Study guide

10.4 Performance Measurement: Productivity, KPIs, Wage Systems, and the Balanced Scorecard

FE Industrial and Systems Study Guide Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview, CBT Strategy & Handbook Navigation

1.1 FE Industrial Exam Structure, CBT Logistics, and Pacing 1.2 Using the NCEES FE Reference Handbook and Approved Calculators

2 Chapter 2: Mathematics for Industrial Engineers

2.1 Analytic Geometry, Coordinate Systems, and Trigonometry 2.2 Calculus: Differential, Integral, and Series Approximations 2.3 Linear Algebra: Matrix Operations, Systems of Equations, and Vectors

3 Chapter 3: Engineering Sciences Core

3.1 Thermodynamics Fundamentals and Fluid Flow Principles 3.2 Statics, Dynamics, and Mechanics of Materials Core 3.3 Electrical Circuits, DC/AC Analysis, and Power in Industrial Systems

4 Chapter 4: Ethics and Professional Practice

4.1 NCEES Model Rules of Professional Conduct and Technical Society Ethics 4.2 Engineering Licensure, Public Welfare, and Professional Liability 4.3 Engineering Contracts, Intellectual Property, and Conflicts of Interest

5 Chapter 5: Engineering Economics

5.1 Time Value of Money, Discount Factors, and Equivalence 5.2 Evaluating Alternatives: Present Worth, Equivalent Annual Cost, and IRR 5.3 Incremental Rate of Return, Replacement Analysis, and Break-Even 5.4 Depreciation Methods, MACRS, Income Taxes, and Inflation

6 Chapter 6: Probability Foundations & Distributions

6.1 Basic Probability Concepts, Conditional Probability, and Bayes' Theorem 6.2 Discrete Probability Distributions 6.3 Continuous Probability Distributions

7 Chapter 7: Statistical Inference, Regression & Design of Experiments

7.1 Sampling Distributions, Central Limit Theorem, and Confidence Intervals 7.2 Hypothesis Testing: Means, Proportions, and Variances 7.3 Linear Regression, Correlation Analysis, and Design of Experiments (ANOVA)

8 Chapter 8: Data, Logic, Modeling & Linear Programming

8.1 Optimization Modeling: Decision Variables, Objectives, and Constraints 8.2 Linear Programming: Graphical Solutions and Simplex Fundamentals 8.3 Duality, Sensitivity Analysis, and Integer Linear Programming 8.4 Data, Logic Development, and Analytics

9 Chapter 9: Stochastic Models & Simulation

9.1 Queuing Theory: Little's Law, M/M/1, and Multi-Server Systems 9.2 Discrete-Time Markov Chains: Transition Matrices and Steady-State Probabilities 9.3 Discrete-Event Simulation Principles and Monte Carlo Modeling

10 Chapter 10: Engineering Management, Project Planning & Performance Measurement

10.1 Organizational Structure, Leadership, and Worker Motivation Theories 10.2 Project Management: WBS, Critical Path Method (CPM), PERT, and Crashing 10.3 Earned Value Management (EVM), Decision Trees, and Risk Preference 10.4 Performance Measurement: Productivity, KPIs, Wage Systems, and the Balanced Scorecard

11 Chapter 11: Manufacturing & Production Systems

11.1 Manufacturing Processes, Material Processing, and Tolerancing 11.2 Assembly Line Balancing, Takt Time, Cycle Time, and Throughput 11.3 Sustainable Manufacturing, Waste Minimization, and Life-Cycle Assessment

12 Chapter 12: Production Planning, Inventory Control & Sequencing

12.1 Demand Forecasting Methods and Forecast Error Tracking 12.2 Aggregate Planning, Master Production Scheduling (MPS), and MRP 12.3 Deterministic Inventory Models: EOQ, EPQ, and Safety Stock 12.4 Job Sequencing, Dispatching Rules, and Flow Shop Scheduling

13 Chapter 13: Lean Systems & Theory of Constraints

13.1 Lean Foundations: Value Stream Mapping, Seven Wastes, and 5S 13.2 Pull Systems, Kanban, Just-In-Time (JIT), and SMED Setup Reduction 13.3 Theory of Constraints: Bottleneck Identification and Drum-Buffer-Rope

14 Chapter 14: Facilities Planning & Material Handling

14.1 Facility Location Analysis: Qualitative Factor Rating and Centroid Method 14.2 Facility Layout Design and Flow Analysis 14.3 Material Handling Equipment, Warehousing, and AS/RS

15 Chapter 15: Supply Chain Design & Logistics

15.1 Supply Chain Network Architecture and Transportation Modes 15.2 Distribution Strategies, Cross-Docking, and Vehicle Routing 15.3 The Bullwhip Effect, Risk Pooling, and Supply Chain Coordination

