Study guide

2.3 Verbal Analogies: Worked Decisions and Error Checks

Free CogAT Levels 15–17/18 Study Guide 2026 Grades 9–12

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: CogAT High School Structure, Administration & Foundation

1.1 CogAT Levels 15-17/18 Architecture, Administration & High School Context 1.2 Psychometric Scoring Metrics: Raw Scores, USS, SAS, Stanines & Norms 1.3 CogAT Ability Profiles: Median Stanines, Patterns (A, B, C, E) & Instructional Differentiation

2 Chapter 2: Verbal Battery — Verbal Analogies

2.1 Verbal Analogies: Relations and Direction 2.2 Verbal Analogies: Precision, Degree, and Multiple Meanings 2.3 Verbal Analogies: Worked Decisions and Error Checks

3 Chapter 3: Verbal Battery — Sentence Completion & Verbal Classification

3.1 Sentence Completion: Context and Logical Direction 3.2 Verbal Classification: Shared Categories and Boundaries 3.3 Verbal Battery: Distinguishing Tasks and Reviewing Errors

4 Chapter 4: Quantitative Battery — Number Analogies

4.1 Number Analogies: Testing a Common Rule 4.2 Number Analogies: Compound Rules and Ambiguity 4.3 Number Analogies: Fractions, Signs, and Solution Audits

5 Chapter 5: Quantitative Battery — Number Puzzles & Number Series

5.1 Number Puzzles: Missing Elements and Equation Checking 5.2 Number Series: Differences, Ratios, and Structured Tests 5.3 Number Series: Alternating and Recursive Patterns

6 Chapter 6: Nonverbal Battery — Figure Matrices

6.1 Figure Matrices: Features and Missing Cells 6.2 Figure Matrices: Rotation, Reflection, and Position 6.3 Figure Matrices: Combination Rules and Distractor Audits

7 Chapter 7: Nonverbal Battery — Paper Folding & Figure Classification

7.1 Paper Folding: Reverse the Folds and Track Layers 7.2 Figure Classification: Visual Categories and Invariants 7.3 Nonverbal Review: Evidence, Layer Counts, and Transfer

8 Chapter 8: Test-Taking Strategy, Timing & Gifted Program Navigation

8.1 Pacing: Use the Assigned Window and Navigation Rules 8.2 Diagnostic Practice: Errors, Transfer, and Study Planning 8.3 Scores, Access, and Local Placement Decisions

2.3 Verbal Analogies: Worked Decisions and Error Checks

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Separate person, instrument, material, workplace, and product roles.

Preserve both the contextual word sense and the relationship direction.

Ambiguous practice items need clearer wording or choices.

Guessing probabilities depend on how many defensible choices remain.

Last updated: October 2026

Make the solution visible

Recognizing a relationship is useful; explaining why competing choices fail is stronger. This section works through original analogy exercises from initial interpretation to a final check. The goal is a repeatable comparison method, not memorization of answer pairs. An answer must match the first pair's meaning and direction with minimal extra assumptions.

Use four steps: identify the sense of each word, state a relationship sentence, predict the missing role, and test the choices. When prediction is difficult, the choices can help clarify the relationship, but always return to the original pair before deciding.

Example: professional and instrument

Complete SURGEON : SCALPEL :: CARPENTER : ? from timber, hammer, workshop, and cabinet.

A surgeon uses a scalpel as a tool in their work. A carpenter uses a hammer. Timber is a material, workshop is a workplace, and cabinet is a possible product. All four are associated with carpentry; only hammer occupies the corresponding instrument role.

Notice that surgeon and scalpel are both nouns. Their grammatical similarity does not make them interchangeable. The relation depends on their roles: person and tool. Rejecting timber because it is “a noun” would fail, because the correct hammer is also a noun. Explain the actual distinction.

Example: an unfamiliar verb

BROOK : DISSENT :: TOLERATE : ? offers opposition, silence, authority, and punishment. Here brook is a verb meaning tolerate or allow. “To brook dissent” means to tolerate disagreement. Tolerate opposition therefore reproduces the relationship.

Do not use the river sense of brook. Do not substitute a new relation such as suppressing expression: suppress and tolerate move in different directions. If brook was unfamiliar during practice, write a sentence such as “She would brook no interruption” and check the definition afterward. Knowing that the word also names a small stream does not explain this stem.

The process shows why vocabulary and reasoning interact. Context can suggest a sense, but it does not make all unknown words inferable. Sometimes the most honest diagnosis is a vocabulary gap, followed by learning the word after the exercise.

Example: member and collection

Complete BERRY : CLUSTER :: FLOWER : ? from petal, bouquet, garden soil, and scent.

The relation is a member of a collection. Bouquet is a collection of flowers. Petal is a part of a flower, reversing a different relationship. Garden soil supports a plant but is not a collection of flowers. Scent is a property or product associated with flowers.

A cluster may include several kinds of things, and a bouquet may include foliage. Those ordinary variations do not defeat the relation. The intended comparison is the role of a berry within a cluster and a flower within a bouquet, not an exhaustive botanical definition.

Example: opposite direction

ADVANCE : RETREAT :: EXPAND : ? offers grow, extend, contract, and increase. Advance and retreat are opposing movements. Contract is the corresponding opposite of expand. Grow, extend, and increase are related to expansion and therefore tempting if you focus only on the target word.

Write the two pairs as sentences: “Retreat reverses the direction of advance; contract reverses the direction of expand.” If your explanation for a choice is merely “it has something to do with size,” it is too broad to establish the analogy.

Compare two plausible candidates

For ARTIST : PORTRAIT :: COMPOSER : ? , both song and symphony could be works created by a composer. If an independent exercise offers both without further context, it may be ambiguous. A reviewer should repair the item, not invent an official rule that the larger work always wins. In a well-formed multiple-choice question, the choices and stem should support a best match.

Distinguish this problem from a near match that requires a different verb. A conductor performs or leads a work; a composer creates it. That difference is enough to favor a musical work over a conductor when the stem links creator and product.

Audit a wrong answer

  • Error What the learner did Repair during practice
  • Association Chose a word on the same topic State each word's role
  • Reversal Matched whole-to-part with part-to-whole Read both pairs in order
  • Sense mismatch Used the river meaning of brook Identify the contextual meaning
  • Overbroad relation Said “both are connected” Replace it with a specific verb
  • Unchecked choice Accepted the first plausible option Compare the remaining alternatives

An error log should quote the relation you used and the correction. “I chose workshop because it belongs to carpentry; the stem asks for a tool” is useful. “Careless mistake” does not identify a method to improve.

Apply the method under time pressure

After untimed accuracy improves, use small timed sets. Standard Verbal Analogies timing is 10 minutes for 24 items, so the average is 25 seconds per item. Individual items may take more or less. Approved timing and navigation can differ; follow the assigned administration.

If an item remains unresolved, eliminate choices only when you can state why they fail. With four choices and two validly eliminated, an uninformed choice among the remaining two has a one-half chance. With five choices and two eliminated, three remain and the chance is one-third. These are conditional arithmetic examples, not promises that elimination is always correct or that every official item has the same number of choices.

Use the final check on direction and sense before submitting. During later review, solve the missed relationship again with different vocabulary to confirm that you learned the reasoning rather than remembered a position.