method Minimum Sample Size Mechanics and Strengths for CIH Applications

Shapiro-Wilk W-Test n = 3 to 50 The most powerful and preferred statistical test for small sample sizes in industrial hygiene. Evaluates the correlation between ordered log-transformed sample values and theoretical normal quantiles. p > 0.05 accepts the null hypothesis of lognormality.

Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S) Test n ≥ 20 Measures the maximum absolute vertical distance (D = max |Fn(x) - F0(x)|) between the empirical cumulative step function and the theoretical CDF. Requires the Lilliefors correction when parameters are estimated from the sample.

Anderson-Darling (A²) Test n ≥ 10 A modification of the K-S test that places heavier statistical weight on the upper and lower tails of the distribution. Highly advantageous in occupational hygiene because tail behavior dictates X95 and compliance risk.

  • 6. Worked Step-by-Step Calculation Examples
  • Worked Example 4.1.1: Calculating GM, GSD, AM, and 95th Percentile

Problem: An industrial hygienist collects six (n = 6) full-shift personal air samples for toluene vapor in a paint spray booth. The laboratory reports the following 8-hour TWA concentrations (in ppm): { 12.0 , 18.0 , 24.0 , 35.0 , 48.0 , 75.0 } \{12.0, \; 18.0, \; 24.0, \; 35.0, \; 48.0, \; 75.0\} { 12.0 , 18.0 , 24.0 , 35.0 , 48.0 , 75.0 }

Calculate the sample Geometric Mean (GM) and Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD).

Calculate the estimated population Arithmetic Mean (AM).

Calculate the estimated 95th percentile (X95) and determine if it complies with the ACGIH TLV-TWA of 20 ppm.

Solution Steps:

Transform data to natural logarithms (yi = ln(xi)):

  • ln(12.0) = 2.4849
  • ln(18.0) = 2.8904
  • ln(24.0) = 3.1781
  • ln(35.0) = 3.5553
  • ln(48.0) = 3.8712
  • ln(75.0) = 4.3175

Calculate log-scale mean (ȳ) and Geometric Mean (GM): ∑ y i = 2.4849 + 2.8904 + 3.1781 + 3.5553 + 3.8712 + 4.3175 = 20.2974 \sum y_i = 2.4849 + 2.8904 + 3.1781 + 3.5553 + 3.8712 + 4.3175 = 20.2974 ∑ y i ​ = 2.4849 + 2.8904 + 3.1781 + 3.5553 + 3.8712 + 4.3175 = 20.2974 y ˉ = 20.2974 6 = 3.3829 \bar{y} = \frac{20.2974}{6} = 3.3829 y ˉ ​ = 6 20.2974 ​ = 3.3829 GM = exp ⁡ ( 3.3829 ) = 29.46 ppm \mathbf{\text{GM} = \exp(3.3829) = 29.46\text{ ppm}} GM = exp ( 3.3829 ) = 29.46 ppm

Calculate log-scale standard deviation (sy) and GSD:

Sum of squared deviations: Σ (yi - ȳ)² ( − 0.8980 ) 2 + ( − 0.4925 ) 2 + ( − 0.2048 ) 2 + ( 0.1724 ) 2 + ( 0.4883 ) 2 + ( 0.9346 ) 2 (-0.8980)^2 + (-0.4925)^2 + (-0.2048)^2 + (0.1724)^2 + (0.4883)^2 + (0.9346)^2 ( − 0.8980 ) 2 + ( − 0.4925 ) 2 + ( − 0.2048 ) 2 + ( 0.1724 ) 2 + ( 0.4883 ) 2 + ( 0.9346 ) 2 = 0.8064 + 0.2426 + 0.0419 + 0.0297 + 0.2384 + 0.8735 = 2.2325 = 0.8064 + 0.2426 + 0.0419 + 0.0297 + 0.2384 + 0.8735 = 2.2325 = 0.8064 + 0.2426 + 0.0419 + 0.0297 + 0.2384 + 0.8735 = 2.2325

Sample variance in log space: sy² = 2.2325/(6 - 1) = 2.2325/5 = 0.4465

Sample standard deviation: sy = √(0.4465) = 0.6682 GSD = exp ⁡ ( 0.6682 ) = 1.95 \mathbf{\text{GSD} = \exp(0.6682) = 1.95} GSD = exp ( 0.6682 ) = 1.95

(Note: GSD = 1.95 indicates a well-defined, homogeneous SEG since 1.5 ≤ GSD ≤ 2.0.)

