Study guide

8.2 Peer Review, Rebuttals, Revisions, and Appeals

Certified Medical Publication Professional CMPP

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & Preparation Strategy

1.1 ISMPP CMPP Certification Overview, Eligibility & Exam Format 1.2 Recertification, Continuing Education (CE) Credits & ISMPP U 1.3 Core Reference Hierarchy, Primary Documents & Test-Taking Strategy

2 Chapter 2: Publication Planning: Strategy, Environment & Scientific Platform

2.1 Medical Publication Lifecycle & Strategic Planning Frameworks 2.2 Therapeutic Landscape Analysis, Unmet Needs & Gap Analysis 2.3 Scientific Communication Platforms and Evidence-Based Language

3 Chapter 3: Publication Planning: Governance, Steering Committees & Venue Selection

3.1 Publication Steering Committees: Charters, Roles & Scientific Governance 3.2 Target Audience Identification: HCPs, Patients, Payers & Regulators 3.3 Venue Selection, Open Access, and Congress Strategy

4 Chapter 4: Publication Planning: Operations, Contracting, Global Alignment & Compliance

4.1 Publication Agreements, Review Rights, Compensation & Disclosure 4.2 Milestones, Gantt Charts, Budgeting & Vendor/Agency Management 4.3 Global vs. Regional/Local Publication Alignment & Localization 4.4 Publication SOPs, Documentation, Quality Control & Audit Readiness

5 Chapter 5: Reporting Guidelines: Foundational Standards & Trial Reporting

5.1 EQUATOR and Design-Specific Reporting Guidelines 5.2 CONSORT 2025 & Flow Diagrams for Randomized Trials 5.3 SPIRIT 2025: Standard Protocol Items for Interventional Trials

6 Chapter 6: Reporting Guidelines: Observational, Reviews & Preclinical

6.1 PRISMA 2020 for Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses 6.2 STROBE & RECORD for Observational and Routinely Collected Data 6.3 ARRIVE 2.0 for In Vivo Animal Research

7 Chapter 7: Specialized Reporting, Plain Language Summaries & Congress Submissions

7.1 STARD 2015, CARE, and Specialized Reporting Guidelines 7.2 Plain-Language Summaries and Patient Partnership 7.3 GPCAP 2026: Congress Abstracts, Presentations & Encores 7.4 Digital Publication Features, Accessibility, and Social Dissemination

8 Chapter 8: Manuscript Lifecycle: Drafting, Peer Review, Open Access & Metrics

8.1 Manuscript Development, Author Review, and Sponsor Boundaries 8.2 Peer Review, Rebuttals, Revisions, and Appeals 8.3 Preprints, Creative Commons & Current Open-Access Requirements 8.4 Post-Publication Metrics and Correcting the Record

9 Chapter 9: Ethical Principles: GPP 2022, Authorship Criteria & Contributorship

9.1 Good Publication Practice 2022: Principles, Scope & Application 9.2 ICMJE Authorship Criteria and Qualification Scenarios 9.3 Nonauthor Contributors, Acknowledgments, and CRediT

10 Chapter 10: Ethics & Transparency: Ghostwriting, Writing Assistance, COI & Disclosure

10.1 Ghostwriting, Guest Authorship, and Authorship Disputes 10.2 Professional Medical Writing: Roles, Authorship, Disclosure & Funding 10.3 Disclosure of Interests and Publication Transparency 10.4 Open Payments, EFPIA Codes & Publication-Related Transfers of Value

11 Chapter 11: Compliance & Legal: Clinical Trial Registration, Data Sharing, Regulatory & Ethics

11.1 Trial Registration and Results Disclosure: US, EU, and ICMJE 11.2 Clinical-Trial Data-Sharing Statements and FAIR Principles 11.3 FDA SIUU Guidance & Promotional/Scientific Communication Boundaries 11.4 2024 Declaration of Helsinki, Ethics Review, Privacy & Copyright

8.2 Peer Review, Rebuttals, Revisions, and Appeals

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

A point-by-point response should reproduce or identify each comment, state the action taken, cite revised locations, and explain respectfully when the authors decline or modify a request.

Reviewer requests do not override protocol, prespecification, participant protection, data integrity, authorship, or accurate reporting; label new analyses and their limitations.

Every substantive revision should be verified across the manuscript, abstract, tables, figures, supplement, registry, reporting checklist, and related assets as applicable.

Appeal grounds and deadlines are journal-specific; factual or procedural error can be a strong basis, but a reasoned disagreement may also be considered when the venue permits it.

“Open peer review” is an umbrella for several practices—open identities, published reports, open participation, or interaction—and does not guarantee that every identity and report is public.

