Study guide
9.2 Financial and Non-Financial Performance Measures in Manufacturing and Service Organisations
CIMA BA2: Fundamentals of Management Accounting Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: The Context of Management Accounting
1.1 The Need for Management Accounting, the GMAP Definition & Comparison with Financial Accounting 1.2 Qualities of Good Management Information: From Data to Decisions 1.3 Information for Operational, Managerial and Strategic Levels 1.4 The Role of the Management Accountant: CIMA's View, IFAC's Domain & Position in the Organisation 1.5 CIMA as a Professional Body: Members, Candidates, the Profession & Society
2 Chapter 2: Cost Identification, Classification and Behaviour
2.1 Cost Classification by Nature, Function, and Element 2.2 Cost Behaviour Patterns and Relevant Range 2.3 The High-Low Method and Cost Prediction 2.4 Scattergraph and Least-Squares Regression for Cost Estimation
3 Chapter 3: Overheads and Absorption Costing
3.1 Production Overheads: Allocation and Apportionment 3.2 Overhead Absorption Rates (OAR) & Under/Over-Absorption
4 Chapter 4: Marginal Costing, Profit Reconciliation and Cost-Based Pricing
4.1 Marginal Costing vs Absorption Costing Principles 4.2 Reconciling Marginal and Absorption Costing Operating Profits 4.3 Pricing with Cost Information: Full-Cost-Plus, Marginal-Cost-Plus, Mark-Ups, Margins and Return Targets
5 Chapter 5: Budget Preparation: Functional, Master and Cash Budgets
5.1 Purposes of Budgeting & The Budgeting Process 5.2 The Principal Budget Factor & Functional Budgets 5.3 The Master Budget: Budgeted Profit or Loss, Financial Position and Cash Flow 5.4 Cash Budgets & Cash Flow Forecasting
6 Chapter 6: Budgetary Control: Flexible Budgets, Behaviour and Budgeting Approaches
6.1 Fixed vs Flexible Budgeting and Budget Flexing 6.2 Budgetary Control Systems, Participation & Behavioural Aspects 6.3 Alternative Budgeting Approaches: Incremental, ZBB & Rolling Budgets
7 Chapter 7: Standard Costing and Cost Variances
7.1 Standard Costing Principles and Types of Standards 7.2 Direct Material Price and Usage Variances 7.3 Direct Labour Rate, Efficiency, and Idle Time Variances 7.4 Variable and Fixed Overhead Variances
8 Chapter 8: Sales Variances, Operating Statements and Interpreting Variances
8.1 Sales Variances and Operating Statements (Marginal and Absorption Formats) 8.2 Interpreting Variances: Causes, Interrelationships and Deciding What to Investigate
9 Chapter 9: Performance Measurement
9.1 The Need for Performance Measures: Responsibility Accounting, Controllability and Service Industries 9.2 Financial and Non-Financial Performance Measures in Manufacturing and Service Organisations
10 Chapter 10: Integrated Accounts, Job and Batch Costing and Management Reports
10.1 Integrating Cost and Financial Accounts: Control Accounts and the Manufacturing Account 10.2 Integrated Ledgers with Under- and Over-Absorption and Standard Cost Variances 10.3 Job and Batch Costing: Job Cost Cards, Job Accounts and Pricing a Job 10.4 Cost Reports for Manufacturing, Service and Not-for-Profit Organisations
11 Chapter 11: Risk, Probability and Statistics for Decision-Making
11.1 Risk, Uncertainty and Probability: Rules and Joint Probabilities for Decisions 11.2 Expected Values, Expected Value Tables and Their Limitations 11.3 Averages and Dispersion: Mean, Median, Mode, Range, Variance, Standard Deviation and Coefficient of Variation 11.4 The Normal Distribution: Z-Scores, Normal Distribution Tables and Business Probabilities
12 Chapter 12: Relevant Costing and Short-Term Decisions
12.1 Relevant Cost Concepts: Future, Incremental, and Opportunity Costs 12.2 Relevant Costs of Materials, Labour, and Overheads 12.3 Short-Term Operational Decisions: Make-or-Buy, Shutdowns, Special Orders
13 Chapter 13: Breakeven Analysis and Limiting Factor Analysis
13.1 Single-Product Break-Even Analysis & Margin of Safety 13.2 Target Profit Calculations, Operating Gearing & CVP Assumptions 13.3 Multi-Product CVP Analysis & Break-Even Charts 13.4 Limiting Factor Analysis (Key Factor Analysis)
14 Chapter 14: Long-Term Decisions: Time Value of Money, Payback, NPV and IRR
14.1 Time Value of Money: Compounding, Discounting, Annuities & Perpetuities 14.2 Payback Period Method: Constant and Uneven Cash Flows 14.3 Net Present Value (NPV): Methodology and Decision Rules 14.4 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and Interpolation
9.2 Financial and Non-Financial Performance Measures in Manufacturing and Service Organisations
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Return on investment (ROI) is controllable operating profit divided by capital employed, and equals profit margin multiplied by asset turnover.
