Study guide
9.4 Native Nations, The West & Federal Indian Policy (1861–1877)
CLEP History of the United States I Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Early America & Colonial Beginnings (1500–1754)
1.1 Indigenous Societies & European Contact (1500–1607) 1.2 Chesapeake & Southern Colonies (1607–1750) 1.3 New England & Middle Colonies (1620–1750) 1.4 Colonial Society, Immigration & Family Life (1607–1763) 1.5 The Origins of Slavery in British North America & Early Resistance (1619–1750) 1.6 Colonial Economy, Mercantilism & Transatlantic Trade
2 Chapter 2: The Revolutionary Era & New Nation (1754–1789)
2.1 The French and Indian War & Imperial Crisis (1754–1775) 2.2 The American Revolution & Independence (1775–1783) 2.3 The Revolution's Social Consequences: Slavery, Women, Loyalists & Native Nations (1775–1790) 2.4 The Articles of Confederation & Critical Period (1781–1787) 2.5 Creating the U.S. Constitution & Bill of Rights (1787–1789)
3 Chapter 3: The Early Republic & Federalist Era (1789–1815)
3.1 Establishing the Federal Government & Federalist vs. Republican Rivalry (1789–1800) 3.2 Republican Ascendancy & Jeffersonian Democracy (1800–1812) 3.3 The Marshall Court & Constitutional Interpretation (1801–1835) 3.4 Foreign Affairs, Expansion & The War of 1812 (1793–1815) 3.5 Early Cultural, Educational & Religious Identity (1790–1815)
4 Chapter 4: Nationalism, Sectionalism & The Era of Good Feelings (1815–1828)
4.1 The Era of Good Feelings & Postwar Nationalism (1815–1824) 4.2 The Panic of 1819 & The Missouri Compromise (1819–1821) 4.3 The Monroe Doctrine & Postwar Diplomacy (1815–1826)
5 Chapter 5: The Market Revolution & Antebellum Society (1815–1860)
5.1 The Market Revolution, Industrialization & Infrastructure (1815–1850) 5.2 Northern Free Labor, Wage Work & Class Formation (1820–1860) 5.3 Southern Society, Plantation Slavery & The Internal Slave Trade (1815–1860) 5.4 Immigration, Nativism & The Antebellum City (1830–1860) 5.5 Land, Resources & The Environment in American Development (1600–1877) 5.6 Social Reform, Abolitionism & Women's Rights (1820–1860) 5.7 Religion in American Society: Disestablishment, Diversity & Schism (1776–1877) 5.8 Antebellum Culture, Religion & Transcendentalism (1820–1860) 5.9 Popular Culture, The Penny Press & Mass Entertainment (1830–1860)
6 Chapter 6: Jacksonian Democracy & Sectional Politics (1824–1848)
6.1 The Rise of Mass Democracy & Jacksonian Politics (1824–1840) 6.2 Banking, Tariffs & The Nullification Crisis (1828–1837) 6.3 Indian Removal & Western Expansion (1830–1848) 6.4 The Second Party System: Democrats vs. Whigs (1834–1852)
7 Chapter 7: Westward Expansion, Manifest Destiny & Sectional Crisis (1830–1855)
7.1 Manifest Destiny & Texas Annexation (1830–1846) 7.2 The Mexican-American War & Territorial Acquisitions (1846–1848) 7.3 California Gold Rush, Western Migration & Border Diplomacy (1848–1855) 7.4 Sectional Crisis & The Compromise of 1850
8 Chapter 8: The Crisis of the Union & The Civil War (1850–1865)
8.1 Sectional Escalation: Kansas-Nebraska Act to Dred Scott (1854–1857) 8.2 The Rise of the Republican Party & Election of 1860 (1854–1860) 8.3 Secession, Military Campaigns & Civil War Strategy (1861–1865) 8.4 Home Fronts, Emancipation Proclamation & Wartime Politics (1861–1865) 8.5 War Economies: Union Finance & Confederate Collapse (1861–1865) 8.6 Civil War Diplomacy & Foreign Relations (1861–1877)
9 Chapter 9: Reconstruction & The Post-War Settlement (1865–1877)
9.1 Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction (1865–1868) 9.2 Reconstruction Amendments (13th, 14th, 15th) & Black Codes (1865–1870) 9.3 Southern Reconstruction, African American Political Life & Backlash (1867–1876) 9.4 Native Nations, The West & Federal Indian Policy (1861–1877) 9.5 The Grant Administration, Corruption & The Retreat from Reconstruction (1869–1876) 9.6 The Compromise of 1877 & Legacy of Reconstruction
9.4 Native Nations, The West & Federal Indian Policy (1861–1877)
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The Dakota War of 1862 in Minnesota ended with the hanging of 38 Dakota men at Mankato on December 26, 1862 — the largest mass execution in United States history.
