Study guide

5.2 Duties and Liabilities of Agents and Principals

AICPA CPA Exam — Regulation REG

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Format, Scoring, and Skill Levels 1.3 New Pronouncements and OBBBA Testing Policy 1.4 Study Strategy and Task-Based Simulations

2 Circular 230 and Tax Return Preparers

2.1 Practice Before the IRS under Circular 230 2.2 Diligence, Written Advice, Fees, and Records 2.3 Tax Return Preparer Identification and Penalties

3 Licensing, Audits, Appeals, and Disclosure

3.1 State Board Licensing and Disciplinary Systems 3.2 IRS Audits, Appeals, and the Judicial Process 3.3 Substantiation, Disclosure, and FBAR Reporting

4 Penalties, Hierarchy, and Legal Duties

4.1 Taxpayer Penalties 4.2 Tax Law Authoritative Hierarchy 4.3 Common Law Duties, Privilege, and Confidentiality

5 Agency Law

5.1 Authority of Agents and Principals 5.2 Duties and Liabilities of Agents and Principals

6 Contracts

6.1 Contract Formation 6.2 Performance and Discharge 6.3 Breach and Remedies

7 Debtor-Creditor Relationships

7.1 Suretyship, Guarantors, and Debtor-Creditor Rights 7.2 UCC Article 9 Attachment, Perfection, and Priority

8 Employment Taxes and Worker Classification

8.1 Federal Employment Taxes 8.2 Employee versus Independent Contractor

9 Bankruptcy, Health Plans, and FCPA

9.1 Bankruptcy Types and Discharge 9.2 Qualified Health Plans and the ACA 9.3 Foreign Corrupt Practices Act

10 Business Structure under State Law

10.1 Selection, Formation, Operation, and Termination 10.2 Rights, Duties, Obligations, and Authority of Owners and Management

11 Basis of Tangible Assets

11.1 Cost Basis and Conversion from Personal Use 11.2 Gift Basis under §1015 11.3 Inherited Basis under §1014

12 Wash Sales and Intangible Basis

12.1 Wash-Sale Basis Adjustments 12.2 Organization, Start-Up, and Loan Cost Basis

13 Cost Recovery

13.1 MACRS Recovery Periods and Conventions 13.2 Section 179 and Bonus Depreciation 13.3 Amortization of Intangibles

14 Individual Gross Income

14.1 Gross Income Inclusions 14.2 Gross Income Exclusions 14.3 Capital Gains, Holding Period, and Virtual Currency

15 Pass-Through Reporting, AGI, and Deductions

15.1 Reporting Items from Pass-Through Entities 15.2 Adjustments to Arrive at AGI 15.3 Standard versus Itemized Deductions 15.4 Qualified Business Income Deduction §199A

16 Loss Limitations and Filing Status

16.1 Capital Loss Netting and Ordinary Business Loss Limits 16.2 Hobby, Wash-Sale, and Personal-Use Loss Disallowance 16.3 Filing Status and Dependents

17 Tax Computation and Credits

17.1 Regular Tax and Net Investment Income Tax 17.2 Refundable and Nonrefundable Credits 17.3 Estimated Tax and Safe Harbors

18 C Corporations and Book-Tax Differences

18.1 Permanent vs Temporary Differences; Schedules M-1 and M-3 18.2 C Corporation Taxable Income and Special Deductions 18.3 C Corporation NOLs, Capital Losses, Credits, and Tax 18.4 State and Local Tax: Nexus, Allocation, Apportionment

19 S Corporations

19.1 Eligibility and Election 19.2 Ordinary Income, Separately Stated Items, and AAA 19.3 Shareholder Stock and Debt Basis

20 Partnerships, LLCs, and Tax-Exempt Organizations

20.1 Partnership Ordinary Income and Separately Stated Items 20.2 Partner's Outside Basis and Partnership Liabilities 20.3 LLC Tax Classification 20.4 Types of Tax-Exempt Organizations

5.2 Duties and Liabilities of Agents and Principals

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

An agent owes the principal fiduciary duties of loyalty (no secret profit or conflict), obedience, care and competence, accounting, and notification of material facts.

