Study guide

7.4 Cost Analysis, Uncertainty, Expected Value, and Decision Trees

FE Other Disciplines Fundamentals of Engineering

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Strategy

About the FE Other Disciplines Exam How to Use This Study Guide

2 Chapter 1: Mathematics

1.1 Analytic Geometry, Trigonometry, and Vector Operations 1.2 Differential and Integral Calculus 1.3 Ordinary Differential Equations and Laplace Transforms 1.4 Linear Algebra, Matrices, and Systems of Equations 1.5 Numerical Methods, Root-Finding, and Numerical Integration

3 Chapter 2: Probability and Statistics

2.1 Probability Distributions, PMFs, and PDFs 2.2 Expected Value, Mean, Variance, and Descriptive Statistics 2.3 Estimation, Confidence Intervals, and Sample Sizes 2.4 Hypothesis Testing, Goodness of Fit, and Linear Regression

4 Chapter 3: Chemistry

3.1 Stoichiometry, Chemical Reactions, and Solutions 3.2 Chemical Equilibrium, Acids/Bases, and Ideal Gas Laws 3.3 Oxidation-Reduction, Electrochemistry, and Corrosion Basics

5 Chapter 4: Instrumentation and Controls

4.1 Sensors, Transducers, and Signal Conditioning 4.2 Data Sampling, Accuracy/Precision, and A/D Conversion 4.3 Logic Diagrams, Boolean Algebra, and Control Logic

6 Chapter 5: Engineering Ethics and Societal Impacts

5.1 NCEES Model Rules of Professional Conduct and Codes of Ethics 5.2 Public Protection, Licensure Boards, and Professional Liability 5.3 Societal Impacts: Sustainability, Life-Cycle Analysis, and Public Safety

7 Chapter 6: Safety, Health, and Environment

6.1 OSHA Regulations, Industrial Hygiene, and PPE 6.2 Hazard Assessment, Risk Management, and Environmental Rules 6.3 Gas Detection and Monitoring 6.4 Electrical Safety 6.5 Confined Space Entry and Ventilation Rates

8 Chapter 7: Engineering Economics

7.1 Time Value of Money, Interest Formulas, and Cash Flow Diagrams 7.2 Capital Budgeting: Present Worth, Annual Worth, IRR, and B/C Ratio 7.3 Depreciation Methods, Income Taxes, and Breakeven Analysis 7.4 Cost Analysis, Uncertainty, Expected Value, and Decision Trees

9 Chapter 8: Statics

8.1 Statics Equilibrium, Free-Body Diagrams, and Force Systems 8.2 Distributed Loads, Resultants, and Equivalent Force-Couple Systems 8.3 Internal Forces in Rigid Bodies: Trusses, Frames, Machines, and Friction 8.4 Three-Dimensional Equilibrium, Cables, and Pulley Systems 8.5 Area Properties: Centroids, Moments of Inertia, and Radius of Gyration 8.6 Weight, Mass, and Force Units: slug, lbm, lbf, and g_c

10 Chapter 9: Dynamics

9.1 Kinematics of Particles and Rigid Bodies 9.2 Newton's Second Law for Particles and Rigid Bodies 9.3 Angular Motion, Torque, and Mass Moment of Inertia 9.4 Work-Energy Principle, Power, and Efficiency 9.5 Impulse-Momentum, Impact, and Coefficient of Restitution 9.6 Dynamic Friction and Vibrations: Natural Frequency and Damping

11 Chapter 10: Strength of Materials

10.1 Stress Types, Axial Stress-Strain, and Thermal Deformation 10.2 Torsion of Circular Shafts, Polar Moment, and Angle of Twist 10.3 Shear and Moment Diagrams 10.4 Flexural Bending Stress and Transverse Shear Stress 10.5 Stress Transformations, Principal Stresses, and Mohr's Circle 10.6 Beam Deflections and Combined Axial/Bending Loading 10.7 Column Buckling (Euler Formula) and Yield/Failure Criteria

12 Chapter 11: Materials

11.1 Crystal Structure, Phase Diagrams, and Material Processing 11.2 Mechanical Properties, Fatigue, Fracture, and Corrosion 11.3 Thermal Properties of Materials 11.4 Electrical and Chemical Properties of Materials 11.5 Material Selection for Engineering Design

