Study guide
6.4 Qualifying Breach, Remedies and the Consumer Duty (CIDRA 2012)
CII IF1 Insurance, Legal and Regulatory Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
About the IF1 Exam How to Use This Guide & Study Strategy
2 Chapter 1: Risk and the Insurance Environment
1.1 The Nature and Features of Risk 1.2 Categories of Risk 1.3 Perils and Hazards 1.4 The Components of Risk: Frequency and Severity 1.5 Pooling and the Features of an Insurable Risk
3 Chapter 2: Risk Management and the UK Insurance Market
2.1 The Risk Management Process 2.2 The Need for and Benefits of Insurance 2.3 Who's Who: The Main Groups in the Insurance Market 2.4 Structure of the UK Insurance Market 2.5 Classes and Distribution of Insurance 2.6 The London Market 2.7 The Purpose of Reinsurance
4 Chapter 3: Insurance Products, Professional Roles and Insurance Premium Tax
3.1 Co-insurance, Dual Insurance and Self-insurance 3.2 Insurance Premium Tax 3.3 Professional Roles and Market Organisations
5 Chapter 4: Contract Law and Agency
4.1 Essential Elements of a Valid Contract 4.2 Formation and Validity of Contracts 4.3 Cancellation and Termination of Contracts 4.4 Principles of Agency 4.5 Authority and Duties of an Agent 4.6 Terms of Business Agreements (TOBAs)
6 Chapter 5: Insurable Interest
5.1 The Nature of Insurable Interest and When It Must Exist 5.2 Application of Insurable Interest Across Classes
7 Chapter 6: Utmost Good Faith and Disclosure
6.1 Utmost Good Faith at Common Law 6.2 The Duty of Fair Presentation — Insurance Act 2015 6.3 Hazards and the Insurer's Right to Information 6.4 Qualifying Breach, Remedies and the Consumer Duty (CIDRA 2012)
8 Chapter 7: Proximate Cause
7.1 The Principle of Proximate Cause 7.2 Concurrent and Successive Causes
9 Chapter 8: Indemnity and its Corollaries
8.1 The Principle of Indemnity and Settlement 8.2 Agreed Value, First Loss and New-for-Old Policies 8.3 The Condition of Average and Excess 8.4 Subrogation 8.5 Contribution
10 Chapter 9: Policy Terms and Documentation
9.1 Warranties, Conditions and Representations 9.2 Policy Documentation and Interpretation
11 Chapter 10: The Regulatory Framework
10.1 The FCA and the PRA 10.2 FSMA 2000 and the Regulatory Perimeter 10.3 Authorisation, Conduct Rulebooks and Solvency 10.4 Reporting, Record Keeping and Training and Competence
12 Chapter 11: Consumer Protection and Conduct
11.1 Treating Customers Fairly and the Consumer Duty 11.2 Conduct of Business, Financial Promotions and Enforcement 11.3 Consumer Rights and CIDRA 2012 11.4 Complaints Handling, DISP and the Financial Ombudsman Service
13 Chapter 12: Compensation, Data Protection and Financial Crime
12.1 The Financial Services Compensation Scheme 12.2 Data Protection — DPA 2018 and UK GDPR 12.3 Financial Crime, Money Laundering and Fraud 12.4 Compulsory Insurance in the UK
14 Chapter 13: Underwriting, Claims and Ethics
13.1 Underwriting Basics 13.2 Claims Handling Basics 13.3 Ethics and the CII Code of Ethics 13.4 Professional Conduct and Discipline
6.4 Qualifying Breach, Remedies and the Consumer Duty (CIDRA 2012)
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Under Insurance Act 2015 section 8 an insurer has a remedy only for a 'qualifying breach', meaning the insurer must show that without the breach it would not have entered the contract at all or would have done so only on different terms
For a non-deliberate or reckless qualifying breach by a commercial insured, Schedule 1 provides proportionate remedies: avoidance with return of premiums if the risk would have been declined, or treating the contract as if made on the terms (including a higher premium) on which the insurer would have taken it
For a deliberate or reckless qualifying breach by a commercial insured, the insurer may avoid the contract, refuse all claims and retain the premiums
The Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 (CIDRA) applies to consumer insureds and imposes only a duty to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation, with no general duty of disclosure
Under CIDRA, remedies for a careless misrepresentation are proportionate (claim reduced or contract treated as if on different terms), while for a deliberate or reckless misrepresentation the insurer may avoid the contract and retain premiums
Last updated: August 2026
Section 8 of the Insurance Act 2015 — The 'Qualifying Breach' Gateway
Under the Insurance Act 2015, a breach of the duty of fair presentation (see section 6.2) does not automatically give the insurer a remedy. Section 8(1) provides that the insurer has a remedy only if it shows that, but for the breach , it would either:
(a) not have entered into the contract at all , or
(b) would have done so only on different terms .