16 Chapter 16: Human Factors & Cognitive Ergonomics

16.1 Cognitive Engineering, Human-Machine Interface, Displays, and Controls 16.2 Anthropometric Principles, Percentile Design, and Biomechanical Posture 16.3 Environmental Ergonomics: Industrial Noise, Lighting, and Heat Stress

17 Chapter 17: Physical Ergonomics & Workplace Safety

17.1 Physical Ergonomics: The NIOSH Manual Lifting Equation 17.2 Cumulative Trauma Disorders and Postural Assessment 17.3 Workplace Safety: OSHA Standards, Hazard Analysis, and Control Hierarchy

18 Chapter 18: Work Design & Measurement

18.1 Methods Engineering, Process Charting, and Principles of Motion Economy 18.2 Direct Stopwatch Time Study: Observed Time, Performance Rating, and Allowances 18.3 Predetermined Time Systems, Work Sampling, and Learning Curves

19 Chapter 19: Quality Management, Six Sigma & Analytical Tools

19.1 Quality Philosophies, Total Quality Management, and Cost of Quality 19.2 Six Sigma DMAIC Methodology and Quality Function Deployment 19.3 The Seven Basic Quality Tools, Root Cause Analysis, and Taguchi Loss Function

20 Chapter 20: Statistical Process Control

20.1 Statistical Process Control Principles, Variation, and Run Rules 20.2 Variable Control Charts: X-bar & R, X-bar & S, and Individual-Moving Range 20.3 Attribute Control Charts: Defectives (p, np) and Defects (c, u)

21 Chapter 21: Process Capability & Acceptance Sampling

21.1 Process Capability Indices and Defect Levels 21.2 Acceptance Sampling Concepts and Operating Characteristic Curves 21.3 Sampling Risks, AQL, LTPD, and Standard Sampling Plans

22 Chapter 22: Systems Engineering & Life-Cycle Management

22.1 The Systems Engineering V-Model, Stakeholder Requirements, and Functional Architecture 22.2 Configuration Management, Interface Control, and Verification & Validation 22.3 Life-Cycle Costing, Maintainability, and System Availability

23 Chapter 23: Reliability Engineering & Risk Analysis

23.1 Reliability Mathematics, Hazard Rates, and the Bathtub Curve 23.2 System Reliability Configurations: Series, Parallel, and k-out-of-n Systems 23.3 Failure Modes and Effects Analysis and Fault Tree Analysis

10.4 Performance Measurement: Productivity, KPIs, Wage Systems, and the Balanced Scorecard

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Productivity is always output divided by input: partial-factor productivity divides by one resource (labor hours, machine hours, kilowatt-hours), while multifactor and total-factor productivity divide a common-currency output by the summed value of several or all inputs.

Utilization, efficiency, and effectiveness measure different things: utilization is the fraction of available time a resource ran, efficiency compares actual output to standard output, and Overall Equipment Effectiveness multiplies Availability, Performance, and Quality into a single ratio.

A usable KPI set balances lagging outcome measures against leading process measures across the Safety, Quality, Delivery, Cost, and People families, and each KPI must name an owner, a formula, a data source, a frequency, and a target.

Wage payment plans differ in how the productivity gain is split: straight piece rate and the standard hour plan give the worker 100% of the gain, Halsey 50-50 splits it evenly, and the Rowan plan pays a bonus fraction that shrinks as efficiency rises.

Kaplan and Norton's Balanced Scorecard translates strategy into four linked perspectives — Financial, Customer, Internal Business Process, and Learning and Growth — where learning drives process, process drives customer outcomes, and customer outcomes drive financial results.

Last updated: September 2026

10.4 Performance Measurement: Productivity, KPIs, Wage Systems, and the Balanced Scorecard

The NCEES FE Industrial and Systems specification lists performance measurement — key performance indicators, productivity, wage scales, balanced scorecard, and customer satisfaction — as a distinct sub-topic of Engineering Management. It is the discipline that converts operational activity into numbers an executive can act on. Industrial engineers own these measures because a badly chosen metric silently rewards the wrong behavior: reward machine utilization and you will get overproduction; reward pieces per hour with no quality gate and you will get scrap.

1. Productivity Measurement

Productivity is a ratio of output produced to input consumed over a defined period: Productivity = Output Input \text{Productivity} = \frac{\text{Output}}{\text{Input}} Productivity = Input Output ​

The measure is only meaningful when the period, the boundary, and the units are stated. Three families are distinguished by how many inputs appear in the denominator.

