Study guide

8.2 Agreed Value, First Loss and New-for-Old Policies

CII IF1 Insurance, Legal and Regulatory Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

About the IF1 Exam How to Use This Guide & Study Strategy

2 Chapter 1: Risk and the Insurance Environment

1.1 The Nature and Features of Risk 1.2 Categories of Risk 1.3 Perils and Hazards 1.4 The Components of Risk: Frequency and Severity 1.5 Pooling and the Features of an Insurable Risk

3 Chapter 2: Risk Management and the UK Insurance Market

2.1 The Risk Management Process 2.2 The Need for and Benefits of Insurance 2.3 Who's Who: The Main Groups in the Insurance Market 2.4 Structure of the UK Insurance Market 2.5 Classes and Distribution of Insurance 2.6 The London Market 2.7 The Purpose of Reinsurance

4 Chapter 3: Insurance Products, Professional Roles and Insurance Premium Tax

3.1 Co-insurance, Dual Insurance and Self-insurance 3.2 Insurance Premium Tax 3.3 Professional Roles and Market Organisations

5 Chapter 4: Contract Law and Agency

4.1 Essential Elements of a Valid Contract 4.2 Formation and Validity of Contracts 4.3 Cancellation and Termination of Contracts 4.4 Principles of Agency 4.5 Authority and Duties of an Agent 4.6 Terms of Business Agreements (TOBAs)

6 Chapter 5: Insurable Interest

5.1 The Nature of Insurable Interest and When It Must Exist 5.2 Application of Insurable Interest Across Classes

7 Chapter 6: Utmost Good Faith and Disclosure

6.1 Utmost Good Faith at Common Law 6.2 The Duty of Fair Presentation — Insurance Act 2015 6.3 Hazards and the Insurer's Right to Information 6.4 Qualifying Breach, Remedies and the Consumer Duty (CIDRA 2012)

8 Chapter 7: Proximate Cause

7.1 The Principle of Proximate Cause 7.2 Concurrent and Successive Causes

9 Chapter 8: Indemnity and its Corollaries

8.1 The Principle of Indemnity and Settlement 8.2 Agreed Value, First Loss and New-for-Old Policies 8.3 The Condition of Average and Excess 8.4 Subrogation 8.5 Contribution

10 Chapter 9: Policy Terms and Documentation

9.1 Warranties, Conditions and Representations 9.2 Policy Documentation and Interpretation

11 Chapter 10: The Regulatory Framework

10.1 The FCA and the PRA 10.2 FSMA 2000 and the Regulatory Perimeter 10.3 Authorisation, Conduct Rulebooks and Solvency 10.4 Reporting, Record Keeping and Training and Competence

12 Chapter 11: Consumer Protection and Conduct

11.1 Treating Customers Fairly and the Consumer Duty 11.2 Conduct of Business, Financial Promotions and Enforcement 11.3 Consumer Rights and CIDRA 2012 11.4 Complaints Handling, DISP and the Financial Ombudsman Service

13 Chapter 12: Compensation, Data Protection and Financial Crime

12.1 The Financial Services Compensation Scheme 12.2 Data Protection — DPA 2018 and UK GDPR 12.3 Financial Crime, Money Laundering and Fraud 12.4 Compulsory Insurance in the UK

14 Chapter 13: Underwriting, Claims and Ethics

13.1 Underwriting Basics 13.2 Claims Handling Basics 13.3 Ethics and the CII Code of Ethics 13.4 Professional Conduct and Discipline

8.2 Agreed Value, First Loss and New-for-Old Policies

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

An agreed value (valued) policy fixes the sum payable for a total loss at inception, so the insurer pays that figure without proving value at the date of loss

Agreed value cover is used where value is hard to establish after the event — marine hull, fine art, antiques, classic cars and specialist plant — and is normally supported by a professional valuation

A first loss policy is written for a sum insured deliberately below the full value of the property, on the basis that a total loss is practically impossible; average is disapplied up to that sum insured

New-for-old (reinstatement) cover pays the cost of a new equivalent item or of rebuilding as new, with no deduction for wear and tear, and is the main modern departure from strict indemnity

All three bases can leave the insured better off than before the loss, so each is a recognised exception to the strict measure of indemnity rather than a contradiction of the principle

Last updated: August 2026

Section 8.1 established the strict measure of indemnity: the insured is restored to the position they occupied immediately before the loss , no better and no worse, with depreciation reflected. Learning outcome 9 then asks candidates to explain three policy bases that deliberately depart from that measure — agreed value policies , first loss policies and new for old cover — as well as the indemnity/benefit distinction. Each is an exception the market has developed because strict indemnity produces a bad practical answer in particular circumstances.

Agreed Value (Valued) Policies

An agreed value policy — also called a valued policy — fixes the amount payable for a total loss at inception . If the subject matter is totally lost, the insurer pays the agreed figure and does not require the insured to prove the value at the date of loss.

