Study guide

3.3 Relativism, Egoism, and Comparing the Ethical Theories

CPA Program Ethics and Governance Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: The Accounting Profession and the Public Interest

1.1 What Distinguishes a Profession and the Social Contract 1.2 The Public Interest and the Profession as a Positive Social Force 1.3 The Four Sectors Where Accountants Work 1.4 Capabilities, Modern Roles, and Sector-Specific Dilemmas

2 Chapter 2: Professional Regulation, Co-Regulation, and Discipline

2.1 IFAC, the Professional Bodies, and Australian Standard Setters 2.2 Australia's Co-Regulatory Model in Practice 2.3 Statutory Regulation and Co-Regulatory Models in Australia 2.4 Quality Assurance, Professional Conduct, and Disciplinary Processes

3 Chapter 3: Ethical Theories and Decision-Making Frameworks

3.1 Teleological (Consequentialist) Ethics and Utilitarianism 3.2 Deontological Ethics and Virtue Ethics 3.3 Relativism, Egoism, and Comparing the Ethical Theories 3.4 Individual, Organisational, and Societal Influences on Ethical Behaviour 3.5 Structured Ethical Decision-Making Models (AAA and Tucker Models)

4 Chapter 4: The APES 110 Code of Ethics

4.1 Structure and Legal Authority of APES 110 4.2 The Five Fundamental Principles 4.3 The Conceptual Framework: Identifying Threats and Applying Safeguards 4.4 Resolving Ethical Conflicts and Responding to NOCLAR 4.5 Independence Standards for Audit and Assurance Engagements

5 Chapter 5: The Corporate Form and Governance Theories

5.1 The Corporate Form: Five Foundational Characteristics 5.2 Separation of Ownership and Control and Defining Corporate Governance 5.3 Agency Theory and Stewardship Theory 5.4 Stakeholder, Resource Dependency, and Managerial Hegemony Theories 5.5 Comparative Corporate Governance: Anglo-American, European, and Asian Models

6 Chapter 6: The ASX Corporate Governance Principles

6.1 The ASX Corporate Governance Council and 'If Not, Why Not' 6.2 The Corporate Governance Statement and the Quality of Explanation 6.3 ASX Principles 1 to 4: Board Foundations, Structure, Culture, and Financial Integrity 6.4 ASX Principles 5 to 8: Disclosure, Shareholder Rights, Risk, and Remuneration

7 Chapter 7: Global Codes, Regulators, and Governance Beyond Listed Companies

7.1 The UK Corporate Governance Code and 'Comply or Explain' 7.2 Section 172, the G20/OECD Principles, and Global Benchmarking 7.3 Regulatory Architecture: ASIC, APRA, ACCC, and the Banking Royal Commission 7.4 Governance in the Public Sector, Charities, NFPs, and SMEs

8 Chapter 8: The Board, Committees, and Executive Remuneration

8.1 Board Role, Appointment, Cessation, and the Chair-CEO Division 8.2 Director Independence, Board Skills, and Diversity 8.3 Audit, Remuneration, Nomination, and Risk Committees 8.4 Executive Remuneration Structure, Malus, and Clawback 8.5 Remuneration Reporting and the Two-Strikes Rule

9 Chapter 9: Security Holders, Risk Oversight, and Market Integrity

9.1 Security Holder Rights, Engagement, and Shareholder Activism 9.2 Risk Governance, the Three Lines of Defence, and COSO ERM 9.3 Continuous Disclosure, Insider Trading, and Market Conduct

10 Chapter 10: Legal Duties, Whistleblowing, Cyber Risk, and Culture

10.1 Competition and Consumer Law and the Criminal-Civil Liability Divide 10.2 Directors' Statutory Duties and Their Enforcement 10.3 Whistleblower Protection Framework under the Corporations Act (Part 9.4AAA) 10.4 Cybersecurity, Privacy Principles (APPs), and Critical Infrastructure 10.5 Modern Slavery, Workplace Protections, and Instilling Ethical Corporate Culture

11 Chapter 11: Corporate Accountability and Reporting Theory

11.1 Conceptual Foundations and Evolution of Corporate Accountability 11.2 The Social Contract and the Social Licence to Operate 11.3 Limitations of Financial Accounting and the Problem of Externalities 11.4 Bridging the Reporting Gap: The Accountant's Role 11.5 Theoretical Perspectives: Legitimacy, Stakeholder, and Institutional Theories

12 Chapter 12: Sustainability Reporting Frameworks and Climate Disclosures

12.1 CSR Models: Carroll's Pyramid, Triple Bottom Line, and Shared Value 12.2 The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and Integrated Reporting (<IR>) Framework 12.3 The ISSB Standards (IFRS S1/S2), Australian Climate Disclosures, and Sustainability Assurance

3.3 Relativism, Egoism, and Comparing the Ethical Theories

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Ethical relativism holds that moral standards are culturally contingent, while absolutism holds that some standards bind universally regardless of local practice.

