Study guide

Relevant Costing and Decision Making

CMA Part 1 Certified Management Accountant

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction

About the CMA Part 1 Exam Exam Structure and Content Breakdown Pass Rates and Scoring How to Use This Study Guide

2 1. External Financial Reporting Decisions

1.A Financial Statement Preparation 1.B Revenue Recognition 1.C Lease Accounting 1.D Inventory and Fixed Assets 1.E Financial Statement Analysis

3 Planning, Budgeting, and Forecasting

Strategic Planning Process Budgeting Methodologies Sales and Production Budgets Financial Budgets Forecasting Techniques

4 Performance Management

Variance Analysis Fundamentals Manufacturing Variances Responsibility Accounting Transfer Pricing Performance Measurement Systems

5 Cost Management

Cost Concepts and Classifications Job-Order and Process Costing Activity-Based Costing Cost-Volume-Profit Analysis Relevant Costing and Decision Making

6 Internal Controls

Internal Control Frameworks Enterprise Risk Management Internal Audit Function Governance and Compliance Fraud Prevention and Detection

7 Technology and Analytics

Data Governance and Management Business Intelligence and Dashboards Predictive Analytics and Modeling Data Visualization Best Practices Emerging Technologies in Finance

Relevant Costing and Decision Making

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Relevant costs differ between alternatives AND occur in the future; sunk costs are never relevant.

Make-or-buy decisions compare avoidable costs of making with the purchase price plus opportunity costs.

Special orders should be accepted if incremental revenue exceeds incremental costs (and capacity exists).

Constrained resource decisions should maximize contribution margin per unit of the constraint.

Segment elimination decisions should consider the avoidable fixed costs and lost contribution margin.

Last updated: January 2026

Quick Answer: Relevant costs are future costs that differ between alternatives. Sunk costs are never relevant. For make-or-buy, compare avoidable internal costs to external price plus opportunity costs. Accept special orders when incremental revenue exceeds incremental cost. Maximize contribution margin per constraint unit for product mix decisions.

Effective decision-making requires identifying which costs are relevant to a specific decision. Irrelevant costs can lead to poor choices.

  • Relevant vs. Irrelevant Costs
  • Relevant Costs

A cost is relevant if it meets BOTH criteria:

  • Criteria Explanation
  • Future cost Will be incurred in the future
  • Differs between alternatives Amount differs depending on the choice
  • Irrelevant Costs
  • Cost Type Definition Why Irrelevant
  • Sunk costs Past costs already incurred Cannot be changed
  • Committed costs Future costs that cannot be avoided Same regardless of decision
  • Allocated fixed costs Don't change with decision Won't differ between options
  • Examples of Relevance
  • Cost Relevant? Reasoning
  • Future variable costs Usually Yes Differ with volume/choice
  • Future avoidable fixed costs Yes Can be eliminated
  • Sunk costs (book value of old asset) No Already spent
  • Depreciation on existing equipment No Sunk cost
  • Opportunity costs Yes Represent foregone benefits
  • Opportunity Costs

Opportunity cost is the benefit foregone by choosing one alternative over another. Opportunity Cost = Value of the Next Best Alternative

Example: Using factory space for Product A means giving up the $50,000 contribution margin from Product B. The $50,000 is an opportunity cost of producing A.

Key Point: Opportunity costs are never recorded in accounting systems but are always relevant to decisions.

Make-or-Buy Decisions

Should the company make a component internally or buy it from an outside supplier?

Relevant Costs for Make-or-Buy

  • Make Buy
  • Avoidable direct materials Purchase price
  • Avoidable direct labor + Additional costs
  • Avoidable variable overhead - Cost savings
  • Avoidable fixed costs
  • + Opportunity costs
  • Make-or-Buy Example

Current Cost to Make (10,000 units):

  • Cost Per Unit Total
  • Direct Materials $6.00 $60,000
  • Direct Labor $4.00 $40,000
  • Variable Overhead $3.00 $30,000
  • Fixed Overhead (allocated) $5.00 $50,000
  • Total Cost $18.00 $180,000
  • Outside Supplier Quote: $15.00 per unit

Analysis:

  • Factor Make Buy
  • Direct Materials $60,000 $0
  • Direct Labor $40,000 $0
  • Variable Overhead $30,000 $0
  • Purchase Price $0 $150,000
  • Total Relevant Costs $130,000 $150,000

Decision: Continue to make—saves $20,000.

Note: The $50,000 allocated fixed overhead is NOT relevant because it will continue regardless of the decision.

