Study guide
11.3 Joint and Several Liability, the Fabre Doctrine and Damages
Florida All-Lines Claims Adjuster 6-20
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Florida Insurance Regulation and Market Structure
1.1 Florida Insurance Regulation and the Department of Financial Services 1.2 The Office of Insurance Regulation, DCI and the NAIC 1.3 Types of Insurers: Admitted, Surplus Lines, Reciprocals and Residual Markets
2 Chapter 2: Florida Adjuster Licensing, Appointment and Discipline
2.1 Florida Adjuster License Types and Employment Relationships 2.2 Qualifying for Licensure: Exam Exemptions and the Primary Appointment 2.3 Continuing Education, the 48-Month Rule and Address Notification 2.4 Disciplinary Grounds, Penalties and Reinstatement
3 Chapter 3: Insurance Principles, Risk and Contract Law
3.1 Risk, Perils and Hazards 3.2 Risk Management, Insurable Risk and Reinsurance 3.3 Elements and Legal Characteristics of the Insurance Contract 3.4 The DICE Policy Structure and Standard Policy Conditions 3.5 Indemnity, Insurable Interest, Proximate Cause and Warranties 3.6 Concealment, Fraud, Waiver, Estoppel and Subrogation
4 Chapter 4: Homeowners and Dwelling Property Insurance
4.1 ISO Homeowners Policy Forms: HO-2 Through HO-8 4.2 Homeowners Section I: Property Coverages, Limits and Exclusions 4.3 Homeowners Section II Liability: Coverages E and F 4.4 ISO Dwelling Policy Forms: DP-1, DP-2 and DP-3 4.5 Dwelling Coverages A Through E, Endorsements and Florida Practice
5 Chapter 5: Commercial Property, Marine and Specialty Property Lines
5.1 The Commercial Package Policy and the Building and Personal Property Form 5.2 Causes of Loss Forms, Business Income and Builders Risk 5.3 The Businessowners Policy (BOP) 5.4 Inland Marine Insurance: The Nationwide Definition, Filed and Non-Filed Forms 5.5 Ocean Marine Insurance: Hull, Cargo, Freight and Protection and Indemnity 5.6 Aviation Insurance
6 Chapter 6: Flood Insurance and Florida Residual Property Markets
6.1 Flood Insurance and the National Flood Insurance Program 6.2 NFIP Waiting Periods, Coverage Mechanics and Private Flood Options 6.3 Citizens Property Insurance: Purpose, Eligibility and the Flood Mandate 6.4 The Citizens Account and the Deficit Assessment Sequence
7 Chapter 7: Florida Hurricane, Sinkhole and Catastrophe Regulation
7.1 The Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund and Statutory Hurricane Deductibles 7.2 Calendar-Year Hurricane Deductibles and the Statutory Hurricane Window 7.3 Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse Versus Sinkhole Loss Coverage 7.4 Sinkhole Investigation, Neutral Evaluation and Stabilization Repairs
8 Chapter 8: Florida Property Reforms, Valued Policy Law and FIGA
8.1 The 2022 and 2023 Property Reforms, the AOB Ban and Claim Notice Deadlines 8.2 Valued Policy Law, Concurrent Causation and the Florida Insurance Guaranty Association
9 Chapter 9: Florida No-Fault PIP and the Personal Auto Policy
9.1 Florida No-Fault: Scope, Covered Vehicles and Coverage Priority 9.2 The 14-Day Rule, Emergency Medical Conditions and PIP Benefits 9.3 PIP Deductibles, Calculations and the Florida Verbal Threshold 9.4 Personal Auto Policy Structure and Florida Insurance Requirements 9.5 The FR-44 Requirement, PAP Part A Liability and Part B Medical Payments 9.6 Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage in Florida
10 Chapter 10: Auto Physical Damage, Commercial Auto and Mechanical Breakdown
10.1 PAP Part D Physical Damage, the Windshield Rule and ACV Settlement 10.2 Total Loss Under F.S. § 319.30, Title Branding and GAP 10.3 Transportation Expenses, Towing and the Florida Automobile Joint Underwriting Association 10.4 The Business Auto Policy and Covered Auto Symbols 10.5 Auto Dealers Coverage and Garagekeepers Insurance 10.6 Mechanical Breakdown Insurance and Motor Vehicle Service Agreements
11 Chapter 11: Casualty and Liability Insurance
