Study guide
4.4 Multiaxial Yield Criteria & Combined-Load Analysis of Welded Members
AWS CWEng Certified Welding Engineer Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & CWEng Exam Overview
About the CWEng Exam: Four Parts, 163 Questions & Testing Logistics Scoring, Composite Weighting, Eligibility & Five-Year Renewal How to Use This Guide & Build Your Open-Book Reference Set
2 Chapter 1: Mathematics & Statistics for Welding Engineers
1.1 Engineering Mathematics: Algebra, Trigonometry & Geometry in Weldments 1.2 Differential & Integral Calculus Fundamentals in Engineering Analysis 1.3 Applied Engineering Statistics, Population Distributions & Quality Metrics 1.4 Polynomial Equations, Conic Sections & Complex Numbers
3 Chapter 2: Physics Fundamentals & Mechanics
2.1 Unit Systems, Dimensional Analysis & Engineering Conversions 2.2 Mechanics: Statics, Equilibrium, Force Vectors & Moments 2.3 Work, Energy, Power & Mechanical Advantage in Welding Systems 2.4 Thermal Physics, Linear/Volumetric Expansion & Heat Capacity
4 Chapter 3: General & Physical Chemistry for Welding
3.1 Atomic Structure, Bonding & Solid-Solution Thermodynamics 3.2 Hume-Rothery Compatibility, Interstitial Strain & HSLA Microalloy Scavenging 3.3 Gas Laws, Dalton Partial Pressures, Arc Dissociation & Sieverts Law 3.4 Cylinder Capacity, Available Arc Time & Gas-Related Porosity Diagnosis 3.5 Redox Thermodynamics, Deoxidation & Slag-Metal Refining 3.6 Basicity Index Calculations, Toughness Prediction & Cryogenic Consumable Selection
5 Chapter 4: Strength of Materials & Mechanics of Materials
4.1 Engineering vs. True Stress-Strain, Elastic Constants & Z-Direction Ductility 4.2 Plane Stress vs. Plane Strain, Triaxial Restraint & Alloy Property Comparison 4.3 Beam Bending, Transverse Shear, Torsion & Mohr Circle Construction 4.4 Multiaxial Yield Criteria & Combined-Load Analysis of Welded Members 4.5 Fatigue Life, Weld-Toe Stress Concentration & Paris-Erdogan Crack Growth 4.6 LEFM Fracture Toughness, Ductile-Brittle Transition & Larson-Miller Creep 4.7 Comparative Failure-Mode Synthesis & Integrated Flaw and Creep Assessment
6 Chapter 5: Heat Transfer & Fluid Mechanics in Welding
5.1 Fourier Conduction, Rosenthal Moving Heat Source & 2D vs. 3D Heat Flow 5.2 Adams Cooling Rate, the t8/5 Window & HAZ Peak-Temperature Distribution 5.3 Convection, Stefan-Boltzmann Radiation & Emissivity of Weld Surfaces 5.4 Arc Radiation Losses, Preheat Maintenance & PWHT Boundary Conditions 5.5 Fluid Statics, Bernoulli, Viscosity & Reynolds-Number Regimes 5.6 Gas Lens Mechanics, Buoyancy Effects & Torch Flow Design 5.7 Hyperbaric, Vacuum & Controlled-Atmosphere Welding Environments
7 Chapter 6: Electrical Engineering Principles for Welding Systems
6.1 DC and AC Waveforms, Polarity Thermodynamics & Welding Circuit Analysis 6.2 Joule Heating, Electrode Stickout Preheating & Circuit Voltage Distribution 6.3 Power Factor, Reactance, Impedance & Magnetic Transformer Principles 6.4 Lorentz Force, Electromagnetic Pinch Effect & Arc Blow
8 Chapter 7: Welding Heat Sources & Arc Physics
7.1 Volt-Ampere Characteristics, Operating Point, Self-Regulation & OCV Limits 7.2 Inductance, Slope Control & Dynamic Power-Source Response 7.3 Arc Fall Regions, Cathode Emission Mechanisms & Shielding-Gas Ionization 7.4 Maecker Plasma Jet, Degree of Ionization & Anode Heat Partitioning 7.5 Droplet Force Balance & Classification of Metal Transfer Regimes 7.6 Transition Current, Mode Comparison & Pulsed Waveform Design
9 Chapter 8: Arc Welding Processes & Parameter Controls
8.1 Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW): Electrode Flux Chemistries & Variables 8.2 GMAW Process Physics, Transfer Modes & Shielding Gas Interactions 8.3 Solid, Metal-Cored & Flux-Cored Wires with CTWD and Parameter Envelopes 8.4 Gas Tungsten (GTAW) & Plasma Arc Welding (PAW): Electrodes & Keyholing 8.5 Submerged Arc Welding (SAW): Flux Basicity, Multi-Wire & High-Deposition Systems
