Study guide

10.3 Step 4: Creating and Innovating Evidence-Based Design Concepts

Evidence-Based Design Accreditation EDAC

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Foundations of Evidence-Based Design

1.1 Definition, History & Core Principles of Evidence-Based Design 1.2 Comparing Evidence-Based Design (EBD) and Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) 1.3 The Eight-Step EBD Process Framework 1.4 Who Benefits from EBD & Which Outcomes It Can Influence

2 Chapter 2: Healthcare Context, Systems Thinking & Leadership

2.1 Macro Healthcare Trends, Demographics & Economic Drivers 2.2 The Healthcare Delivery System: Care Settings, Hospital Types & Networks 2.3 The Systems-Based Approach (Formerly the Environment of Care) 2.4 Organizational Culture, Culture Change & Cross-Cultural Design 2.5 Healthcare Stakeholders, Facility Users & Governance Roles 2.6 Executive Leadership, Project Lifecycle Changes & Succession Planning

3 Chapter 3: Healing Environments, Theory & the EDAC Credential

3.1 Healing Environments, Psycho-Neuro-Immunology & Stress Reduction 3.2 Positive Distractions, Biophilia & Roger Ulrich Landmark Research 3.3 Integrative Medicine & Designing Healing and Therapeutic Environments 3.4 Healthcare Workplace Design, Staff Retention & Fatigue Reduction 3.5 Professional Responsibility, Healthcare Outcomes & the EDAC Credential

4 Chapter 4: Research Fundamentals & Evidence Sources

4.1 The Role of Research in Healthcare Architecture & Design 4.2 Types of Evidence: Internal vs. External Evidence 4.3 Literature Searches, Academic Databases & Search Strategies 4.4 Screening, Extracting & Synthesizing Healthcare Design Literature

5 Chapter 5: Evidence Hierarchies & Critical Appraisal

5.1 The Hierarchy of Evidence: Systematic Reviews to Expert Opinion 5.2 Internal Validity, External Validity & Reliability in EBD 5.3 Research Bias, Confounding Factors & Threat Mitigation 5.4 Step 3: The Critical Interpretation & Appraisal Process

6 Chapter 6: Research Methodologies, Data Analysis & the Research Plan

6.1 Quantitative Research Designs, Metrics & Statistical Significance 6.2 Qualitative Methods, Behavioral Observation & Spatial Mapping 6.3 Mixed Methods, Data Triangulation & Research-to-Design Translation 6.4 The Research Process: Research Questions, Research Plans, Ethics & Reporting

7 Chapter 7: Project Setup & Predesign

7.1 Project Setup: Early Capital Planning, Context & Culture, and the EBD Budget 7.2 Step 1: Defining Evidence-Based Vision, Goals & Objectives 7.3 Participative Design, Charrettes & Advisory Councils 7.4 Functional Programming, Adjacencies & Flow Analysis

8 Chapter 8: Hypotheses, Baselines & the Business Case

8.1 Step 5: Formulating Rigorous, Testable EBD Hypotheses 8.2 Step 6: Planning & Collecting Baseline Performance Measures 8.3 The Business Case for EBD: Capital Costs vs. Operational Life-Cycle 8.4 Prioritizing Design Interventions Under Budget Constraints

9 Chapter 9: Designing for Safety: Risk Assessment, Infection, Falls & Medication Safety

9.1 Attributes of a Safe Environment & the Safety Risk Assessment 9.2 Infection Control, Single-Bed Rooms & Hand-Hygiene Design 9.3 Fall Prevention, Same-Handed Rooms & Bathroom Adjacencies 9.4 Medication Safety, Decentralized Nursing Stations & Workflow

10 Chapter 10: Design Phase: Environmental Factors, Concepts & Mock-Ups

10.1 Healthcare Acoustics, Noise Reduction & Sound Absorption 10.2 Circadian Lighting, Natural Daylight & Visual Performance 10.3 Step 4: Creating and Innovating Evidence-Based Design Concepts 10.4 Step 4 Prototyping: Mock-Ups, Simulation & Iterative Evaluation