At Sand Creek on November 29, 1864, Colorado militia under Colonel John Chivington killed roughly 150 to 200 Cheyenne and Arapaho, mostly women and children, in a camp flying an American flag.
The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 ended Red Cloud's War, closed the Bozeman Trail, and guaranteed the Great Sioux Reservation including the Black Hills 'in perpetuity.'
Grant's Peace Policy of 1869 placed reservation agencies under church nominees and created the Board of Indian Commissioners, aiming at assimilation rather than extermination.
Congress ended treaty-making with Native nations in 1871, redefining them as wards of the federal government rather than parties to negotiated agreements.
Last updated: August 2026
A Blind Spot Worth Closing
The CLEP blueprint names "the causes and consequences of conflicts with Native Americans" alongside the Seven Years' War, the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War, and the Civil War and Reconstruction — and the exam's period runs through 1877 . Most study plans stop Native history at the Trail of Tears. That leaves out fifteen years of continuous warfare that occurred simultaneously with the Civil War and Reconstruction, which is exactly the kind of chronological overlap examiners like to test.
Why the West Erupted During the Civil War
Three pressures converged in 1861:
Regular troops were withdrawn from western posts for the war, replaced by volunteer militia — locally raised, less disciplined, and often openly hostile to Native people.
Wartime legislation accelerated settlement. The Homestead Act and Pacific Railway Act of 1862 pushed migration and railroad survey directly across hunting territory.
Mineral rushes drew sudden populations into Colorado (1858), Nevada (1859), Idaho (1860), and Montana (1862), each creating instant demands for roads and protection.
The Wars
Conflict Dates Key events
Bear River Massacre Jan 1863 California volunteers under Patrick Connor killed roughly 250–400 Shoshone in Idaho Territory — probably the deadliest single attack on Native people in the West
Dakota (Sioux) War Aug–Sep 1862 Starving Dakota in Minnesota rose after annuity payments were withheld and traders refused credit; roughly 500 settlers and many Dakota died. Lincoln reviewed 303 death sentences and commuted all but 39; 38 were hanged at Mankato on December 26, 1862 , the largest mass execution in U.S. history
Navajo Long Walk 1864 Kit Carson's scorched-earth campaign forced roughly 8,000–9,000 Navajo to march some 300 miles to Bosque Redondo , where perhaps a quarter died before the 1868 treaty let survivors return
Sand Creek Massacre Nov 29, 1864 Colonel John Chivington's Colorado militia attacked Black Kettle's camp on the Big Sandy — flying both an American flag and a white flag under army assurance of safety — killing roughly 150–200 Cheyenne and Arapaho, mostly women and children, and mutilating the dead. A congressional investigation condemned it; no one was punished
Red Cloud's War 1866–68 Oglala Lakota under Red Cloud closed the Bozeman Trail to the Montana goldfields; the Fetterman Fight (Dec 1866) destroyed a command of 81 soldiers. Ended by treaty on Native terms — the only such outcome in the era
Washita Nov 1868 Custer's 7th Cavalry attacked Black Kettle's Cheyenne camp on the Washita River; Black Kettle, a consistent peace advocate, was killed
Modoc War 1872–73 Modoc under Captain Jack held the California lava beds against far larger forces for months
Red River War 1874–75 Campaign against Comanche, Kiowa, and southern Cheyenne on the southern Plains, ending organized resistance there
Great Sioux War 1876–77 Triggered by the Black Hills gold rush; Little Bighorn (June 25–26, 1876) destroyed Custer's immediate command, after which the army pursued Lakota and Cheyenne bands until surrender
The Treaty System and Its End
Two major treaty councils tried to confine Plains nations to defined reservations:
Medicine Lodge Treaty (1867) assigned Kiowa, Comanche, Cheyenne, and Arapaho to reservations in Indian Territory in exchange for annuities, housing, and schools. Congress underfunded the promises almost immediately.