10 Chapter 9: Advanced, Resistance & Solid-State Joining Processes
9.1 High-Energy-Density Beam Physics & Electron Beam Welding 9.2 Laser Beam Welding, EBW/LBW Comparison & Fiber Laser Parameter Derivation 9.3 Resistance Welding Physics, Electrode Materials & Spot Weld Sequence 9.4 Nugget Sizing, Seam and Projection Welding, and Lobe Curve Process Windows 9.5 Solid-State Joining: Friction Stir Welding (FSW), Explosion & Diffusion 9.6 Thermal Cutting & Gouging: Oxyfuel, Plasma Arc and Air Carbon Arc 9.7 High-Frequency, Flash, Stud & Ultrasonic Welding; Surfacing and Thermal Spray
11 Chapter 10: Physical & Transformation Metallurgy of Steels
10.1 Fe-Fe3C System, Crystal Lattices, c/a Ratio & Interstitial Solubility 10.2 Critical Temperatures, Invariant Reactions & the Lever Rule 10.3 Alloying Elements, the Gamma Loop & Phase-Fraction Calculations 10.4 TTT and CCT Diagrams, Constitutional Supercooling & Scheil Microsegregation 10.5 Non-Equilibrium Transformation Products & Martensite Modeling 10.6 HAZ Anatomy, Microstructural Sub-Zones & Multi-Pass Reheated Regions 10.7 HAZ Hardness Traverses, Toughness Gradients & Peak-Temperature Control
12 Chapter 11: Weldability, Cracking Mechanisms & Alloy Metallurgy
11.1 Hydrogen Cracking Conditions, Carbon Equivalent & Diffusible Hydrogen Control 11.2 Preheat, Interpass and Post-Heat Calculations for Cold-Crack Prevention 11.3 Solidification Cracking, Bead Aspect Ratio, Liquation & Lamellar Tearing 11.4 Lamellar Tearing Mitigation & Hot-Cracking Susceptibility Evaluation 11.5 Stainless Families, Schaeffler and WRC-1992 Diagrams, Ferrite Number & Sensitization 11.6 Duplex Stainless Metallurgy & Dissimilar-Metal Ferrite Prediction 11.7 Aluminum Oxide and Porosity Control, and Titanium Reactive-Metal Welding 11.8 Nickel Superalloys, Strain-Age Cracking & Guinier-Preston Aging Sequences
13 Chapter 12: Weldment Design, Stress Analysis & Joint Mechanics
12.1 AWS A2.4 Welding Symbol Anatomy, Symbol Library & Dimension Syntax 12.2 Joint Architecture, CJP versus PJP, and NDE Examination Symbols 12.3 Fillet and Groove Weld Sizing under Direct Stress in ASD and LRFD 12.4 Plug and Slot Welds, Stress Gradients & the Fillet Weld Break Test 12.5 Eccentric Loading Analysis: Elastic Vector Method vs Instantaneous Center 12.6 Fatigue Design of Welded Connections & Residual Stress/Distortion Control
14 Chapter 13: Non-Destructive Examination (NDE) & Discontinuity Analysis
13.1 Visual Testing Gages & Liquid Penetrant Capillary Mechanics 13.2 Magnetic Particle Testing: Flux Leakage, Field Geometry & Prod Amperage 13.3 Radiographic Physics, Geometric Unsharpness, Density & IQI Sensitivity 13.4 Computed and Digital Radiography & Radiographic Discontinuity Interpretation 13.5 Acoustic Wave Mechanics, Refraction & Angle-Beam Sound-Path Geometry 13.6 AWS D1.1 Decibel Rating, Phased Array & Time-of-Flight Diffraction
15 Chapter 14: Brazing, Soldering & Industrial Welding Safety
14.1 Brazing Thermodynamics, Capillary Wetting Physics & Joint Clearance 14.2 AWS A5.8 Brazing Filler Metals, FB Fluxes & Industrial Heating Processes 14.3 Soldering Fundamentals, Flux Chemistries & Intermetallic Formation 14.4 Hierarchy of Controls, Electric Shock Physics & Industrial Ventilation 14.5 Fume Exposure Limits, Arc Radiation, Hot Work and Confined-Space Entry 14.6 Arc-Generated Toxic Gases, Moving-Equipment Hazards & TWA Exposure Calculation
16 Chapter 15: Structural Fabrication & AWS D1.1 Code Implementation