Partial-Factor Productivity

A single resource sits in the denominator, so output and input may be in physical units: Labor Productivity = Units produced Direct labor hours Machine Productivity = Units produced Machine hours \text{Labor Productivity} = \frac{\text{Units produced}}{\text{Direct labor hours}} \qquad \text{Machine Productivity} = \frac{\text{Units produced}}{\text{Machine hours}} Labor Productivity = Direct labor hours Units produced ​ Machine Productivity = Machine hours Units produced ​ Material Yield = Good output weight Raw material weight Energy Productivity = Units produced kWh consumed \text{Material Yield} = \frac{\text{Good output weight}}{\text{Raw material weight}} \qquad \text{Energy Productivity} = \frac{\text{Units produced}}{\text{kWh consumed}} Material Yield = Raw material weight Good output weight ​ Energy Productivity = kWh consumed Units produced ​

Partial measures are easy to collect and easy to game. Labor productivity rises when a plant automates, even if the total cost per unit rises, because the substituted capital never appears in the denominator.

Multifactor and Total-Factor Productivity

When several inputs are combined, they must be converted to a common currency: MFP = Value of output Labor $ + Material $ + Energy $ + Capital $ \text{MFP} = \frac{\text{Value of output}}{\text{Labor \$} + \text{Material \$} + \text{Energy \$} + \text{Capital \$}} MFP = Labor $ + Material $ + Energy $ + Capital $ Value of output ​

Total-factor productivity (TFP) extends the denominator to every purchased input. A dimensionless MFP or TFP above 1.0 means the operation generates more output value than it consumes in input value.

Productivity Index and Growth

Comparisons across periods use an index against a base period: Productivity Index = Productivity current Productivity base × 100 % Growth = P current − P base P base × 100 % \text{Productivity Index} = \frac{\text{Productivity}_{\text{current}}}{\text{Productivity}_{\text{base}}} \times 100 \qquad \%\,\text{Growth} = \frac{P_{\text{current}} - P_{\text{base}}}{P_{\text{base}}} \times 100\% Productivity Index = Productivity base ​ Productivity current ​ ​ × 100 % Growth = P base ​ P current ​ − P base ​ ​ × 100%

Exam Watchout — Deflate Before Comparing : If output is measured in dollars, a 5% selling-price increase inflates measured productivity even though nothing physical improved. Multi-period productivity comparisons must use constant (real) dollars for both output and inputs, applying the same base-year price deflator used in the inflation analysis of engineering economics.

2. Utilization, Efficiency, Effectiveness, and OEE

These three words are not interchangeable, and the FE exam tests the distinction directly.

Metric Formula Question It Answers

Utilization Time the resource actually ran Time the resource was available \dfrac{\text{Time the resource actually ran}}{\text{Time the resource was available}} Time the resource was available Time the resource actually ran ​ Was the asset busy?

Efficiency Actual output Standard (expected) output \dfrac{\text{Actual output}}{\text{Standard (expected) output}} Standard (expected) output Actual output ​ Did it run at the standard rate?

Effectiveness Output that met the objective Output planned \dfrac{\text{Output that met the objective}}{\text{Output planned}} Output planned Output that met the objective ​ Did it produce the right result?

A press can run 95% of the shift (high utilization) at 60% of standard speed (poor efficiency) producing parts that fail final gauge (zero effectiveness).

Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE)

OEE is the standard composite equipment metric in lean and TPM programs. It multiplies three independent loss categories: OEE = A × P × Q \text{OEE} = A \times P \times Q OEE = A × P × Q A = Operating Time Planned Production Time P = Ideal Cycle Time × Total Pieces Operating Time Q = Good Pieces Total Pieces A = \frac{\text{Operating Time}}{\text{Planned Production Time}} \qquad P = \frac{\text{Ideal Cycle Time} \times \text{Total Pieces}}{\text{Operating Time}} \qquad Q = \frac{\text{Good Pieces}}{\text{Total Pieces}} A = Planned Production Time Operating Time ​ P = Operating Time Ideal Cycle Time × Total Pieces ​ Q = Total Pieces Good Pieces ​

Availability ( A A A ) captures downtime losses: breakdowns, changeovers, starvation. Planned production time already excludes scheduled non-production such as breaks and planned maintenance.

Performance ( P P P ) captures speed losses: minor stops, idling, running below rated rate. P P P can never legitimately exceed 1.0; a value above 1.0 means the "ideal" cycle time is wrong.

Quality ( Q Q Q ) captures defect losses: scrap and rework, including startup rejects.