13 Chapter 12: Fluid Mechanics

12.1 Fluid Properties, Hydrostatic Pressure, and Manometry 12.2 Dimensionless Numbers and Flow Regimes 12.3 Continuity Equation, Bernoulli Equation, and Energy Equation 12.4 Impulse-Momentum Equation and Forces on Control Volumes 12.5 Flow in Pipes, Friction Factors (Moody Diagram), and Head Losses 12.6 Turbomachinery: Pumps, Turbines, Fans, and Compressors 12.7 Open-Channel Flow, Manning's Equation, and Drag 12.8 Fluid Transport Systems and Flow Measurement 12.9 Ideal Gas Law, Gas Mixtures, and the Real Gas Law

14 Chapter 13: Basic Electrical Engineering

13.1 Electrical Fundamentals, Ohm's Law, and DC Circuits 13.2 AC Circuits, Phasors, Impedance, and Three-Phase Power 13.3 Magnetic Fields, Induction, Transformers, and Motor Efficiency 13.4 Electrical Measuring Devices: Voltmeter, Ammeter, and Wattmeter

15 Chapter 14: Thermodynamics and Heat Transfer

14.1 First & Second Laws of Thermodynamics and Pure Substance Properties 14.2 Thermodynamic Processes and Property Diagrams (T-s, P-h, P-v) 14.3 Heat Transfer: Conduction, Convection, and Radiation 14.4 Ideal Gas Processes and Power/Refrigeration Cycles 14.5 Mass and Energy Balances on Control Volumes 14.6 Combustion and Combustion Products 14.7 Psychrometrics: Relative Humidity, Wet-Bulb Temperature, and the Psychrometric Chart

7.4 Cost Analysis, Uncertainty, Expected Value, and Decision Trees

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Sunk costs are past and unrecoverable and must be excluded from every forward-looking economic decision.

Only incremental cash flows that differ between alternatives affect the decision; identical costs cancel and can be ignored.

Expected monetary value is the probability-weighted sum of outcomes, and the alternative with the best expected value is chosen when the decision maker is risk-neutral.

Decision trees are solved by rolling back from right to left, taking expected values at chance nodes and the best value at decision nodes.

Expected value of perfect information equals the expected value under certainty minus the best expected value without information, and it caps what any study is worth.

Last updated: August 2026

7.4 Cost Analysis, Uncertainty, Expected Value, and Decision Trees

The NCEES Engineering Economics specification lists five sub-topics. Time value of money, economic analyses, and project selection are covered in the three preceding sections. This section covers the remaining two: cost analysis ("incremental, average, sunk, estimating") and uncertainty ("expected value and risk"). These items usually involve less arithmetic than a present-worth problem but punish sloppy reading, because the trap is almost always a number that should have been ignored.

Cost Classifications the Exam Actually Tests

  • Cost type Definition Decision relevance
  • Sunk cost Already incurred and unrecoverable Never relevant. Excluded entirely

Incremental (differential) cost The difference in cash flow between two alternatives The only thing that matters

  • Opportunity cost Value of the best foregone alternative Relevant, even though no cash changes hands
  • Fixed cost Does not vary with output over the relevant range Relevant only if it differs between alternatives
  • Variable cost Varies directly with output Relevant per unit
  • Marginal cost Cost of producing one additional unit Used for optimal-output decisions
  • Average cost Total cost divided by units produced Useful for reporting, misleading for decisions
  • The Sunk-Cost Trap

A company has spent $400{,}000 developing a prototype. Completing it requires $150{,}000 more and will yield revenue of $220{,}000. Should they finish?

Yes. The $400{,}000 is gone whichever way the decision goes; it appears in no future cash flow. The forward-looking comparison is $220{,}000 of revenue against $150{,}000 of remaining cost, a $70{,}000 gain. Total project accounting shows a $330{,}000 loss, and that loss is real — but abandoning the project makes it a $400{,}000 loss instead. Past money cannot be recovered by refusing to earn future money.

The mirror-image error is equally common: continuing a project because of what has already been spent ("we've come too far to stop"). Both errors come from letting a sunk cost enter the comparison. The test is mechanical — if a number is dated before the decision point, strike it out.

