Study guide

6.2 Performance and Discharge

AICPA CPA Exam — Regulation REG

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Format, Scoring, and Skill Levels 1.3 New Pronouncements and OBBBA Testing Policy 1.4 Study Strategy and Task-Based Simulations

2 Circular 230 and Tax Return Preparers

2.1 Practice Before the IRS under Circular 230 2.2 Diligence, Written Advice, Fees, and Records 2.3 Tax Return Preparer Identification and Penalties

3 Licensing, Audits, Appeals, and Disclosure

3.1 State Board Licensing and Disciplinary Systems 3.2 IRS Audits, Appeals, and the Judicial Process 3.3 Substantiation, Disclosure, and FBAR Reporting

4 Penalties, Hierarchy, and Legal Duties

4.1 Taxpayer Penalties 4.2 Tax Law Authoritative Hierarchy 4.3 Common Law Duties, Privilege, and Confidentiality

5 Agency Law

5.1 Authority of Agents and Principals 5.2 Duties and Liabilities of Agents and Principals

6 Contracts

6.1 Contract Formation 6.2 Performance and Discharge 6.3 Breach and Remedies

7 Debtor-Creditor Relationships

7.1 Suretyship, Guarantors, and Debtor-Creditor Rights 7.2 UCC Article 9 Attachment, Perfection, and Priority

8 Employment Taxes and Worker Classification

8.1 Federal Employment Taxes 8.2 Employee versus Independent Contractor

9 Bankruptcy, Health Plans, and FCPA

9.1 Bankruptcy Types and Discharge 9.2 Qualified Health Plans and the ACA 9.3 Foreign Corrupt Practices Act

10 Business Structure under State Law

10.1 Selection, Formation, Operation, and Termination 10.2 Rights, Duties, Obligations, and Authority of Owners and Management

11 Basis of Tangible Assets

11.1 Cost Basis and Conversion from Personal Use 11.2 Gift Basis under §1015 11.3 Inherited Basis under §1014

12 Wash Sales and Intangible Basis

12.1 Wash-Sale Basis Adjustments 12.2 Organization, Start-Up, and Loan Cost Basis

13 Cost Recovery

13.1 MACRS Recovery Periods and Conventions 13.2 Section 179 and Bonus Depreciation 13.3 Amortization of Intangibles

14 Individual Gross Income

14.1 Gross Income Inclusions 14.2 Gross Income Exclusions 14.3 Capital Gains, Holding Period, and Virtual Currency

15 Pass-Through Reporting, AGI, and Deductions

15.1 Reporting Items from Pass-Through Entities 15.2 Adjustments to Arrive at AGI 15.3 Standard versus Itemized Deductions 15.4 Qualified Business Income Deduction §199A

16 Loss Limitations and Filing Status

16.1 Capital Loss Netting and Ordinary Business Loss Limits 16.2 Hobby, Wash-Sale, and Personal-Use Loss Disallowance 16.3 Filing Status and Dependents

17 Tax Computation and Credits

17.1 Regular Tax and Net Investment Income Tax 17.2 Refundable and Nonrefundable Credits 17.3 Estimated Tax and Safe Harbors

18 C Corporations and Book-Tax Differences

18.1 Permanent vs Temporary Differences; Schedules M-1 and M-3 18.2 C Corporation Taxable Income and Special Deductions 18.3 C Corporation NOLs, Capital Losses, Credits, and Tax 18.4 State and Local Tax: Nexus, Allocation, Apportionment

19 S Corporations

19.1 Eligibility and Election 19.2 Ordinary Income, Separately Stated Items, and AAA 19.3 Shareholder Stock and Debt Basis

20 Partnerships, LLCs, and Tax-Exempt Organizations

20.1 Partnership Ordinary Income and Separately Stated Items 20.2 Partner's Outside Basis and Partnership Liabilities 20.3 LLC Tax Classification 20.4 Types of Tax-Exempt Organizations

6.2 Performance and Discharge

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

A condition precedent must occur before a duty arises; concurrent conditions are due at the same time; a condition subsequent cuts off an already-arisen duty.

Common-law construction contracts are satisfied by substantial performance; UCC §2-601 requires perfect tender of goods, subject to the seller's right to cure under §2-508.

A contract is discharged by complete performance or proper tender, by agreement (rescission, novation, accord and satisfaction, release, waiver), by impossibility, impracticability, or frustration of purpose, or by operation of law (bankruptcy, statute of limitations).

