Study guide

Evaluation and Management (E/M) Guidelines & Medical Decision Making (MDM) Scoring

CPMA Certified Professional Medical Auditor Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Medical Auditing Foundations & Exam Structure

About the CPMA Exam & AAPC Certification Standards Fundamentals of Medical Auditing vs. Medical Coding Types of Audits: Internal, External, Retrospective, and Prospective

2 Chapter 2: Audit Planning, Sampling Methodology, and Scope

Defining Audit Objectives, Scope, and Benchmarks Sampling Methodologies: Random, Stratified, Convenience, and Targeted Statistical Sampling, Error Rate Calculation, and Financial Extrapolation

3 Chapter 3: Clinical Documentation & E/M Auditing

Medical Record Documentation Standards and Key Requirements Evaluation and Management (E/M) Guidelines & Medical Decision Making (MDM) Scoring E/M Time-Based Coding and Prolonged Services Validation CPT Procedure Coding & Operative Note Audit Techniques

4 Chapter 4: Diagnosis Alignment, Modifiers & Surgical Edits

ICD-10-CM Diagnosis Coding & Medical Necessity Alignment HCPCS Level II & Modifier Validation (Modifiers 25, 59, 57, 24, XE/XP/XS/XU) Surgical Global Package Auditing and NCCI PTP/MUE Edits

5 Chapter 5: Regulatory Compliance, Legal Risk, and Federal Guidelines

Federal Healthcare Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Laws (FCA, Anti-Kickback, Stark Law) OIG Compliance Program Guidance and Annual Work Plans Overpayment Identification, Self-Disclosure Protocols, and 60-Day Rule HIPAA Privacy, Security, and Minimum Necessary Standards in Auditing Government Audit Programs: RAC, MAC, CERT, ZPIC/UPIC, and MIC

6 Chapter 6: Reporting Audit Results, Provider Education, and Remediation

Audit Workpapers, Evidence Documentation, and Findings Analysis Structuring the Formal Audit Report and Executive Summary Provider Feedback Sessions, Communication Strategies, and Education Designing Corrective Action Plans (CAPs) and Monitoring Controls Re-Auditing Workflows, Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), and Sustained Compliance

Evaluation and Management (E/M) Guidelines & Medical Decision Making (MDM) Scoring

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Following the 2021 and 2023 CPT revisions, Evaluation and Management (E/M) code selection for office, outpatient, inpatient, observation, and emergency department visits is determined strictly by Medical Decision Making (MDM) or Total Time.

MDM scoring evaluates three core elements: Number and Complexity of Problems Addressed, Amount and/or Complexity of Data Reviewed and Analyzed, and Risk of Complications and/or Morbidity or Mortality.

To achieve a specific level of MDM (Straightforward, Low, Moderate, High), the clinical documentation must meet or exceed the minimum threshold requirements for at least 2 of the 3 MDM elements.

Data Category scoring requires strict differentiation: ordering and reviewing the same test during an encounter counts as one unique item, and tests separately billed by the provider cannot be counted toward MDM Data.

Social Determinants of Health (SDOH) can escalate the Risk element to Moderate MDM only when documentation demonstrates that SDOH significantly limited diagnosis or treatment decisions.

Last updated: July 2026

Evaluation and Management (E/M) Guidelines & Medical Decision Making (MDM) Scoring

The Evaluation and Management (E/M) coding framework underwent landmark revisions in 2021 (for Office and Outpatient codes 99202–99215) and 2023 (for Facility, Inpatient, Observation, Emergency Department, Nursing Facility, and Domiciliary codes 99221–99239, 99281–99285, etc.). These changes eliminated the historical requirement to score History and Physical Examination elements (such as HPI, ROS, PFSH, and exam body areas) to select code levels. While a medically appropriate history and physical exam must still be performed and documented, final E/M code selection is driven strictly by Medical Decision Making (MDM) OR Total Time .

Audit Warning: Auditors must no longer downcode an E/M encounter simply because a multi-system Review of Systems (ROS) or comprehensive physical exam was omitted, provided the documented history and examination were medically appropriate for the patient's presenting clinical condition.

The Three Elements of Medical Decision Making (MDM)

CPT defines Medical Decision Making as the process in which a physician or qualified healthcare professional (QHP) establishes diagnoses, assesses the severity of health problems, and chooses management options. MDM is evaluated across three core elements:

Element 1: Number and Complexity of Problems Addressed

To count toward MDM, a problem must be addressed during the encounter. A problem is addressed when it is evaluated or treated by the reporting provider (e.g., ordering tests, prescribing meds, monitoring, or deciding on watchful waiting). Problems noted in past medical history that require no evaluation or management do NOT count.