A principal owes the agent compensation as agreed, reimbursement of authorized outlays, indemnity for authorized liabilities, and cooperation in the agency's performance.

The principal is bound on contracts made with actual or apparent authority or later ratified; an agent who lacks authority is liable to the third party for breach of the implied warranty of authority.

Respondeat superior makes an employer vicariously liable for an employee's torts in the scope of employment; independent contractors generally do not trigger that liability except for nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work.

A detour remains in the scope of employment; a frolic does not. Notice to an agent authorized to receive it is notice to the principal. Criminal acts of an agent are generally not imputed.

Last updated: August 2026

5.2 Duties and Liabilities of Agents and Principals

Once an agency exists, REG Blueprint II.A.2 asks who owes whom what, and who pays when something goes wrong. Duties run inside the agency (principal ↔ agent). Contract and tort liability run outside it (principal or agent ↔ third parties). Keep those two planes separate; mixing them is the usual miss. Worker classification for employment-tax purposes is a different topic, in employment taxes and worker classification ; this section stays on common-law duties and vicarious liability.

Agent duties to the principal

The agent is a fiduciary . The Restatement catalog that REG tests:

Duty Content Typical REG breach

Loyalty Act solely for the principal's benefit in the agency matter; no secret profit, no conflicting representation, no usurping a business opportunity Kickback from a vendor; buying the principal's target property in the agent's own name

Obedience Follow lawful, reasonable instructions Ignoring a purchase cap; signing a prohibited guarantee

Care / competence Act with the care, competence, and diligence normally exercised by agents in similar circumstances; a specialist is held to the specialist's standard Negligent failure to place required insurance; a CPA-agent bungling a filing the engagement covered

Accounting Keep and render an account of money and property; no commingling Depositing collections in the agent's personal account

Notification / information Use reasonable effort to provide the principal with facts the agent knows, or should know, are material Sitting on a customer's insolvency notice; failing to pass along a defect claim

Secret profit is the loyalty item that writes itself. If the agent takes a side commission, the principal may recover that profit even if the principal also got a fair price. Consent after full disclosure is the only clean cure. Dual agency — representing both sides of a deal — is a loyalty conflict unless both principals consent with knowledge of the material facts.

A gratuitous agent still owes loyalty and, once the agent begins performance, a duty of care. REG will not reward an unpaid agent who is reckless merely because no fee was agreed.

Principal duties to the agent

The principal is not a fiduciary in the same way, but the principal owes:

Compensation as agreed, or a reasonable value if the agency is not gratuitous and the parties left the amount open.

Reimbursement for payments the agent made that were authorized or necessary in the agency.

Indemnity against losses and liabilities the agent incurs in authorized activity, unless the loss comes from the agent's own fault.

Cooperation — do not unreasonably interfere with the agent's performance, and do not destroy the subject matter of the agency (for example, undercutting a listing in a way that cheats the agent of an earned commission, depending on the listing contract).

Contract liability: authorized acts and the warranty of authority

If the agent acts with actual or apparent authority , or the principal ratifies , the principal is bound to the third party on the contract. Whether the agent is also bound depends on disclosure status, covered in 5.1 : disclosed principal, agent generally out; unidentified or undisclosed, agent generally in.

If the agent acts without authority and the principal does not ratify, the principal is not bound. The agent is then liable to the third party for breach of the implied warranty of authority : the agent impliedly warrants that the principal exists and that the agent has the power the agent purports to have. That is a warranty theory, not a claim that the agent became a party to the underlying contract (though an unidentified or undisclosed agent may be that as well). A disclosed agent who truthfully says "I do not have authority to go above $10,000" does not make that warranty.

An agent who signs a deed or negotiable instrument in a personal capacity, or who fails to name the principal, can be personally liable on the instrument regardless of internal authority.

Tort: respondeat superior, independent contractors, frolic and detour

Respondeat superior makes an employer vicariously liable for an employee's torts committed within the scope of employment . Scope includes acts of the kind the employee is employed to perform, substantially within authorized time and space, and actuated at least in part by a purpose to serve the employer. Intentional torts are generally outside scope unless the employment contemplates force (a bouncer) or the tort is a misguided attempt to serve the employer (an overzealous collector).