A useful algebraic shortcut collapses all three: OEE = Good Pieces × Ideal Cycle Time Planned Production Time \text{OEE} = \frac{\text{Good Pieces} \times \text{Ideal Cycle Time}}{\text{Planned Production Time}} OEE = Planned Production Time Good Pieces × Ideal Cycle Time ​

World-class discrete manufacturing OEE is commonly benchmarked near 85% ( A ≈ 90 % A \approx 90\% A ≈ 90% , P ≈ 95 % P \approx 95\% P ≈ 95% , Q ≈ 99 % Q \approx 99\% Q ≈ 99% ); typical plants land between 45% and 65%.

Two related composites appear in maintenance-heavy plants: TEEP (Total Effective Equipment Performance) multiplies OEE by the schedule-loading fraction to measure against all 168 calendar hours, while OOE uses total operating time rather than planned production time in the availability term.

3. Designing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

A key performance indicator is a quantified measure tied to a specific objective and used to trigger action. A metric that no one will act on is reporting overhead, not a KPI.

The Anatomy of a Defined KPI

Every KPI on a plant scorecard must specify seven attributes:

  • Name and objective it supports
  • Formula , written explicitly with numerator and denominator
  • Unit of measure
  • Data source and collection method (MES tag, ERP transaction, manual count)
  • Reporting frequency (per shift, daily, weekly, monthly)
  • Owner — a single named accountable person
  • Target and threshold for action
  • Leading vs. Lagging Indicators

Lagging indicators report a completed outcome: recordable injury rate, scrap dollars, on-time delivery percentage, gross margin. They are accurate but arrive too late to change the result.

Leading indicators predict the outcome and can still be influenced: near-miss reports filed, preventive maintenance compliance, first-pass yield at the upstream operation, training hours completed, supplier PPM at receiving.

A balanced operations review pairs each lagging outcome with the leading measures believed to drive it.

The SQDCP Families

Most manufacturing scorecards organize KPIs into five families, deliberately kept in this order so safety is discussed first:

  • Family Representative KPIs
  • Safety TRIR, DART rate, near-miss reports per 100 employees, ergonomic assessments closed

Quality First-pass yield, defects per million opportunities, cost of poor quality as % of sales, supplier PPM, warranty claim rate

  • Delivery On-time in-full (OTIF), schedule attainment, manufacturing lead time, inventory turns, fill rate
  • Cost Unit conversion cost, labor cost per unit, OEE, scrap and rework dollars, energy cost per unit
  • People Absenteeism, voluntary turnover, cross-training matrix coverage, suggestions implemented per employee

Inventory turns , a recurring exam quantity, is defined as: Inventory Turnover = Annual Cost of Goods Sold Average Inventory Value Days of Supply = 365 Turns \text{Inventory Turnover} = \frac{\text{Annual Cost of Goods Sold}}{\text{Average Inventory Value}} \qquad \text{Days of Supply} = \frac{365}{\text{Turns}} Inventory Turnover = Average Inventory Value Annual Cost of Goods Sold ​ Days of Supply = Turns 365 ​

Common KPI Pathologies

Vanity metrics : Impressive numbers with no decision attached (total pieces produced since 1998).

Metric conflict : Rewarding departmental machine utilization while also demanding low WIP; the two cannot both be maximized.

Denominator drift : Changing the population or period mid-year so the trend line becomes meaningless.

Goodhart's law : "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." Measuring only pieces per hour reliably produces pieces per hour — and scrap. Pair every rate metric with a quality gate.

4. Wage Scales, Job Evaluation, and Incentive Plans

Performance measurement and compensation are directly coupled: the wage plan determines whose behavior the measurement actually changes.

Establishing the Wage Scale: Job Evaluation

A wage scale is the structure of pay grades assigned to jobs. Four classical job-evaluation methods set it:

Method Basis Mechanics

Ranking Whole job, qualitative Jobs ordered simplest to most demanding. Fast; no scale of difference.

Classification (Grading) Whole job, qualitative Pre-written grade descriptions; each job slotted into the best-fitting grade (the U.S. federal GS system).

Point Factor Job parts, quantitative Compensable factors (skill, effort, responsibility, working conditions) are weighted and scored; total points map to a pay grade. Most defensible and most common.

Factor Comparison Job parts, quantitative Benchmark jobs are ranked factor by factor and their existing wage is allocated across factors, producing a monetary scale.

Point totals are plotted against market wage data to fit a wage curve ; jobs above the line are red-circled (pay frozen until the grade catches up) and jobs below are green-circled (scheduled for increase).

Wage Payment Plans

Let R R R = hourly base rate, H H H = hours actually worked, S S S = standard hours earned (pieces produced multiplied by standard time per piece), and time saved = S − H = S - H = S − H .