This mirrors the common-law principle of inducement established in Pan Atlantic Insurance Co Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Co Ltd [1995] 1 AC 501. The insurer must prove that the breach actually made a difference to its underwriting decision.
A breach for which the insurer has a remedy is called a 'qualifying breach' (section 8(3)). The insurer bears the burden of showing that the breach was a qualifying breach — that is, that it was induced to act differently.
Deliberate or Reckless vs Other Breaches
Section 8(4) splits qualifying breaches into two categories:
Deliberate or reckless — the insured knew that it was in breach of the duty, or did not care whether it was. The burden is on the insurer to prove that the breach was deliberate or reckless.
Neither deliberate nor reckless — sometimes called an 'innocent' or 'careless' breach. Even a careless breach can give rise to a remedy, provided the inducement test is met.
This two-tier structure is important because the remedy depends on which category the breach falls into.
Schedule 1 — Remedies for Non-Consumer (Commercial) Insurance
The actual remedies are set out in Schedule 1 to the 2015 Act. The table below summarises the position for non-consumer insurance contracts.
Type of qualifying breach What the insurer would have done Remedy under Schedule 1
Deliberate or reckless (any) Insurer may avoid the contract, refuse all claims, and retain the premiums (Sch 1, para 2)
Not deliberate or reckless Would not have entered at all Insurer may avoid and refuse all claims, but must return the premiums (Sch 1, para 4)
Not deliberate or reckless Would have entered on different (non-premium) terms Contract is treated as if entered into on those different terms (Sch 1, para 5)
Not deliberate or reckless Would have charged a higher premium Insurer may reduce the claim proportionately (Sch 1, para 6)
The proportionate reduction under paragraph 6 uses a straightforward formula: the insurer pays only X% of the claim, where X = (premium actually charged ÷ premium that would have been charged) × 100 . For example, if the insurer charged £10,000 but would have charged £15,000 on a fair presentation, the claim can be reduced by one-third — the insurer pays two-thirds. Paragraphs 5 and 6 can both apply, so the contract may be treated as if made on different terms and the claim reduced for a higher premium.
The key reform is the move away from the old 'all-or-nothing' avoidance remedy for non-deliberate breaches. A careless non-disclosure no longer risks the entire policy; the remedy is scaled to what the insurer would have done had the risk been fairly presented.
A Worked Commercial Example
A commercial insured fails to disclose three prior theft claims when presenting a shop policy. The insurer charged a premium of £4,000. On a fair presentation, the insurer says it would still have offered cover but would have charged £8,000 and imposed a £1,000 theft excess. This is a qualifying breach (the insurer would have acted differently), but it is not deliberate or reckless — the insured's risk manager simply failed to collate the claims history.
The remedy under Schedule 1 is a combination : the contract is treated as if it included a £1,000 theft excess (paragraph 5), and the theft claim is reduced proportionately to reflect the premium differential — the insurer pays 50% of the otherwise payable amount (£4,000 ÷ £8,000 × 100) (paragraph 6). The insurer cannot avoid the policy altogether, because it would have offered cover on a fair presentation.