Independent contractors generally do not trigger vicarious liability. Two REG-level exceptions, kept short:

Nondelegable duties (a land occupier's duty to keep public-facing premises reasonably safe; certain statutory duties).

Inherently dangerous activities (blasting, and similar work that remains dangerous even when carefully done).

Whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor for vicarious-liability purposes is a common-law control test: who controls the manner and means of the work, who supplies tools, how the person is paid, and whether the work is part of the regular business. Do not import Form W-2 versus Form 1099-NEC rules into this chapter; those are the employment-tax overlay in chapter 8.

Frolic versus detour is the scope-of-employment fork:

A detour is a minor deviation. The employee is still within scope; the employer remains vicariously liable.

A frolic is a substantial departure for the employee's own purposes. Vicarious liability pauses until the employee reasonably returns to the employer's business.

Criminal acts of an agent are generally not imputed to the principal. A principal can of course be liable for a crime the principal directed, or for a regulatory offense that does not require personal mens rea, but REG's default is: the crime stays with the actor. Do not convert respondeat superior into automatic criminal imputation.

Notice to the agent is notice to the principal

A notification given to an agent is effective as to the principal when the agent receives it, if the agent has actual or apparent authority to receive that kind of notice, and if the information comes to the agent in the course of the agency . Knowledge the agent acquires while acting for the principal is generally imputed. Exceptions REG may flag: the agent is acting adversely to the principal (the adverse-agent limitation), or the third party knows the agent will not pass the information along. A customer who tells a sales clerk that goods are defective has notified the store; a customer who tells the clerk a personal secret unrelated to the agency has not.

Duty table

  • Duty Owed by Typical breach
  • Loyalty (no secret profit, no conflict) Agent → principal Side commission; self-dealing in the subject matter
  • Obedience Agent → principal Ignoring lawful instructions
  • Care / competence Agent → principal Negligent performance of the assigned work
  • Accounting Agent → principal Commingling or failure to render an account
  • Notification / information Agent → principal Withholding material facts learned in the agency
  • Compensation Principal → agent Nonpayment of an earned fee
  • Reimbursement Principal → agent Leaving the agent to eat authorized outlays
  • Indemnity Principal → agent Refusing to cover liabilities from authorized acts
  • Cooperation Principal → agent Blocking performance or destroying the agency's subject matter
  • Worked scenario: lunch detour versus delivery

Facts. River & Co. employs Sam as a driver. Sam's job is to deliver parts in a company van. On Tuesday, while on a scheduled delivery route, Sam takes a two-block side trip to a drive-through, then continues to the customer. Backing out of the drive-through, Sam negligently hits a parked car. On Thursday, Sam finishes the last delivery at 2:00 p.m., drives 18 miles in the opposite direction to a personal appointment, and, still in the company van, runs a red light and injures a pedestrian.

Analysis.

Tuesday. A two-block lunch stop on an active delivery route is a detour — a minor deviation. Sam is still within the scope of employment. River & Co. is vicariously liable to the parked-car owner under respondeat superior. Sam remains personally liable as the tortfeasor; vicarious liability is additional , not a substitution.

Thursday. An 18-mile trip in the opposite direction for a personal appointment after the day's deliveries is a frolic . River & Co. is not vicariously liable for the red-light injury unless Sam had reasonably returned to the employer's business. The van's logo does not, by itself, recreate scope.

Independent-contractor contrast. If Sam were a true independent courier controlling the manner and means of deliveries, River & Co. generally would not be vicariously liable for either accident, absent a nondelegable or inherently dangerous exception — neither of which a routine parts run is.

Criminal overlay. If Thursday's red light were charged as a crime, that prosecution runs against Sam. River & Co. is not a criminal defendant merely because it owns the van.

Notice overlay. If a customer handed Sam a written rejection of nonconforming parts during the Tuesday delivery, River & Co. has notice when Sam receives the writing. The firm cannot claim it never heard because Sam stuffed the paper in the visor.

Contract-side drills on who is bound sit in 5.1 . Additional REG application items are at /practice/cpa-reg .