15.1 AWS D1.1 Scope, Prequalification Limits, Base-Metal Groups & Matching Filler 15.2 Prequalified Joint Details, Backing Systems & Joint Specification Verification 15.3 Thermal Cut Edges, Fit-Up Tolerances & Minimum Preheat Requirements 15.4 Preheat Application Zones, Measurement Instrumentation & Fabrication Audits 15.5 PWHT Fundamentals, D1.1 Thermal Cycles & Visual Acceptance Criteria 15.6 D1.1 Nondestructive Examination Protocols, PWHT Scheduling & Visual Audit Practice
17 Chapter 16: Welding Procedure Qualification (WPS & PQR) per ASME IX & AWS B2.1
16.1 PQR versus WPS Hierarchy, Qualification Workflow & Standard Procedures 16.2 Manufacturer Responsibility, Subcontracting Limits & Multi-Process Qualification 16.3 Essential, Supplementary Essential and Nonessential Variables with Heat Input Mechanics 16.4 Waveform-Controlled Power Sources, Appendix H & Heat-Input Compliance 16.5 P-Numbers, Group Numbers, F-Numbers & A-Numbers 16.6 QW-451 Mechanical Test Protocols & Procedure Qualification Test Evaluation
18 Chapter 17: Filler Metal Specifications, Selection & Consumable Control
17.1 AWS A5 Architecture: SMAW, GMAW/GTAW and FCAW Consumable Classifications 17.2 SAW Wire-Flux Systems, Alloy Pickup & PWHT Property Effects 17.3 Stainless Filler Specifications, Solidification Modes & Dissimilar-Metal Joints 17.4 AWS A5.10 Aluminum Filler Selection & Dilution and Ferrite-Number Calculations 17.5 Consumable Storage, Conditioning Envelopes & Atmospheric Exposure Limits 17.6 Low-Hydrogen Designators, the Yurioka Parameter & Preheat Sizing
19 Chapter 18: Welder Performance Qualification, Quality Management & Welding Economics
18.1 Welder Qualification Philosophy, Test Positions & Thickness and Diameter Ranges 18.2 F-Number Hierarchy, Operator Qualification & Continuity Requirements 18.3 ISO 3834, Welding Coordination, Inspection Test Plans & Equipment Validation 18.4 EN 10204 Material Certification, Traceability & Heat-Input Nonconformance Auditing 18.5 Weld Cost Anatomy, Deposition Rates, Operating Factor & the Overwelding Law 18.6 Economic Optimization Strategies & Fabrication Cost Comparison
4.4 Multiaxial Yield Criteria & Combined-Load Analysis of Welded Members
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The Distortion Energy (von Mises) failure criterion accurately predicts yield under multiaxial loading for ductile metals, establishing a pure shear yield strength τ_y = σ_y / √3 ≈ 0.577σ_y, whereas the Maximum Shear Stress (Tresca) criterion is more conservative at τ_y = 0.50σ_y.
The maximum-shear (Tresca) criterion is always more conservative than the distortion-energy (von Mises) criterion, with the largest divergence occurring in pure shear.
Under pure shear, von Mises predicts yielding at about 0.577 times the uniaxial yield strength, which is the origin of the shear allowables used in weld design codes.
Maximum-normal-stress theory is reserved for brittle materials such as cast iron and hardfacing deposits, where fracture is governed by tensile stress rather than shear.
Combined-load problems must resolve every stress component at the same point on the cross-section before any yield criterion is applied.
Last updated: September 2026
5. Multiaxial Failure Theories for Structural Alloys
When structural weldments endure multiaxial stresses, yield criteria predict the onset of plastic deformation by relating the complex stress tensor to the material's uniaxial tensile yield strength σ y \sigma_y σ y . σ_2 ^
| von Mises Ellipse:
- | σ_1² - σ_1·σ_2 + σ_2² = σ_y²
- +----+----+
/| | |\ Tresca Hexagon:
- / | | | \ Max(|σ_1 - σ_2|, |σ_2 - σ_3|, |σ_3 - σ_1|) = σ_y
- / | | | \
- ----------+---+----+----+---+-----------> σ_1
- \ | | | /
- \ | | | /
- \| | |/
- +----+----+
- |
- 1. Maximum Normal Stress Theory (Rankine)
Criterion: Yielding or fracture occurs when the maximum principal stress reaches the uniaxial tensile strength: σ 1 = σ u t \sigma_1 = \sigma_{ut} σ 1 = σ u t .
