Study guide
7.2 Concurrent and Successive Causes
CII IF1 Insurance, Legal and Regulatory Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
About the IF1 Exam How to Use This Guide & Study Strategy
2 Chapter 1: Risk and the Insurance Environment
1.1 The Nature and Features of Risk 1.2 Categories of Risk 1.3 Perils and Hazards 1.4 The Components of Risk: Frequency and Severity 1.5 Pooling and the Features of an Insurable Risk
3 Chapter 2: Risk Management and the UK Insurance Market
2.1 The Risk Management Process 2.2 The Need for and Benefits of Insurance 2.3 Who's Who: The Main Groups in the Insurance Market 2.4 Structure of the UK Insurance Market 2.5 Classes and Distribution of Insurance 2.6 The London Market 2.7 The Purpose of Reinsurance
4 Chapter 3: Insurance Products, Professional Roles and Insurance Premium Tax
3.1 Co-insurance, Dual Insurance and Self-insurance 3.2 Insurance Premium Tax 3.3 Professional Roles and Market Organisations
5 Chapter 4: Contract Law and Agency
4.1 Essential Elements of a Valid Contract 4.2 Formation and Validity of Contracts 4.3 Cancellation and Termination of Contracts 4.4 Principles of Agency 4.5 Authority and Duties of an Agent 4.6 Terms of Business Agreements (TOBAs)
6 Chapter 5: Insurable Interest
5.1 The Nature of Insurable Interest and When It Must Exist 5.2 Application of Insurable Interest Across Classes
7 Chapter 6: Utmost Good Faith and Disclosure
6.1 Utmost Good Faith at Common Law 6.2 The Duty of Fair Presentation — Insurance Act 2015 6.3 Hazards and the Insurer's Right to Information 6.4 Qualifying Breach, Remedies and the Consumer Duty (CIDRA 2012)
8 Chapter 7: Proximate Cause
7.1 The Principle of Proximate Cause 7.2 Concurrent and Successive Causes
9 Chapter 8: Indemnity and its Corollaries
8.1 The Principle of Indemnity and Settlement 8.2 Agreed Value, First Loss and New-for-Old Policies 8.3 The Condition of Average and Excess 8.4 Subrogation 8.5 Contribution
10 Chapter 9: Policy Terms and Documentation
9.1 Warranties, Conditions and Representations 9.2 Policy Documentation and Interpretation
11 Chapter 10: The Regulatory Framework
10.1 The FCA and the PRA 10.2 FSMA 2000 and the Regulatory Perimeter 10.3 Authorisation, Conduct Rulebooks and Solvency 10.4 Reporting, Record Keeping and Training and Competence
12 Chapter 11: Consumer Protection and Conduct
11.1 Treating Customers Fairly and the Consumer Duty 11.2 Conduct of Business, Financial Promotions and Enforcement 11.3 Consumer Rights and CIDRA 2012 11.4 Complaints Handling, DISP and the Financial Ombudsman Service
13 Chapter 12: Compensation, Data Protection and Financial Crime
12.1 The Financial Services Compensation Scheme 12.2 Data Protection — DPA 2018 and UK GDPR 12.3 Financial Crime, Money Laundering and Fraud 12.4 Compulsory Insurance in the UK
14 Chapter 13: Underwriting, Claims and Ethics
13.1 Underwriting Basics 13.2 Claims Handling Basics 13.3 Ethics and the CII Code of Ethics 13.4 Professional Conduct and Discipline
7.2 Concurrent and Successive Causes
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Where two causes operate concurrently, one insured and the other uninsured but not excepted, the insurer is liable (The Miss Jay Jay)
Where two causes operate concurrently, one insured and the other excepted, the insurer is not liable — the exclusion prevails (Wayne Tank; University of Exeter v Allianz)
A new and independent intervening cause can break the chain and become the new proximate cause, displacing an earlier insured peril
Where the insured cannot identify which of several possible causes was the dominant one, the claim fails (The Popi M)
Some life and personal accident wordings include a loss-of-life proviso so that, where loss of life is caused by an insured peril, the insurer remains liable even if an excepted peril contributed
Last updated: August 2026
Concurrent Causes — The Two Causes Rule
A loss frequently has two or more causes operating at the same time , each of which is sufficiently dominant to be a proximate cause. This is the situation of concurrent causes . English law, developed in the common law and applied alongside section 55 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 , resolves these cases by looking at the legal character of each rival cause: is the second cause uninsured (but not excepted) , or is it excepted (excluded) by the policy? The answer determines whether the insured can recover.
