Study guide

13.3 Implications for Strategy and Strategic Responses to New Business Models

CPA Program — Global Strategy and Leadership Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Introduction to Strategy, Leadership and the Capstone (Module 1)

1.1 Exam Structure, Case Technique and Capstone Integration 1.2 Defining Strategy, Strategic Intent and the Strategic Process 1.3 The Role of the Finance Professional as Strategic Business Partner 1.4 Stakeholder Theory and the Resource-Based View Foundation 1.5 Organisational Context for Strategy 1.6 Leadership Theories and the Role of Leaders in Strategy

2 Chapter 2: External Environment — Industry Definition, Macro Environment and Industry Structure (Module 2)

2.1 Macro-Environmental Analysis Using PESTEL 2.2 Industry Analysis Using Porter's Five Forces 2.3 Industry Life Cycle and Structural Evolution

3 Chapter 3: External Environment — Competitors, Strategic Groups, Uncertainty and Data (Module 2)

3.1 Strategic Groups Analysis and Mobility Barriers 3.2 Competitor Analysis and Key Success Factors (KSFs) 3.3 Scenario Planning and Managing Environmental Uncertainty

4 Chapter 4: Internal Environment — Resources, Capabilities and VRIO (Module 3)

4.1 Resource-Based View: Tangible, Intangible and Organisational Assets 4.2 The VRIO/VRIN Framework for Sustainable Advantage 4.3 Core Competences and Dynamic Capabilities

5 Chapter 5: Internal Environment — Value Chain, Performance Drivers, Culture and SWOT (Module 3)

5.1 Porter's Value Chain and Margin Analysis 5.2 Financial Analysis and Strategic Benchmarking 5.3 Organisational Culture and Capability Gaps 5.4 Strategic, Operational and People Drivers of Performance 5.5 Combining External and Internal Analysis: SWOT, TOWS and Gap Analysis

6 Chapter 6: Product, Service and Market Development — Growth Directions (Module 4)

6.1 Growth Vectors and the Ansoff Matrix 6.2 Porter's Generic Strategies and Competitive Positioning 6.3 Blue Ocean Strategy and Value Innovation

7 Chapter 7: Product, Service and Market Development — Portfolio, Customers and Growth Methods (Module 4)

7.1 BCG Growth-Share Matrix and Portfolio Strategy 7.2 Market Segmentation, Targeting and Customer Lifetime Value 7.3 Strategic Alliances, Joint Ventures and M&A vs Organic Growth

8 Chapter 8: Innovation, New Product and Service Development, and Intellectual Property (Module 4)

8.1 Innovation: Types, Essentials and Leading Innovation 8.2 New Product Development: Process, Double Diamond and Accounting Impacts 8.3 New Service Development and Productised Services 8.4 Approaches to Developing New Products and Services: Design Thinking, Lean Start-up and Open Innovation 8.5 Intellectual Property: Protection, Strategy and Accounting

9 Chapter 9: Strategy Development — Option Evaluation and SAF (Module 5)

9.1 The Johnson-Scholes SAF Framework: Suitability 9.2 Financial Acceptability: Investment Appraisal and Value Creation 9.3 Feasibility: Financial, Operational and Human Constraints

10 Chapter 10: Strategy Development — Risk, Integrating Options and the Strategic Plan (Module 5)

10.1 Strategic Risk Identification and Risk Appetite 10.2 Risk Assessment, Heat Maps and the 4Ts Response Framework 10.3 Strategic Drivers and Levers, Prioritising Options and Integrating Them into Themes 10.4 Formulating the Strategic Plan and Strategic Objectives

11 Chapter 11: Strategy Implementation — Plans, Projects, Structure and Control (Module 6)

11.1 Designing Implementation Plans: Projects, Programs and Governance 11.2 Structure Follows Strategy: Organisational Architectures 11.3 The McKinsey 7S Framework and Organisational Cohesion 11.4 Resource Allocation, Strategic Budgeting and Control

12 Chapter 12: Global Strategy, Market Entry and Leading Change (Modules 1, 4 and 6)

12.1 Global Strategy: Bartlett and Ghoshal Framework 12.2 Foreign Market Entry Modes and International Risk 12.3 Leading Strategic Change and Overcoming Resistance

13 Chapter 13: Strategy and Leadership for Emerging Business Models (Module 7)

13.1 The Changing Business Environment and Business Models 13.2 Disruptive Innovation and Platform Business Models 13.3 Implications for Strategy and Strategic Responses to New Business Models 13.4 Strategic Ambidexterity, Agility and Business Ecosystems 13.5 Strategic Leadership Theories and Executive Decision-Making

14 Chapter 14: Governance, Ethics, Sustainability and Case Technique

14.1 Corporate Governance and Board Strategic Oversight 14.2 Strategic Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility and ESG 14.3 Case Scenario Analysis and Integrated Recommendation Technique

13.3 Implications for Strategy and Strategic Responses to New Business Models

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Whittington's four perspectives on strategy are classical, evolutionary, systemic and processual.

Discovery-driven planning works back from the required profit, lists critical assumptions and tests them cheaply at milestones.