ROI can cause dysfunctional decisions when managers reject projects that earn more than the cost of capital but less than the division's current ROI.
Residual income is controllable profit minus a notional interest charge on capital employed, and encourages managers to accept projects earning above the cost of capital.
Financial measures are historical and can encourage short-termism, so they are combined with non-financial indicators such as quality, delivery, customer satisfaction and utilisation.
The balanced scorecard groups measures into financial, customer, internal business process and learning and growth perspectives; BA2 does not require detailed knowledge of it.
Last updated: September 2026
As organizations expand in size and complexity, top executives decentralize decision-making authority to divisional managers. Decentralization improves operational responsiveness, empowers local leaders, and frees senior executives to focus on corporate strategy. However, decentralization requires robust performance measurement systems to ensure that divisional managers act in harmony with corporate goals ( goal congruence ).
1. From Responsibility Centres to Measures
Section 9.1 explained responsibility centres and the controllability principle. This section calculates the measures used to judge them: cost variances for cost centres, sales variances for revenue centres, controllable profit and margins for profit centres, and ROI or residual income for investment centres.
2. Investment Centre Performance: ROI vs. Residual Income (RI)
Because investment centre managers control capital allocation, assessing them solely on operating profit is inadequate. A division generating $1,000,000 profit on $5,000,000 capital is performing far better than a division generating $1,000,000 profit on $20,000,000 capital. Management accounting employs two primary financial metrics to assess investment centres:
Return on Investment (ROI)
Return on Investment (ROI) expresses controllable operating profit as a percentage of divisional capital employed: ROI = Controllable Operating Profit Divisional Capital Employed × 100 % \text{ROI} = \frac{\text{Controllable Operating Profit}}{\text{Divisional Capital Employed}} \times 100\% ROI = Divisional Capital Employed Controllable Operating Profit × 100%
ROI can be decomposed using the DuPont Analysis Framework into two operational drivers: ROI = Operating Profit Margin × Asset Turnover \text{ROI} = \text{Operating Profit Margin} \times \text{Asset Turnover} ROI = Operating Profit Margin × Asset Turnover ROI = ( Controllable Operating Profit Sales Revenue ) × ( Sales Revenue Divisional Capital Employed ) \text{ROI} = \left( \frac{\text{Controllable Operating Profit}}{\text{Sales Revenue}} \right) \times \left( \frac{\text{Sales Revenue}}{\text{Divisional Capital Employed}} \right) ROI = ( Sales Revenue Controllable Operating Profit ) × ( Divisional Capital Employed Sales Revenue )
Advantages: Intuitive percentage format; enables direct performance comparisons between divisions of differing scale; widely understood by capital markets.
Disadvantages: Incentivizes sub-optimization and short-termism, as demonstrated below.
Residual Income (RI)
Residual Income (RI) measures the absolute currency operating profit generated above the required cost of capital charge (imputed interest) on the assets employed: Residual Income (RI) = Controllable Operating Profit − ( Divisional Capital Employed × Cost of Capital ) \text{Residual Income (RI)} = \text{Controllable Operating Profit} - (\text{Divisional Capital Employed} \times \text{Cost of Capital}) Residual Income (RI) = Controllable Operating Profit − ( Divisional Capital Employed × Cost of Capital )
Cost of Capital: The minimum required hurdle rate (e.g., weighted average cost of capital, WACC) set by corporate headquarters.
Advantages: Encourages goal congruence; managers accept any investment that yields a return greater than the cost of capital.
Disadvantages: Expressed in absolute currency amounts rather than a percentage, making direct comparisons between divisions of different sizes difficult.
3. The Dysfunctional Decision-Making Problem: ROI vs. RI
A classic illustration of why the choice of measure matters is how reliance on ROI can induce dysfunctional decision-making (sub-optimisation), whereas residual income encourages goal congruence .