APES 110 is structurally absolutist: the five fundamental principles apply to every member in every jurisdiction, which is why 'local business custom' is never a defence to a facilitation payment.

Ethical egoism treats the maximisation of long-term self-interest as the moral standard, and is distinguished from psychological egoism, which is a descriptive claim about motivation rather than a normative one.

The normative theories frequently converge on the same answer in accounting cases; they diverge most sharply where a misstatement produces a genuine short-term aggregate benefit.

Exam answers score best when a scenario is analysed through more than one lens and the divergence between them is stated explicitly, rather than asserting a single 'correct' theory.

Last updated: September 2026

  • 3.3 Relativism, Egoism, and Comparing the Ethical Theories
  • 1. Relativism versus Absolutism and Ethical Egoism
  • Ethical Relativism

Ethical Relativism is the doctrine that moral values and ethical standards are not universally valid; rather, they are social conventions, cultural customs, or personal preferences that vary across societies and eras.

Descriptive Relativism: Simply observes that different cultures have different moral customs (an uncontroversial empirical fact).

Normative Cultural Relativism: Asserts that an action is morally right if the culture in which it occurs approves of it; therefore, no external culture or professional body has the right to judge the practices of another culture ( "When in Rome, do as the Romans do" ). [ Ethical Absolutism / Moral Realism ]

Universal, immutable moral truths exist and apply to all professionals globally.

  • ▲
  • │ (Philosophical Spectrum)
  • ▼
  • [ Ethical Relativism / Conventionalism ]

Morality is relative to local culture, time, and jurisdiction; no universal standard.

The Professional Trap of Relativism

On the CPA exam, candidates must recognize cultural relativism as a profound danger in international commercial practice. For instance, an Australian multinational operating in a developing country may face demands for "facilitation payments" (bribes) to secure government mining permits. A cultural relativist might excuse this as standard local business custom. However, for a CPA, moral absolutism and legal mandates prevail:

Section 70.2 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) makes bribing a foreign public official a severe corporate criminal offence with extraterritorial jurisdiction.

APES 110 categorically prohibits professional accountants from offering, paying, or accepting bribes, regardless of local geographic customs.

Moral Absolutism (Moral Realism)

Moral Absolutism maintains that objective, universal moral standards exist and apply across all historical periods, geographical boundaries, and commercial environments. An act such as falsifying books of account or committing fraud is objectively wrong everywhere, regardless of whether a local culture or corporate management condones it.

Ethical Egoism

Ethical Egoism is a normative theory asserting that an individual ought always to act in their own rational long-term self-interest. It should not be confused with psychological egoism (the descriptive theory that humans are naturally selfish).

Key Proponents: Thomas Hobbes (historical roots) and Ayn Rand (Objectivism).

Incompatibility with Professional Accounting: Ethical egoism is the philosophical antithesis of the accounting profession. A professional accountant's legitimacy is grounded entirely in subordination of private self-interest to the public interest . An accountant acting on egoist principles would readily conceal corporate fraud if the personal financial kickback or promotion prospects outweighed the probability of personal regulatory detection.

2. Comprehensive Comparison Matrix of Ethical Theories

The following matrix provides a clear comparative overview of the major normative frameworks:

Theoretical Dimension Teleology / Utilitarianism Deontology / Kantianism Virtue Ethics Ethical Egoism

Primary Analytical Focus The consequences / outcomes of the action. The inherent nature of the action and adherence to duty. The character and integrity of the decision-maker. The self-interest of the individual agent.

Key Proponents Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill Immanuel Kant, W.D. Ross Aristotle, Alasdair MacIntyre Thomas Hobbes, Ayn Rand

Core Decision Rule Act to produce the greatest net happiness for the greatest number. Act in accordance with universal duties; never treat people merely as means. Act as a person of virtuous character and practical wisdom would act. Act to maximize one's own rational long-term self-interest.

Key Strengths Pragmatic; stakeholder-inclusive; aligns with cost-benefit analysis. Absolute protection of individual rights; provides clear, inviolable rules. Context-sensitive; recognizes human moral growth and internal motivation. Clear personal motivation; avoids hypocritical self-sacrifice.

Application to Accounting Conducting stakeholder impact analyses; evaluating public interest impact of insolvencies. Complying strictly with APES 110; refusing to falsify records under any circumstances. Exercising professional scepticism; upholding independence of mind in audits. Identifying perverse corporate incentive structures and agency problems.