The entrepreneurial strategy compass combines collaborate-or-compete with control-or-execution to give intellectual property, architectural, value chain and disruption strategies.

Incumbent responses to new business models include block, milk, invest in the disruptor, disrupt yourself, retreat to a niche, redefine the core and exit.

In fast-changing markets leaders devolve decisions, shape culture and protect a stable core while teams experiment.

Last updated: October 2026

13.3 Implications for Strategy and Strategic Responses to New Business Models

Executive Summary: When unknowns outweigh knowns, classical long-range planning breaks down. This section uses Whittington's four perspectives on strategy to explain when emergent approaches are needed, describes discovery-driven planning and the entrepreneurial strategy compass, and sets out the options incumbents have when a new business model threatens them, the different positions of start-ups and established firms, and the leadership roles these situations demand.

Four Perspectives on Strategy

Richard Whittington classified approaches to strategy along two dimensions: whether outcomes are profit-maximising or pluralistic (several goals), and whether processes are deliberate or emergent .

Deliberate process Emergent process

Profit-maximising Classical: rational analysis and planning by top management Evolutionary: markets select the fittest; keep costs low and options open

Pluralistic Systemic: strategy reflects the social and cultural system the firm belongs to Processual: strategy emerges from learning, negotiation and compromise among stakeholders

The classical approach suits stable environments where knowns outweigh unknowns. In dynamic environments with emerging business models, organisations lean toward evolutionary and processual approaches: many small experiments, rapid learning and continuous adjustment.

Discovery-Driven Planning

Rita McGrath and Ian MacMillan's discovery-driven planning is a disciplined way to plan when uncertainty is high. Instead of projecting detailed revenues and then hoping to achieve them, it:

Starts with the required result: a "reverse income statement" works back from the profit the venture must earn to justify the risk, to the revenue needed and the costs allowed.

Lists the assumptions that must be true to achieve it (price, volumes, conversion rates, costs).

Tests the most critical assumptions first , as cheaply as possible.

Sets milestones at which assumptions are checked and the plan is revised, expanded or stopped.

The aim is to convert assumptions into knowledge at the lowest cost. It complements design thinking (Section 8.4) and the lean start-up method.

The Entrepreneurial Strategy Compass

Joshua Gans, Erin Scott and Scott Stern's entrepreneurial strategy compass helps a new venture choose how to commercialise an idea. It combines two choices: whether to collaborate with or compete against incumbents, and whether to invest in control (protecting the idea and building proprietary assets) or in execution (moving fast and building competitive strength without relying on protection).

Collaborate with incumbents Compete against incumbents

Control Intellectual property strategy: develop and protect ideas, then license or sell them to established firms Architectural strategy: create and control a new value chain, platform or standard

Execution Value chain strategy: fit into an existing value chain as a specialised supplier or partner Disruption strategy: enter quickly and attack incumbents by out-executing them

Each strategy needs a coherent set of choices about customers, technology, organisation and competition. The authors recommend testing at least two strategies before committing to one.

How Incumbents Can Respond to New Business Models

Established firms facing a disruptive model have a menu of responses, which can be combined or sequenced:

Response What it involves When it fits

Block Use legal, regulatory or contractual means to slow the entrant Short-term only; rarely stops a superior model

Milk Accept decline and maximise cash from the legacy business Shrinking market, no capability to compete in the new one

Invest in the disruptor Acquire or fund the new players (corporate venturing) Strong cash reserves, weak internal capability

Disrupt yourself Launch a competing model even though it cannibalises existing sales Leadership willing to accept short-term cannibalisation

Retreat to a niche Focus on the segment the new model serves poorly Loyal, distinctive customers who value what the incumbent does best

Redefine the core Change how the core business operates to match the new model's agility The core proposition is still valued but the operating model is outdated

Exit Sell the business while it still has value The new model is clearly superior and the incumbent has no edge

Constantinos Markides and Constantinos Charitou showed that incumbents can also run the old and new models side by side, keeping them separate where the two conflict and integrating them where they share resources—an application of ambidexterity (Section 13.4).

A local footwear retailer squeezed by online competitors illustrates redefining the core: she moved from long, expensive leases to short-term pop-up sites, matching the flexibility and low overheads of online rivals while keeping her advantage in expert, in-person fitting.

Start-ups Versus Established Organisations

Start-ups can build a new model from scratch but lack resources, brand and scale; established firms have resources and customers but must protect today's profits while funding tomorrow's model. The established firm's challenge is therefore organisational as much as strategic: creating space for new models without letting the legacy business smother them.

Leadership and Management Roles

Centralised decision-making becomes a bottleneck when markets move quickly. Leaders of organisations facing new business models:

devolve decisions to teams close to customers and give them clear boundaries;

shape culture —psychological safety, learning from failure and customer focus—rather than making every decision themselves;

  • adopt a servant-leadership stance that removes obstacles and develops people;
  • protect a stable core of purpose, values and governance while allowing the edges to experiment (Section 13.4);

invest in leadership development , because these capabilities must exist throughout the organisation, not only at the top.

Managers, in turn, translate experiments into scalable operations, measure results honestly and allocate resources to the experiments that work.