Application: Valid only for brittle materials (gray cast iron, ceramics, un-tempered martensite). It completely neglects shear stress and produces dangerously non-conservative predictions for ductile structural steels.
2. Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca / Guest)
Criterion: Yielding occurs when the maximum shear stress equals the shear stress at yield in a uniaxial tensile test ( τ max = σ y / 2 \tau_{\max} = \sigma_y / 2 τ m a x = σ y /2 ): τ abs, max = σ max − σ min 2 ≥ σ y 2 ⟹ σ max − σ min ≥ σ y \tau_{\text{abs, max}} = \frac{\sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}}{2} \ge \frac{\sigma_y}{2} \implies \sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min} \ge \sigma_y τ abs, max = 2 σ m a x − σ m i n ≥ 2 σ y ⟹ σ m a x − σ m i n ≥ σ y
Pure Shear Yield: In pure shear ( σ 1 = τ , σ 2 = − τ , σ 3 = 0 \sigma_1 = \tau, \sigma_2 = -\tau, \sigma_3 = 0 σ 1 = τ , σ 2 = − τ , σ 3 = 0 ), σ 1 − σ 2 = 2 τ = σ y ⟹ τ y = 0.50 σ y \sigma_1 - \sigma_2 = 2\tau = \sigma_y \implies \tau_y = 0.50 \sigma_y σ 1 − σ 2 = 2 τ = σ y ⟹ τ y = 0.50 σ y .
Application: Conservative yield criterion adopted in ASME Section VIII Division 1 and Division 2 (stress intensity method).
3. Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises / Huber-Hencky)
Criterion: Yielding occurs when the distortional strain energy per unit volume ( U d U_d U d ) equals that at yield in uniaxial tension. Distortional energy is the energy required to change shape without changing volume.
General 3D Formulation: σ v M = 1 2 ( σ 1 − σ 2 ) 2 + ( σ 2 − σ 3 ) 2 + ( σ 3 − σ 1 ) 2 ≥ σ y \sigma_{vM} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \sqrt{ (\sigma_1 - \sigma_2)^2 + (\sigma_2 - \sigma_3)^2 + (\sigma_3 - \sigma_1)^2 } \ge \sigma_y σ v M = 2 1 ( σ 1 − σ 2 ) 2 + ( σ 2 − σ 3 ) 2 + ( σ 3 − σ 1 ) 2 ≥ σ y
Plane Stress Formulation ( ( σ x , σ y , τ x y ) (\sigma_x, \sigma_y, \tau_{xy}) ( σ x , σ y , τ x y ) ): σ v M = σ x 2 − σ x σ y + σ y 2 + 3 τ x y 2 ≥ σ y \sigma_{vM} = \sqrt{ \sigma_x^2 - \sigma_x \sigma_y + \sigma_y^2 + 3\tau_{xy}^2 } \ge \sigma_y σ v M = σ x 2 − σ x σ y + σ y 2 + 3 τ x y 2 ≥ σ y
Pure Shear Yield: In pure shear ( σ x = 0 , σ y = 0 , τ x y = τ \sigma_x = 0, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = \tau σ x = 0 , σ y = 0 , τ x y = τ ), σ v M = 3 τ 2 = τ 3 = σ y \sigma_{vM} = \sqrt{3\tau^2} = \tau\sqrt{3} = \sigma_y σ v M = 3 τ 2 = τ 3 = σ y : τ y = σ y 3 ≈ 0.57735 σ y \tau_y = \frac{\sigma_y}{\sqrt{3}} \approx 0.57735 \sigma_y τ y = 3 σ y ≈ 0.57735 σ y
Application: The standard, most accurate criterion for ductile metals (carbon steels, HSLA, stainless steels, aluminum), matching experimental yield data within 1 – 2 % 1\text{--}2\% 1 – 2% .