Under UCC §2-509, FOB origin (shipment) passes risk of loss when conforming goods are duly delivered to the carrier; FOB destination passes risk on due tender at the named destination.

Rights are generally assignable and duties generally delegable, but a delegator remains liable unless the obligee agrees to a novation that releases the original party.

Last updated: August 2026

6.2 Performance and Discharge

A formed contract still has to be performed or discharged. REG Blueprint II.B.2 tests whether both parties fulfilled their performance obligations and, if not, whether the contract is nonetheless discharged. Formation rules stay in /study-guides/cpa-reg/contracts/contract-formation ; this section assumes a contract exists.

Conditions

A condition is an event, not certain to occur, that must occur before a duty becomes due, or that extinguishes a duty.

Condition precedent. Must occur before a duty arises. "Payment is due when the architect issues a certificate" — the certificate is a condition precedent to the owner's duty to pay. If the condition never occurs, the duty never arises, unless the party who would benefit wrongfully prevents it.

Concurrent conditions. Each party's performance is due at the same time; each is a condition of the other. In a cash sale of goods, tender of the goods and tender of the price are concurrent.

Condition subsequent. An event that cuts off an already-arisen duty. "Liability ends if the buyer does not give written notice of defect within 10 days of delivery." Failure to give notice discharges the seller's remaining duty on that claim.

Express conditions require strict compliance. Constructive (implied-in-law) conditions of exchange are satisfied by substantial performance at common law, which is why construction cases come out the way they do.

Substantial performance versus perfect tender

Common law — substantial performance. In construction and other service contracts, a party who has substantially performed — a good-faith effort that leaves only a relatively small, compensable defect — has a right to the contract price minus damages for the defect. The owner may not walk away from a 95%-complete building because a fixture is the wrong brand, unless the defect is material (wrong location, unsafe structure, a different building). Material failure to perform is a total breach and discharges the other party's remaining duties.

UCC §2-601 — perfect tender. Unless otherwise agreed, if the goods or the tender of delivery fail in any respect to conform to the contract, the buyer may reject the whole, accept the whole, or accept any commercial unit and reject the rest. "Close enough" is not the goods rule.

UCC §2-508 — cure. Perfect tender is not a trap with no exit. If the time for performance has not expired, a seller whose tender is rejected as nonconforming may seasonably notify the buyer of an intention to cure and may then make a conforming delivery within the contract time . If the seller had reasonable grounds to believe the nonconforming tender would be acceptable (with or without a money allowance), the seller may have a further reasonable time to substitute a conforming tender after seasonable notice. Installment contracts (§2-612) use a substantial-impairment test, not perfect tender, for rejecting a single installment.

Anticipatory repudiation

Anticipatory repudiation is a party's definite statement or voluntary act, before performance is due, indicating that the party will not perform. A vague expression of doubt is not enough; a clear "we will not ship" or a sale of unique subject matter to someone else is. The nonrepudiating party may:

  • treat the repudiation as an immediate total breach and sue,
  • wait for the performance date (and urge retraction), or

suspend its own performance and demand adequate assurance (UCC §2-609; a commercially reasonable analog is used at common law).

A repudiation can be retracted until the other party has materially changed position or indicated that the repudiation is treated as final. Continuing to perform after a clear repudiation creates mitigation problems developed in /study-guides/cpa-reg/contracts/breach-remedies .

Ways a contract is discharged

REG's representative task lists performance, agreement, and operation of law. Teach the catalog:

Method What it is REG trap

Performance Complete performance of all duties Substantial performance still discharges the builder's remaining construction duty, with a damages offset

Tender An offer of complete performance that the other party refuses Proper tender discharges the tendering party's duty to do more; it does not, by itself, pay the contract price. The refusing party is in breach

Mutual rescission Both parties agree to cancel remaining executory duties If one side has fully performed, a rescission needs new consideration

Novation A new party is substituted and the original obligor is released Assignment or delegation without a release is not a novation

Accord and satisfaction Accord = agreement to take a different performance; satisfaction = carrying it out Until satisfaction, the original duty is only suspended, not discharged

Release A writing discharging a claim, typically for consideration An oral "forget about it" is a waiver question, not a release

Waiver Voluntary relinquishment of a known right Can be inferred from conduct; may be retracted as to future duties if the other party has not relied

Impossibility Objective impossibility: destruction of identified subject matter, death in a personal-services contract, later illegality "More expensive than I thought" is not impossibility