Minimal: 1 self-limited or minor problem (e.g., cold, localized rash, small insect bite).

Low: 2 or more self-limited or minor problems; 1 stable chronic illness (e.g., well-controlled hypertension on maintenance meds); 1 acute, uncomplicated illness or injury (e.g., uncomplicated cystitis, minor ankle sprain).

Moderate: 1 or more chronic illnesses with exacerbation, progression, or side effects of treatment (e.g., poorly controlled asthma flare); 2 or more stable chronic illnesses; 1 undiagnosed new problem with uncertain prognosis (e.g., breast lump requiring biopsy); 1 acute illness with systemic symptoms (e.g., pyelonephritis, lobar pneumonia); 1 acute complicated injury (e.g., concussion with loss of consciousness).

High: 1 or more chronic illnesses with severe exacerbation, progression, or side effects of treatment (e.g., acute decompensated heart failure); 1 acute or chronic illness or injury that poses a threat to life or bodily function (e.g., acute myocardial infarction, pulmonary embolism, severe sepsis).

Element 2: Amount and/or Complexity of Data to Be Reviewed and Analyzed

Data scoring evaluates the cognitive effort involved in reviewing external medical records, ordering tests, and consulting external experts. Data is categorized into three distinct categories:

Category 1: Tests, Documents, or Independent Historian(s)

Any combination of 2 items (Low Data) or 3 items (Moderate Data) from the following:

Review of prior external note(s) from each unique source.

Review of the result of each unique test.

Ordering of each unique test.

Assessment requiring an independent historian (e.g., parent, caregiver, surrogate when patient cannot provide history).

Critical Data Audit Rules:

Ordering vs. Reviewing: Ordering a test and reviewing its result during the same encounter counts as ONE unique test/item , not two.

Separately Billed Tests: Any test that is separately billed by the reporting provider (e.g., ECG 93000 performed in clinic) CANNOT be counted toward MDM Data scoring.

Category 2: Independent Interpretation of Tests

Independent interpretation of a test performed by another physician/QHP (not separately reported).

Category 3: Discussion of Management or Test Interpretation

Discussion of management or test interpretation with an external physician or other QHP or appropriate source (not separately reported).

Element 3: Risk of Complications and/or Morbidity or Mortality

Risk measures the potential severity of adverse outcomes associated with the diagnostic tests and treatment options chosen at the visit:

Minimal Risk: Rest, OTC medications, minor dressing changes.

Low Risk: OTC drugs at prescription strength, physical therapy, minor surgery without identified risk factors.

Moderate Risk:

Prescription drug management (initiating, modifying, or continuing prescription medications).

Decision regarding minor surgery with identified patient/procedure risk factors.

Decision regarding elective major surgery without identified risk factors.

Diagnosis or treatment significantly limited by Social Determinants of Health (SDOH) (e.g., economic hardship, food insecurity, housing instability impacting treatment compliance).

High Risk:

Drug therapy requiring intensive monitoring for toxicity (e.g., warfarin requiring routine INR monitoring, IV chemotherapy, lithium requiring serum levels).

Decision regarding elective major surgery with identified risk factors.

Decision regarding emergency major surgery.

Decision regarding hospitalization or escalation of hospital-level care.

Decision not to resuscitate or to de-escalate care due to poor prognosis.

The 2-Out-of-3 MDM Scoring Rule and Audit Matrix

To determine the final MDM level, the documentation must satisfy or exceed the required scoring thresholds for at least 2 out of the 3 MDM elements .

  • Final MDM Level Code Level (Office Estab / New) Problem Complexity Data Complexity Management Risk
  • Straightforward 99212 / 99202 Minimal Minimal / None Minimal
  • Low 99213 / 99203 Low Low (Cat 1: 2 items) Low
  • Moderate 99214 / 99204 Moderate Moderate (1 of 3 Cats) Moderate
  • High 99215 / 99205 High High (2 of 3 Cats) High
  • Case Study Audit Calculation

An established patient presents with poorly controlled Type 2 Diabetes (Moderate Problem) and hypertension. The physician orders a CBC and CMP (2 Category 1 Data items = Low Data). The physician adjusts the insulin dosage (Prescription Drug Management = Moderate Risk).

  • Problem Complexity: Moderate
  • Data Complexity: Low
  • Management Risk: Moderate

Audit Outcome: Applying the 2-out-of-3 rule, 2 elements (Problem and Risk) reach the Moderate level. The final MDM score is Moderate , supporting CPT code 99214 .