Study guide
15.1 Comparative Financial Statements & Predecessor Auditor Reporting
AICPA CPA Exam — Auditing & Attestation AUD
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Orientation & the Auditing Regulatory Environment
1.1 CPA AUD Exam Structure, Scoring & Blueprint Strategy 1.2 Regulatory Authorities & Auditing Standards Hierarchy 1.3 Preconditions for an Audit & Engagement Letters (AU-C 210)
2 Chapter 2: Professional Ethics & the AICPA Code of Conduct
2.1 AICPA Code of Professional Conduct & Conceptual Framework 2.2 Independence Rules: AICPA vs. SEC and PCAOB Standards 2.3 Independence Under Government (GAGAS) & Employee Benefit (DOL) Standards 2.4 Professional Skepticism, Professional Judgment & Client Confidentiality
3 Chapter 3: Quality Management at Firm & Engagement Levels
3.1 Firm System of Quality Management: SQMS No. 1 3.2 Engagement Quality Reviews: SQMS No. 2 3.3 Engagement-Level Quality Management: SAS 146 & AU-C 220
4 Chapter 4: Audit Planning, Strategy & Materiality
4.1 Audit Planning & Overall Audit Strategy (AU-C 300) 4.2 Materiality, Performance Materiality & Tolerable Misstatement (AU-C 320 & 450) 4.3 The Audit Risk Model & Risk Assessment Mechanics
5 Chapter 5: Entity Understanding, Inherent Risk & Internal Control
5.1 Understanding the Entity, Environment & Inherent Risk Factors (SAS 145 / AU-C 315) 5.2 Economic Conditions, Industry Factors & SOX Corporate Governance 5.3 COSO 2013 Internal Control Framework: 5 Components & 17 Principles 5.4 IT General Controls (ITGCs) & Application Controls 5.5 Evaluating Design & Implementation of Controls
6 Chapter 6: Fraud Risk, Laws & Specialized Resources
6.1 Fraud Risk Assessment & Auditor Responses (AU-C 240) 6.2 Consideration of Laws, Regulations & Non-Compliance (AU-C 250 & NOCLAR) 6.3 Group Audits: AU-C 600 and the SAS No. 149 Transition 6.4 Using the Work of Internal Auditors (AU-C 610) & Specialists (AU-C 620)
7 Chapter 7: Audit Evidence Fundamentals & General Procedures
7.1 Audit Evidence: Sufficiency, Appropriateness & Management Assertions (AU-C 500) 7.2 Audit Data: Relational Databases, Measurement Scales, Extraction & Reliability 7.3 Types of Audit Procedures & Audit Data Analytics (ADA) 7.4 Substantive Analytical Procedures (AU-C 520)
8 Chapter 8: Audit Sampling Concepts & Attribute Testing
8.1 Audit Sampling Principles & Sampling Risk (AU-C 530) 8.2 Attribute Sampling for Tests of Controls 8.3 Non-Statistical Sampling & Dual-Purpose Testing
9 Chapter 9: Variables Sampling & Monetary Unit Sampling (MUS)
9.1 Classical Variables Sampling Methods (MPU, Ratio, Difference) 9.2 Monetary Unit Sampling (MUS / PPS) Mechanics & Sizing 9.3 Evaluating Variables Sampling Results & Upper Misstatement Limits
10 Chapter 10: Substantive Testing: Revenue, Receivables & Confirmations
10.1 Auditing the Revenue and Receivables Cycle & Cutoff 10.2 External Confirmations: Positive, Negative & Non-Responses (AU-C 505) 10.3 Allowance for Credit Losses (CECL) & Valuation of Receivables
11 Chapter 11: Substantive Testing: Purchasing, Inventory, Cash & Long-Term Assets
11.1 Purchasing, Accounts Payable & Search for Unrecorded Liabilities 11.2 Inventory Observation & Valuation (AU-C 501) 11.3 Auditing Cash, Bank Reconciliations & Interbank Transfers (Kiting) 11.4 Auditing Property, Plant & Equipment, Debt & Equity Cycles
12 Chapter 12: Complex Estimates, Related Parties & Concluding Evidence
12.1 Auditing Accounting Estimates & Fair Value (AU-C 540) 12.2 Investments in Securities, Derivatives & Equity-Method Investees 12.3 Related Parties & Significant Unusual Transactions (AU-C 550) 12.4 Litigation, Claims & Assessments and Legal Inquiry (AU-C 501 / ASC 450) 12.5 Subsequent Events & Subsequently Discovered Facts (AU-C 560)
13 Chapter 13: Final Evaluation, Written Representations & Documentation
13.1 Evaluating Audit Findings & Misstatement Accumulation (AU-C 450) 13.2 Going Concern Evaluation (AU-C 570) 13.3 Written Management Representations (AU-C 580) 13.4 Audit Documentation, Assembly & Retention (AU-C 230)
14 Chapter 14: The Standard Audit Report & Opinion Modifications
14.1 The Standard Unmodified Audit Report (AU-C 700) 14.2 Audit Report Modifications: Qualified, Adverse & Disclaimer (AU-C 705) 14.3 Emphasis-of-Matter & Other-Matter Paragraphs (AU-C 706) 14.4 Key Audit Matters (AU-C 701) & Critical Audit Matters (AS 3101)
15 Chapter 15: Comparative Statements, Other Information & PCAOB Reporting