11.1 Tort Law Fundamentals, the Elements of Negligence and Defenses 11.2 House Bill 837 and Categories of Civil Liability in Florida 11.3 Joint and Several Liability, the Fabre Doctrine and Damages 11.4 Commercial General Liability: Architecture, Coverage A and Coverage Triggers 11.5 CGL Coverages B and C, Limits, Professional Liability and EPLI 11.6 Commercial Crime Insurance and Surety Bonds 11.7 Excess and Umbrella Liability 11.8 Farm Liability and Equipment Breakdown Coverage
12 Chapter 12: Florida Workers' Compensation and Health Insurance Basics
12.1 The Grand Bargain and Florida Coverage Thresholds 12.2 Exclusive Remedy, Compensability and Medical Benefits 12.3 Indemnity Benefits, Reporting Deadlines and the FWCJUA 12.4 Health Insurance Essentials for All-Lines Adjusters
13 Chapter 13: Claims Handling, Investigation and Loss Valuation
13.1 FNOL, Coverage Verification and Loss Reserving 13.2 Reservation of Rights, Non-Waiver Agreements and Field Investigation 13.3 Proof of Loss, Examinations Under Oath, Subrogation and Settlement 13.4 Property Valuation Methods: ACV, Replacement Cost and Depreciation 13.5 Coinsurance Calculations and the Valued Policy Law Interaction
14 Chapter 14: Florida Claims Deadlines and Building Code Compliance
14.1 Florida Prompt-Pay Clocks Under F.S. § 627.70131 14.2 Claim Notice Deadlines and Ordinance or Law Coverage 14.3 The 25 Percent Roof Rule and Allocating Code Upgrade Costs
15 Chapter 15: Adjuster Ethics, Unfair Practices, Fraud and Dispute Resolution
15.1 The Florida Adjuster Code of Ethics and Conflicts of Interest 15.2 Public Adjuster Ethics, Fee Caps and the Dual-License Bar 15.3 Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Under F.S. § 626.9541 15.4 Civil Remedy Notices, Bad Faith and the House Bill 837 Changes 15.5 Insurance Fraud, Red Flags and Mandatory DCI Reporting 15.6 Claims Dispute Resolution: Appraisal Versus DFS Mediation
11.3 Joint and Several Liability, the Fabre Doctrine and Damages
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Florida abolished joint and several liability, so under F.S. § 768.81 each defendant pays a judgment only in proportion to its own percentage of fault.
Under the Fabre doctrine the jury may apportion fault to non-parties whose negligence contributed to the injury, which reduces the share payable by the named defendants.
Compensatory damages divide into special or economic damages such as medical bills, lost wages and repair costs, and general or non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, mental anguish and loss of consortium.
Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of intentional misconduct or gross negligence and may not be pleaded initially without a reasonable evidentiary showing under F.S. § 768.72.
F.S. § 768.73 caps punitive damages at the greater of three times compensatory damages or $500,000, rising to four times or $2 million for conduct motivated by unreasonable financial gain, and removes the cap for specific intent to harm or intoxication.
Last updated: September 2026
1. Abolition of Joint and Several Liability & The Fabre Doctrine
Historically, Florida followed the common-law doctrine of joint and several liability , which allowed a plaintiff to collect 100% of their judgment against any single defendant found even 1% at fault, leaving that defendant to seek contribution from other tortfeasors ("deep pocket" recovery).
Under Florida Statutes § 768.81 , the Florida Legislature has completely abolished joint and several liability in Florida negligence actions. Florida now adheres strictly to pure proportionate fault apportionment :
In any negligence case, the court must enter judgment against each liable party strictly on the basis of that party's percentage of fault , not jointly and severally.
A defendant who is found 20% liable can never be forced to pay more than 20% of the total damages awarded.