Impracticability UCC §2-615 and the common-law analog: an unforeseen contingency, the non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption, makes performance impracticable A market-price swing the seller could have hedged is usually the seller's problem

Frustration of purpose Performance is still possible, but the principal purpose known to both parties is destroyed Hall rental for a cancelled event; a tax-law change that merely makes a deal less profitable is usually not enough

Operation of law Bankruptcy discharge of the contractual duty; statute of limitations barring the remedy Discharge in bankruptcy is a defense, not a statement that the contract never existed. Limitations bar the suit. Bankruptcy types are covered in /study-guides/cpa-reg/bankruptcy-aca-fcpa/bankruptcy

UCC risk of loss — §2-509, FOB origin versus destination

Blueprint Area II includes UCC contracts, so risk of loss is in scope even though it sits next to performance rather than formation.

If the contract requires or authorizes the seller to ship by carrier :

Shipment contract / FOB origin (FOB seller's city). The seller's job is to put conforming goods into the carrier's possession and make a reasonable contract for transportation (§2-504). Risk of loss passes to the buyer when the goods are duly delivered to the carrier (§2-509(1)(a)), even if the seller reserves a security interest. If the truck burns on the highway, the buyer bears the loss and still owes the price (unless the seller was in breach — then §2-510 keeps risk on the seller).

Destination contract / FOB destination (FOB buyer's city). The seller must transport to the named destination and tender there. Risk passes when the goods are duly tendered at destination so the buyer can take delivery (§2-509(1)(b)).

If there is no carrier term and the seller is a merchant , risk passes on the buyer's receipt of the goods; if the seller is a nonmerchant, risk passes on tender of delivery (§2-509(3)). Absence of an FOB term is generally treated as a shipment contract. FOB is a delivery and risk term under §2-319, not a title-magic word. REG will name a city. If it is the seller's city, think shipment. If it is the buyer's city, think destination.

Assignment and delegation

Assignment transfers rights . Contract rights are generally assignable. Exceptions: a right that is personal to the obligee, an assignment that would materially change the obligor's duty or increase the burden or risk, or a valid anti-assignment clause (under the UCC, a clause barring assignment of the right to payment is generally ineffective as to that assignment). The assignee steps into the assignor's shoes and takes subject to defenses.

Delegation transfers duties . Duties are generally delegable unless they involve the personal skill, judgment, or reputation of the delegator (a portrait painter, a particular surgeon, a named expert). The delegator remains liable after a delegation. Only a novation — the obligee's agreement to release the original party and look solely to the new one — discharges the delegator.

An assignment of "the contract" is generally both an assignment of rights and a delegation of duties. Do not confuse this with Article 9 security interests in accounts; those are the next chapter, /study-guides/cpa-reg/debtor-creditor/ucc-article-9 , and they are not this topic.

Worked scenario: builder 95% complete with a small defect

Facts. Northridge Construction agrees, in a written common-law contract, to build an office annex for $800,000, completion June 1. Specifications call for a particular grade of interior door hardware. Northridge finishes on May 28. An inspector finds that three interior doors have a commercially equivalent but different hardware set that can be swapped for $2,400 in parts and labor. The annex is occupied and used. The owner has paid $600,000 on progress bills and now refuses to pay the $200,000 balance, claiming perfect tender and material breach. Northridge sues for the balance.

Analysis.

This is a services/construction contract, not a sale of goods. UCC §2-601 perfect tender does not apply.

Northridge has substantially performed . The annex is complete and usable. The hardware deviation is small relative to an $800,000 job and is curable for $2,400. There is no indication of bad faith.

The owner's remaining duty to pay is not discharged . Northridge is entitled to the contract price minus damages for the defect: $800,000 − $2,400 − $600,000 already paid = $197,600 , plus or minus any other proven defect damages.

If the defect had been a structural failure that made the annex unsafe, or a willful refusal to follow a specification that went to the essence of the bargain, the breach would be material . The owner could then treat the contract as at an end, refuse the balance, and pursue cost-of-completion and other remedies (next section).

If this had been a sale of 1,000 specified doors rather than a construction job, the buyer could have rejected the nonconforming lot under §2-601, subject to the seller's §2-508 cure if time remained or if the seller reasonably believed the substitute hardware would be acceptable.

The exam move is to classify the contract first, then decide substantial performance versus perfect tender. Money remedies after a breach are in /study-guides/cpa-reg/contracts/breach-remedies . Additional scenario drills: /practice/cpa-reg .

Loading diagram... UCC §2-509 risk of loss on carrier contracts