  • Plan Earnings Formula Share of the Gain
  • Day Work (hourly) E = H × R E = H \times R E = H × R 0% to the worker

Measured Daywork E = H × R E = H \times R E = H × R , with pay grade reset periodically from measured performance Delayed

Straight Piece Rate E = N pieces × r piece E = N_{\text{pieces}} \times r_{\text{piece}} E = N pieces ​ × r piece ​ , where r piece = R × r_{\text{piece}} = R \times r piece ​ = R × standard time per piece 100% to the worker

Standard Hour Plan E = S × R E = S \times R E = S × R (with H × R H \times R H × R guaranteed as a floor) 100% to the worker

Halsey 50-50 E = H R + 0.5 ( S − H ) R E = H R + 0.5 (S - H) R E = H R + 0.5 ( S − H ) R 50% to the worker

Rowan E = H R + ( S − H S ) H R E = H R + \left(\dfrac{S - H}{S}\right) H R E = H R + ( S S − H ​ ) H R A share that decreases as efficiency rises

Taylor Differential Piece Rate Low piece rate below standard, high piece rate at or above standard Step change at standard

Gainsharing (Scanlon, Improshare) Group bonus from plant-level labor-cost savings Shared by the whole plant

Two structural notes the exam probes:

The guaranteed base rate. Modern piece-rate and standard-hour plans guarantee H × R H \times R H × R regardless of output, so the incentive only ever adds to pay. The Taylor differential plan, which penalizes below-standard output, is largely of historical interest for exactly this reason.

Rowan's self-limiting bonus. Because the bonus fraction is ( S − H ) / S (S - H)/S ( S − H ) / S , an operator who halves the standard time earns at most a 100% bonus and the marginal reward shrinks as efficiency climbs. Halsey's fixed 50% share does not self-limit, which is why loose standards are far more expensive under Halsey than under Rowan.

5. Customer Satisfaction Measurement

Internal efficiency metrics are meaningless if the customer is unhappy, so the specification pairs productivity and wage measures with customer satisfaction.

Perceptual Measures

CSAT (Customer Satisfaction Score) : Percentage of respondents selecting the top boxes on a satisfaction scale. Report the top-two-box percentage rather than a mean, because the underlying scale is ordinal.

Net Promoter Score (NPS) : From the 0-10 "how likely are you to recommend" question, classify 9-10 as Promoters , 7-8 as Passives , and 0-6 as Detractors : NPS = % Promoters − % Detractors \text{NPS} = \%\,\text{Promoters} - \%\,\text{Detractors} NPS = % Promoters − % Detractors NPS ranges from − 100 -100 − 100 to + 100 +100 + 100 and is reported as an integer, not a percentage. Passives are counted in the denominator but never in the numerator.

Customer Effort Score (CES) : How much work the customer had to do to get resolution; a strong predictor of repurchase in service settings.

SERVQUAL gap model : Measures the difference between customer expectation and perception across reliability, assurance, tangibles, empathy, and responsiveness.

Objective (Behavioral) Measures

Perceptual scores lag; objective service metrics can be measured every day:

On-Time In-Full (OTIF) : Fraction of orders delivered complete and on the promised date.

Perfect Order Index : The product of the on-time rate, complete rate, damage-free rate, and correct-documentation rate. Because it multiplies, four separate 95% performances yield only 0.95 4 = 81.5 % 0.95^4 = 81.5\% 0.9 5 4 = 81.5% perfect orders — the same multiplicative erosion seen in series reliability.

Warranty claim rate, return rate, and complaint rate per million units shipped.

First-contact resolution rate and mean time to resolve.

6. The Balanced Scorecard

Robert Kaplan and David Norton introduced the Balanced Scorecard in 1992 to correct the dominance of purely financial reporting, which measures only past results and encourages short-term decisions. The scorecard translates strategy into objectives, measures, targets, and initiatives across four linked perspectives. The Balanced Scorecard Causal Chain

  • ┌──────────────────────────┐
  • │ LEARNING AND GROWTH │ Skills, information systems, culture
  • │ "Can we keep improving?" │ KPIs: cross-training coverage, training
  • └────────────┬─────────────┘ hours, employee engagement, turnover
  • │ enables
  • ▼
  • ┌──────────────────────────┐
  • │ INTERNAL BUSINESS PROCESS│ The processes we must excel at
  • │ "What must we excel at?" │ KPIs: OEE, first-pass yield, cycle time,
  • └────────────┬─────────────┘ schedule attainment, cost of poor quality
  • │ drives
  • ▼
  • ┌──────────────────────────┐
  • │ CUSTOMER │ How customers see us
  • │ "How do customers see us?"│ KPIs: OTIF, NPS, warranty rate, share
  • └────────────┬─────────────┘
  • │ produces
  • ▼
  • ┌──────────────────────────┐
  • │ FINANCIAL │ How we look to shareholders
  • │ "How do we look to owners?"│ KPIs: ROI, EVA, revenue growth, margin
  • └──────────────────────────┘

Key properties tested on the exam:

The four perspectives are Financial, Customer, Internal Business Process, and Learning and Growth . "Competitor" and "Regulatory" are not scorecard perspectives.