Calculate estimated population Arithmetic Mean (AM): AM ^ = GM ⋅ exp ⁡ ( 0.5 ⋅ s y 2 ) = 29.46 ⋅ exp ⁡ ( 0.5 × 0.4465 ) = 29.46 ⋅ exp ⁡ ( 0.22325 ) \widehat{\text{AM}} = \text{GM} \cdot \exp(0.5 \cdot s_y^2) = 29.46 \cdot \exp(0.5 \times 0.4465) = 29.46 \cdot \exp(0.22325) AM = GM ⋅ exp ( 0.5 ⋅ s y 2 ​ ) = 29.46 ⋅ exp ( 0.5 × 0.4465 ) = 29.46 ⋅ exp ( 0.22325 ) AM ^ = 29.46 × 1.2501 = 36.83 ppm \widehat{\text{AM}} = 29.46 \times 1.2501 = \mathbf{36.83\text{ ppm}} AM = 29.46 × 1.2501 = 36.83 ppm

(Notice that AM = 36.83 ppm > GM = 29.46 ppm, reflecting the skewness of peak exposures).

Calculate the 95th Percentile (X95): ln ⁡ ( X 95 ) = y ˉ + 1.645 ⋅ s y = 3.3829 + ( 1.645 × 0.6682 ) = 3.3829 + 1.0992 = 4.4821 \ln(X_{95}) = \bar{y} + 1.645 \cdot s_y = 3.3829 + (1.645 \times 0.6682) = 3.3829 + 1.0992 = 4.4821 ln ( X 95 ​ ) = y ˉ ​ + 1.645 ⋅ s y ​ = 3.3829 + ( 1.645 × 0.6682 ) = 3.3829 + 1.0992 = 4.4821 X 95 = exp ⁡ ( 4.4821 ) = 88.42 ppm X_{95} = \exp(4.4821) = \mathbf{88.42\text{ ppm}} X 95 ​ = exp ( 4.4821 ) = 88.42 ppm

Alternatively: X95 = GM · GSD(1.645) = 29.46 · (1.95)(1.645) = 29.46 · 3.0014 = 88.42 ppm.

Compliance Evaluation: The estimated 95th percentile (88.42 ppm) substantially exceeds the ACGIH TLV-TWA of 20 ppm. The exposure profile is unacceptable, requiring immediate engineering controls.

Worked Example 4.1.2: Calculating Exceedance Fraction from Baseline Parameters

Problem: Historical baseline monitoring of an abrasive blasting operation indicates that personal respirable crystalline silica exposures follow a lognormal distribution with a Geometric Mean GM = 0.022 mg/m³ and a Geometric Standard Deviation GSD = 2.10. Calculate the statistical probability (fe) that a worker's daily shift exposure exceeds the OSHA Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) of 0.050 mg/m³.

Solution Steps:

Convert parameters to log space:

  • ȳ = ln(GM) = ln(0.022) = -3.8167
  • sy = ln(GSD) = ln(2.10) = 0.7419
  • ln(OEL) = ln(0.050) = -2.9957

Calculate standard normal score (Z): Z = ln ⁡ ( OEL ) − y ˉ s y = − 2.9957 − ( − 3.8167 ) 0.7419 = 0.8210 0.7419 = + 1.107 Z = \frac{\ln(\text{OEL}) - \bar{y}}{s_y} = \frac{-2.9957 - (-3.8167)}{0.7419} = \frac{0.8210}{0.7419} = +1.107 Z = s y ​ ln ( OEL ) − y ˉ ​ ​ = 0.7419 − 2.9957 − ( − 3.8167 ) ​ = 0.7419 0.8210 ​ = + 1.107

Determine exceedance probability (fe):

  • From standard normal cumulative tables: Φ(1.107) = 0.8658
  • Exceedance fraction: fe = 1 - Φ(1.107) = 1 - 0.8658 = 0.1342 = 13.42%

Result: There is a 13.4% probability that any given work shift will exceed the OSHA PEL, confirming that exposure controls are currently inadequate under AIHA criteria (which require exceedance < 5%).