The Fabre Doctrine ( Fabre v. Marin , 1993)
Because joint and several liability is abolished, Florida permits defendants to shift or dilute liability using the Fabre Doctrine :
A named defendant in a civil lawsuit may formally plead that a non-party (known as a Fabre defendant ) shares fault for the plaintiff's injuries.
If the defendant meets their evidentiary burden, the trial judge must include the non-party Fabre defendant's name on the jury verdict form alongside the named parties.
The jury allocates fault percentages across all responsible entities—both parties and non-parties. The named defendant pays only their assigned percentage, significantly lowering casualty claim exposures for insurers.
2. Damages in Florida Casualty Claims
When legal liability is established, the claims adjuster must quantify the damages owed. Florida law divides civil damages into two broad categories: compensatory (designed to make the plaintiff whole) and punitive (designed to punish and deter). Civil Damages
- ├── Compensatory Damages
- │ ├── Special Damages (Economic: bills, wages, out-of-pocket costs)
- │ └── General Damages (Non-Economic: pain & suffering, anguish)
- └── Punitive Damages (Punishment/Deterrence: F.S. § 768.73 statutory caps)
- Compensatory Damages: Special vs. General
Special Damages (Economic Damages): Quantifiable, objectively measurable out-of-pocket financial losses directly resulting from the tort:
Past and future medical, surgical, and rehabilitation expenses.
Lost past wages and verified loss of future earning capacity.
Property damage repair costs, total loss fair market values, and vehicle loss-of-use expenses.
General Damages (Non-Economic Damages): Intangible, subjective non-monetary losses that cannot be calculated with mathematical exactness:
Physical pain and suffering, physical impairment, and permanent disfigurement or scarring.
Mental anguish, emotional distress, and loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life.
Loss of Consortium: A derivative claim brought by the uninjured spouse for the deprivation of companionship, affection, and spousal relations.
Punitive Damages Standards & Statutory Caps (F.S. § 768.72 & § 768.73)
Punitive damages are not intended to compensate the victim; their sole legal purpose is to punish extreme wrongdoing and deter the defendant and the public from similar conduct.
Evidentiary Threshold: Under F.S. § 768.72, punitive damages cannot even be alleged in an initial complaint; the claimant must make a preliminary evidentiary proffer showing a reasonable basis. At trial, punitive damages must be established by clear and convincing evidence (a higher standard than the civil preponderance of evidence) that the defendant was personally guilty of intentional misconduct or gross negligence .
Gross Negligence Defined: Conduct so reckless or wanting in care that it constituted a conscious disregard or indifference to the life, safety, or rights of persons exposed to its effects.
Statutory Caps on Punitive Damages (F.S. § 768.73)
To prevent catastrophic, runaway jury awards, the Florida Legislature enacted strict statutory limitations on punitive damage awards:
Standard Statutory Cap: Punitive damages are capped at the greater of three (3) times the amount of compensatory damages awarded to the claimant, or $500,000 .
Heightened Cap for Financial Gain: If the wrongful conduct was motivated primarily by unreasonable financial gain and the unreasonably dangerous nature of the conduct was known, the cap rises to the greater of four (4) times compensatory damages, or $2,000,000 .
Uncapped Punitive Damages: Punitive damages are completely uncapped (no statutory limit) if the jury finds the defendant acted with specific intent to harm the claimant, or if the defendant was intoxicated by alcohol or illegal drugs at the time of the incident (F.S. § 768.736).
3. Pleading and Proving Nonparty Fault
The Fabre doctrine is not self-executing. F.S. § 768.81(3) puts two burdens on the defense, and the adjuster's investigation is what satisfies them:
The defendant must affirmatively plead the fault of the nonparty in its answer, identifying that person or entity rather than gesturing at "others."
The defendant must then prove the nonparty's fault at trial by the greater weight of the evidence — the same preponderance standard the plaintiff carries.
That is why a liability adjuster who suspects a third party should preserve the evidence early: the failed component, the maintenance contract, the subcontractor's scope sheet, the 911 audio, the surveillance video. A Fabre defendant who cannot be proved is simply a percentage the insured pays.