Why it exists. For some property, establishing value after the event is difficult, contentious or impossible. There is no reliable second-hand market for a 1930s racing car, a painting by a particular artist, or a bespoke piece of production machinery. Arguing about value at the worst possible moment helps neither party, so the parties agree it in advance.

How it works in practice.

The insured obtains a professional valuation and the insurer agrees to it before cover incepts. The agreed figure is recorded in the schedule.

On a total loss the insurer pays the agreed value, even if the market value has since fallen. Equally, the insured cannot claim more if the market value has risen.

Partial losses are usually settled on ordinary repair-cost principles, not as a proportion of the agreed value, unless the policy says otherwise.

Because the agreed figure is the measure, average does not apply to it: there is no underinsurance to test.

Valuations are normally reviewed periodically — often annually or every three years — so that the agreed figure does not drift far from reality.

Typical classes: marine hull, fine art and antiques, classic and vintage vehicles, jewellery, specialist and irreplaceable plant.

Agreed value and benefit policies are not the same thing

Both pay a pre-set sum, but for different reasons.

  • Agreed value (valued) policy Benefit policy
  • Subject matter Property with a value that is hard to establish after loss Life, or a defined bodily event

Why a fixed sum Value cannot practically be proved at the date of loss The subject matter has no financial value that can be measured at all

  • Relationship to indemnity An exception to the measure of indemnity Not a contract of indemnity at any point
  • Examples Marine hull, a valued painting Life assurance, personal accident benefits, critical illness
  • First Loss Policies

A first loss policy is written with a sum insured deliberately set below the full value of the property at risk, because a total loss is practically impossible .

The classic case is theft cover on a very large warehouse. The building may hold £8 million of stock, but a thief cannot remove £8 million of goods in one night — the realistic maximum loss might be £400,000. Insuring the full £8 million against theft would waste premium on cover that could never be needed.

How it works.

The insured and the insurer agree an estimated maximum loss (EML) and set the sum insured at that figure.

The insurer pays claims in full up to that sum insured , without applying average, even though the sum insured is a fraction of the full value at risk.

The insurer knows the full value and prices the first loss limit accordingly, so the premium is not simply proportionate to the reduced sum insured.

The insured must still declare the full value at risk ; a first loss policy is an agreed structure, not a way of concealing exposure.

The critical distinction from underinsurance. A first loss policy and an underinsured policy can look identical on paper — a sum insured below full value — but they are opposites:

  • First loss Underinsurance
  • Sum insured below full value? Yes, deliberately and by agreement Yes, by accident or omission
  • Insurer aware of full value? Yes, and has priced for it No
  • Average applied? No — claims paid in full to the limit Yes — claim reduced proportionately (Section 8.3)
  • New for Old (Reinstatement) Cover

New for old , or reinstatement , cover pays the cost of a new equivalent item , or of rebuilding as new, with no deduction for wear, tear or depreciation . It is the most common departure from strict indemnity in the modern market, and most household contents and buildings policies are written this way.

Contents. A five-year-old television destroyed by fire is replaced with a new equivalent model , not with the depreciated value of a five-year-old set. As Section 8.1 explains, if the insured takes cash instead of the replacement, the insurer's payment is normally limited to what the replacement would have cost the insurer through its own supplier.

Buildings. Reinstatement pays the cost of rebuilding as new, subject to the reinstatement conditions : the work must actually be carried out, generally within a reasonable time, and the sum insured must be adequate. If the insured chooses not to rebuild, the basis of settlement usually reverts to indemnity — market value — which can be dramatically lower.

Common exclusions. Clothing, household linen and similar items are frequently excluded from new-for-old and settled on an indemnity (wear-and-tear) basis instead.

Average still applies. Reinstatement cover does not disapply average. The sum insured must represent the full cost of rebuilding as new , and a sum insured based on market value or on a depreciated figure will trigger average at the moment of claim.

Betterment

Where repair unavoidably improves the property beyond its pre-loss condition, the insurer may seek a contribution for betterment . New-for-old cover is essentially betterment that has been paid for in the premium and written into the contract, which is why it is an exception rather than a breach of the principle.

Putting the Three Together

  • Basis What it changes Average applies? Typical use
  • Agreed value Fixes the total-loss payment at inception No Marine hull, fine art, classic cars

First loss Sets the sum insured at the estimated maximum loss No, up to the first loss limit Theft on large stock holdings

New for old Removes the deduction for wear and tear Yes Household contents and buildings

All three can leave the insured better off in money terms than immediately before the loss. That does not defeat the principle of indemnity: it is a commercial modification the parties have agreed and the insurer has priced. What the principle continues to prohibit is the insured profiting from the same loss twice , which is why subrogation and contribution (Sections 8.4 and 8.5) still apply to all three bases.