15.1 Comparative Financial Statements & Predecessor Auditor Reporting 15.2 Other Information, Supplementary Information & Special Purpose Frameworks 15.3 Reviews of Interim Financial Information (AU-C 930 & PCAOB AS 4105) 15.4 PCAOB Reporting & Integrated Audits of ICFR (AS 3101 & AS 2201)
16 Chapter 16: SSARS Engagements: Preparation, Compilation & Review
16.1 The SSARS Framework & Hierarchy of Services (AR-C 60-90) 16.2 Preparation of Financial Statements (AR-C 70) 16.3 Compilation Engagements (AR-C 80) 16.4 Review of Financial Statements (AR-C 90)
17 Chapter 17: SSAE Attestation, SOC Reports & Government Audits
17.1 The SSAE Attestation Framework: Assertion-Based and Direct Examinations and Reviews 17.2 Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements (AT-C 215, SSAE No. 19) 17.3 Service Organization Controls: SOC 1 & SOC 2 Engagements (AT-C 320) 17.4 Reporting on Compliance: AU-C 806, AT-C 315 & AU-C 935 17.5 Government Auditing Standards (Yellow Book / GAGAS) & Uniform Guidance Single Audits
15.1 Comparative Financial Statements & Predecessor Auditor Reporting
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Under AU-C 700, a continuing auditor reports on all comparative periods presented, either updating prior opinions if circumstances have changed or reaffirming them if unchanged.
When an updated opinion on a prior period differs from the one issued, an Other-Matter paragraph gives the previous report date, prior opinion type, substantive reasons, and that the opinion now differs.
Before reissuing, a predecessor reads the current statements, compares the prior statements, and gets letters from management and the successor (AU-C 560), keeping the original date unless revised.
If a predecessor's report is not reissued, the successor auditor includes an Other-Matter paragraph detailing that prior statements were audited by a predecessor, the opinion expressed, any emphasis or other-matter paragraphs, and the predecessor's report date, without naming the predecessor.
When comparative prior periods were reviewed or compiled under SSARS, or were unaudited, an Other-Matter paragraph must state the service performed, report date, significant findings, and that no audit assurance was obtained.
Last updated: September 2026
15.1 Comparative Financial Statements & Predecessor Auditor Reporting
Core Principle: Financial statements are frequently presented on a comparative basis to enhance comparability and enable users to identify financial trends across periods. Under AU-C 700 ( Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements ), an auditor's reporting responsibilities extend to all periods presented when reporting on comparative financial statements. A continuing auditor must update their report across all periods, while engagements involving a change in auditors require strict adherence to predecessor reporting protocols depending on whether the predecessor's report is reissued or omitted.
1. Overview of Comparative Financial Statements (AU-C 700)
Comparative financial statements consist of financial statements of two or more periods presented in adjacent columns for comparison. Financial reporting frameworks like U.S. GAAP generally encourage or require comparative presentations (for example, SEC rules require two balance sheets and three years of income statements, cash flows, and changes in stockholders' equity for public filers). +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | AUDITOR COMPARATIVE REPORTING FRAMEWORK |
- | |
- | SCENARIO 1: Continuing Auditor SCENARIO 2: Predecessor Auditor Reissues |
- | - Auditor audited ALL periods presented - Client requests predecessor reissue prior report |
- | - Updates report on all periods - Predecessor performs limited update procedures |
- | - May reiterate or change prior opinion - Uses original report date (or dual date if restated) |
- | |
- | SCENARIO 3: Predecessor Report NOT Reissued SCENARIO 4: Prior Period Unaudited / SSARS |
- | - Successor reports on current period only - Prior period reviewed or compiled under SSARS |
- | - Adds Other-Matter paragraph for prior year - Adds Other-Matter paragraph disclaiming audit |
- | - Never names predecessor auditor - Clearly indicates level of service performed |
- +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- The Continuing Auditor Concept
A continuing auditor is an independent auditor who has audited the financial statements of the current period and one or more consecutive immediate prior periods.