The perspectives are causally linked bottom-up , and this chain is drawn explicitly on a strategy map . Learning and Growth is the foundation; Financial is the outcome.

The scorecard deliberately balances lagging financial outcomes against leading operational and human-capital drivers , and balances external (financial, customer) against internal (process, learning) views.

Each objective carries a measure, a target, and a funded initiative ; a scorecard without initiatives is a report, not a management system.

Benchmarking

Targets are set credibly by benchmarking against a reference: internal (best shift or sister plant), competitive (direct rivals), functional (best-in-class at the same function in another industry — the classic case being a hospital studying an aircraft pit crew for patient handoffs), or generic (universal processes such as order entry).

  • 7. Step-by-Step Worked Engineering Calculations
  • Worked Example 10.4.1: Multifactor Productivity and Productivity Growth

Problem : A machining plant reports the following weekly figures. Output is valued at $50.00 per unit and all dollar figures are already expressed in constant base-year dollars.

  • Period Units Labor Material Energy Capital and Overhead
  • Baseline 12,000 1,600 hr at $28.00/hr $310,000 $18,000 $52,000
  • After Kaizen 13,200 1,600 hr at $28.00/hr $335,000 $18,500 $52,000

Compute baseline labor productivity and baseline multifactor productivity.

Compute both measures after the Kaizen event.

Compute the percentage growth in each, and explain the divergence.

Solution :

Step 1: Baseline

Labor cost: 1,600 × $ 28.00 = $ 44,800 1{,}600 \times \text{\textdollar}28.00 = \text{\textdollar}44{,}800 1 , 600 × $ 28.00 = $ 44 , 800

Output value: 12,000 × $ 50.00 = $ 600,000 12{,}000 \times \text{\textdollar}50.00 = \text{\textdollar}600{,}000 12 , 000 × $ 50.00 = $ 600 , 000

Total input value: $ 44,800 + $ 310,000 + $ 18,000 + $ 52,000 = $ 424,800 \text{\textdollar}44{,}800 + \text{\textdollar}310{,}000 + \text{\textdollar}18{,}000 + \text{\textdollar}52{,}000 = \text{\textdollar}424{,}800 $ 44 , 800 + $ 310 , 000 + $ 18 , 000 + $ 52 , 000 = $ 424 , 800 Labor Productivity base = 12,000 units 1,600 hr = 7.50 units/labor hour \text{Labor Productivity}_{\text{base}} = \frac{12{,}000\text{ units}}{1{,}600\text{ hr}} = 7.50\text{ units/labor hour} Labor Productivity base ​ = 1 , 600 hr 12 , 000 units ​ = 7.50 units/labor hour MFP base = $ 600,000 $ 424,800 = 1.4124 \text{MFP}_{\text{base}} = \frac{\$600{,}000}{\$424{,}800} = 1.4124 MFP base ​ = $424 , 800 $600 , 000 ​ = 1.4124

Step 2: After Kaizen

Output value: 13,200 × $ 50.00 = $ 660,000 13{,}200 \times \text{\textdollar}50.00 = \text{\textdollar}660{,}000 13 , 200 × $ 50.00 = $ 660 , 000

Total input value: $ 44,800 + $ 335,000 + $ 18,500 + $ 52,000 = $ 450,300 \text{\textdollar}44{,}800 + \text{\textdollar}335{,}000 + \text{\textdollar}18{,}500 + \text{\textdollar}52{,}000 = \text{\textdollar}450{,}300 $ 44 , 800 + $ 335 , 000 + $ 18 , 500 + $ 52 , 000 = $ 450 , 300 Labor Productivity new = 13,200 1,600 = 8.25 units/labor hour \text{Labor Productivity}_{\text{new}} = \frac{13{,}200}{1{,}600} = 8.25\text{ units/labor hour} Labor Productivity new ​ = 1 , 600 13 , 200 ​ = 8.25 units/labor hour MFP new = $ 660,000 $ 450,300 = 1.4657 \text{MFP}_{\text{new}} = \frac{\$660{,}000}{\$450{,}300} = 1.4657 MFP new ​ = $450 , 300 $660 , 000 ​ = 1.4657