Marginal vs. Average Cost

Total cost of producing Q Q Q units with fixed cost F F F and unit variable cost v v v : T C = F + v Q , A C = F Q + v , M C = d ( T C ) d Q = v TC = F + vQ, \qquad AC = \frac{F}{Q} + v, \qquad MC = \frac{d(TC)}{dQ} = v TC = F + v Q , A C = Q F ​ + v , MC = d Q d ( TC ) ​ = v

Average cost falls continuously as Q Q Q rises because fixed cost spreads thinner, while marginal cost stays at v v v . Accept-or-reject decisions on incremental volume use marginal cost, not average cost. An order priced above v v v but below A C AC A C still improves profit.

  • Cost Estimating
  • Capacity Scaling (the Six-Tenths Rule)

Equipment cost does not scale linearly with capacity, because cost tracks surface area while capacity tracks volume: C 2 C 1 = ( Q 2 Q 1 ) n \frac{C_2}{C_1} = \left(\frac{Q_2}{Q_1}\right)^{n} C 1 ​ C 2 ​ ​ = ( Q 1 ​ Q 2 ​ ​ ) n

where n ≈ 0.6 n \approx 0.6 n ≈ 0.6 for much process equipment. Doubling capacity costs about 2 0.6 = 1.52 2^{0.6} = 1.52 2 0.6 = 1.52 times as much, not twice as much — the origin of economies of scale .

Cost Indexes for Escalation C now = C then × I now I then C_{\text{now}} = C_{\text{then}} \times \frac{I_{\text{now}}}{I_{\text{then}}} C now ​ = C then ​ × I then ​ I now ​ ​

Worked Example: Combined Scaling and Escalation

A 5{,}000 L reactor cost $180{,}000 when the cost index was 480. Estimate the cost today of a 12{,}000 L reactor with the index at 624, using n = 0.6 n = 0.6 n = 0.6 .

Scale for capacity: C = 180,000 ( 12,000 5,000 ) 0.6 = 180,000 ( 2.4 ) 0.6 C = 180{,}000\left(\frac{12{,}000}{5{,}000}\right)^{0.6} = 180{,}000\,(2.4)^{0.6} C = 180 , 000 ( 5 , 000 12 , 000 ​ ) 0.6 = 180 , 000 ( 2.4 ) 0.6 ( 2.4 ) 0.6 = e 0.6 ln ⁡ 2.4 = e 0.6 ( 0.8755 ) = e 0.5253 = 1.691 (2.4)^{0.6} = e^{0.6\ln 2.4} = e^{0.6(0.8755)} = e^{0.5253} = 1.691 ( 2.4 ) 0.6 = e 0.6 l n 2.4 = e 0.6 ( 0.8755 ) = e 0.5253 = 1.691 C = 180,000 ( 1.691 ) = $ 304,400 C = 180{,}000(1.691) = \$304{,}400 C = 180 , 000 ( 1.691 ) = $304 , 400

Then escalate: C now = 304,400 × 624 480 = 304,400 ( 1.30 ) = $ 395,700 C_{\text{now}} = 304{,}400 \times \frac{624}{480} = 304{,}400(1.30) = \boxed{\$395{,}700} C now ​ = 304 , 400 × 480 624 ​ = 304 , 400 ( 1.30 ) = $395 , 700 ​

Trap: capacity rose 140% but cost rose only 69% before escalation. Candidates who scale linearly get $432{,}000 before escalation and $561{,}600 after — a 42% overestimate.

Uncertainty: Expected Value and Risk

Expected monetary value (EMV) is the probability-weighted average outcome: E [ X ] = ∑ i p i x i , ∑ i p i = 1 E[X] = \sum_{i} p_i x_i, \qquad \sum_i p_i = 1 E [ X ] = i ∑ ​ p i ​ x i ​ , i ∑ ​ p i ​ = 1

A risk-neutral decision maker chooses the alternative with the best EMV. Variance measures the dispersion around it: σ 2 = ∑ i p i ( x i − E [ X ] ) 2 \sigma^2 = \sum_i p_i (x_i - E[X])^2 σ 2 = i ∑ ​ p i ​ ( x i ​ − E [ X ] ) 2

Two alternatives with identical EMV but different variance are not equivalent to a real decision maker; the exam may ask which carries more risk, which is answered by variance or standard deviation, not by EMV.