- 6. Comparative Synthesis of Failure Theories
- Table 4.2-1: Classical Static Failure Theories in Engineering Design
Failure Theory Originator Yield Condition / Governing Formula Predicted Pure Shear Yield τ y \tau_y τ y Primary Application Field Relative Conservatism
Maximum Normal Stress Rankine σ 1 = σ u or σ 3 = − σ u c \sigma_1 = \sigma_u \quad \text{or} \quad \sigma_3 = -\sigma_{uc} σ 1 = σ u or σ 3 = − σ u c τ y = 1.00 σ y \tau_y = 1.00 \sigma_y τ y = 1.00 σ y Brittle weld metals, gray cast iron, ceramics Non-conservative for ductile metals (dangerous)
Maximum Shear Stress Tresca max ( ∣ σ 1 − σ 2 ∣ , ∣ σ 2 − σ 3 ∣ , ∣ σ 3 − σ 1 ∣ ) = σ y \max(\vert\sigma_1 - \sigma_2\vert, \vert\sigma_2 - \sigma_3\vert, \vert\sigma_3 - \sigma_1\vert) = \sigma_y max ( ∣ σ 1 − σ 2 ∣ , ∣ σ 2 − σ 3 ∣ , ∣ σ 3 − σ 1 ∣ ) = σ y τ y = 0.500 σ y \tau_y = 0.500 \sigma_y τ y = 0.500 σ y Pressure vessels (ASME VIII), nuclear components Conservative (yield envelope inscribed in von Mises)
Distortion Energy von Mises 1 2 ∑ ( σ i − σ j ) 2 = σ y \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{\sum(\sigma_i - \sigma_j)^2} = \sigma_y 2 1 ∑ ( σ i − σ j ) 2 = σ y τ y = 0.577 σ y \tau_y = 0.577 \sigma_y τ y = 0.577 σ y Structural steel framing (AISC/AWS), machinery, pipelines Most accurate for ductile metals (15.5% higher shear cap)
Mohr-Coulomb Coulomb σ 1 σ u t − σ 3 σ u c = 1 \frac{\sigma_1}{\sigma_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_3}{\sigma_{uc}} = 1 σ u t σ 1 − σ u c σ 3 = 1 Depends on σ u c / σ u t \sigma_{uc}/\sigma_{ut} σ u c / σ u t Brittle metals with unequal tension/compression strength Standard for cast irons and soil mechanics
7. Comprehensive Worked Numerical Example: Combined Bending, Torsion & Direct Shear on a Welded Cantilever Tube
Problem Statement
A cylindrical boom member in a materials handling rig is fabricated from S355 structural steel tubing ( σ y = 355 MPa \sigma_y = 355\text{ MPa} σ y = 355 MPa ) and welded to a rigid base column with a full-penetration groove weld. The tubular dimensions are:
Outer diameter D o = 120.0 mm D_o = 120.0\text{ mm} D o = 120.0 mm (outer radius c = 60.0 mm c = 60.0\text{ mm} c = 60.0 mm )
Wall thickness t = 6.0 mm t = 6.0\text{ mm} t = 6.0 mm
Inner diameter D i = D o − 2 t = 120.0 − 12.0 = 108.0 mm D_i = D_o - 2t = 120.0 - 12.0 = 108.0\text{ mm} D i = D o − 2 t = 120.0 − 12.0 = 108.0 mm
Cantilever length L = 1.20 m = 1 , 200.0 mm L = 1.20\text{ m} = 1,200.0\text{ mm} L = 1.20 m = 1 , 200.0 mm
At the free end, the boom sustains combined simultaneous loads:
Transverse downward vertical point load P = 12.0 kN = 12 , 000 N P = 12.0\text{ kN} = 12,000\text{ N} P = 12.0 kN = 12 , 000 N
Twisting torque T = 4.50 kN ⋅ m = 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm T = 4.50\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} = 4,500,000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} T = 4.50 kN ⋅ m = 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm
Calculate:
The cross-sectional area A A A , moment of inertia I I I , elastic section modulus S S S , and polar moment of inertia J J J .
The state of stress ( σ x , σ y , τ x y ) (\sigma_x, \sigma_y, \tau_{xy}) ( σ x , σ y , τ x y ) at Point A located on the uppermost outer surface of the tube at the fixed support.
The principal normal stresses σ 1 , σ 2 \sigma_1, \sigma_2 σ 1 , σ 2 , maximum in-plane shear stress τ max \tau_{\max} τ m a x , and principal angle θ p \theta_p θ p at Point A using Mohr's circle.
The von Mises equivalent stress σ v M \sigma_{vM} σ v M and Tresca stress σ Tresca \sigma_{\text{Tresca}} σ Tresca at Point A, and determine the structural factor of safety ( S F SF SF ) against initial yield.