Practical Demonstration Scenario
Nexus Global plc has a corporate cost of capital of 12% . Two decentralized divisions—Division Alpha and Division Beta—face new capital investment opportunities:
Division Alpha Current Position:
- Capital Employed: $1,000,000
- Controllable Operating Profit: $250,000
Current Divisional ROI: $ 250 , 000 $ 1 , 000 , 000 = 25.0 % \frac{\text{\textdollar}250,000}{\text{\textdollar}1,000,000} = \mathbf{25.0\%} $ 1 , 000 , 000 $ 250 , 000 = 25.0%
Current Divisional RI (at 12%): $ 250 , 000 − ( $ 1 , 000 , 000 × 12 % ) = $ 250 , 000 − $ 120 , 000 = $ 130 , 000 \text{\textdollar}250,000 - (\text{\textdollar}1,000,000 \times 12\%) = \text{\textdollar}250,000 - \text{\textdollar}120,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}130,000} $ 250 , 000 − ( $ 1 , 000 , 000 × 12% ) = $ 250 , 000 − $ 120 , 000 = $ 130 , 000
The Proposed Project for Division Alpha:
- Required Initial Investment: $200,000
- Forecast Annual Controllable Profit: $34,000
Project ROI: $ 34 , 000 $ 200 , 000 = 17.0 % \frac{\text{\textdollar}34,000}{\text{\textdollar}200,000} = \mathbf{17.0\%} $ 200 , 000 $ 34 , 000 = 17.0%
Corporate Perspective vs. Divisional Manager Decision
Corporate Headquarters Perspective:
The project earns 17.0% , which exceeds the corporate cost of capital ( 12.0% ).
Undertaking the project creates positive economic value of $ 34 , 000 − ( $ 200 , 000 × 12 % ) = + $ 10 , 000 \text{\textdollar}34,000 - (\text{\textdollar}200,000 \times 12\%) = +\text{\textdollar}10,000 $ 34 , 000 − ( $ 200 , 000 × 12% ) = + $ 10 , 000 per year.
Corporate verdict: ACCEPT the project.
Division Alpha Manager Evaluated on ROI:
New combined Capital Employed: $ 1 , 000 , 000 + $ 200 , 000 = $ 1 , 200 , 000 \text{\textdollar}1,000,000 + \text{\textdollar}200,000 = \text{\textdollar}1,200,000 $ 1 , 000 , 000 + $ 200 , 000 = $ 1 , 200 , 000
New combined Operating Profit: $ 250 , 000 + $ 34 , 000 = $ 284 , 000 \text{\textdollar}250,000 + \text{\textdollar}34,000 = \text{\textdollar}284,000 $ 250 , 000 + $ 34 , 000 = $ 284 , 000
New Combined ROI: $ 284 , 000 $ 1 , 200 , 000 = 23.67 % \frac{\text{\textdollar}284,000}{\text{\textdollar}1,200,000} = \mathbf{23.67\%} $ 1 , 200 , 000 $ 284 , 000 = 23.67%
Because 23.67% is lower than the division's current 25.0% ROI, the manager's reported performance drops!
Manager's Decision under ROI: REJECT the project!
This is classic dysfunctional decision-making : the manager rejects a commercially viable project that would have generated $10,000 net value for shareholders.
Division Alpha Manager Evaluated on Residual Income (RI):
Project Residual Income: $ 34 , 000 − ( $ 200 , 000 × 12 % ) = + $ 10 , 000 \text{\textdollar}34,000 - (\text{\textdollar}200,000 \times 12\%) = +\text{\textdollar}10,000 $ 34 , 000 − ( $ 200 , 000 × 12% ) = + $ 10 , 000
New Divisional RI: $ 130 , 000 + $ 10 , 000 = $ 140 , 000 \text{\textdollar}130,000 + \text{\textdollar}10,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}140,000} $ 130 , 000 + $ 10 , 000 = $ 140 , 000
Because Residual Income increases by $10,000, the manager's performance rating rises.
Manager's Decision under RI: ACCEPT the project!
Residual income encourages goal congruence between divisional management and corporate shareholders.
Asset Valuation Dilemmas in ROI and RI
Both ROI and RI require measuring Capital Employed . The valuation method chosen has significant behavioural consequences:
Net Book Value (NBV): Assets are valued at historical cost less accumulated depreciation. As assets age, NBV declines, causing calculated ROI to rise artificially over time even if physical output declines. This discourages managers from replacing obsolete machinery with modern equipment.
Gross Book Value (GBV): Assets are valued at original cost before depreciation. Prevents artificial ROI inflation but ignores wear and tear.
Replacement Cost: Revalues assets at current market acquisition price. Reflects true economic capital but involves subjective, costly valuations.
4. Limitations of Financial Performance Indicators & Non-Financial KPIs
While ROI and RI provide valuable financial summaries, relying exclusively on financial performance indicators suffers from severe shortcomings:
Historical and Lagging: Financial statements report past results rather than current competitiveness or future capability.
Encourages Managerial Myopia: To meet short-term quarterly profit targets, managers may cut essential discretionary expenditures, such as preventative machine maintenance, research & development (R&D), customer service, and staff training.