Fort Laramie Treaty (1868) ended Red Cloud's War: the army abandoned its Bozeman Trail forts, and the United States guaranteed the Great Sioux Reservation , including the Black Hills , as Lakota territory in perpetuity, with additional unceded hunting grounds.
The Fort Laramie guarantee is the one to remember, because of what happened next. Custer's 1874 expedition confirmed gold in the Black Hills , miners poured in, the government offered to buy and was refused, and Congress simply took the Hills by the Act of February 1877 — a taking for which the Supreme Court awarded the Lakota compensation over a century later in United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians (1980).
In 1871 , Congress attached a rider to an appropriations bill ending the practice of making treaties with Native nations. Existing treaties remained in force, but future relations would be governed by statute and executive agreement. The change was more than procedural: it redefined Native nations from sovereigns capable of negotiation into wards of the federal government , a status foreshadowed by Marshall's "domestic dependent nations" language in 1831.
Grant's Peace Policy (1869)
Sand Creek and the Fetterman Fight produced a reform reaction. President Grant's Peace Policy aimed to end corruption in the Indian Office and to substitute assimilation for war:
Reservation agencies were assigned to Christian denominations , which nominated agents — Quakers received several of the first appointments.
A Board of Indian Commissioners of unpaid philanthropists was created in 1869 to oversee spending.
Ely S. Parker , a Seneca and Grant's wartime military secretary, became the first Native Commissioner of Indian Affairs.
Native people who accepted reservation life were to receive rations, agricultural instruction, and schooling; those who refused would be treated as hostile and pursued by the army.
Judge the policy honestly, as the exam expects. It was a genuine alternative to extermination, and its authors believed themselves humane. It was also coercive assimilation : it required abandoning mobility, hunting, communal landholding, language, and religion, and it made rations a lever of control. Corruption persisted despite the reforms, and the "peace or war" structure meant the army remained the enforcement arm throughout.
The Bison
The most consequential change was ecological rather than military. A bison population estimated in the tens of millions in 1800 fell to a few hundred wild animals by the mid-1880s. The causes compounded:
Commercial hide hunting exploded after 1870, when a tanning process made bison hides usable for industrial leather belting.
Railroads carried hunters in and hides out, and split the herd into northern and southern populations.
Drought, competition from horses and cattle, and bovine disease stressed the herds independently.
Military policy encouraged it. General Sheridan and others understood that destroying the bison destroyed the material basis of Plains independence more surely than any campaign could.
Without the bison, the Plains nations had no alternative to the reservation and the ration line. The exam's likeliest framing is causal: subsistence collapse, not battlefield defeat, ended Plains resistance.
Reconstruction and the West Together
Hold the two stories in one frame. In the same decade that the Fourteenth Amendment defined national citizenship for people born in the United States, it expressly excluded "Indians not taxed." The Republican Party that guaranteed Black male suffrage in 1870 also funded the campaigns that dispossessed Native nations. The federal government's willingness to use force in the South declined through the 1870s exactly as its willingness to use force in the West increased — and the same troop shortages that ended Reconstruction reflected an army increasingly committed to the Plains.