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Compute geometric section properties A = π 4 ( D o 2 − D i 2 ) = π 4 ( 120.0 2 − 108.0 2 ) = π 4 ( 14 , 400.0 − 11 , 664.0 ) = π 4 ( 2 , 736.0 ) = 2 , 148.85 mm 2 A = \frac{\pi}{4} (D_o^2 - D_i^2) = \frac{\pi}{4} (120.0^2 - 108.0^2) = \frac{\pi}{4} (14,400.0 - 11,664.0) = \frac{\pi}{4} (2,736.0) = 2,148.85\text{ mm}^2 A = 4 π ( D o 2 − D i 2 ) = 4 π ( 120. 0 2 − 108. 0 2 ) = 4 π ( 14 , 400.0 − 11 , 664.0 ) = 4 π ( 2 , 736.0 ) = 2 , 148.85 mm 2 I = π 64 ( D o 4 − D i 4 ) = π 64 ( 120.0 4 − 108.0 4 ) = π 64 ( 207 , 360 , 000.0 − 136 , 048 , 896.0 ) = π 64 ( 71 , 311 , 104.0 ) = 3 , 500 , 438.0 mm 4 I = \frac{\pi}{64} (D_o^4 - D_i^4) = \frac{\pi}{64} (120.0^4 - 108.0^4) = \frac{\pi}{64} (207,360,000.0 - 136,048,896.0) = \frac{\pi}{64} (71,311,104.0) = 3,500,438.0\text{ mm}^4 I = 64 π ( D o 4 − D i 4 ) = 64 π ( 120. 0 4 − 108. 0 4 ) = 64 π ( 207 , 360 , 000.0 − 136 , 048 , 896.0 ) = 64 π ( 71 , 311 , 104.0 ) = 3 , 500 , 438.0 mm 4 S = I c = 3 , 500 , 438.0 mm 4 60.0 mm = 58 , 340.63 mm 3 S = \frac{I}{c} = \frac{3,500,438.0\text{ mm}^4}{60.0\text{ mm}} = 58,340.63\text{ mm}^3 S = c I = 60.0 mm 3 , 500 , 438.0 mm 4 = 58 , 340.63 mm 3 J = 2 I = 2 × 3 , 500 , 438.0 = 7 , 000 , 876.0 mm 4 J = 2 I = 2 \times 3,500,438.0 = 7,000,876.0\text{ mm}^4 J = 2 I = 2 × 3 , 500 , 438.0 = 7 , 000 , 876.0 mm 4
Step 2: Determine resultant forces and state of stress at Point A At the fixed root ( x = 0 x = 0 x = 0 ):
Bending moment M = P × L = 12 , 000 N × 1 , 200 mm = 14 , 400 , 000 N ⋅ mm M = P \times L = 12,000\text{ N} \times 1,200\text{ mm} = 14,400,000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} M = P × L = 12 , 000 N × 1 , 200 mm = 14 , 400 , 000 N ⋅ mm
- Torsional torque T = 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm T = 4,500,000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} T = 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm
- Vertical shear force V = 12 , 000 N V = 12,000\text{ N} V = 12 , 000 N
Evaluate stresses at Point A (top extreme fiber, y = + 60.0 mm y = +60.0\text{ mm} y = + 60.0 mm ):
Normal Bending Stress ( σ x \sigma_x σ x ): σ x = M S = 14 , 400 , 000 N ⋅ mm 58 , 340.63 mm 3 = 246.83 MPa ( Tension ) \sigma_x = \frac{M}{S} = \frac{14,400,000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm}}{58,340.63\text{ mm}^3} = 246.83\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Tension}) σ x = S M = 58 , 340.63 mm 3 14 , 400 , 000 N ⋅ mm = 246.83 MPa ( Tension )
Normal Transverse Stress ( σ y \sigma_y σ y ): Unconfined outer surface: σ y = 0 \sigma_y = 0 σ y = 0 .
Transverse Shear Stress ( τ V \tau_V τ V ): At the extreme top fiber, Q = 0 Q = 0 Q = 0 , so vertical shear stress is zero: τ V = 0 \tau_V = 0 τ V = 0 .
Torsional Shear Stress ( τ torsion \tau_{\text{torsion}} τ torsion ): τ x y = T ⋅ c J = 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm × 60.0 mm 7 , 000 , 876.0 mm 4 = 38.57 MPa \tau_{xy} = \frac{T \cdot c}{J} = \frac{4,500,000\text{ N}\cdot\text{mm} \times 60.0\text{ mm}}{7,000,876.0\text{ mm}^4} = 38.57\text{ MPa} τ x y = J T ⋅ c = 7 , 000 , 876.0 mm 4 4 , 500 , 000 N ⋅ mm × 60.0 mm = 38.57 MPa
Thus, the stress state at Point A is: σ x = 246.83 MPa , σ y = 0 , τ x y = 38.57 MPa \sigma_x = 246.83\text{ MPa}, \sigma_y = 0, \tau_{xy} = 38.57\text{ MPa} σ x = 246.83 MPa , σ y = 0 , τ x y = 38.57 MPa .