Make-or-Buy with Opportunity Cost

If the freed capacity can generate $25,000 contribution margin:

  • Factor Make Buy
  • Relevant Production Costs $130,000 $0
  • Purchase Price $0 $150,000
  • Opportunity Cost $25,000 $0
  • Total $155,000 $150,000

Decision: Buy from supplier—saves $5,000.

Special Order Decisions

Should the company accept a one-time order at a price below normal selling price?

  • Decision Rule
  • Accept if: Incremental Revenue > Incremental Costs
  • Special Order Considerations
  • Accept If Reject If
  • Price > Incremental costs Price < Incremental costs
  • Excess capacity exists Would displace regular sales
  • Won't affect regular pricing Could damage brand/pricing
  • Covers all variable costs Capacity constraints exist
  • Special Order Example

Normal Operations:

  • Selling price: $100 per unit
  • Variable cost: $60 per unit
  • Fixed costs: $200,000 (at 10,000 unit capacity)
  • Current production: 7,000 units
  • Special Order: 2,000 units at $75 each
  • Analysis Amount
  • Special order revenue 2,000 × $75 = $150,000
  • Incremental variable costs 2,000 × $60 = $120,000
  • Incremental profit $30,000

Decision: Accept—adds $30,000 to profit.

Important: Fixed costs are not relevant if they don't change. The $75 price exceeds the $60 variable cost, so the order contributes to fixed costs and profit.

Product Mix with Constraints

When resources are limited (labor hours, machine time, materials), maximize contribution margin per unit of the constrained resource .

Decision Rule CM per Constraint Unit = CM per Product ÷ Constraint Used per Product

Prioritize products with the highest CM per constraint unit.

  • Constrained Resource Example
  • Machine capacity: 10,000 hours
  • Product CM/Unit Machine Hrs/Unit CM per Machine Hour
  • A $30 2 hours $30 ÷ 2 = $15
  • B $50 5 hours $50 ÷ 5 = $10
  • C $24 1.5 hours $24 ÷ 1.5 = $16
  • Optimal Production Order: C, then A, then B
  • If demand is: A = 3,000 units; B = 2,000 units; C = 4,000 units
  • Product Priority Units Hours Used Cumulative Hours
  • C 1st 4,000 6,000 6,000
  • A 2nd 2,000 4,000 10,000
  • B 3rd 0 0 10,000

Product A is partially produced (2,000 of 3,000 demanded); Product B is not produced.

Segment Elimination Decisions

Should a product line, department, or division be eliminated?

Decision Framework

  • Keep If Eliminate If
  • CM > Avoidable Fixed Costs CM < Avoidable Fixed Costs
  • Segment covers its direct costs Segment doesn't cover direct costs
  • Strategic value exists No strategic benefit
  • Segment Elimination Example
  • Item Product Line X
  • Sales $500,000
  • Variable Costs $350,000
  • Contribution Margin $150,000
  • Avoidable Fixed Costs $100,000
  • Allocated Fixed Costs $80,000
  • Operating Income (Loss) ($30,000)

Analysis:

  • Factor Amount
  • Lost Contribution Margin $150,000
  • Avoided Fixed Costs $100,000
  • Net Impact of Eliminating ($50,000) loss

Decision: Keep Product Line X—eliminating it reduces total company profit by $50,000.

Key Insight: The $80,000 allocated fixed costs will continue regardless of the decision, so they are irrelevant. The $150,000 CM exceeds the $100,000 avoidable fixed costs.

Sell or Process Further

Should a product be sold at split-off or processed further?

Decision Rule

Process further if: Incremental Revenue > Incremental Costs Incremental Revenue = Final Sales Value - Sales Value at Split-off

  • Incremental Costs = Further Processing Costs
  • Sell or Process Example
  • Option Sales Value Processing Cost
  • Sell at split-off $80,000 $0
  • Process further $120,000 $25,000
  • Analysis: Incremental Revenue = \$120,000 - \$80,000 = \$40,000
  • Incremental Cost = \$25,000
  • Incremental Profit = \$40,000 - \$25,000 = \$15,000

Decision: Process further—adds $15,000 to profit.

Note: Joint costs (costs incurred before split-off) are sunk costs and irrelevant to this decision.

Summary: Relevant Cost Decision Framework

  • Decision Type Key Relevant Costs
  • Make or Buy Avoidable costs vs. purchase price + opportunity costs
  • Special Order Incremental revenues vs. incremental costs
  • Product Mix CM per unit of constraint
  • Segment Elimination Lost CM vs. avoidable fixed costs
  • Sell or Process Further Incremental revenue vs. incremental processing costs