This is sometimes called the two causes rule in IF1 materials.
Rule 1 — Insured Peril + Uninsured (Non-Excepted) Peril: Insurer IS Liable
Where two concurrent causes operate together to produce the loss, one an insured peril and the other an uninsured peril that is not excluded by the policy, the insurer is generally liable . The insured peril is still a proximate cause, and the uninsured peril is legally irrelevant because the parties did not agree to exclude it.
The leading authority is JJ Lloyd Instruments Ltd v Northern Star Insurance Co Ltd (The Miss Jay Jay) [1987] 1 Lloyd's Rep 32 . A yacht was lost through a combination of perils of the sea (insured) and negligence of the crew (uninsured but not excluded). The Court of Appeal held that where one proximate cause is insured and the other is uninsured but not excepted, the insurer is liable.
Example: A property policy covers storm but is silent on sprinkler leakage . A storm damages the sprinkler system, which then leaks and ruins stock. Storm and sprinkler leakage operate together. Sprinkler leakage is uninsured but not excluded, so the insurer is liable for the storm-damage and the consequent stock loss — the insured peril (storm) is a proximate cause, and the mere uninsured peril does not defeat it.
Rule 2 — Insured Peril + Excepted (Excluded) Peril: Insurer is NOT Liable
Where the concurrent causes are an insured peril and an excepted peril (a peril the policy expressly excludes), the insurer is not liable . The exclusion prevails over the insured peril.
The leading authority is Wayne Tank and Pump Co Ltd v Employers' Liability Assurance Corp Ltd [1974] QB 57 . Two causes of equal efficiency operated together: negligence of the insured (insured under a public liability policy) and an inherent vice in the insured's own product (excluded). The Court of Appeal held that where an insured peril and an excepted peril operate concurrently, the exclusion prevails and the insurer is not liable.
The rule was reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in University of Exeter v Allianz [2023] EWCA Civ 1484 . A Second World War bomb was dropped in 1942 and detonated in a controlled explosion in 2021; both the original dropping and the modern detonation were treated as concurrent causes, and the war exclusion prevailed, defeating the claim.
Example: A property policy insures against storm but excepts flood . A severe weather event produces both storm-driven rain and river flooding at the same time, and both together destroy the building. Storm is insured, flood is excepted, and they operate concurrently. Under the Wayne Tank rule, the exclusion for flood prevails and the insurer is not liable for the loss.
The Two Causes Rule — Comparison Table
- Concurrent causes Second cause's legal character Outcome Authority
- Insured peril + uninsured peril Not insured, but not excluded Insurer is liable The Miss Jay Jay [1987]
Insured peril + excepted peril Expressly excluded by the policy Insurer is not liable (exclusion prevails) Wayne Tank [1974]; University of Exeter v Allianz [2023]
- Insured peril + insured peril Both insured Insurer is liable s.55(1) MIA 1906
- Excepted peril + uninsured peril No insured peril at all Insurer is not liable s.55(1) MIA 1906
The whole table can be compressed into a single exam sentence: an insured peril beats an uninsured peril, but an excepted peril beats an insured peril.
Successive Causes and the Intervening Cause
A loss may also have a successive chain of causes, with one event following another over time. If the chain is unbroken and the original insured peril remains the dominant efficient cause throughout, the original insured peril is the proximate cause (as with the fire-collapse scenario in section 7.1). But if a new, independent cause intervenes and becomes the dominant cause of the loss, the chain is broken and the intervening cause becomes the proximate cause.
An intervening cause (sometimes called a novus actus interveniens ) is therefore a fresh event that displaces the earlier cause. Whether an intervening event breaks the chain is a question of fact and common sense — the same dominant-efficient-cause test applied across time.
Example — chain not broken: A fire (insured) damages a wall. The wall is left in a precarious state and collapses a week later in ordinary weather. The collapse is the natural consequence of the fire damage; the chain is not broken, and fire remains the proximate cause.