Apportionment does not apply everywhere. Under F.S. § 768.81(4) the statute does not reach actions for damage from pollution, actions based on an intentional tort , or situations where another chapter of the Florida Statutes expressly imposes joint and several liability. In an intentional-tort case the old common-law rule survives, so an insured who committed a battery cannot dilute the judgment by pointing at a bystander.
Section 11.2 covers the companion rule from House Bill 837 — the modified comparative negligence bar that ends recovery for a claimant found more than 50 percent at fault, with a carve-out for medical negligence actions under chapter 766. Read the two together: fault percentages first decide whether the claimant recovers at all, then decide how much each defendant pays.
4. Proving Medical Damages After F.S. § 768.0427
House Bill 837 also rewrote what a claimant may put in front of a jury as medical damages, and it changed how a bodily injury adjuster values a file:
- Category of medical charge Admissible evidence of the amount
- Past charges already satisfied The amount actually paid , regardless of who paid it
Past charges still unpaid, claimant has health coverage What the health insurer is obligated to pay plus the claimant's share of deductible, copay and coinsurance
Past charges still unpaid, claimant is uninsured or on Medicare or Medicaid 120 percent of the Medicare reimbursement rate for that service
- No applicable Medicare rate exists 170 percent of the Florida Medicaid rate
- Future medical care The same coverage-based or Medicare/Medicaid benchmarks, projected forward
When treatment was furnished under a letter of protection , the claimant must disclose the letter itself, itemized bills coded to CPT, HCPCS or ICD standards, the identity of any factoring company that bought the account and the discount it paid, whether the claimant had health coverage, and who referred the claimant for treatment. A referral by the claimant's own attorney is admissible, and the financial relationship between the law firm and the provider is fair game as evidence of provider bias. The practical effect for the adjuster is that a $180,000 letter-of-protection bill is no longer the starting point for negotiation; the Medicare-based benchmark usually is.
5. Collateral Sources and Settlement Leverage
F.S. § 768.76 requires the court to reduce a damages award by collateral source payments made for the claimant's benefit — but not by payments from any source that holds a right of subrogation or reimbursement. Medicare, Medicaid, workers' compensation and Department of Health medical programs are therefore excluded from the setoff. The claimant must notify collateral source providers by certified or registered mail of the intent to pursue the tortfeasor; a provider that does not assert its subrogation or reimbursement right within 30 days waives it.
F.S. § 768.79 gives both sides a fee-shifting tool. A defendant's offer of judgment that the plaintiff rejects entitles the defendant to fees and costs if the judgment is at least 25 percent less than the offer; a plaintiff's demand entitles the plaintiff to fees if the judgment is at least 25 percent greater than the demand. An offer stays open for 30 days . Adjusters use the proposal to convert a soft liability defense into real downside risk for the plaintiff.
6. Putting It Together: Allocating a Florida Verdict
A slip-and-fall claimant is awarded $600,000 in compensatory damages. The jury assigns 25 percent fault to the insured store, 55 percent to the nonparty janitorial contractor named as a Fabre defendant, and 20 percent to the claimant. The claimant's health insurer paid $48,000 of a $130,000 hospital bill and has asserted a written subrogation lien.
Step Computation Result
Does the claimant recover at all? (§ 768.81(6)) The claimant is 20 percent at fault, which is not more than 50 percent, so the bar does not apply Recovery permitted, diminished in proportion to fault under § 768.81(2)
- Store's share of the judgment (§ 768.81(3)) $600,000 × 25 percent $150,000
- Nonparty contractor's share $600,000 × 55 percent $330,000, collectible only from the contractor
- Collateral source setoff (§ 768.76) Health insurer asserted subrogation, so no setoff $0 reduction
The store's carrier owes $150,000 and nothing more. Under the old joint and several liability rule, before the Legislature abolished it in § 768.81 and before Fabre allowed fault to be placed on non-parties, the same verdict could have exposed that carrier to the entire award.