Report Scope: The continuing auditor's report applies to each set of financial statements presented.
Report Date: The updated report is dated no earlier than the date sufficient appropriate evidence is obtained for the most recent audit , because the evaluation of the prior statements is updated through that date.
2. Continuing Auditor Updating Opinions: Required Disclosures
An updated report is not merely a reissuance of the previous report. A continuing auditor updates their report on prior comparative statements by taking into account information acquired during the current audit. UPDATING A PRIOR PERIOD AUDIT OPINION
- |
- +--------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------+
- | |
- OPINION REMAINS UNCHANGED OPINION CHANGES ON PRIOR PERIOD
- Reiterate prior opinion on prior year; (e.g., Prior GAAP departure cured by restatement)
- Express current opinion on current year. Express updated opinion on prior period;
- (Can express different opinions on each Add Other-Matter paragraph (EOM too if restated)
period, e.g., Qualified Y1, Unqualified Y2) giving the four required disclosures.
When an Opinion on a Prior Period Changes
During the current period audit, the continuing auditor may become aware of circumstances or events that affect the financial statements of a prior period. For example, a prior qualification might have been caused by a departure from GAAP (such as failure to capitalize finance leases or improper inventory valuation). In the current year, the entity retroactively restates the prior period in full accordance with GAAP.
When the continuing auditor updates their report and issues an opinion that differs from the previous opinion, AU-C 700 requires an Other-Matter paragraph with the four disclosures below. If the prior statements were restated to correct a material misstatement, AU-C 708 separately requires an Emphasis-of-Matter paragraph about the restatement.
The Four Required Disclosures for a Changed Opinion
- # Required Content in the Other-Matter Paragraph
- 1 The date of the auditor's previous report
- 2 The type of opinion previously expressed (for example, qualified)
- 3 The substantive reasons for the different opinion (for example, restatement to conform with GAAP)
- 4 A statement that the opinion on the amended financial statements differs from the previous opinion
- Illustrative Scenario: Prior Qualification Cured by Restatement
Year 1: Client valued inventory at fair market value (a GAAP departure). The auditor issued a qualified audit report on March 15, Year 2.
Year 2: On February 20, Year 3, client adopts GAAP lower of cost or net realizable value, retroactively restating the Year 1 financial statements. The restatement is appropriately disclosed in Note 4.
Auditor Action: The continuing auditor expresses an unmodified opinion on both Year 1 and Year 2 . The auditor includes an Other-Matter paragraph stating the date of the previous report (March 15, Year 2), the opinion previously expressed (qualified), the reason for the change (restatement to GAAP, described in Note 4), and that the updated opinion on Year 1 differs from the previous opinion. Because Year 1 was restated to correct a misstatement, the report also includes an Emphasis-of-Matter paragraph referring to Note 4.
3. Predecessor Auditor's Report is Reissued
When a company changes accounting firms, the prior-period financial statements may be presented alongside the current-period statements. One option is for management to request the predecessor auditor to reissue their previous report. +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | PROCEDURES FOR REISSUING PREDECESSOR AUDIT REPORT |
- | |
- | Step 1: Read Current Statements --> Inspect current period comparative presentation. |
- | Step 2: Compare Statements --> Verify prior figures match audited records. |
- | Step 3: Successor Rep Letter --> Inquire if successor found material prior errors. |
- | Step 4: Management Rep Letter --> Confirm no unrecorded subsequent events affecting prior. |
- | |
- | REPORT DATING: |
- | - Standard Reissuance: Retain ORIGINAL report date (assumes no post-issuance responsibility). |
- | - Restated Prior Period: DUAL DATE (e.g., "March 10, Year 2, except for Note 3, as to which...") |
- +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- Mandatory Predecessor Procedures Before Reissuing
A predecessor auditor is not expected to perform a complete re-audit. However, because their name is being associated with current comparative filings, AU-C 560 requires the predecessor to perform four specific procedures before reissuing:
Read the financial statements of the current period.
Compare the prior-period statements that were audited with the comparative financial statements to be presented.
Obtain a letter of representation from the successor auditor , inquiring whether the successor's audit revealed any matters that might have a material effect on, or require disclosure in, the prior-period financial statements.