11 Chapter 11: Construction, Commissioning & Activation

11.1 Step 7: Monitoring Implementation Fidelity & Guarding EBD Intent 11.2 Commissioning: Verifying the Building Meets EBD Intent Before Occupancy 11.3 Activation Readiness, Transition Planning & Finalizing the POE Research Plan

12 Chapter 12: Post-Occupancy Evaluation & Knowledge Sharing

12.1 Step 8: Post-Occupancy Evaluation Methodology & Timing 12.2 Executing the POE Research Plan, Independent Evaluation & Finalizing the Business Case 12.3 Analyzing POE Data, Isolating Environmental Effects & Mixed Outcomes 12.4 Knowledge Dissemination, Peer Review & Continuous Improvement

10.3 Step 4: Creating and Innovating Evidence-Based Design Concepts

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Step 4 of CHD's eight-step EBD process is to create and innovate evidence-based design concepts from the interpreted evidence.

EDAC study materials list six schematic design tasks: annotate diagrams, document assumptions, update hypotheses, test design concepts, select the best options, and construct mock-ups.

Annotated diagrams communicate the intent behind EBD interventions and link them to expected outcomes.

Testing each design concept against the project's guiding principles gives a consistent way to judge how well it addresses the original goals.

The Design domain of CHD's exam content outline adds coordinating the program with the approved budget, using an information repository, and obtaining milestone approvals from executive leadership and key stakeholders.

Last updated: September 2026

Step 4: Creating and Innovating Evidence-Based Design Concepts

EDAC Core Concept: Step 4 of CHD's eight-step process is to create and innovate evidence-based design concepts . It is where interpreted evidence (Step 3) becomes spatial ideas—and where EBD teams do extra work that typical design teams skip: annotating diagrams, documenting assumptions, updating hypotheses, and testing each concept against the project's guiding principles before choosing a direction.

Where Step 4 Happens in the Project

EDAC study materials describe the research plan, the vision, and the business case being linked during the schematic design and design development phases. During this work:

New design ideas for interventions often emerge.

New hypotheses may come to the team's attention. There may be many, but not all of them need to be researched (Section 8.1).

The research plan continues to be updated with new information, assumptions, and ideas throughout the design phase.

Early in design , the team should make sure the business case clearly states the costs, benefits, and executive support for incorporating EBD.

Design-Domain Tasks in CHD's Current Exam Content Outline

Domain 4 (Design) of the outline expands Step 4 into a set of tasks the interdisciplinary team carries through schematic design and design development.

Coordinate the Program With the Approved Budget

The team coordinates the functional and space programs with the approved budget and develops design diagrams incorporating the accepted EBD concepts and strategies , checking that concepts, strategies, and interventions are consistent with the project goals and objectives, the budget , and the schedule .

Develop, Test, Adjust, and Refine Concepts Using Many Data Sources

The outline lists the information used to develop and refine concepts:

  • Data Source How It Informs Concepts
  • Project vision, goals, and objectives Defines what a concept must achieve
  • Guiding principles and design guidelines Provides the test each concept is scored against
  • Research questions Keeps design choices connected to what will be studied
  • Components of systems-based planning Checks people, systems, and operations, not only the physical space
  • Relevant evidence in the information repository Supplies appraised research and project records
  • Benchmarking Compares options with peer facilities and internal performance
  • Additional literature review and critical evaluation Fills gaps that new ideas reveal
  • User group and key stakeholder input Adds operational knowledge and experience
  • Pilot studies, simulations, and physical and virtual mock-ups Tests ideas before they are built

The team then critically evaluates and incorporates research findings to select the best options for adjacencies, flow, user and staff experiences, safety, building systems, material choices, and structure and finishes .

Record and Synthesize: The Information Repository

The outline calls for recording and synthesizing information in an information repository —an organized, searchable record of evidence, decisions, assumptions, hypotheses, mock-up findings, and stakeholder input. It keeps the link between design strategies and EBD goals visible when people change and value engineering begins. The team also determines the documentation required to illustrate the link between design strategies and the EBD goals .

