Study guide

27.5 Court Cases & Precedent

Enrolled Agent EA

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Part 1, Chapter 1: Tax Return Basics & Filing Requirements

1.1 Form 1040 Overview & Structure 1.2 Form 1040-SR for Seniors 1.3 Who Must File (Income Thresholds) 1.4 Filing Deadlines & Extensions (Form 4868) 1.5 Penalties: Failure to File vs. Failure to Pay 1.6 Sources of Tax Information (W-2s, 1099s, K-1s) 1.7 Preparer Due Diligence Requirements 1.8 Amended Returns (Form 1040-X)

2 Part 1, Chapter 2: Filing Status & Dependents

2.1 Single & Married Filing Jointly 2.2 Married Filing Separately 2.3 Head of Household Requirements 2.4 Qualifying Surviving Spouse 2.5 Qualifying Child Test (5 Tests) 2.6 Qualifying Relative Test (4 Tests) 2.7 SSN, ITIN & Residency Status

3 Part 1, Chapter 3: Wages & Employee Compensation

3.1 W-2 Income & Withholding 3.2 Employee vs. Independent Contractor 3.3 1099-NEC, 1099-MISC & 1099-K Reporting 3.4 Fringe Benefits (Taxable vs. Non-Taxable) 3.5 Stock Options (ISO vs. NQSO) 3.6 Special Categories (Clergy, Military, Foreign)

4 Part 1, Chapter 4: Interest, Dividends & Other Income

4.1 Taxable vs. Tax-Exempt Interest 4.2 US Savings Bonds & OID 4.3 Ordinary vs. Qualified Dividends 4.4 Schedule B Requirements 4.5 Rental & Royalty Income Basics 4.6 Alimony, Gambling & Other Income 4.7 Cancelled Debt & Form 1099-C 4.8 Net Operating Loss (NOL)

5 Part 1, Chapter 5: Capital Gains & Property Transactions

5.1 Capital vs. Non-Capital Assets 5.2 Cost Basis Calculation 5.3 Inherited & Gifted Property Basis 5.4 Short-Term vs. Long-Term Gains 5.5 Capital Gains Tax Rates (0%, 15%, 20%) 5.6 Netting & the $3,000 Loss Limit 5.7 Wash Sales & Related Party Rules 5.8 Sale of Primary Residence (Section 121) 5.9 Installment Sales (Form 6252) 5.10 Like-Kind Exchanges (Section 1031)

6 Part 1, Chapter 6: Adjustments to Income

6.1 Educator Expenses & HSA Contributions 6.2 Self-Employment Tax Deduction 6.3 IRA Contributions (Traditional) 6.4 Student Loan Interest Deduction 6.5 Alimony Paid (Pre-2019 Divorces) 6.6 Other Adjustments & New OBBBA Deductions (Tips, Overtime, Auto Loan, Senior Bonus)

7 Part 1, Chapter 7: Deductions (Standard & Itemized)

7.1 Standard Deduction by Filing Status 7.2 Medical & Dental Expenses (7.5% Floor) 7.3 State & Local Taxes (SALT $40K Cap) 7.4 Mortgage Interest Deduction 7.5 Charitable Contributions 7.6 Casualty & Theft Losses 7.7 QBI Deduction (Section 199A)

8 Part 1, Chapter 8: Tax Calculation & Credits

8.1 Tax Tables & Rate Schedules 8.2 Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) 8.3 Self-Employment Tax Calculation 8.4 Child Tax Credit & Additional CTC 8.5 Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) 8.6 Education Credits (AOC & LLC) 8.7 Child & Dependent Care Credit 8.8 Other Credits (Saver's, Premium Tax)

9 Part 1, Chapter 9: Retirement Accounts & Social Security

9.1 Traditional vs. Roth IRA 9.2 401(k), 403(b) & TSP Basics 9.3 SEP-IRA & SIMPLE IRA 9.4 Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) 9.5 Early Withdrawal Penalties & Exceptions 9.6 Social Security Taxation

10 Part 1, Chapter 10: Specialized Individual Returns

10.1 Estate Tax (Form 706) 10.2 Gift Tax (Form 709) 10.3 Foreign Income (Form 2555) 10.4 FBAR & FATCA Reporting 10.5 Farm Income (Schedule F) 10.6 Disaster Area Rules