Vulnerable to Accounting Manipulation: Operating profit can be distorted through subjective inventory valuations, depreciation policies, and timing of revenue recognition.
Ignores Intangibles: Financial metrics fail to measure customer loyalty, employee morale, brand equity, or product innovation.
To overcome these limitations, modern management accounting pairs financial measures with leading non-financial Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) :
Operational Dimension Leading Non-Financial KPIs
Manufacturing Quality Defect rate (parts per million), scrap percentage, rework cost, warranty return rate.
Customer Service On-Time In-Full (OTIF) delivery %, customer retention rate, Net Promoter Score (NPS), customer acquisition cost.
Process Efficiency Manufacturing cycle time, machine downtime percentage, order-to-delivery lead time.
Human Resources Employee turnover rate, absenteeism rate, training hours per employee, staff satisfaction index.
5. Measures in Service and Not-for-Profit Organisations
Because services are intangible, perishable and variable (Section 9.1), service organisations lean heavily on non-financial and capacity measures:
Organisation Financial measures Non-financial measures
Hotel Revenue per available room; cost per occupied room-night Occupancy %; guest satisfaction scores; repeat bookings
- Airline Revenue and cost per passenger-km Load factor %; on-time departures; lost baggage rate
- Hospital Cost per patient-day; cost per treatment Bed occupancy; waiting times; readmission rates
Accountancy practice Fee income per partner; chargeable hours × rate Utilisation % (chargeable ÷ available hours); client retention
Charity or public service Cost per unit of service against budget Economy, efficiency and effectiveness (value for money) measures
Section 10.4 calculates composite measures such as cost per patient-day and cost per tonne-kilometre.
6. The Kaplan & Norton Balanced Scorecard
Note
The BA2 syllabus notes that detailed knowledge of the balanced scorecard is not required . Know the four perspectives and the idea of balancing financial with non-financial measures; the detail below is for context.
Developed by Robert Kaplan and David Norton, the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is a strategic performance management framework that translates an organization's mission and strategy into a comprehensive set of performance measures.
The Balanced Scorecard provides balance across four critical dimensions:
- Between financial and non-financial metrics
- Between short-term and long-term objectives
- Between lagging indicators (past outcomes) and leading indicators (future drivers)
- Between internal operations and external stakeholders
- The Four Perspectives of the Balanced Scorecard
Financial Perspective:
Core Question: "To succeed financially, how should we appear to our shareholders?"
Typical Metrics: Return on Capital Employed (ROCE), Residual Income (RI), cash flow from operations, operating profit margin, revenue growth from new products.
Customer Perspective:
Core Question: "To achieve our strategic vision, how should we appear to our customers?"
Typical Metrics: Customer satisfaction ratings, customer retention rate, market share percentage, Net Promoter Score (NPS), delivery punctuality.
Internal Business Processes Perspective:
Core Question: "To satisfy our shareholders and customers, what business processes must we excel at?"
Typical Metrics: Manufacturing cycle efficiency, defect rate in production, unit cost reduction, new product development time, inventory turnover.
Learning and Growth Perspective (Organizational Capacity):
Core Question: "To achieve our vision, how will we sustain our ability to change and improve?"
Typical Metrics: Hours of employee training per year, key employee retention rate, implementation of worker process improvement suggestions, IT system capabilities.
Cause-and-Effect Strategy Mapping
A fundamental strength of the Balanced Scorecard is its explicit cause-and-effect hypothesis . A strategy is not a collection of independent goals; it is a chain of logical linkages: Investment in Employee Training (Learning & Growth) ⇓ Fewer Manufacturing Errors & Faster Cycle Times (Internal Processes) ⇓ Higher On-Time Delivery & Customer Satisfaction (Customer) ⇓ Increased Repeat Orders, Operating Profit, and ROI (Financial) \begin{matrix}
- \text{Investment in Employee Training (Learning \& Growth)} \\
- \Downarrow \\
- \text{Fewer Manufacturing Errors \& Faster Cycle Times (Internal Processes)} \\
- \Downarrow \\
- \text{Higher On-Time Delivery \& Customer Satisfaction (Customer)} \\
- \Downarrow \\
- \text{Increased Repeat Orders, Operating Profit, and ROI (Financial)}
\end{matrix} Investment in Employee Training (Learning & Growth) ⇓ Fewer Manufacturing Errors & Faster Cycle Times (Internal Processes) ⇓ Higher On-Time Delivery & Customer Satisfaction (Customer) ⇓ Increased Repeat Orders, Operating Profit, and ROI (Financial)
By monitoring leading non-financial indicators in the lower perspectives, management anticipates and protects future financial performance long before issues materialize in the statutory profit and loss accounts.