Step 3: Growth % Δ Labor Productivity = 8.25 − 7.50 7.50 × 100 % = 10.0 % \%\,\Delta\text{Labor Productivity} = \frac{8.25 - 7.50}{7.50} \times 100\% = 10.0\% % Δ Labor Productivity = 7.50 8.25 − 7.50 ​ × 100% = 10.0% % Δ MFP = 1.4657 − 1.4124 1.4124 × 100 % = 3.77 % \%\,\Delta\text{MFP} = \frac{1.4657 - 1.4124}{1.4124} \times 100\% = 3.77\% % Δ MFP = 1.4124 1.4657 − 1.4124 ​ × 100% = 3.77%

Engineering interpretation : Labor productivity jumped 10% because the same 1,600 hours produced 1,200 more units. Multifactor productivity rose only 3.8% because material consumption grew nearly in proportion to output ( + 8.1 % +8.1\% + 8.1% ), so most of the extra output was bought , not earned . Reporting only the labor number would overstate the improvement by a factor of roughly 2.7. This is exactly why capital-substitution projects must be judged on MFP.

Worked Example 10.4.2: Overall Equipment Effectiveness

Problem : An injection molding press is scheduled for a 480-minute shift. Contractual breaks and a planned mold-preventive-maintenance window total 45 minutes and are excluded from planned production time. During the shift the press suffered 55 minutes of unplanned downtime (a hydraulic fault and a material starvation event). It produced 620 total shots at an ideal cycle time of 0.50 minutes per shot; 595 shots passed final inspection.

Compute Availability, Performance, Quality, and OEE, and identify the dominant loss.

Solution :

Step 1: Availability Planned Production Time = 480 − 45 = 435 minutes \text{Planned Production Time} = 480 - 45 = 435\text{ minutes} Planned Production Time = 480 − 45 = 435 minutes Operating Time = 435 − 55 = 380 minutes \text{Operating Time} = 435 - 55 = 380\text{ minutes} Operating Time = 435 − 55 = 380 minutes A = 380 435 = 0.8736 ( 87.36 % ) A = \frac{380}{435} = 0.8736 \quad (87.36\%) A = 435 380 ​ = 0.8736 ( 87.36% )

Step 2: Performance P = Ideal Cycle Time × Total Pieces Operating Time = 0.50 × 620 380 = 310 380 = 0.8158 ( 81.58 % ) P = \frac{\text{Ideal Cycle Time} \times \text{Total Pieces}}{\text{Operating Time}} = \frac{0.50 \times 620}{380} = \frac{310}{380} = 0.8158 \quad (81.58\%) P = Operating Time Ideal Cycle Time × Total Pieces ​ = 380 0.50 × 620 ​ = 380 310 ​ = 0.8158 ( 81.58% )

Step 3: Quality Q = 595 620 = 0.9597 ( 95.97 % ) Q = \frac{595}{620} = 0.9597 \quad (95.97\%) Q = 620 595 ​ = 0.9597 ( 95.97% )

Step 4: OEE OEE = A × P × Q = 0.8736 × 0.8158 × 0.9597 = 0.6839 ( 68.4 % ) \text{OEE} = A \times P \times Q = 0.8736 \times 0.8158 \times 0.9597 = 0.6839 \quad (68.4\%) OEE = A × P × Q = 0.8736 × 0.8158 × 0.9597 = 0.6839 ( 68.4% )

Verification using the shortcut : OEE = 595 × 0.50 435 = 297.5 435 = 0.6839 ✓ \text{OEE} = \frac{595 \times 0.50}{435} = \frac{297.5}{435} = 0.6839 \quad \checkmark OEE = 435 595 × 0.50 ​ = 435 297.5 ​ = 0.6839 ✓

Step 5: Loss diagnosis : The largest single loss is Performance at 81.6% — the press ran 380 minutes but delivered only 310 minutes of ideal-cycle output, meaning 70 minutes were consumed by minor stops and slow cycles. Availability losses cost 55 minutes and quality losses cost 25 shots. Because minor stops are invisible on a downtime log, the corrective action is short-interval cycle logging at the press, not another maintenance program.

Worked Example 10.4.3: Comparing Wage Incentive Plans

Problem : The standard time for a bracket weldment is 12.0 minutes per piece, so the standard output is 5 pieces per hour. The guaranteed base rate is R = $ 24.00 R = \text{\textdollar}24.00 R = $ 24.00 per hour. In an 8-hour shift ( H = 8 H = 8 H = 8 ), an operator completes 46 acceptable pieces; the shift standard is 40 pieces.

Compute the operator's shift earnings and the employer's direct labor cost per piece under (a) day work, (b) straight piece rate, (c) the standard hour plan, (d) Halsey 50-50, and (e) the Rowan plan.