Step 3: Mohr's circle and principal stresses at Point A σ avg = σ x + σ y 2 = 246.83 + 0 2 = 123.415 MPa \sigma_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} = \frac{246.83 + 0}{2} = 123.415\text{ MPa} σ avg = 2 σ x + σ y = 2 246.83 + 0 = 123.415 MPa R = ( σ x − σ y 2 ) 2 + τ x y 2 = ( 123.415 ) 2 + ( 38.57 ) 2 = 15 , 231.26 + 1 , 487.64 = 16 , 718.90 = 129.30 MPa R = \sqrt{ \left( \frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2} \right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2 } = \sqrt{ (123.415)^2 + (38.57)^2 } = \sqrt{ 15,231.26 + 1,487.64 } = \sqrt{ 16,718.90 } = 129.30\text{ MPa} R = ( 2 σ x − σ y ) 2 + τ x y 2 = ( 123.415 ) 2 + ( 38.57 ) 2 = 15 , 231.26 + 1 , 487.64 = 16 , 718.90 = 129.30 MPa
Principal normal stresses: σ 1 = σ avg + R = 123.415 + 129.30 = 252.72 MPa \sigma_1 = \sigma_{\text{avg}} + R = 123.415 + 129.30 = 252.72\text{ MPa} σ 1 = σ avg + R = 123.415 + 129.30 = 252.72 MPa σ 2 = σ avg − R = 123.415 − 129.30 = − 5.89 MPa ( Compression ) \sigma_2 = \sigma_{\text{avg}} - R = 123.415 - 129.30 = -5.89\text{ MPa} \quad (\text{Compression}) σ 2 = σ avg − R = 123.415 − 129.30 = − 5.89 MPa ( Compression )
Maximum in-plane shear stress: τ max = R = 129.30 MPa \tau_{\max} = R = 129.30\text{ MPa} τ m a x = R = 129.30 MPa
Principal plane angle θ p \theta_p θ p : tan ( 2 θ p ) = 2 τ x y σ x − σ y = 2 × 38.57 246.83 = 77.14 246.83 = 0.3125 ⟹ 2 θ p = 17.35 ∘ ⟹ θ p = 8.68 ∘ \tan(2\theta_p) = \frac{2 \tau_{xy}}{\sigma_x - \sigma_y} = \frac{2 \times 38.57}{246.83} = \frac{77.14}{246.83} = 0.3125 \implies 2\theta_p = 17.35^\circ \implies \theta_p = 8.68^\circ tan ( 2 θ p ) = σ x − σ y 2 τ x y = 246.83 2 × 38.57 = 246.83 77.14 = 0.3125 ⟹ 2 θ p = 17.3 5 ∘ ⟹ θ p = 8.6 8 ∘
Step 4: Failure theories and factor of safety Because σ 1 > 0 \sigma_1 > 0 σ 1 > 0 and σ 2 < 0 \sigma_2 < 0 σ 2 < 0 , the out-of-plane stress σ 3 = 0 \sigma_3 = 0 σ 3 = 0 is the intermediate principal stress ( σ 1 > σ 3 > σ 2 \sigma_1 > \sigma_3 > \sigma_2 σ 1 > σ 3 > σ 2 ).