11 Part 2, Chapter 11: Business Entity Types

11.1 Overview of Entity Types 11.2 State Law vs. Tax Classification 11.3 Entity Selection: Reasonable Comp & QBI 11.4 Form 8832 & Rev. Proc. 2009-41 11.5 LLC Deep Dive: Spouses & EINs 11.6 Changing Status: The 60-Month Rule

12 Part 2, Chapter 12: Starting a Business

12.1 Hobby vs. Business (Profit Motive) 12.2 Employer Identification Number (EIN) 12.3 Tax Year Selection 12.4 Recordkeeping Requirements 12.5 Statute of Limitations 12.6 Related Party Transactions 12.7 Start-Up Costs, Entity Choice & OBBBA Business Changes (2025)

13 Part 2, Chapter 13: Worker Classification & Payroll

13.1 Employee vs. Independent Contractor 13.2 Common Law Test (Behavioral, Financial, Relationship) 13.3 Statutory Employees & Non-Employees 13.4 Form 941 & Payroll Deposits 13.5 Trust Fund Recovery Penalty 13.6 FUTA & Unemployment Taxes

14 Part 2, Chapter 14: Accounting Methods & Income

14.1 Cash vs. Accrual Method 14.2 Hybrid Methods & Changes 14.3 Inventory & COGS 14.4 Gross Receipts & Income Recognition 14.5 Constructive Receipt 14.6 Form 1099 Reporting Requirements 14.7 §163(j) Business Interest Expense Limitation 14.8 §174 Research & Experimental Expenditures

15 Part 2, Chapter 15: Depreciation & Asset Treatment

15.1 MACRS Basics & Recovery Periods 15.2 Mid-Month, Mid-Quarter, Half-Year Conventions 15.3 Section 179 Expense Deduction 15.4 Bonus Depreciation 15.5 Listed Property Rules 15.6 Amortization of Intangibles 15.7 Depletion 15.8 Disposition of Business Assets

16 Part 2, Chapter 16: Business Deductions

16.1 Ordinary & Necessary Test 16.2 Business Travel Expenses 16.3 Business Meals (50% Limitation) 16.4 Business Use of Vehicle 16.5 Home Office Deduction 16.6 Business Interest Limitation (163(j)) 16.7 Business Bad Debts

17 Part 2, Chapter 17: Business Credits & Fringe Benefits

17.1 General Business Credit Overview 17.2 R&D Credit & Disabled Access Credit 17.3 Small Employer Health Insurance Credit 17.4 Fringe Benefit Rules 17.5 Cafeteria Plans (Section 125) 17.6 Achievement Awards & Other Benefits

18 Part 2, Chapter 18: Sole Proprietorships

18.1 Schedule C Overview 18.2 Calculating Net Profit/Loss 18.3 Self-Employment Tax (Schedule SE) 18.4 Estimated Tax Payments 18.5 Hobby Loss Rules

19 Part 2, Chapter 19: Partnerships

19.1 Partnership Formation 19.2 Partner's Basis Calculation 19.3 Form 1065 Overview 19.4 Schedule K-1 (Partner's Share) 19.5 Guaranteed Payments 19.6 Partnership Distributions 19.7 At-Risk & Passive Activity Rules 19.8 Partnership Termination & Liquidation

20 Part 2, Chapter 20: C Corporations

20.1 Form 1120 Overview 20.2 Corporate Tax Rate (21%) & CAMT 20.3 Accumulated Earnings Tax 20.4 Dividends Received Deduction 20.5 Earnings & Profits (E&P) 20.6 Corporate Distributions, Dividends & Stock Redemptions 20.7 §351 Transfers, §1032, §1202 QSBS & Other Corporate Provisions 20.8 Corporate Liquidation

21 Part 2, Chapter 21: S Corporations

21.1 S Election Requirements (Form 2553) 21.2 Form 1120-S Overview 21.3 Shareholder Basis Calculation 21.4 Reasonable Compensation 21.5 S Corporation Distributions 21.6 Built-In Gains Tax & Termination

22 Part 2, Chapter 22: Specialized Business Returns

22.1 Trusts & Estates (Form 1041) 22.2 Simple vs. Complex Trusts 22.3 Distributable Net Income (DNI) 22.4 Tax-Exempt Organizations (Form 990) 22.5 Retirement Plans (Form 5500) 22.6 Qualified Retirement Plans Overview 22.7 Farm Taxation 22.8 Rental Real Estate Activities