Techniques for Developing and Documenting Concepts

The outline lists techniques used to develop, evaluate, and document EBD concepts during design development and for future research: user group and key stakeholder input , annotated diagrams , hypotheses , business case development for each design strategy , virtual simulations , and conceptual and structural mock-ups . Research plans prepared for the Institutional Review Board are covered in Section 6.4.

Approvals at Project Milestones

Before proceeding to the next stage of design and documentation, the interdisciplinary team should obtain approval at project milestones from the owner's executive leadership team (governing body) and key stakeholders . Milestone approvals confirm that the direction still supports the vision and budget, and they make later reversals less likely.

The Six Tasks of Schematic Design Development and Evaluation

EDAC Study Guide 3 lists what is important during schematic design development and evaluation:

Task What It Involves Why It Matters

1. Annotate diagrams Label plans and diagrams with the intent behind each EBD intervention and the outcome it targets Annotated diagrams communicate intent and link interventions to expected outcomes, so the reasoning survives handoffs and value engineering

2. Document assumptions Record the assumptions behind design choices Documenting assumptions is typically a qualitative statement that does not need to be specific or quantitative

3. Update hypotheses Refine or add hypotheses as concepts change Keeps Step 5 and the research plan current

4. Test design concepts Evaluate each concept against the guiding principles Provides a consistent method to judge how well each concept addresses the original project goals

5. Select the best options Compare alternatives using explicit criteria Makes trade-offs transparent

6. Construct mock-ups Build physical or virtual prototypes of key spaces The time and money saved later outweigh the up-front cost (Section 10.4) Interpreted evidence (Step 3)

  • │
  • ▼
  • Design concepts ──► annotate diagrams ──► document assumptions ──► update hypotheses
  • │
  • ▼
  • Test each concept against GUIDING PRINCIPLES
  • │
  • ▼
  • Select best options (considering implementation, operations, flexibility,
  • project & operating costs, schedule, systems components, outcomes)
  • │
  • ▼
  • Mock-ups ──► refine ──► design development ──► construction documents
  • Testing Concepts Against Guiding Principles

The guiding principles defined at the start of the project set the goals, serve as a planning framework, and guide decisions (Section 7.2). In Step 4 they become the yardstick: testing each design concept against the project's guiding principles gives the team a consistent evaluation method for deciding to what extent a planning and design concept addresses the original goals.

A simple scoring grid works well:

  • Guiding Principle Concept A Concept B Concept C
  • Patients can see caregivers and caregivers can see patients Strong Moderate Weak
  • Families are supported as partners in care Moderate Strong Moderate
  • Staff walking and interruptions are minimized Strong Weak Moderate
  • Design adapts to future care models Moderate Moderate Strong
  • Selecting the Best Options

Beyond the guiding principles, EDAC study materials list other considerations for choosing among design options:

  • Complexity of implementation
  • Impact on operations and functional programs
  • Long-term flexibility
  • Project costs
  • Operational costs
  • Schedule and timeline
  • Systems-based components, formerly the Environment of Care (Section 2.3)
  • Outcomes

Because the systems-based components act concurrently, a concept that looks best on paper can fail if it ignores operations, systems, or implementation.

Innovation With Evidence

"Create and innovate" does not mean copying a prior project. EBD innovation means:

Starting from the goals and the appraised evidence , not from a favorite precedent.

Combining evidence with expertise and user input —the same triad described in Section 1.2.

Treating new ideas as hypotheses to be tested in mock-ups and, where feasible, measured after occupancy.

Documenting the reasoning meticulously so the links among goals, evidence, and design decisions stay visible.

Exam Watch: High-Yield Traps & Pitfalls

Warning

Trap 1: Assumptions vs. hypotheses. Documenting assumptions is usually qualitative and need not be specific or quantitative; hypotheses are testable predictions.

Warning

Trap 2: What concepts are tested against. Design concepts are tested against the project's guiding principles to see how well they address the original goals.

Warning

Trap 3: Research every idea? Many hypotheses may arise during design, but not all need to be researched.

Loading diagram... Step 4 Workflow: From Evidence to Tested Design Concepts