Tresca (Maximum Shear Stress): σ Tresca = σ 1 − σ 2 = 252.72 − ( − 5.89 ) = 258.61 MPa \sigma_{\text{Tresca}} = \sigma_1 - \sigma_2 = 252.72 - (-5.89) = 258.61\text{ MPa} σ Tresca = σ 1 − σ 2 = 252.72 − ( − 5.89 ) = 258.61 MPa S F Tresca = σ y σ Tresca = 355.0 258.61 = 1.373 SF_{\text{Tresca}} = \frac{\sigma_y}{\sigma_{\text{Tresca}}} = \frac{355.0}{258.61} = 1.373 S F Tresca = σ Tresca σ y = 258.61 355.0 = 1.373
von Mises (Distortion Energy): σ v M = σ x 2 + 3 τ x y 2 = ( 246.83 ) 2 + 3 ( 38.57 ) 2 = 60 , 925.05 + 3 ( 1 , 487.64 ) = 65 , 387.97 = 255.71 MPa \sigma_{vM} = \sqrt{ \sigma_x^2 + 3\tau_{xy}^2 } = \sqrt{ (246.83)^2 + 3(38.57)^2 } = \sqrt{ 60,925.05 + 3(1,487.64) } = \sqrt{ 65,387.97 } = 255.71\text{ MPa} σ v M = σ x 2 + 3 τ x y 2 = ( 246.83 ) 2 + 3 ( 38.57 ) 2 = 60 , 925.05 + 3 ( 1 , 487.64 ) = 65 , 387.97 = 255.71 MPa S F v M = σ y σ v M = 355.0 255.71 = 1.388 SF_{vM} = \frac{\sigma_y}{\sigma_{vM}} = \frac{355.0}{255.71} = 1.388 S F v M = σ v M σ y = 255.71 355.0 = 1.388
Evaluation: The joint is structurally adequate with a factor of safety of 1.39 1.39 1.39 per von Mises and 1.37 1.37 1.37 per Tresca.
- 8. Real-World Engineering Scenarios & Exam Pitfalls
- Industrial Scenario: Torsional Dynamic Failure of an Open Crane Boom
A mobile lattice crane experienced catastrophic collapse during slewing (swinging) with a rated load. The original boom design utilized four main corner chord members braced with welded back-to-back angle latticing forming an open cross-section. Dynamic inertial slewing generated a cyclical torque of 180 kN ⋅ m 180\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m} 180 kN ⋅ m . Because the open latticed section possessed an effective torsional constant J J J less than 1 / 50 1/50 1/50 th of an equivalent closed box, the boom underwent severe warping and out-of-plane twist. The resulting combined flexure, warping torsion, and secondary bending stresses exceeded the yield strength at the chord-to-lattice fillet welds, triggering weld root peeling and total boom failure. The remediation required redesigning the boom with a continuously welded tubular truss (closed space frame) where closed-cell shear flow prevented warping and reduced peak torsional shear stress by 84 % 84\% 84% .
Common Exam Traps
Exam Trap 1: Calculating Absolute Maximum Shear Stress in 3D When finding τ abs, max \tau_{\text{abs, max}} τ abs, max for a plane stress problem where both in-plane principal stresses are tensile ( σ 1 > 0 , σ 2 > 0 \sigma_1 > 0, \sigma_2 > 0 σ 1 > 0 , σ 2 > 0 ), candidates often mistakenly calculate τ max = ( σ 1 − σ 2 ) / 2 \tau_{\max} = (\sigma_1 - \sigma_2)/2 τ m a x = ( σ 1 − σ 2 ) /2 . Because σ 3 = 0 \sigma_3 = 0 σ 3 = 0 , the minimum principal stress is σ 3 \sigma_3 σ 3 , meaning the true 3D maximum shear stress is τ abs, max = ( σ 1 − 0 ) / 2 = σ 1 / 2 \tau_{\text{abs, max}} = (\sigma_1 - 0)/2 = \sigma_1 / 2 τ abs, max = ( σ 1 − 0 ) /2 = σ 1 /2 . Confusing the in-plane circle with the outer 3D circle causes severe under-prediction of maximum shear stress.
Exam Trap 2: Using Flange Width Instead of Web Thickness in Jourawski's Formula When calculating transverse shear stress τ = V Q / ( I t ) \tau = VQ/(It) τ = V Q / ( I t ) in an I-beam, t t t represents the width of the material at the plane of the cut. To find web shear stress, t t t must be the web thickness t w t_w t w . Substituting flange width b f b_f b f underestimates web shear stress by a factor of 10 to 30 10\text{ to }30 10 to 30 .
Exam Trap 3: Confusing Pure Shear Yield Factors Between Tresca and von Mises Exam questions frequently test the exact shear yield multiplier. Under Tresca, τ y = 0.500 σ y \tau_y = 0.500 \sigma_y τ y = 0.500 σ y ( 50 % 50\% 50% of tensile yield). Under von Mises, τ y = σ y / 3 ≈ 0.577 σ y \tau_y = \sigma_y / \sqrt{3} \approx 0.577 \sigma_y τ y = σ y / 3 ≈ 0.577 σ y ( 57.7 % 57.7\% 57.7% of tensile yield). Reversing these factors introduces a 15.5 % 15.5\% 15.5% error.