The Consumer Regime — CIDRA 2012
Consumer insureds are governed not by the Insurance Act 2015 but by the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 (CIDRA) , which came into force on 6 April 2013 . The 2015 Act deliberately left the consumer regime untouched, recognising that consumers need a lighter duty than commercial insureds.
The Consumer's Duty — Reasonable Care
Under section 2(2) of CIDRA, a consumer insured owes only one duty before the contract is made (or varied): to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation to the insurer. There is no general duty of disclosure for consumers. A consumer who answers the insurer's questions honestly and carefully has discharged the duty, even if they have not volunteered facts the insurer did not ask about.
The standard of reasonable care is assessed on the 'reasonable consumer' benchmark (section 3), taking into account the clarity and specificity of the insurer's questions, the explanatory material the insurer provided, and any characteristics of the actual consumer the insurer knew or ought to have known. A dishonest misrepresentation is always treated as falling below the reasonable-care standard.
Qualifying Misrepresentation and Remedies
Under section 4 , an insurer has a remedy only if the consumer made a misrepresentation in breach of the section 2(2) duty and the insurer shows that without the misrepresentation it would not have entered into the contract at all, or would have done so only on different terms. This is the consumer equivalent of the 'qualifying breach' gateway in the 2015 Act.
The remedies are set out in Schedule 1 to CIDRA and, like the commercial regime, are proportionate :
Type of misrepresentation Remedy under CIDRA Sch 1
Deliberate or reckless Insurer may avoid the contract, refuse all claims, and retain premiums (subject to a fairness check on retaining premiums)
Careless — insurer would have declined Insurer may avoid and refuse all claims, but must return the premiums
Careless — insurer would have entered on different (non-premium) terms Contract is treated as if made on those different terms
Careless — insurer would have charged a higher premium Claim is reduced proportionately (the insurer pays X% where X = (premium charged ÷ premium that would have been charged) × 100)
The structure closely mirrors the commercial regime, but the starting duty is different: the consumer has no duty to volunteer information, only a duty to answer honestly and carefully.
Contrasting the Two Regimes
The distinction between the commercial and consumer regimes is a favourite exam topic. The table below draws the contrast directly.
- Feature Non-consumer (Insurance Act 2015) Consumer (CIDRA 2012)
- Governing Act Insurance Act 2015, ss.3, 7, 8, Sch 1 CIDRA 2012, ss.2–4, Sch 1
Duty Fair presentation of the risk (disclose material circumstances; clear and accessible; before contract) Take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation
Duty to volunteer Yes — must disclose every material circumstance known or ought to be known No — only must answer the insurer's questions honestly and carefully
Reasonable search Yes, under s.3(4) Not applicable — consumer is not expected to search
Remedies Proportionate under Sch 1; avoid + retain premiums for deliberate or reckless Proportionate under Sch 1; avoid + retain premiums for deliberate or reckless
Inducement / qualifying Insurer must show it would have acted differently (s.8) Insurer must show it would have acted differently (s.4)
Key Takeaways
Under section 8 of the Insurance Act 2015 a commercial insurer has a remedy only for a 'qualifying breach' — one where, but for the breach, it would not have entered the contract or would have done so only on different terms.
For a non-deliberate or reckless commercial breach, Schedule 1 provides proportionate remedies: avoidance with return of premiums if the risk would have been declined, or treating the contract as if made on the terms (including any higher premium) on which the insurer would have taken it.
For a deliberate or reckless commercial breach, the insurer may avoid the contract, refuse all claims and retain the premiums.
CIDRA 2012 governs consumer insureds and imposes only a duty to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation — there is no general duty of disclosure for consumers.
CIDRA remedies are proportionate for careless misrepresentations (claim reduced or contract treated as if on different terms) and allow avoidance with retention of premiums for a deliberate or reckless misrepresentation.