Example — chain broken: A fire (insured) damages a roof. Before the owner can repair it, an unrelated storm (an uninsured peril under this policy) tears the weakened roof away. If the storm is the dominant cause of the final loss, the storm is the new proximate cause; if storm is uninsured, the claim for the later damage fails. If, however, the fire damage was itself the dominant cause and the storm merely accelerated an inevitable collapse, fire remains the proximate cause and the claim succeeds. The answer turns on which cause was, in fact, dominant and efficient .
No Identifiable Dominant Cause — The Popi M
Where the evidence does not allow the court to identify any single dominant cause, the claim fails. The burden of proof is on the insured, and a court must not invent a cause to fill the gap. This is the rule of Rhesa Shipping Co SA v Edmunds (The Popi M) [1985] 1 WLR 948 : where two possible causes are both consistent with the evidence but neither is proved to be the dominant one, the insured has not discharged the burden and the insurer is not liable.
This applies with equal force to concurrent-cause cases: the insured must prove that an insured peril was, on the balance of probabilities, a proximate cause. Speculation is not enough.
The Loss-of-Life Proviso
Some life and personal accident policies, and certain marine wordings, contain a loss-of-life proviso . The proviso provides that, where loss of life or personal injury is caused by an insured peril, the insurer remains liable even if an excepted peril contributed to the loss. In effect, for death or injury claims the usual Wayne Tank rule (excepted peril overrides insured peril) is modified by the wording : the insured peril still attracts cover.
This is a feature of policy drafting rather than a universal rule of statute, and IF1 candidates should treat it as a wording-driven exception. The nearest statutory analogue is section 55(2)(a) of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 , which provides that even where the wilful misconduct of the assured would otherwise exclude cover, the insurer remains liable for any loss proximately caused by an insured peril even though the loss would not have happened but for the negligence of the master or crew . The same principle — an insured peril prevailing over an excepted peril in defined circumstances — underpins the loss-of-life proviso found in many wordings.
Example: A personal accident policy covers accidental death but excepts war. The insured is killed in a terrorist act during a war. Without a loss-of-life proviso, the war exception would defeat the claim under the Wayne Tank rule. With a loss-of-life proviso, the insured peril (violent accidental injury) prevails and the policy pays, because the proviso is drafted to modify the exclusion for death claims.
Worked Scenario — Concurrent Causes in Practice
A factory is insured under a property policy that covers fire and storm and excepts flood and terrorism . During a single severe weather event, the following occur together:
High winds (storm — insured) tear off part of the roof.
River water (flood — excepted) inundates the ground floor.
A resulting electrical fault causes a fire (insured).
The fire and storm damage is payable to the extent it can be separately identified, because insured perils are proximate causes of those parts of the loss. The flood damage is not payable, because flood is an excepted peril operating concurrently and the Wayne Tank rule bars recovery for that part. Where insured and excepted perils cause indivisible damage together, the excepted peril prevails for the indivisible loss. This fact-sensitive apportionment is typical of concurrent-cause claims handling.
Common Exam Pitfalls
Do not treat an uninsured peril the same as an excepted peril. Uninsured-but-not-excluded leaves cover intact ( The Miss Jay Jay ); excepted overrides cover ( Wayne Tank ).
Do not assume the most recent event is the proximate cause in a successive chain. Ask which cause is dominant and efficient .
Do not assume an intervening event always breaks the chain. It only does so if it is new, independent, and dominant .
Remember the burden of proof : if the insured cannot prove an insured peril was a proximate cause, the claim fails ( The Popi M ).
Remember that a loss-of-life proviso is wording-driven; do not assume it applies to every policy or to non-death claims.
Key Takeaways
Where an insured peril and an uninsured (non-excepted) peril operate concurrently, the insurer is liable — the uninsured peril is legally irrelevant ( The Miss Jay Jay ).
Where an insured peril and an excepted peril operate concurrently, the insurer is not liable — the exclusion prevails ( Wayne Tank ; University of Exeter v Allianz ).
In a successive chain, a new, independent, dominant intervening cause breaks the chain and becomes the new proximate cause.
Where no dominant cause can be proved, the claim fails — the burden of proof is on the insured ( The Popi M ).
A loss-of-life proviso in certain wordings modifies the excepted-peril rule so that, where death is caused by an insured peril, the insurer remains liable even if an excepted peril contributed; section 55(2)(a) MIA 1906 reflects a similar principle for master/crew negligence.