Study guide
8.2 Interpreting Variances: Causes, Interrelationships and Deciding What to Investigate
CIMA BA2: Fundamentals of Management Accounting Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: The Context of Management Accounting
1.1 The Need for Management Accounting, the GMAP Definition & Comparison with Financial Accounting 1.2 Qualities of Good Management Information: From Data to Decisions 1.3 Information for Operational, Managerial and Strategic Levels 1.4 The Role of the Management Accountant: CIMA's View, IFAC's Domain & Position in the Organisation 1.5 CIMA as a Professional Body: Members, Candidates, the Profession & Society
2 Chapter 2: Cost Identification, Classification and Behaviour
2.1 Cost Classification by Nature, Function, and Element 2.2 Cost Behaviour Patterns and Relevant Range 2.3 The High-Low Method and Cost Prediction 2.4 Scattergraph and Least-Squares Regression for Cost Estimation
3 Chapter 3: Overheads and Absorption Costing
3.1 Production Overheads: Allocation and Apportionment 3.2 Overhead Absorption Rates (OAR) & Under/Over-Absorption
4 Chapter 4: Marginal Costing, Profit Reconciliation and Cost-Based Pricing
4.1 Marginal Costing vs Absorption Costing Principles 4.2 Reconciling Marginal and Absorption Costing Operating Profits 4.3 Pricing with Cost Information: Full-Cost-Plus, Marginal-Cost-Plus, Mark-Ups, Margins and Return Targets
5 Chapter 5: Budget Preparation: Functional, Master and Cash Budgets
5.1 Purposes of Budgeting & The Budgeting Process 5.2 The Principal Budget Factor & Functional Budgets 5.3 The Master Budget: Budgeted Profit or Loss, Financial Position and Cash Flow 5.4 Cash Budgets & Cash Flow Forecasting
6 Chapter 6: Budgetary Control: Flexible Budgets, Behaviour and Budgeting Approaches
6.1 Fixed vs Flexible Budgeting and Budget Flexing 6.2 Budgetary Control Systems, Participation & Behavioural Aspects 6.3 Alternative Budgeting Approaches: Incremental, ZBB & Rolling Budgets
7 Chapter 7: Standard Costing and Cost Variances
7.1 Standard Costing Principles and Types of Standards 7.2 Direct Material Price and Usage Variances 7.3 Direct Labour Rate, Efficiency, and Idle Time Variances 7.4 Variable and Fixed Overhead Variances
8 Chapter 8: Sales Variances, Operating Statements and Interpreting Variances
8.1 Sales Variances and Operating Statements (Marginal and Absorption Formats) 8.2 Interpreting Variances: Causes, Interrelationships and Deciding What to Investigate
9 Chapter 9: Performance Measurement
9.1 The Need for Performance Measures: Responsibility Accounting, Controllability and Service Industries 9.2 Financial and Non-Financial Performance Measures in Manufacturing and Service Organisations
10 Chapter 10: Integrated Accounts, Job and Batch Costing and Management Reports
10.1 Integrating Cost and Financial Accounts: Control Accounts and the Manufacturing Account 10.2 Integrated Ledgers with Under- and Over-Absorption and Standard Cost Variances 10.3 Job and Batch Costing: Job Cost Cards, Job Accounts and Pricing a Job 10.4 Cost Reports for Manufacturing, Service and Not-for-Profit Organisations
11 Chapter 11: Risk, Probability and Statistics for Decision-Making
11.1 Risk, Uncertainty and Probability: Rules and Joint Probabilities for Decisions 11.2 Expected Values, Expected Value Tables and Their Limitations 11.3 Averages and Dispersion: Mean, Median, Mode, Range, Variance, Standard Deviation and Coefficient of Variation 11.4 The Normal Distribution: Z-Scores, Normal Distribution Tables and Business Probabilities
12 Chapter 12: Relevant Costing and Short-Term Decisions
12.1 Relevant Cost Concepts: Future, Incremental, and Opportunity Costs 12.2 Relevant Costs of Materials, Labour, and Overheads 12.3 Short-Term Operational Decisions: Make-or-Buy, Shutdowns, Special Orders
13 Chapter 13: Breakeven Analysis and Limiting Factor Analysis
13.1 Single-Product Break-Even Analysis & Margin of Safety 13.2 Target Profit Calculations, Operating Gearing & CVP Assumptions 13.3 Multi-Product CVP Analysis & Break-Even Charts 13.4 Limiting Factor Analysis (Key Factor Analysis)
14 Chapter 14: Long-Term Decisions: Time Value of Money, Payback, NPV and IRR
14.1 Time Value of Money: Compounding, Discounting, Annuities & Perpetuities 14.2 Payback Period Method: Constant and Uneven Cash Flows 14.3 Net Present Value (NPV): Methodology and Decision Rules 14.4 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and Interpolation
8.2 Interpreting Variances: Causes, Interrelationships and Deciding What to Investigate
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Variances can be caused by operational performance, by poorly set or out-of-date standards, or by measurement errors, so an adverse variance does not automatically mean poor management.
Buying cheaper, lower-quality material can give a favourable price variance but adverse material usage and labour efficiency variances.
Using more highly skilled labour typically gives an adverse labour rate variance with favourable labour efficiency and material usage variances.
Cutting the selling price gives an adverse sales price variance but may create a favourable sales volume variance if demand responds.
Whether to investigate depends on the size of the variance, its trend, whether it is controllable, and whether the benefit of correcting it exceeds the cost of investigation.