Obtain a letter of representation from former client management , confirming whether management believes any subsequent events have occurred that require adjustment or disclosure in the prior-period statements.
Report Dating Rules for Reissued Reports
Unchanged Statements: The reissued report retains the original report date to avoid implying that the predecessor investigated events occurring after that date.
Restated Prior-Period Statements: If the prior statements were restated due to a subsequent event or error correction, the predecessor auditor must either dual date the report (e.g., "March 15, Year 2, except for Note 6, as to which the date is March 1, Year 3") or use a new, current report date (which requires extending subsequent event procedures to the new date).
4. Predecessor Auditor's Report is NOT Reissued
If the predecessor auditor refuses to reissue their report, or if client management decides not to engage them to do so, the successor auditor must report on the current period while addressing the prior period in the audit report. +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- | SUCCESSOR AUDITOR OTHER-MATTER PARAGRAPH (AU-C 700) |
- | |
- | The successor auditor must include an Other-Matter paragraph stating: |
- | 1. The prior-period financial statements were audited by a predecessor auditor. |
- | 2. The PREDECESSOR AUDITOR IS NOT NAMED (unless the predecessor's practice was acquired/merged). |
- | 3. The TYPE OF OPINION expressed by the predecessor (and substantive reasons if modified). |
- | 4. The NATURE of any Emphasis-of-Matter or Other-Matter paragraphs in the predecessor's report. |
- | 5. The DATE of the predecessor auditor's report. |
- +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
- Successor Handling of Prior Period Restatements
What happens if the prior-period financial statements audited by a predecessor auditor are materially misstated and retroactively restated in the current comparative presentation?
Scenario Successor Reporting Action
Predecessor Agrees to Reissue Predecessor audits the adjustment, follows AU-C 700 procedures, and dual dates their reissued report.
Predecessor Report Not Reissued & Successor Audits Adjustments The successor auditor includes an Other-Matter paragraph indicating that a predecessor audited the prior statements before restatement, states the predecessor's opinion/date, and adds a statement that the successor auditor was engaged to audit and verify the restatement adjustments only.
Exam Trap: The successor auditor never names the predecessor auditor in their Other-Matter paragraph. Saying "The Year 1 financial statements were audited by Smith & Jones, CPAs" is an automatic exam distractor. The only narrow exception is when the predecessor's accounting practice was formally acquired by or merged with the successor firm.
5. Prior-Period Statements Reviewed, Compiled, or Unaudited
When current-period financial statements are audited but prior comparative periods were subject to a lower level of service (or no service at all), users must be informed of the lack of audit assurance. COMPARATIVE PRIOR PERIOD NON-AUDIT SERVICES
- |
- +--------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------+
- | |
- PRIOR PERIOD REVIEWED OR COMPILED (SSARS) PRIOR PERIOD UNAUDITED
Successor adds an Other-Matter paragraph stating: Successor adds an Other-Matter paragraph stating:
- Prior service performed (Review or Compilation) - Prior statements were not audited, reviewed, or compiled
- Date of the prior SSARS report - Auditor assumes no responsibility for them
- Description of material modifications (if any) - Statements should be clearly labeled as "UNAUDITED"
- Statement that no audit was performed and no audit assurance obtained - Auditor disclaims an opinion on the prior period
Mandatory Statements in the Other-Matter Paragraph for Prior SSARS Engagements
If prior-period statements were reviewed or compiled under SSARS and presented comparatively with current audited statements:
State the service performed (compilation or review) in the prior period.
State the date of the prior report.
Describe any material modifications noted in that prior report.
Explicitly state that the service was less in scope than an audit, did not involve obtaining reasonable assurance, and that the auditor expresses no opinion and assumes no responsibility for the prior period.
6. Comprehensive Decision Matrix: Comparative Financial Statements
Scenario Reporting Mechanism Paragraph Type Predecessor Named? Dating Convention
Continuing Auditor (No Opinion Change) Single report covering all periods presented Standard Opinion Paragraph N/A (Same firm) Current report date
Continuing Auditor (Opinion Changes) Updated report on comparative statements Other-Matter paragraph (EOM too if restated) N/A (Same firm) Current report date
Predecessor Reissues Report Two separate audit reports presented Predecessor issues own report Yes (Predecessor signs) Predecessor retains original date (dual dates if restated)
Predecessor Report Not Reissued Successor issues report on current period only Other-Matter paragraph added to current report NO (Strictly prohibited) Current report date
Prior Period Reviewed under SSARS Audit report on current period Other-Matter paragraph added to current report No Current report date