Worked Example: Expected Cost of a Design Choice

A pipeline coating decision:

  • Alternative First cost Failure probability in 20 yr Cost if failure occurs
  • Standard coating $220{,}000 0.18 $1{,}400{,}000

Enhanced coating $430{,}000 0.03 $1{,}400{,}000 E [ Standard ] = 220,000 + 0.18 ( 1,400,000 ) = 220,000 + 252,000 = $ 472,000 E[\text{Standard}] = 220{,}000 + 0.18(1{,}400{,}000) = 220{,}000 + 252{,}000 = \$472{,}000 E [ Standard ] = 220 , 000 + 0.18 ( 1 , 400 , 000 ) = 220 , 000 + 252 , 000 = $472 , 000 E [ Enhanced ] = 430,000 + 0.03 ( 1,400,000 ) = 430,000 + 42,000 = $ 472,000 E[\text{Enhanced}] = 430{,}000 + 0.03(1{,}400{,}000) = 430{,}000 + 42{,}000 = \$472{,}000 E [ Enhanced ] = 430 , 000 + 0.03 ( 1 , 400 , 000 ) = 430 , 000 + 42 , 000 = $472 , 000

The expected costs are identical . A risk-neutral analyst is indifferent — but the enhanced coating caps the worst case at $1{,}830{,}000 with 3% probability rather than 18%, and reduces the standard deviation of the outcome substantially. Where the failure consequence includes public safety or environmental release, the lower-variance option is the defensible engineering choice even at equal EMV. This is where the Engineering Economics area meets the ethics area.

Decision Trees

A decision tree lays out sequential choices and chance events:

  • Decision node (square): the analyst chooses; take the best value
  • Chance node (circle): nature chooses; take the expected value
  • Solve by rolling back right to left (backward induction)
  • Worked Example: Rolling Back a Two-Stage Tree

A firm can build a large plant or a small plant. Demand is high with probability 0.6 and low with probability 0.4.

  • High demand (0.6) Low demand (0.4)
  • Large plant +$900{,}000 −$200{,}000
  • Small plant +$400{,}000 +$250{,}000

Expected values at the two chance nodes: E [ Large ] = 0.6 ( 900,000 ) + 0.4 ( − 200,000 ) = 540,000 − 80,000 = $ 460,000 E[\text{Large}] = 0.6(900{,}000) + 0.4(-200{,}000) = 540{,}000 - 80{,}000 = \$460{,}000 E [ Large ] = 0.6 ( 900 , 000 ) + 0.4 ( − 200 , 000 ) = 540 , 000 − 80 , 000 = $460 , 000 E [ Small ] = 0.6 ( 400,000 ) + 0.4 ( 250,000 ) = 240,000 + 100,000 = $ 340,000 E[\text{Small}] = 0.6(400{,}000) + 0.4(250{,}000) = 240{,}000 + 100{,}000 = \$340{,}000 E [ Small ] = 0.6 ( 400 , 000 ) + 0.4 ( 250 , 000 ) = 240 , 000 + 100 , 000 = $340 , 000

At the decision node, take the larger: build the large plant, EMV $460{,}000.

Expected Value of Perfect Information

Now suppose a market study could reveal demand with certainty before the plant decision. With perfect information you would build large if high (+$900{,}000) and small if low (+$250{,}000): E V with perfect information = 0.6 ( 900,000 ) + 0.4 ( 250,000 ) = 540,000 + 100,000 = $ 640,000 EV\text{ with perfect information} = 0.6(900{,}000) + 0.4(250{,}000) = 540{,}000 + 100{,}000 = \$640{,}000 E V with perfect information = 0.6 ( 900 , 000 ) + 0.4 ( 250 , 000 ) = 540 , 000 + 100 , 000 = $640 , 000 E V P I = 640,000 − 460,000 = $ 180,000 EVPI = 640{,}000 - 460{,}000 = \boxed{\$180{,}000} E V P I = 640 , 000 − 460 , 000 = $180 , 000 ​

Interpretation: $180{,}000 is the maximum worth of any study, however good. A study quoted at $210{,}000 must be declined even if it is perfectly reliable, and a real study that is less than perfect is worth strictly less than $180{,}000.

Trap: EVPI uses the probabilities before the information arrives, weighting each branch by how likely you are to be told that branch. Candidates who compute 900,000 − 460,000 900{,}000 - 460{,}000 900 , 000 − 460 , 000 get $440{,}000, treating the best possible outcome as if it were certain.