Last updated: September 2026
Why this topic is examined
Syllabus area C2(d) asks you to explain why variances could have arisen and the inter-relationships between variances . Questions present a scenario (for example, "the purchasing manager switched to a cheaper supplier") and ask which combination of variances is most likely, or give a set of variances and ask for the most plausible explanation. You will not be asked to calculate here, but you must connect causes to the variances calculated in Sections 7.2 to 8.1.
Three sources of variances
Before blaming a manager, ask which kind of cause is behind a variance:
Source Explanation Example
Operational Actual performance genuinely differed from what was achievable Careless handling increased material wastage
Planning (standard setting) The standard itself was unrealistic or has become out of date The standard material price was set before a general price rise
Measurement or recording error The figures are wrong Material issued to one job was coded to another
Only operational variances say something about how well managers performed. A variance caused by an out-of-date standard should lead to revising the standard , not to criticising the manager.
Typical causes of each variance
Variance Possible favourable causes Possible adverse causes
Material price Bulk discounts; cheaper supplier; lower-quality material; falling market prices Price rises; higher-quality material; urgent purchases at premium prices; loss of discounts
Material usage Higher-quality material; more skilled workers; better machinery Lower-quality material; wastage, theft or spoilage; inexperienced workers; poor machine maintenance
Labour rate Using lower-grade (cheaper) staff; less overtime than planned Pay rise not in the standard; overtime or shift premiums; using higher-grade staff
Labour idle time Always adverse Machine breakdowns; material shortages; poor scheduling; power cuts
Labour efficiency Skilled, motivated staff; better methods or equipment; good-quality material Inexperienced or poorly supervised staff; poor-quality material; machine problems
Variable overhead expenditure Lower prices for power or consumables Higher tariffs or consumable prices
Variable overhead efficiency Same causes as favourable labour (or machine) efficiency Same causes as adverse labour (or machine) efficiency
Fixed overhead expenditure Savings on rent, insurance or salaries Unexpected rises in rent, insurance or supervisory costs
Sales price Stronger demand; less discounting; price rise Price cuts; discounts; competitor pressure
Sales volume Successful marketing; lower prices; competitor problems Price rises; weak demand; production shortages; new competitors
Note
When variable overhead is absorbed on labour hours, the variable overhead efficiency variance has the same cause as the labour efficiency variance, because both measure the same difference between standard and actual hours.
Interrelationships: one decision, several variances
Variances are rarely independent. A decision that improves one variance often worsens another.
Decision or event Favourable variance Adverse variances likely
Buying cheaper, lower-quality material Material price Material usage (more waste); labour efficiency (more rework); possibly variable overhead efficiency
- Buying higher-quality material Material usage; labour efficiency Material price
- Using more skilled, higher-paid workers Labour efficiency; material usage Labour rate
- Using trainees or lower-grade staff Labour rate Labour efficiency; material usage
- Cutting the selling price Sales volume (if demand responds) Sales price
- Working overtime to meet demand Sales volume Labour rate (overtime premium)
- A major machine breakdown None Idle time; labour efficiency; possibly sales volume if orders are lost
The practical lesson is that responsibility must be assessed across the business . A purchasing manager who earns a favourable price variance by buying poor material may have caused a larger adverse usage variance in production. Rewarding the purchasing manager and blaming the production manager would be unfair and would encourage the wrong behaviour.
Worked interpretation
In Section 8.1, Apex Precision Systems reported these variances for May:
- Variance $
- Sales price 19,000 F
- Sales volume (at standard contribution) 9,500 A
- Material usage 2,500 F
- Labour rate 5,000 A
- Labour efficiency 3,000 F
- Variable overhead efficiency 1,000 F
- Fixed overhead expenditure 4,000 A
A coherent explanation:
Sales: Apex raised its average price from $50 to $52. The price rise earned a $19,000 favourable price variance but probably reduced demand, causing 500 fewer sales than budgeted and a $9,500 adverse volume variance. Overall, the price decision added $9,500 net.
Labour and materials: The adverse labour rate variance alongside favourable labour efficiency and material usage variances suggests more experienced, higher-paid staff were used. They worked faster (500 hours saved) and wasted less material. The favourable variable overhead efficiency variance follows directly from the hours saved. Together these three favourable variances ($6,500) exceed the adverse rate variance ($5,000).
Fixed overhead: The $4,000 adverse expenditure variance is unrelated to volume in a marginal costing system; it needs a separate explanation, such as an unbudgeted rent or insurance increase.
Deciding whether to investigate
Investigating every variance would be expensive. Management by exception focuses attention on the variances that matter. Factors to consider:
Factor Question to ask
Materiality (size) Is the variance large in absolute terms, or as a percentage of the standard cost? Many organisations set a threshold such as a fixed percentage of standard.
Trend Is a small variance growing month after month? A persistent trend may matter more than a one-off large variance.
Controllability Can a manager act on it? An adverse price variance caused by a global commodity price rise may not be controllable.
Cost versus benefit Will the savings from correcting the problem exceed the cost of investigating it?
Type of standard With an ideal standard, adverse variances are expected and less significant; with an attainable standard, they are more worrying.
Interdependence Is the variance a side effect of a decision that produced a larger favourable variance elsewhere?
Favourable variances too A large favourable variance may reveal an out-of-date standard or cut corners (for example, skipped maintenance) and deserves attention as well.
Tip
In scenario questions, look for the root cause first, then list every variance that cause would affect. Answer options that include only one variance for a decision that obviously affects several areas are usually incomplete.