Solution :

Step 0: Establish standard hours earned S = 46 pieces × 12.0 min 60 min/hr = 46 × 0.200 = 9.20 standard hours S = 46\text{ pieces} \times \frac{12.0\text{ min}}{60\text{ min/hr}} = 46 \times 0.200 = 9.20\text{ standard hours} S = 46 pieces × 60 min/hr 12.0 min ​ = 46 × 0.200 = 9.20 standard hours Time saved = S − H = 9.20 − 8.00 = 1.20 hours Efficiency = 9.20 8.00 = 115 % \text{Time saved} = S - H = 9.20 - 8.00 = 1.20\text{ hours} \qquad \text{Efficiency} = \frac{9.20}{8.00} = 115\% Time saved = S − H = 9.20 − 8.00 = 1.20 hours Efficiency = 8.00 9.20 ​ = 115%

(a) Day Work E = H × R = 8 × $ 24.00 = $ 192.00 Labor cost/piece = 192.00 46 = $ 4.174 E = H \times R = 8 \times \$24.00 = \$192.00 \qquad \text{Labor cost/piece} = \frac{192.00}{46} = \$4.174 E = H × R = 8 × $24.00 = $192.00 Labor cost/piece = 46 192.00 ​ = $4.174

(b) Straight Piece Rate Piece price = R × = R \times = R × standard time per piece = $ 24.00 × 0.200 = $ 4.80 = \text{\textdollar}24.00 \times 0.200 = \text{\textdollar}4.80 = $ 24.00 × 0.200 = $ 4.80 per piece. E = 46 × $ 4.80 = $ 220.80 Labor cost/piece = $ 4.80 E = 46 \times \$4.80 = \$220.80 \qquad \text{Labor cost/piece} = \$4.80 E = 46 × $4.80 = $220.80 Labor cost/piece = $4.80

(c) Standard Hour Plan E = S × R = 9.20 × $ 24.00 = $ 220.80 Labor cost/piece = $ 4.80 E = S \times R = 9.20 \times \$24.00 = \$220.80 \qquad \text{Labor cost/piece} = \$4.80 E = S × R = 9.20 × $24.00 = $220.80 Labor cost/piece = $4.80

Identical to the straight piece rate — the two plans are algebraically the same whenever the piece price is derived from the base rate and the standard time.

(d) Halsey 50-50 E = H R + 0.5 ( S − H ) R = 192.00 + 0.5 ( 1.20 ) ( 24.00 ) = 192.00 + 14.40 = $ 206.40 E = H R + 0.5 (S - H) R = 192.00 + 0.5(1.20)(24.00) = 192.00 + 14.40 = \$206.40 E = H R + 0.5 ( S − H ) R = 192.00 + 0.5 ( 1.20 ) ( 24.00 ) = 192.00 + 14.40 = $206.40 Labor cost/piece = 206.40 46 = $ 4.487 \text{Labor cost/piece} = \frac{206.40}{46} = \$4.487 Labor cost/piece = 46 206.40 ​ = $4.487

(e) Rowan E = H R + ( S − H S ) H R = 192.00 + ( 1.20 9.20 ) ( 192.00 ) = 192.00 + 25.04 = $ 217.04 E = H R + \left(\frac{S - H}{S}\right) H R = 192.00 + \left(\frac{1.20}{9.20}\right)(192.00) = 192.00 + 25.04 = \$217.04 E = H R + ( S S − H ​ ) H R = 192.00 + ( 9.20 1.20 ​ ) ( 192.00 ) = 192.00 + 25.04 = $217.04 Labor cost/piece = 217.04 46 = $ 4.718 \text{Labor cost/piece} = \frac{217.04}{46} = \$4.718 Labor cost/piece = 46 217.04 ​ = $4.718

Comparison and interpretation :

  • Plan Shift Earnings Bonus over Day Work Labor Cost per Piece
  • Day work $192.00 — $4.174
  • Halsey 50-50 $206.40 $14.40 $4.487
  • Rowan $217.04 $25.04 $4.718
  • Straight piece rate / standard hour $220.80 $28.80 $4.800

At 115% efficiency the plans rank Halsey < Rowan < piece rate in operator earnings, and the ranking of employer unit labor cost is the mirror image. Day work shows the lowest unit labor cost here only because the operator produced 15% above standard without additional pay — a condition that does not persist, which is the entire rationale for incentive plans. Note also that at very high efficiency the Rowan bonus fraction ( S − H ) / S (S-H)/S ( S − H ) / S approaches 1.0 and flattens, capping the employer's exposure to a loose standard, whereas Halsey's fixed 50% share and the straight piece rate do not self-limit.