23 Part 3, Chapter 23: Practice Before the IRS

23.1 What is Practice Before the IRS? 23.2 Who Can Practice (Full Rights) 23.3 Limited Practice Rights (AFSP, Unenrolled) 23.4 Special Relationships (Family, Employees) 23.5 PTIN Requirements 23.6 Circular 230 Overview 23.7 Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR)

24 Part 3, Chapter 24: Becoming & Maintaining EA Status

24.1 Two Paths to EA (Exam vs. IRS Experience) 24.2 Application Process (Form 23) 24.3 Background & Compliance Checks 24.4 Renewal Requirements (Form 8554) 24.5 Continuing Education Requirements 24.6 Inactive Status & Termination

25 Part 3, Chapter 25: Practitioner Duties (Circular 230)

25.1 Due Diligence Requirements 25.2 Knowledge of Client's Omission 25.3 Conflict of Interest Rules 25.4 Fee Requirements (Contingent, Unconscionable) 25.5 Advertising & Solicitation Rules 25.6 Tax Return Position Standards 25.7 Written Advice Standards 25.8 Sanctions & Penalties for Violations

26 Part 3, Chapter 26: Power of Attorney & Authorization

26.1 Form 2848 (Power of Attorney) 26.2 CAF (Centralized Authorization File) 26.3 Form 8821 (Tax Information Authorization) 26.4 Third-Party Designee 26.5 Signing Returns for Taxpayers 26.6 Client Confidentiality & Privilege 26.7 Representing Clients in Audits (Examination) 26.8 Appealing IRS Decisions 26.9 Collection Representation

27 Part 3, Chapter 27: Legal Authority & Research

27.1 Hierarchy of Tax Authority 27.2 Internal Revenue Code 27.3 Treasury Regulations 27.4 Revenue Rulings & Procedures 27.5 Court Cases & Precedent 27.6 Statutes of Limitations

28 Part 3, Chapter 28: Specific Representation Issues

28.1 Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (TFRP) 28.2 Innocent Spouse Relief (Form 8857) 28.3 Injured Spouse Allocation (Form 8379) 28.4 Penalty Abatement (FTA & Reasonable Cause) 28.5 Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) 28.6 Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)

29 Part 3, Chapter 29: Final Review & Exam Strategy

29.1 Exam Structure & Logistics (2026-2027) 29.2 The "Clock" of Representation (Master Deadlines) 29.3 Ethics vs. Law (Sanctions & Penalties) 29.4 Final Mock Review & Exam Strategy

30 Part 3, Chapter 30: Filing Process & E-File

30.1 E-File Requirements (The "More Than 10 Returns" Rule) 30.2 ERO Responsibilities 30.3 EFIN & Application Process 30.4 Form 8879 (Signature Authorization) 30.5 Record Retention & Data Security (WISP) 30.6 Preparer Penalties (Filing Specific)

27.5 Court Cases & Precedent

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

U.S. Tax Court: Only forum where you can sue WITHOUT paying tax first.

District Court: Only forum with a JURY trial.

Court of Federal Claims: Review claims against the US government (pay first).

Tax Court Small Case Division ("S Case"): Disputes ≤ $50,000. No appeal allowed.

Golsen Rule: Tax Court follows the Court of Appeals for the taxpayer's circuit.

Supreme Court decisions are binding on everyone.

Last updated: October 2026

  • Court Cases & Precedent: The Tax Court System
  • Why This Matters for the Exam

Understanding the court system is essential for Part 3 because it determines how taxpayers can challenge IRS decisions. The exam tests your knowledge of which court to use, the differences between them, and how precedent works.

The Three Trial Courts for Tax Cases

When a taxpayer disputes an IRS determination and cannot resolve it through Appeals, they can take the case to court. There are three trial-level options:

  • Factor U.S. Tax Court U.S. District Court Court of Federal Claims
  • Pay First? No ("deficiency" jurisdiction) Yes (refund suit) Yes (refund suit)
  • Jury Trial? No Yes (only court with jury) No

Location Travels nationwide Taxpayer's district Washington, D.C.