Critical Flaws in Accounting May justify sacrificing minority rights; measurement subjectivity. Inflexible; cannot easily resolve conflicts between competing absolute duties. Lacks a rigid step-by-step decision algorithm; open to subjective interpretation. Destroys public trust; directly violates the fundamental duty to serve the public interest.

  • 3. Concrete Accounting Scenarios Analyzed Through Each Lens
  • Scenario 1: Whistleblowing on Off-Balance Sheet Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs)

The Dilemma: Senior Audit Senior Priya discovers that an ASX-listed client has transferred $80 million of toxic credit liabilities into an off-balance sheet SPV controlled by executive family members. The CFO warns Priya that disclosing this will cause the company's share price to collapse, throwing 1,200 employees out of work, destroying pension fund investments, and costing her audit firm their multi-million-dollar audit contract.

Utilitarian Analysis:

Act Utilitarianism: Might tempt Priya to stay silent in the immediate quarter if she calculates that 1,200 jobs and pension savings outweigh the abstract harm to future potential investors.

Rule Utilitarianism: Priya recognizes that if all auditors concealed off-balance sheet fraud, capital market transparency would evaporate, borrowing costs would skyrocket across the entire economy, and systemic trust would fail. Therefore, the long-term utility of the rule "always report material accounting misstatements" mandates blowing the whistle.

Deontological Analysis:

First Formulation: Can Priya universalize the maxim "Conceal client fraud to protect local jobs and audit fees" ? No; universalizing this renders statutory audit reports meaningless.

Second Formulation: Concealing the SPV deceives prospective bondholders, lenders, and retail investors, treating them merely as instruments to protect the company's executive bonuses. Priya possesses a categorical duty to uphold APES 110 fundamental principles of Integrity and Objectivity. The whistle must be blown regardless of downstream consequences.

Virtue Ethics Analysis: Priya asks: "What would a virtuous auditor of integrity and courage do?" Allowing intimidation to silence her demonstrates the vice of cowardice and professional deficiency. Exercising practical wisdom ( phronesis ), Priya displays professional courage, upholds the internal goods of truthful financial stewardship, and reports the fraud through appropriate governance channels (the Board Audit Committee and ASIC under whistleblower provisions).

Scenario 2: Aggressive Tax Avoidance (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting)

The Dilemma: Tax Director Lachlan is asked to implement a complex offshore transfer pricing structure that shifts $200 million in taxable profits from Australia to a zero-tax haven via artificial intellectual property (IP) licensing royalties. The scheme exploits technical statutory ambiguities and is deemed to have a "51% chance of surviving an ATO audit under Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ."

Utilitarian Analysis: Lachlan balances the immediate financial gain to multinational shareholders against the loss of $60 million in tax revenue to the Australian public (funding hospitals, roads, and education), alongside the severe reputational damage if the scheme is publicly exposed by a Senate inquiry. Aggregate social utility strongly opposes aggressive profit-shifting.

Deontological Analysis: The scheme violates the spirit of the tax legislation. Universalizing the maxim "Exploit artificial legal loopholes to avoid paying domestic taxes wherever detection probability is low" would collapse government fiscal infrastructure. Furthermore, it treats the host nation's public infrastructure as a free resource while refusing reciprocal contribution, violating the categorical duty of justice.

Virtue Ethics Analysis: Lachlan reflects on professional temperance and justice. Engaging in contrived, artificial tax structures reflects corporate greed (excess) rather than legitimate commercial tax planning (the virtuous mean). A virtuous CPA refuses to facilitate schemes that rely on obfuscation and deceit.

4. Exam Traps and Study Tips

Exam Trap 1 (Utilitarianism vs Self-Interest): Never confuse Utilitarianism with Ethical Egoism . Utilitarianism is profoundly altruistic: the decision-maker's own pleasure counts for no more than the pleasure of any other affected person. An action that benefits the company or CEO but harms thousands of external stakeholders is anti-utilitarian.

Exam Trap 2 (Rule Utilitarianism vs Deontology): Candidates often mix up Rule Utilitarianism with Deontology because both employ rules. Remember: Rule Utilitarianism validates rules solely because they produce the best overall consequences , whereas Deontology validates rules because they are intrinsically right duties , completely independent of consequences.

Exam Trap 3 (Virtue Ethics is Not Rule-Free): Do not assume virtue ethics ignores rules entirely. Virtue ethics acknowledges rules as useful heuristics, but insists that rules without virtuous character ( phronesis ) result in legalistic, tick-the-box compliance that fails to protect the public interest.