Last updated: October 2026

Peer Review, Rebuttals, Revisions, and Appeals

Peer review is an editorial evaluation, not an instruction to satisfy every request at any cost. A strong revision answers the underlying scientific concern, protects the integrity of the analysis, and leaves a clear record of what changed.

Triage the decision letter

Read the editor's letter before individual reviews. The editor may prioritize comments, reject a reviewer request, set a deadline, or condition reconsideration on specific work. Build a comment log with owner, classification, response, manuscript location, dependencies, and approval status.

Classify comments as:

  • editorial or presentation;
  • factual clarification;
  • reporting omission;
  • statistical or methodological;
  • request for new data or analysis;
  • interpretation or tone;
  • scope-changing request;
  • ethical, privacy, authorship, or integrity concern;

inconsistent or impossible request.

Similar comments can be grouped internally, but the response letter should make it easy for each reviewer and editor to find the answer.

Construct the response

A point-by-point response normally:

  • thanks the editor and reviewers professionally;
  • quotes, numbers, or clearly paraphrases each comment;
  • states what the authors did;
  • provides the revised text or a concise description;
  • identifies page, paragraph, line, table, or figure in the clean revision;

explains the scientific basis when a request is not followed exactly.

Do not call a reviewer careless, speculate about identity, or claim a change was made when it was not. “Done” is weaker than a precise answer. If tracked changes are requested, provide them along with the clean file and response.

Requests for additional analysis

A reviewer may identify a valuable analysis, but authors should first ask whether it is supported by the data, consent and permitted use, protocol and analysis plan, statistical assumptions, resources, and article scope.

For a post hoc subgroup request:

  • explain whether the subgroup and interaction were prespecified;
  • assess sample size, multiplicity, missingness, and biological rationale;
  • do not infer a subgroup effect merely because one subgroup is significant and another is not;
  • label an added analysis exploratory;
  • report the interaction or other appropriate comparison when justified;
  • avoid causal or confirmatory language beyond the design;

decline the request with a reason when it would be invalid, misleading, disclosive, or impossible.

Supplementary placement does not cure a flawed analysis. Conversely, “not prespecified” does not automatically mean an analysis can never be informative; it changes its evidentiary status.

Protect consistency and authorship

A revision can alter the abstract, conclusions, tables, figures, plain-language summary, disclosure, data-sharing statement, and reporting checklist. Use a cross-document check after material changes. Verify values against current approved outputs and update the participant flow or registry when required.

Named authors should review material scientific revisions and approve the final version to be published. Do not let a coordinator infer approval from silence. New contributors may affect acknowledgments or authorship, and any byline change must follow the journal's process.

If a reviewer asks for identifying participant data, confidential sponsor information, or use outside consent or governance, explain the constraint and discuss a privacy-protective alternative with the editor. Peer review does not waive law, consent, contracts, or ethical oversight.

Conflicting or inappropriate comments

When reviewers conflict, describe the conflict and propose a resolution to the editor. Follow the editor's explicit direction if it is scientifically and ethically acceptable. If a comment contains an error, correct it with evidence rather than dismissing it.

A reviewer request to cite their own work should be assessed for relevance. Add genuinely relevant sources; explain why irrelevant citations were not added. Report suspected coercive citation, discriminatory language, confidentiality breach, or conflict through the journal's process.

Appeals

An appeal asks a journal to reconsider a decision; it is not a second routine rebuttal. Read the journal's grounds, deadline, word limit, and submission route. Strong appeals are concise and evidence based. They may identify a material factual misunderstanding, procedural failure, unmanaged conflict, overlooked evidence, or another ground the journal accepts.

Do not teach that factual error is the only ethical basis for appeal. Some journals allow a reasoned challenge to editorial or scientific assessment; others state that priority decisions are not appealable. The venue decides. Repeated lobbying, contacting reviewers, or submitting the same manuscript elsewhere while an appeal is active can violate policy.

If the team chooses not to appeal, revise for another venue. Do not submit simultaneously. Reformat and recheck the work rather than carrying forward an obsolete cover letter or an unsupported claim added during the first review.

Review models

Common labels are not perfectly standardized:

Single-anonymized: reviewers usually know author identity; authors do not know reviewer identity.

Double-anonymized: author and reviewer identities are concealed from each other during review to the extent feasible.

Open peer review: may involve signed reviews, public reports, open identities, author–reviewer interaction, or open participation in different combinations.

Post-publication review: commentary or formal review occurs after public release.

Check the journal's definition. Open reports do not necessarily reveal reviewer names, and signed review does not necessarily mean the full decision history is published.

Important

On exam scenarios, answer the concern rather than obeying mechanically: protect data integrity, label exploratory work, document every change, obtain author approval, and follow the journal's own appeal and review policy.