  • Judges Tax specialists Generalists Generalists
  • Small Case Option? Yes (≤ $50,000) No No

Appeal Route Court of Appeals for taxpayer's circuit Court of Appeals for taxpayer's circuit Court of Appeals for Federal Circuit

U.S. Tax Court

The Tax Court is the only court where taxpayers can challenge the IRS without paying the disputed tax first . This is called "deficiency" jurisdiction.

Key Characteristics:

90-Day Letter: The taxpayer must receive a Statutory Notice of Deficiency and file a petition within 90 days (150 if abroad).

Judges: 19 presidentially appointed judges, all tax specialists.

Location: Judges travel to cities across the country to hold trials.

Appeals: To the Court of Appeals for the taxpayer's circuit.

Small Tax Case (S Case):

Available for disputes of $50,000 or less per tax year.

Procedures are simplified (less formal).

Decisions are final —no appeal is allowed.

Decisions cannot be cited as precedent.

U.S. District Court

District Court is the only option if the taxpayer wants a jury trial . However, the taxpayer must pay the tax first and then sue for a refund.

Key Characteristics:

Pay First: File a refund claim, wait for denial (or 6 months), then sue.

Jury: Available upon request.

Judges: Generalists (hear all types of federal cases).

Location: Taxpayer's home district.

Appeals: To the Court of Appeals for the taxpayer's circuit.

When to Choose District Court:

Taxpayer wants a jury (may be favorable for sympathetic cases).

The law in the taxpayer's circuit favors the taxpayer's position.

Court of Federal Claims

The Court of Federal Claims hears claims against the federal government, including tax refund suits.

Key Characteristics:

Pay First: Must pay the tax and sue for refund.

No Jury: Bench trial only.

Location: Washington, D.C. (judges may travel).

Appeals: To the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (not the taxpayer's geographic circuit).

When to Choose the Court of Federal Claims:

The law in the Federal Circuit favors the taxpayer's position.

The taxpayer's geographic circuit has unfavorable precedent.

The Appellate System

  • Trial Court Appeals To
  • Tax Court Court of Appeals for taxpayer's circuit
  • District Court Court of Appeals for taxpayer's circuit
  • Court of Federal Claims Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
  • All Courts of Appeals U.S. Supreme Court (certiorari)
  • The Golsen Rule

The Golsen Rule (from Golsen v. Commissioner , 1970) states that the Tax Court will follow the precedent of the Court of Appeals to which the case is appealable —i.e., the circuit where the taxpayer resides.

Example:

A taxpayer in California (9th Circuit) petitions Tax Court.

The 9th Circuit has ruled on the issue.

Under Golsen, the Tax Court will follow the 9th Circuit's ruling, even if the Tax Court disagrees.

Why It Matters:

Forum shopping: If your circuit has favorable precedent, use Tax Court (Golsen applies).

If your circuit has unfavorable precedent, consider the Court of Federal Claims (Federal Circuit may have different precedent).

Precedent Hierarchy

  • Court Binding On
  • U.S. Supreme Court All courts, IRS, and taxpayers
  • Court of Appeals District Courts and Tax Court within that circuit
  • Tax Court (Regular) Not binding on other cases (but persuasive)
  • Tax Court (S Case) Not precedent; cannot be cited
  • District Court Not binding on other cases (but persuasive)
  • Real-World Scenario

Scenario: A taxpayer receives a 90-Day Letter proposing a $40,000 deficiency. They disagree with the IRS.

Option 1: Tax Court – Petition within 90 days without paying. Simple procedure.

Option 2: Wait and Pay – Let assessment happen, pay the tax, file for refund, then sue in District Court (jury) or Court of Federal Claims.

Strategic Consideration: If the taxpayer's circuit (say, 5th Circuit) has ruled against the IRS on this issue, Tax Court may apply Golsen and follow the 5th Circuit. Otherwise, consider whether the Federal Circuit has more favorable law.

On the Exam

Question types to practice on courts and precedent:

  • Forum Questions: "Which court allows litigation without paying first?"
  • Jury Questions: "Which court offers a jury trial?"
  • Golsen Questions: "What does the Golsen Rule require?"
  • S Case Questions: "What is the limit for a Small Tax Case?"

The key is to remember: Tax Court = no pay first, District = jury, Claims = D.C., Golsen = follow taxpayer's circuit.